Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 13 min read

Last reviewed:

A Defective Zero-km Vehicle (Consumer Rights)

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, failures in a zero-km vehicle that lacks the qualities it should have at delivery, such as manufacturing defects that persist despite repair, constitute a defect. The consumer may choose one of the four elective rights in Law No. 6502 Art. 11: rescission with a refund of the price, a price reduction proportionate to the defect, free repair, or replacement with a defect-free equivalent. Defects appearing within six months of delivery are presumed to have existed at delivery, and the burden of proving that the vehicle is not defective shifts to the seller (Art. 10). The seller, producer and importer are jointly and severally liable for free repair and replacement; even if repair was chosen, the consumer may move to replacement or rescission if the vehicle breaks down again within the warranty period, the maximum repair time is exceeded or repair proves impossible (Art. 56/3). The consumer court is competent, and applying to a mediator before suing is a precondition to suit (art. 73/A); liability for defective goods is subject to a two-year limitation period from delivery, but the limitation rules do not apply where the defect was concealed by gross fault or fraud (Art. 12).

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

The consumer's rights when a zero-km vehicle turns out defective: the definition of defective goods (Law 6502, Art. 8), hidden defects and the six-month presumption of proof (Art. 10), the four elective rights — free repair, replacement with a defect-free equivalent, rescission (refund) and price reduction (Art. 11), the joint and several liability of seller-producer-importer, warranty and a defect not remediable by repair (Art. 56), competent court, the two-year limitation and non-application of limitation where the defect is concealed by fraud/gross fault (Art. 12), and Court of Cassation decisions.

A defective zero-kilometre vehicle, the definition of defective goods (Art. 8), hidden defects and the six-month presumption of proof (Art. 10), the consumer's elective rights — free repair, replacement with a defect-free equivalent, rescission (refund) and a price reduction proportionate to the defect (Art. 11), the joint and several liability of seller, producer and importer, warranty period and a defect that cannot be remedied by repair (Art. 56), competent court and the consumer arbitration committee, the two-year limitation and the non-application of limitation where the defect is concealed by gross fault or fraud (Art. 12), under Law No. 6502, and Court of Cassation decisions.

A consumer buys a zero-kilometre vehicle expecting delivery in flawless, ready-to-use condition. If defects originating in manufacture and not remediable by repair appear in the engine, transmission, or electrical/electronic systems, there is defective goods and the consumer may exercise the elective rights granted by Law No. 6502 on the Protection of Consumers. This article addresses the definition of a defective vehicle, hidden defects, the burden of proof, the elective rights, joint liability, the competent court, limitation, and the settled criteria of the Court of Cassation.

What Is a “Defective Good” in a Zero-km Vehicle?

A defective good is one that, at the moment of delivery, lacks the qualities agreed or that it should objectively possess. In a zero-km vehicle, the expected quality is a flawlessly functioning, safe vehicle delivering the performance reasonably expected of its type.

Relevant provision — Law No. 6502, Art. 8 (unofficial translation)

“(1) A defective good is one which, at the moment of delivery to the consumer, is contrary to the contract because it does not conform to the agreed sample or model, or does not possess the qualities it should objectively have. (2) Goods that lack one or more of the features stated on their packaging, label, manual, internet portal, or advertisements; that are contrary to the quality declared by the seller or established in their technical regulation; or that contain material, legal or economic deficiencies which fail to meet the purpose of their equivalents, reduce or eliminate the benefits the consumer reasonably expects, are also deemed defective.”

Hidden Defects and Proof: the Six-Month Presumption

Defects not visible at first sight but emerging in use are hidden defects. The law gives a strong presumption in the consumer's favour: a defect emerging within six months of delivery is deemed to have existed at delivery, and the burden of proving the vehicle is defect-free shifts to the seller.

Relevant provision — Law No. 6502, Art. 10/1 (unofficial translation)

“Defects emerging within six months of the delivery date are deemed to have existed at the delivery date. In that case the burden of proving that the good is not defective lies with the seller. This presumption does not apply if it is incompatible with the nature of the good or the defect.”

In practice the existence and nature of the defect are usually established by an expert report on the inspected vehicle; in zero-km vehicle disputes, an automotive expert examination is highly important.

The Consumer's Four Elective Rights

Once the vehicle is found defective, the consumer may use whichever of four elective rights they choose; the seller must comply with that choice.

Relevant provision — Law No. 6502, Art. 11 (unofficial translation)

“(1) Where the good is found defective, the consumer may exercise one of the following elective rights: a) rescinding the contract by declaring readiness to return the good; b) keeping the good and demanding a price reduction in proportion to the defect; c) demanding free repair at the seller's expense, provided it does not require excessive cost; ç) if possible, demanding replacement with a defect-free equivalent. The seller is obliged to fulfil the consumer's chosen demand. … (4) Where free repair or replacement is chosen, the demand must be fulfilled within a maximum of thirty working days from being directed to the seller, producer or importer …; otherwise the consumer is free to use the other elective rights. (5) Where the consumer chooses rescission or a price reduction, the whole price paid or the reduction amount is refunded to the consumer immediately.”

Free repair

The right to demand repair at the seller's expense. The demand must be met within a maximum of thirty working days (or the maximum repair time for listed goods); otherwise the consumer may move to the other rights.

Replacement with a defect-free equivalent

Replacement of the vehicle with a defect-free, zero-km equivalent of the same make, model and specifications. The Court of Cassation frequently finds replacement equitable for important defects originating in manufacture and not remediable by repair.

Rescission (refund)

The consumer returns the vehicle and demands an immediate refund of the full price paid. If free repair or replacement entails disproportionate difficulty for the seller, the consumer may turn to rescission or a price reduction.

Price reduction proportionate to the defect

The consumer may keep the vehicle and demand that an amount corresponding to the defect be deducted from the sale price.

Against Whom? Joint and Several Liability

The rights of free repair and replacement may be used not only against the seller but also against the producer or importer. Seller, producer and importer are jointly and severally liable for the fulfilment of these rights. Thus the consumer may also apply to the distributor or producer alongside the authorised dealer/seller.

Warranty Period and a Defect Not Remediable by Repair

The warranty period for vehicles is at least two years from delivery. The key rule: even if the consumer first chose free repair, if the vehicle malfunctions again within the warranty period, the maximum repair time is exceeded, or repair turns out impossible, the consumer may move to the other elective rights (replacement or rescission); the seller cannot reject this demand.

Relevant provision — Law No. 6502, Art. 56 (unofficial translation)

“(2) The warranty period is at least two years, beginning from the delivery date of the good. … (3) If the consumer has used the repair right among the elective rights in Article 11, where the good malfunctions again within the warranty period, the maximum repair time is exceeded, or repair is understood to be impossible, the consumer may use the other elective rights in Article 11. The seller cannot reject the consumer's demand. If this demand is not met, the seller, producer and importer are jointly and severally liable.”

Competent Court and the Consumer Arbitration Committee

Buying a zero-km vehicle is a consumer transaction; the competent court is the consumer court (where there is none, the civil court of first instance acting as a consumer court). For disputes below the statutory monetary threshold, applying first to the consumer arbitration committee is mandatory; this threshold is updated each year by the revaluation rate. Since vehicle prices far exceed this threshold, zero-km vehicle defect actions go directly to the consumer court. In disputes to be heard by the consumer court, applying to a mediator before suing is a precondition to suit; disputes within the consumer arbitration committee’s jurisdiction and objections to its decisions are excluded (Consumer Protection Law art. 73/A(1)).

Limitation Period

Liability for defective goods is subject to a two-year limitation from the delivery date, even if the defect appears later. Critical exception: where the defect is concealed by gross fault or fraud, the limitation provisions do not apply.

Relevant provision — Law No. 6502, Art. 12 (unofficial translation)

“(1) Unless a longer period is set by law or by the parties' contract, liability for defective goods, even if the defect appears later, is subject to a two-year limitation from the date of delivery to the consumer. This period is five years for residential or holiday immovables. (2) … in second-hand sales the seller's liability for defective goods cannot be less than one year, and three years for residential or holiday immovables. (3) Where the defect is concealed by gross fault or fraud, the limitation provisions do not apply.”

Court of Cassation Decisions

For a hidden defect in a zero-km vehicle the burden of proof lies with the seller; replacement is equitable

Court of Cassation

“… the defect in the vehicle is in the nature of a hidden defect and is not based on user error; the burden of proof — that the vehicle has no defect — lies with the defendant; … the benefit expected of a zero-kilometre vehicle could not be obtained, and the plaintiff's use of the elective right in the form of replacement is consistent with equity and the balance of the parties' rights and interests; therefore all the defendants' appeal objections are rejected and the lawful judgment must be upheld.” (unofficial translation)

Replacement (Art. 11/1-ç) for a chronic defect originating in manufacture and not remediable by repair

Court of Cassation

“… the defect in question is continuous and the vehicle is in a state of chronic malfunction … the fault in the electrical system of the vehicle of which the defendants are producer and seller could not be remedied, this being a hidden defect originating in a manufacturing fault; accordingly, since the plaintiff exercised the elective right in the direction of replacement under Article 11/(1)-ç of Law No. 6502 … [the rules were] correctly applied …” (unofficial translation)

The seller's liability for defects, the burden of proof, and rescission (refund)

Court of Cassation

“The seller is liable not only where the qualities it declared in any way are absent in the thing sold, but also for material, legal or economic defects that eliminate or substantially reduce the benefits the buyer expected from it. The seller is liable for these defects even if unaware of their existence. … the burden of proving that the good was not defective at the time of sale lies with the defendant … the conditions of rescission having arisen … the judgment must be upheld.” (unofficial translation)

Where the defect is concealed by gross fault or fraud, limitation does not run

Court of Cassation

“… since limitation does not run owing to the defendant's gross fault and fraud, the defendant's limitation defence is unfounded; the expert report obtained in the case file being suitable for party and judicial review, and the good in dispute having been established as defective … the defendant's appeal objections are rejected and the lawful judgment is upheld.” (unofficial translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I have my defective zero-km vehicle replaced with a new one?

Yes. Where a defect exists you choose one of four elective rights; one of them is replacement of the vehicle with a defect-free equivalent (same make/model, zero-km). Especially for important defects originating in manufacture and not remediable by repair, the Court of Cassation finds replacement equitable.

Who must prove the vehicle is not defective?

For defects emerging within six months of delivery, the burden of proving the vehicle is defect-free lies with the seller (Art. 10). This is a strong presumption in the consumer's favour.

The service repaired it repeatedly but the fault recurs; what can I do?

Even if you used the repair right, if the vehicle malfunctions again within the warranty, the maximum repair time is exceeded, or repair is impossible, you may move to the other elective rights (replacement or rescission); the seller cannot reject this (Art. 56/3).

Can I direct my demand only to the dealer, or also to the producer/importer?

Free repair and replacement may be used against the producer or importer too; seller, producer and importer are jointly and severally liable (Art. 11/2).

Which court should I apply to?

A zero-km vehicle is a consumer transaction; since the price far exceeds the consumer arbitration committee's monetary threshold, the competent court is the consumer court (or the civil court of first instance acting as such). Applying to a mediator before suing is a precondition to suit.

I bought the vehicle years ago; has the period expired?

As a rule, liability for defective goods is two years from delivery. But where the defect was concealed by gross fault or fraud, the limitation provisions do not apply (Art. 12/3).

Çapar Law Office handles filing and pursuing defective-vehicle actions within Consumer Law and contract/sales disputes.

Related Articles

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Consumer Law

All Consumer Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “A Defective Zero-km Vehicle (Consumer Rights)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/defective-zero-km-vehicle

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›