Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 12 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

State Pays for Land Lost to a Forged Power of Attorney: Turkish Cassation Assembly on Civil Code Art. 1007

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under the Turkish Civil Code, if an immovable sold under a forged power of attorney has passed to a third person who relied in good faith on the land register entry, that person’s acquisition is protected (Civil Code art. 1023) and the owner cannot recover the title. In its decision of 13.05.2026, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay Hukuk Genel Kurulu) stated that the State is strictly liable for this loss under Civil Code art. 1007 and that the Treasury must prove that the causal link has been broken. In a case where many immovables were sold below market value using an identity card issued and a power of attorney drawn up on the same day, the fault of the notary and the fake attorney did not break the causal link. The decision of resistance was reversed unanimously and with final effect; the actual loss is yet to be determined, and the case may not be final.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that the State is strictly liable under Civil Code art. 1007 for the owner’s loss where immovables sold under a forged power of attorney remain with third persons in good faith, and that the fault of the notary and the fake attorney did not break the causal link.

Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that the State is strictly liable under Civil Code art. 1007 for the loss of an owner who could not recover, from third persons in good faith, immovables sold using a forged identity card and a forged power of attorney.

The Dispute

The plaintiff owns a large number of immovables in Gebze. On 18.11.2003 persons not party to the case, using a woman acting as the plaintiff’s double, obtained a new identity card bearing the plaintiff’s photograph and on the same day had a sale power of attorney drawn up before a notary. On the same day the fake attorney sold 12 immovables to one person at the land registry, and on 05.12.2003 sold 17 immovables to another; the first buyer transferred three of them to others in December 2003.

The fraudsters were convicted by a criminal court. Through an action for annulment of title and re-registration, the plaintiff recovered part of the immovables; however, those who had acquired three parcels were found to be third persons in good faith, and the action was dismissed with final effect as regards those parcels. The plaintiff brought an action for compensation for these parcels against the Treasury and the land registry directorate under Civil Code art. 1007.

The first-instance court partly allowed the action and awarded TRY 1,252,977 in compensation against the Treasury. The regional court of appeal, by contrast, stating that the land registry officials had verified the power of attorney with the notary, accepted that the causal link had been broken by the acts of the notary and the fake attorney, and dismissed the action. The 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed that decision; the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal resisted, also pointing out that the dismissal of an action on the same grounds brought by a person who had bought some of the immovables had been upheld by the Chamber.

Outcome of the Decision

On 13.05.2026 the Assembly of Civil Chambers accepted the plaintiff’s grounds of appeal and reversed the decision of resistance for the reasons set out in the Chamber’s reversal decision. The Treasury’s appeal, which concerned only the attorney’s fee, was dismissed for lack of legal interest. The decision was given unanimously and with final effect; the file was sent to the regional court of appeal.

The Assembly stated that the plaintiff’s actual loss should be determined and paid as compensation. At the time of writing, no new decision in this case could be found; the case may not be final.

Reasoning

The Assembly laid down the test for the State’s liability as follows:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“Whether or not the land registry director or officer is at fault, it is sufficient that the rules of law protecting persons’ patrimonial interests have been breached in keeping the land register. … Accordingly, the State cannot escape liability unless it proves that the causal link has been broken. For the causal link to be broken, there must be gross fault on the part of the injured party, gross fault of a third person of a nature capable of breaking the causal link, or an unforeseeable circumstance in the occurrence of the harmful result.”

The Assembly also assessed the loss of ownership resulting from the protection of the good-faith third person’s acquisition in terms of the right of property under Article 35 of the Constitution:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/362, K. 2026/319, 13.05.2026 (assessment in terms of the right of property)

“…although the interference consisting of the immovable being registered wrongfully in another person’s name because of an unlawfulness in keeping the land register, and of the ownership of the immovable then being lost because the acquisitions of third persons in good faith are protected, is legally foreseeable and pursues a legitimate aim, there is no doubt that the approach that the conditions for compensation under Article 1007 of the TMK are not met is incompatible not only with the provision in that article on the State’s strict liability for keeping land register records but also with the right of property guaranteed by Article 35 of the Constitution.”

It assessed the present case as follows:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“Moreover, the certificate of loss and replacement of the identity card obtained from the neighbourhood headman’s office, the identity card issued at the population directorate, the immovable sale power of attorney drawn up at the notary with that identity card on the same day, and the attempt, again on the same day, to sell at the land registry, through the attorneys of both parties, a large number of immovables belonging to the same owner below their true market value are highly suspicious. … The source of the plaintiff’s loss is the wrongful registration, and although the third persons notified of the action … are at fault, it cannot be said that their acts broke the adequate causal link between the unlawful acts and transactions of the land registry officers and the loss.”

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision answers the question of who must pay for the loss when an action for annulment of title produces no result against a third person in good faith: Civil Code art. 1023 protects the good-faith third person’s acquisition, while the owner’s loss is borne by the State under Civil Code art. 1007. The Assembly also based this conclusion on decisions of the Constitutional Court on the right of property and on the European Court of Human Rights’ decision in Devecioğlu v. Turkey.

In practice, the burden of proof is decisive. The Treasury’s defence that the power of attorney had been found to conform to the original did not change the outcome. The Treasury must prove force majeure, gross fault of the injured party or fault of a third person serious enough to break the causal link; according to the Assembly, a break in the link through a third person’s act is to be interpreted very narrowly. The State has recourse against the officials at fault for the compensation it pays (Civil Code art. 1007/2).

Note: the Assembly did not separately address, in its reasoning, the action of the person who had bought some of the immovables, which the regional court of appeal had mentioned. The decision concerns the original owner who could not recover the title as against third persons in good faith; the claims of those in the position of buyers are assessed according to their own circumstances. Since the decision, no decision departing from this test has been found among the accessible Civil Code art. 1007 decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers and the 5th Civil Chamber.

Where a sale based on a forged power of attorney is annulled, the notary is also liable for the buyer’s loss; the notary’s liability does not depend on fault (Assembly of Civil Chambers)

Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers (the Assembly’s reasoning)

“The notary can escape liability only by proving that the causal link was broken by the gross fault of the injured party, or that a third party committed gross fault capable of breaking the causal link, or that an unforeseeable event occurred in bringing about the harmful result. … It cannot be said that the defendant notary, who drew up the power of attorney on the application of a non-party who came to the notary for that purpose but was not the true holder of the identity card, exercised the necessary care and attention, nor therefore that the causal link was broken by the grossly negligent acts of third parties.” (unofficial translation)

On the same day, the Assembly of Civil Chambers examined the notary’s liability in a separate case whose facts overlap with those discussed in this article: on 18.11.2003 an identity card bearing the owner’s photograph was obtained and, with another woman posing as the owner, a power of attorney to sell was drawn up before a notary the same day; the title of the person who bought the immovable under that power was annulled in the owner’s action for cancellation of title and registration. The buyer, who lost an expropriation award and had to repay compensation he had received, sued those who committed the forgery, the notary and, for the population registry acts, the Ministry of Interior. The first-instance court held that, because the identity card was capable of deceiving, the causal link was broken as regards the notary, and insisted on that view against the reversal of the 3rd Civil Chamber. The Assembly characterised the liability under Article 162 of the Notaries Law as an aggravated ordinary causal liability with no exculpatory proof available to the notary; it held that verifying and identifying the match between the identity card and the applicant is the notary’s task, that the notary bears the burden of proving that the causal link was broken and had not done so, and reversed the insistence judgment unanimously. The decision was rendered under the former procedural code with rectification of decision still available; the case may not be final.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 1007 (Liability)

“The State is liable for all damage arising from the keeping of the land register.

The State has recourse against the officials at fault in causing the damage.

Actions concerning the liability of the State are heard by the court of the place where the land register is kept.”

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 1023 (Against third persons in good faith)

“The acquisition of a third person who, relying in good faith on an entry in the land register, acquires ownership or another right in rem is protected.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Can land sold under a forged power of attorney be recovered?

Under Turkish law, in this decision the owner recovered part of the immovables through an action for annulment of title and re-registration. However, if the immovable has passed to a third person who acquired it relying in good faith on the land register entry, that acquisition is protected (Civil Code art. 1023). In this case, those protected were the later owners who acquired from the first buyer.

If the title cannot be recovered, who pays for the loss?

According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the State pays under Civil Code art. 1007. In this case the defendant is the Treasury; the action brought against the land registry directorate was dismissed for lack of standing to be sued.

Is the State liable even if the land registry officer was not at fault?

Yes. The State’s liability is strict liability; an unlawfulness in keeping the register and a causal link suffice. Fault matters only for the State’s recourse against the official at fault (Civil Code art. 1007/2).

Does the fault of the notary or the fraudsters release the State from liability?

The Assembly of Civil Chambers held that it did not in this case. The Treasury must prove that the causal link has been broken; the outcome depends on the circumstances of the case.

In which court is the compensation action brought?

Under Civil Code art. 1007/3, actions concerning the State’s liability are heard by the court of the place where the land register is kept. This case was heard by the ordinary (civil) courts.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Real Estate Law

All Real Estate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “State Pays for Land Lost to a Forged Power of Attorney: Turkish Cassation Assembly on Civil Code Art. 1007”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-19, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/forged-power-of-attorney-land-sale-state-compensation

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›