Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 15 min read

Last reviewed:

The Physician's Liability in Medical Malpractice

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, a physician must act in line with the requirements and rules of medicine and with the care that a prudent colleague in the same field would show; according to the Court of Cassation, the physician is liable for even the slightest fault (TCO Art. 506). Liability requires fault, damage and a causal link between them; a complication arising despite compliance with medical rules does not, as a rule, give rise to liability, but the physician’s duty to inform the patient of that risk in advance and to manage the complication properly remains. The physician bears the burden of proving that the duty to inform was duly performed, and standard printed consent forms that do not specifically set out the risks of the procedure are not sufficient on their own. With a private/independent physician or a private hospital the relationship is, as a rule, a mandate contract and claims are mostly heard by the consumer courts; in a public hospital, the action is brought not against the physician but against the administration, as a full-remedy action before the administrative judiciary. Aesthetic procedures performed without medical necessity are treated by the Court of Cassation as works contracts, so the physician undertakes to achieve the agreed result.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

The physician's civil liability in medical malpractice: the nature of the patient–physician relationship (mandate for a private/independent physician — TCO Art. 502; a public-law relationship in a public hospital; a works contract for aesthetics), the duty of care and liability for the slightest fault (TCO Art. 506), the complication–malpractice distinction, informed consent and the duty to inform (Law No. 1219, Art. 70), the physician bearing the burden of proving disclosure, the competent court (consumer court / full-remedy action before the administrative judiciary), the compulsory liability insurance (Law No. 1219, Add. Art. 12), and decisions of the 13th and 6th Civil Chambers and the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.

The physician's civil liability in medical malpractice; the nature of the patient–physician relationship (a mandate contract for a private/independent physician — TCO Art. 502; a public-law/administrative relationship in a public hospital), the physician's duty of care and liability for the slightest fault (TCO Art. 506), the distinction between complication and malpractice, informed consent and the duty to inform (Law No. 1219, Art. 70), the physician bearing the burden of proving disclosure, the treatment of aesthetic procedures as a works contract with a result obligation, the competent court (consumer court / full-remedy action before the administrative judiciary), the compulsory professional liability insurance, and decisions of the 13th and 6th Civil Chambers and the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.

Medical malpractice is harm caused to a patient by a physician or healthcare institution acting contrary to the requirements and rules of medicine (breach of the duty of care). Not every adverse outcome is malpractice; complications that may arise despite all due care do not, as a rule, give rise to liability. This article addresses the legal nature of the patient–physician relationship, the physician's duty of care, the complication–malpractice distinction, informed consent, the burden of proof, the special position of aesthetic procedures, the competent court, and the settled criteria of the Court of Cassation.

What Is Medical Malpractice?

A physician must fulfil all professional requirements so that the patient is not harmed, determine the patient's condition in time and without delay, take in full the measures the concrete situation requires, and apply the appropriate treatment without delay. Where harm to the patient results from medical practice that is careless, deficient or erroneous and contrary to this duty, medical malpractice arises. For liability, as a rule, a fault (breach of the duty of care), a loss, and a causal link between the two are required.

The Legal Nature of the Patient–Physician Relationship: Mandate, Public Relationship and Works

The legal basis of liability changes according to who provides the healthcare service:

Independent physician or private hospital: mandate contract

If the physician practises independently or the service is provided in a private healthcare institution, the relationship with the patient is, as a rule, a mandate contract. The physician owes not a result (recovery) but diligent performance.

Relevant provision — Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Art. 502 (unofficial translation)

“A mandate contract is a contract by which the agent undertakes to carry out a piece of business or a transaction of the principal. The provisions on mandate apply, to the extent suitable to their nature, also to contracts for the performance of work not otherwise regulated in this Code. Where there is a contract or custom, the agent is entitled to a fee.”

Public hospital: a public-law (administrative) relationship

In hospitals of the State, universities, municipalities and other public bodies there is no contract between patient and physician; the relationship is public-law. Here liability rests on the administration's service fault, and the action is brought not against the physician but against the administration, as a full-remedy action before the administrative judiciary (see “Competent Court” below).

Aesthetic procedure: works contract

Aesthetic procedures arising not from medical necessity but from the aim of improving appearance are treated by the Court of Cassation as a works contract; here the physician undertakes a particular result (see “Aesthetic Procedures” below).

The Physician's Duty of Care and Liability for the Slightest Fault

In the mandate relationship the physician's basic obligation is the duty of care. The physician must show the attention and care that a prudent colleague performing work in a similar field would show; any conduct falling below that standard, even a slight fault, gives rise to liability.

Relevant provision — TCO Art. 506 (unofficial translation)

“The agent is bound to perform the mandate personally. However, where authority has been given to the agent, or the situation makes it necessary, or custom makes it possible, the agent may have the work done by another. The agent must carry out the work and services undertaken with loyalty and care, observing the legitimate interests of the principal. In determining the agent's liability arising from the duty of care, the conduct that a prudent agent undertaking work and services in a similar field would be required to show is taken as the basis.”

According to the settled practice of the Court of Cassation, the physician must act with care “like an employee” and is liable even for the slightest fault; hence all faults of the physician within the professional field (however slight) are treated as an element of liability.

Complication or Malpractice?

The legally critical distinction is whether the harm arose from a complication or from faulty practice (malpractice). A complication is an adverse outcome that may arise despite compliance with the rules of medicine — foreseeable but not always preventable. According to the Court of Cassation, if the rules and requirements of medicine were observed but the outcome did not change, the physician cannot be held liable. Conversely, even when a complication arises, two duties of the physician continue: to have informed the patient beforehand of the possibility of that complication, and to manage the process correctly when it occurs. Breach of these duties gives rise to liability in itself.

Informed Consent and the Duty to Inform

Every medical intervention is an interference with a person's bodily integrity; it therefore becomes lawful, as a rule, only with the patient's free and informed consent. This basis rests on the right to protect one's material and moral existence under Article 17 of the Constitution. Mere “consent to the operation” is not enough; the patient must be told, in language they can understand, of the purpose, nature, chances of success, risks, complications, alternative treatment options and the consequences of refusal.

Relevant provision — Law No. 1219 on the Practice of Medicine and Its Branches, Art. 70 (unofficial translation)

“Physicians, dentists and dental practitioners obtain, beforehand, the consent of the patient — or, if the patient is a minor or under interdiction, of the parent or guardian — for every kind of operation they will perform. For major surgical operations this consent must be in writing. … (Where there is no parent or guardian, or none is present, or the person to be operated on is incapable of expression, consent is not required.) …”

For major surgical interventions the consent must by law be in writing; following a 2025 amendment this consent may also be obtained electronically. The disclosure itself, however, may be written or oral; what matters is that the patient was genuinely and sufficiently informed. General/standard consent forms signed by the patient are not, on their own, sufficient for valid informed consent unless they concretely set out the risks and complications specific to the intervention.

Burden of Proof and Evidence (Expert Examination)

The burden of proving that the duty to inform was duly discharged lies with the physician (or hospital). This rests on the legal presumption that there was no consent to the intervention and on the physician's duty to keep and archive records; failure to keep records may create a factual presumption in the patient's favour. Whether the medical practice complied with the rules and whether there was fault is, as a rule, determined by expert examination (panels formed from the Forensic Medicine Institution and/or the relevant specialist departments of universities). It is therefore very important to obtain in full, before the action, the medical records, discharge summaries, images and consent documents.

Aesthetic Procedures: Works Contract and Result Liability

Aesthetic procedures performed without medical necessity are, unlike ordinary treatment, assessed by the Court of Cassation within the framework of a works contract. Here the physician undertakes not merely diligent effort but the agreed result (a defect-free result meeting the aesthetic expectation); if the result is not achieved, the obligation is not deemed performed. Even so, the physician's duty to inform the patient of the risks and complications and to manage the complication process correctly continues. In aesthetic disputes the defect provisions of the works contract (price reduction, remedy of the defect, damages) come into play.

Competent Court, Compulsory Insurance and Limitation

Actions against a private hospital or independent physician mostly fall within the jurisdiction of the consumer court, because the healthcare service is treated as a consumer transaction (including aesthetic = works disputes). Where a public hospital is concerned, the action is brought not against the physician but against the administration, as a full-remedy action before the administrative judiciary; the administrative application and action time-limits (the Administrative Procedure Law) must also be observed.

For physicians, the Compulsory Financial Liability Insurance for Medical Malpractice has been made mandatory by Additional Article 12 of Law No. 1219; disputes arising from this insurance, in which the insurer is a party, are, owing to their commercial nature, subject to a different judicial branch (the commercial court). As limitation differs between contract-based (mandate) claims, tort-based claims and the time-limits before the administrative judiciary, obtaining legal advice immediately after the event is recommended to avoid loss of rights.

Court of Cassation Decisions

Disputes over the civil liability of physicians/private hospitals were historically decided by the now-closed 13th Civil Chamber; in the current structure these matters are heard by the 3rd and 6th Civil Chambers and, on points of principle, by the Assembly of Civil Chambers. Actions relating to the compulsory medical-malpractice liability insurance (in which the insurer is a party) come before the 11th Civil Chamber. The decisions below were verified in full text from the official case-law database.

The physician's duty of care and liability for the slightest fault; no liability for the outcome where medical rules were followed, but complications must be disclosed

Court of Cassation

“… although the agent is not liable for failing to achieve the result he/she aimed at, he/she is liable for damage arising from the lack of care in the efforts, transactions, acts and conduct undertaken to achieve that result. … Like an employee, the agent must act with care and is liable even for the slightest fault (Art. 396/1 of the Turkish Code of Obligations). Therefore, all faults of the physician within his/her professional field, even if slight, must be accepted as an element of liability. … If, although the requirements and rules of medicine were complied with, the result did not change, the physician should not be held liable. … Mere consent to the operation is not sufficient. The complications must also be explained. … In informed consent, however, the burden of proof lies with the physician or the hospital. … If it is determined that the perforation that occurred in the plaintiff is a complication, it must be taken into account that the disclosure was not sufficient, and a decision must be given in accordance with the resulting outcome.”

Nature of the relationship: mandate for an independent physician, a public relationship in a public hospital; the burden of proving disclosure lies with the physician

Court of Cassation

“Where the physician practises independently, there is a contract between physician and patient. As by this contract the physician undertakes not a result obligation but an obligation of diligent performance, this contract is generally accepted in Turkish law as a mandate contract. … On the other hand, since the relationship between the hospitals of the State, universities, municipalities and other public bodies and the doctors is a public-law relationship, there is no contractual relationship between patient and doctor. … the burden of proof in the physician's duty to inform must lie on the physician.” (unofficial translation)

Disclosure is the physician's principal duty; failure to inform gives rise to liability in itself

Court of Cassation

“… in the light of the foregoing, the duty to inform must be accepted as resting principally on the physician. … As accepted also by the first-instance court, the duty to inform was not discharged, and the defendant physician must be held liable for that failure …” (unofficial translation)

An aesthetic procedure is a works contract; the physician guarantees the result

Court of Cassation

“In the present case, the legal relationship between the claimant and the defendant covering the aesthetic intervention is in the nature of a works contract; by its nature it differs from the mandate contract relating to treatment carried out for medical necessity between physician and patient, and the provisions of the works contract must be applied. … by the very nature of the works contract the contractor guarantees the result. As for complications, the duty to inform and the correct management of the complication are again the contractor's responsibility.” (unofficial translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

My treatment ended badly; is every adverse outcome malpractice?

No. Adverse outcomes that may arise despite compliance with the rules and requirements of medicine are complications and, as a rule, do not give rise to liability. Liability requires faulty conduct of the physician contrary to the duty of care, a loss, and a causal link between them. Even where there is a complication, the physician's duty to inform beforehand and to manage the process correctly continues.

I signed a consent form before the operation; can I still sue?

Yes, you can. Mere “consent” is not enough; the risks, complications and alternatives of the intervention must have been explained to you in a way you can understand. General/standard forms are not valid informed consent if they do not concretely set out the risks specific to the intervention. The burden of proving that disclosure was duly made lies with the physician.

I was harmed in a public hospital; whom and where do I sue?

In public hospitals there is no contract between patient and physician; the relationship is public-law. The action is therefore brought not against the physician but against the administration, as a full-remedy action before the administrative judiciary. The administrative application and action time-limits also matter; obtain advice early so as not to miss the deadline.

Which court is competent for a private hospital or an aesthetic procedure?

Actions against a private hospital/independent physician mostly fall within the jurisdiction of the consumer court. As aesthetic procedures are treated as a works contract, where the result is not achieved the defect provisions of the works contract (price reduction, remedy, damages) apply.

If the physician has compulsory insurance, can I recover from the insurer?

Compulsory Financial Liability Insurance for Medical Malpractice (Law No. 1219, Additional Art. 12) is mandatory for physicians. Where the conditions are met, the loss may be covered from this insurance within the policy limits; disputes in which the insurer is a party are heard, owing to their commercial nature, in a separate judicial branch.

How is the existence of fault determined?

Whether the medical practice complied with the rules and whether there was fault is, as a rule, determined by expert examination (panels from the Forensic Medicine Institution and/or relevant specialist departments of universities). Medical records, discharge summaries, images and consent documents are therefore very important as evidence.

Within Health Law, Çapar Law Office handles claims for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages arising from medical malpractice, the assessment of breaches of informed consent and the duty of care, and applications relating to compulsory professional liability insurance.

Related Articles

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Health Law

All Health Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “The Physician's Liability in Medical Malpractice”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/physicians-liability-medical-malpractice

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›