Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 16 min read

Last reviewed:

Defective Delivery in a Turnkey (Works) Contract

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, having a job done on a turnkey basis is a works contract, and the delivered work is defective if it does not conform to the contract, to the rules of the art or to the owner’s purpose. The owner must inspect the work as soon as possible after delivery and notify the contractor of apparent defects within a reasonable time and of hidden defects that emerge later without delay; otherwise the work is deemed accepted (TCO Art. 474, Art. 477). Where the contractor is liable for a defect, the owner may choose rescission, a price reduction proportionate to the defect or free repair, and the right to claim damages under general provisions is reserved (TCO Art. 475). Rescission is not available where the work was built on the owner’s immovable property and its removal would cause excessive harm. Actions for a defective work become time-barred, counting from delivery, after two years for works other than immovable structures, five years for immovable structures and twenty years where the contractor is grossly at fault (TCO Art. 478).

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Defective delivery in a turnkey works contract: the definition of the works contract (TCO Art. 470) and the lump-sum price (TCO Art. 480), the apparent/hidden defect distinction, the duty to inspect and notify defects (TCO Art. 474), the owner's optional rights — rescission, price reduction, free repair and damages (TCO Art. 475), acceptance of the work and fraudulently concealed defects (TCO Art. 477), defects arising from the owner's instructions (TCO Art. 476), the competent court and venue, the five-year limitation for immovable structures and twenty years in case of gross fault (TCO Art. 478), and decisions of the 15th and 6th Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.

Defective delivery in a turnkey (works/construction) contract; the definition of the works contract (TCO Art. 470) and its relation to a turnkey lump-sum price (TCO Art. 480), the distinction between apparent and hidden defects, the owner's burden to inspect and to notify defects (TCO Art. 474), the owner's optional rights — rescission, price reduction, free repair and damages (TCO Art. 475), express/implied acceptance of the work and defects fraudulently concealed (TCO Art. 477), defects arising from the owner's instructions (TCO Art. 476), the competent court, the five-year limitation for immovable structures and twenty years in case of gross fault (TCO Art. 478), and Court of Cassation decisions.

Having a dwelling, business premises, factory or machine built on a “turnkey” basis is, in law, a works (contract for work). The contractor undertakes to produce and deliver the work, and the owner to pay the price in return. The most common dispute in practice is that the delivered work does not conform to the contract, to the rules of the art, or to the owner's purpose — that is, it is defective. A cracking, water-leaking building, concrete and reinforcement not matching the project, missing or faulty workmanship, or a non-functioning installation or machine all fall here. This article addresses the types of defect, the owner's duty to inspect and notify, the optional rights available, the consequences of acceptance, the competent court, limitation, and the settled criteria of the Court of Cassation.

What Is a Works Contract and a “Turnkey” Job?

A works contract is a synallagmatic contract for the performance of work in which one party (the contractor) undertakes to produce a result — the building, the flat, the machine, the software, the repair — and the other (the owner) to pay the price. Its essential feature is the undertaking of a result: the contractor owes not merely effort but a work conforming to the contract.

Relevant provision — Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Art. 470 (unofficial translation)

“A works contract is a contract by which the contractor undertakes to produce a work and the owner to pay a price in return.”

“Turnkey” describes a works contract — usually with a lump-sum price — in which the contractor undertakes to complete the job in all its stages (materials, labour, permits, finishing) and deliver it to the owner ready for use. This structure matters both for the fixity of the price and for the scope of liability for defects (see “Lump-Sum Price” below).

What Is a Defect? Apparent and Hidden Defects

A work is defective if it lacks the qualities agreed in the contract, is contrary to the rules of the art, or fails to meet the owner's intended purpose. The contractor's liability for defects (warranty against defects) is the complement of the delivery obligation; it means undertaking the defects and deficiencies in the work.

Defects are of two kinds:

Apparent defect

Defects detectable upon delivery by an ordinary inspection — e.g. visible cracks, missing work, wrong dimensions.

Hidden defect

Defects not detectable by simple/ordinary inspection at delivery, surfacing over time or with use — e.g. concrete strength below project, insufficient reinforcement, waterproofing failure. For hidden defects the notice period runs from when the defect surfaces.

The Duty to Inspect and to Notify Defects

After taking delivery the owner must inspect the work within a suitable time and notify the contractor of the defects seen. For apparent defects notice is given within a reasonable time; for hidden defects, without delay once the defect surfaces. If the duty to notify is not discharged, the work is, as a rule, deemed accepted.

Relevant provision — TCO Art. 474 (unofficial translation)

“After delivery of the work, the owner must inspect it as soon as practicable according to the ordinary course of business and, if there are defects, notify the contractor within a suitable time. Each party may, bearing the cost, request that the work be examined by an expert and the result determined by a report.”

An important point: whether notice was timely is in the nature of a defence (objection): unless the contractor raises it, the court does not take it into account of its own motion (see the decision below). Moreover, where a warranty period is agreed, the contractor is deemed to have undertaken in advance to remedy defects arising within that period without the need for notice.

The Owner's Optional Rights: Rescission, Reduction, Repair and Damages

If the work is defective the owner may, according to the gravity of the defect, exercise one of three optional rights; the right to claim damages under the general provisions is also reserved.

Relevant provision — TCO Art. 475 (unofficial translation)

“Where the contractor is liable for the defect in the work, the owner may exercise one of the following optional rights: 1. Rescission of the contract, if the work is defective to such an extent that the owner cannot use it or cannot in equity be compelled to accept it, or is to the same extent contrary to the contract. 2. Keeping the work and demanding a reduction of the price in proportion to the defect. 3. Demanding the free repair of the work, all costs being borne by the contractor, provided this does not require excessive expense. The owner's right to claim damages under the general provisions is reserved. If the work has been made on the owner's immovable and its removal would cause excessive harm, the owner cannot exercise the right of rescission.”

In practice the routes most often used are the claim for the cost of repairing the defect and a reduction of the price in proportion to the defect. Rescission is possible only where the work is defective to a degree that makes it unusable or impossible to be compelled to accept; moreover, if the work was made on the owner's immovable and removal would cause excessive harm, rescission cannot be used. Hence in construction works the practical outcome is usually the repair cost or a price reduction.

Defects Arising from the Owner's Instructions

Not every defect makes the contractor liable. If the defect arose from the owner's insistent instruction despite the contractor's express warning, or is otherwise attributable to the owner, the owner cannot exercise its defect-based rights. It is therefore critical, for proof, that the contractor warned the owner in writing against problematic materials or instructions.

Relevant provision — TCO Art. 476 (unofficial translation)

“If the defectiveness of the work arose from an instruction given by the owner despite the contractor's express warning, or is for any reason attributable to the owner, the owner cannot exercise the rights arising from the defectiveness of the work.”

Acceptance of the Work and Fraudulently Concealed Defects

Express or implied acceptance of the work, as a rule, releases the contractor from liability. But there are two exceptions: defects fraudulently concealed by the contractor and defects undetectable by ordinary inspection (hidden). When a hidden defect surfaces later, if the owner does not notify without delay, the work is deemed accepted with that defect.

Relevant provision — TCO Art. 477 (unofficial translation)

“After the express or implied acceptance of the work, the contractor is released from all liability; however, its liability continues for defects fraudulently concealed by it and those that could not be detected during a proper inspection. If the owner neglects to inspect and to notify, the work is deemed accepted. If a defect in the work surfaces later, the owner must notify the contractor of the situation without delay; failing which the work is deemed accepted.”

Turnkey Lump-Sum Price and Adaptation of the Contract

In turnkey jobs the price is usually set as a lump sum: the contractor undertakes to complete the work for that price and, as a rule, cannot demand an increase even if the work required more labour/expense than foreseen. Conversely, if extraordinary circumstances unforeseeable at the outset render performance excessively difficult, the contractor may ask the court to adapt the contract or, failing that, to rescind/terminate.

Relevant provision — TCO Art. 480 (unofficial translation)

“If the price has been fixed as a lump sum, the contractor is bound to produce the work for that price. Even if the work required more labour and expense than foreseen, the contractor cannot demand an increase of the fixed price. However, if circumstances unforeseeable at the outset, or foreseeable but not taken into account by the parties, prevent or render extremely difficult the making of the work for the lump sum fixed by the parties, the contractor has the right to ask the judge to adapt the contract to the new conditions and, where this is not possible or cannot be expected of the other party, to rescind the contract. Where the rules of good faith so require, the contractor may exercise only the right of termination. Even if the work required less labour and expense than foreseen, the owner is bound to pay the entire price fixed.”

Competent Court and Venue

In defect and debt actions arising from a works contract the competent court is, as a rule, the civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk). If both parties are merchants and the dispute is a commercial transaction for both, the commercial court of first instance is competent. Where the job is procured by a person acting as a consumer (e.g. a consumer's home/renovation work), the dispute may fall within the jurisdiction of the consumer court. As to venue, although the general rule is the defendant's domicile, the court of the place of performance (where the work was produced) may also have jurisdiction.

Limitation: Two, Five and Twenty Years

In actions for a defective work the limitation period varies with the nature of the work and the contractor's fault: two years for works other than immovable structures, five years for immovable structures, and, where the contractor is at gross fault, twenty years regardless of the nature of the work. The period runs from delivery; for hidden defects the surfacing of the defect and actionability are significant.

Relevant provision — TCO Art. 478 (unofficial translation)

“If the contractor has produced a defective work, the actions to be brought for this reason become time-barred, running from the date of delivery, on the lapse of two years for works other than immovable structures; five years for immovable structures; and, if the contractor is at gross fault, twenty years regardless of the nature of the defective work.”

Works-contract claims other than for defects (e.g. the price, delay) are subject to the general five-year limitation of the TCO.

Court of Cassation Decisions

Disputes over defects under works contracts were historically decided by the now-closed 15th Civil Chamber; following the post-2020 restructuring, these matters are currently heard by the 6th Civil Chamber. The decisions below were verified in full text from the official case-law database.

The contractor's warranty against defects and the inspection-notice scheme for apparent/hidden defects

Court of Cassation

“The work must be produced in conformity with the rules of science and art and so as to meet the owner's purpose. Otherwise the work is defective and the contractor's liability for the harmful result of the defect arises. … the contractor's liability for the harmful result of the defect is, as the complement of its obligation to deliver the work, the obligation to assume the defects and deficiencies appearing in the work it produced. … for apparent defects the owner must inspect the work as soon as practicable (within a reasonable time) after delivery and notify the apparent defects, … where the defect is hidden and surfaces later, it must notify the contractor without delay (immediately), failing which the work is deemed accepted as is …” (unofficial translation)

Hidden defect: a defect undetectable by simple inspection, and determining the repair cost

Court of Cassation

“It is beyond doubt that these defects stated in the report are in the nature of a hidden defect, as it was not possible to detect them by a simple inspection at delivery. … if there has been an increase in the repair and reinforcement cost because of the defects, that increased cost … is to be calculated at the free-market rates of the date reached by adding to the date the hidden defect surfaced … the reasonable time needed to begin the repair and reinforcement work …” (unofficial translation)

Notice of defect is a defence; unless raised, the court cannot consider it of its own motion

Court of Cassation

“… notice of defect is by its nature a defence and, unless raised, cannot be considered by the court of its own motion. As the defendant did not raise in its answer a defence that the claimant administration failed to give timely notice of defect … the court should accept that timely notice of defect was given and proceed to the merits …” (unofficial translation)

Limitation: defect actions under Art. 478 (movables 2, immovable structures 5, gross fault 20 years), non-defect claims 5 years

Court of Cassation

“… under Article 478 of Law No. 6098, if the contractor has produced a defective work, the actions to be brought for this reason become time-barred, running from delivery, on the lapse of two years for works other than immovable structures; five years for immovable structures; and, if the contractor is at gross fault, twenty years regardless of the nature of the defective work. On the other hand, for claims arising from the works contract other than for defects, the five-year limitation in Article 147/6 of the TCO applies. … for the special limitation rule in Article 478 to apply, the claim must arise exclusively from the defective delivery of the work.” (unofficial translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

A defect appeared in my turnkey construction; what rights can I use?

According to the gravity of the defect you may use one of three optional rights: rescission if the work is defective to a degree that makes it unusable or impossible to be compelled to accept; keeping the work and a price reduction in proportion to the defect; or (if it does not require excessive expense) free repair at the contractor's cost. Your right to damages under the general provisions is also reserved (TCO Art. 475). If the work was made on your immovable and removal would cause excessive harm, rescission cannot be used; in practice the repair cost or a price reduction comes to the fore.

What is the difference between an apparent and a hidden defect; when must I notify?

An apparent defect is one visible by ordinary inspection at delivery and must be notified within a reasonable time. A hidden defect is one not detectable by simple inspection that surfaces later; it must be notified without delay (immediately) once it surfaces. If no notice is given, the work may be deemed accepted with that defect (TCO Arts. 474, 477).

How long do I have to sue for a hidden defect in a building?

For immovable structures, defective-work actions are subject to a five-year limitation from delivery; for works other than immovable structures, two years. If the contractor is at gross fault, the period is twenty years regardless of the nature of the work (TCO Art. 478).

The contractor says I “did not notify the defect in time”; do I lose my right entirely?

Failure to give timely notice is a defence; unless the contractor expressly raises it, the court does not consider it of its own motion. Moreover, if the contract provides a warranty period, remedy may be claimed for defects arising within that period without the notice requirement. Still, to avoid missing deadlines, notifying the defect in writing (notary/registered mail) is the safest course.

We agreed a lump-sum price; the contractor now wants extra payment — must I pay?

As a rule, no. Under a lump-sum price the contractor cannot demand an increase even if the work required more labour/expense than foreseen. However, if extraordinary circumstances unforeseeable at the outset rendered performance excessively difficult, the contractor may ask the court for adaptation or, failing that, rescission/termination (TCO Art. 480).

If the defect stems from my own instruction, is the contractor still liable?

If the defect arose from your instruction despite the contractor's express warning, or is otherwise attributable to you, you cannot exercise your defect-based rights (TCO Art. 476). This is why it matters that the contractor warned the owner in writing against the problematic instruction/material.

Within Real Estate Law, Çapar Law Office handles, in turnkey construction and works contracts, actions for the cost of repair, price reduction, rescission and damages arising from defective workmanship.

Related Articles

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Defective Delivery in a Turnkey (Works) Contract”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/defective-delivery-turnkey-contract

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›