Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 26 min read

Last reviewed:

Damages for Delayed Healthcare in Turkish Prisons: Jurisdiction, Time Limits, Service Fault and Interest

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, the State must provide examination and treatment to convicts and remand prisoners in its custody; late provision of this service may constitute service fault and give rise to a full-remedy action. On jurisdiction, however, there are two lines in the 10th Chamber of the Council of State: in one case based on a delayed hospital referral the ordinary courts were held competent (by majority), while the same Chamber continues to examine on the merits claims based on fault in the operation of the health service. Before suing, an application must be made to the administration within one year of learning of the damage and in any event within five years of the action; after a rejection or thirty days of silence, the action must be brought within sixty days. Heads of damage must be claimed separately and by name. Under a decision of the Council of State Assembly for the Unification of Judgments, interest runs on an increased amount from the same date as on the amount originally claimed. Since the files in the reversed cases cited here return to the regional administrative courts for a new decision, their outcomes may not yet be final.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, harm caused by delayed examination, treatment or hospital referral in a penal institution is claimed through a full-remedy action against the administration: the ordinary and administrative court divide, the one-year application and sixty-day action time limits, service fault, heads of damage, non-pecuniary damages and interest.

Full-remedy actions in Türkiye for harm caused by delayed examination, treatment or hospital referral in a penal institution: jurisdiction, time limits, service fault, heads of damage, non-pecuniary damages and interest.

A person held in a penal institution can reach health care only through the institution. When, for example, a convict whose request for an urgent examination goes unanswered for hours, or whose hospital referral is postponed, suffers lasting harm because of the delay, neither the person nor the family usually knows which court to turn to, within what time and for what. This article explains the framework under Turkish law on the basis of current legislation and decisions of the Council of State (Danıştay).

What Is the Right to Health in a Penal Institution and the Administration’s Liability?

The Turkish Constitution secures everyone’s right to life and to protect and develop their material and spiritual existence (Constitution art. 17) and charges the State with ensuring that everyone leads their life in physical and mental health (Constitution art. 56). Because a person deprived of liberty cannot reach health care by his or her own means, timely provision of that care is the responsibility of the administration running the penal institution.

The remedy for harm caused by a breach of this duty is a full-remedy action (tam yargı davası) against the administration. The administration’s liability is as a rule based on service fault: the service not operating at all, operating badly or operating late. Delayed access to health care is a typical example of the last category; there is no need to identify an individual official at fault.

Legal Basis

The constitutional basis of the administration’s duty to compensate is as follows:

Constitutional Provision — Constitution of the Republic of Türkiye (Law No. 2709) art. 125 (final paragraph) (unofficial translation)

“The administration shall be liable to compensate for damage arising from its own acts and actions.”

The exercise of the right to health is regulated in Law No. 5275:

Statutory Provision — Law on the Execution of Penalties and Security Measures (Law No. 5275) art. 71/1 (Requests of convicts for examination and treatment) (unofficial translation)

“(1) A convict has the right to benefit from examination and treatment facilities and medical equipment for the protection of his or her physical and mental health and for the diagnosis of illnesses. For this purpose, the convict shall be treated first in the institution’s infirmary and, where this is not possible, in the prisoners’ wards of State or university hospitals.”

Statutory Provision — Law on the Execution of Penalties and Security Measures (Law No. 5275) art. 78/1-2 (Examination and treatment of convicts) (unofficial translation)

“(1) The organisation of health conditions in the institution and the emergency or ordinary examination and treatment of the convict shall be carried out by the institution’s physician. The results of all examinations and treatments carried out generally or because of illness shall be entered on the health monitoring card and kept in the convict’s file.

(2) The Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Labour and Social Security and the health institutions of universities are responsible for providing the necessary assistance for the treatment of convicts.”

Statutory Provision — Law on the Execution of Penalties and Security Measures (Law No. 5275) art. 80 (Referral to hospital) (unofficial translation)

“(1) Where the referral of a convict to hospital for health reasons is considered necessary, the institution’s physician shall immediately notify the management of the penal institution of the situation by a report.”

Those of these provisions that are “compatible with the status of remand detention” may also be applied to remand prisoners (Law No. 5275 art. 116/1). The obligation to enter examination results on the health monitoring card makes that card an important source of evidence in a later action. The enforcement judge (infaz hâkimliği), for its part, examines complaints about “having their medical examinations and treatment carried out for the protection of their physical and mental health” and about referrals (Law No. 4675 on Enforcement Judges art. 4); this route is decisive in the debate on jurisdiction.

Competent Courts: Ordinary or Administrative?

As regards health care in penal institutions, two approaches can be seen in the 10th Chamber of the Council of State.

The ordinary-court approach. In a case brought on the allegation that a person held in remand after conviction died because his referral to hospital was delayed although he had fallen ill, the Chamber reversed the judgments on the merits for lack of jurisdiction, relying on the enforcement and complaint system of Laws No. 5275 and 4675:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2021/4240, K. 2025/1114, 25.02.2025 (the Chamber’s reversal reasoning on jurisdiction; alleged delay in hospital referral; majority decision)

“… considering that the claim for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages arises from the allegation that the defendant administration was at service fault because referral to hospital was delayed despite the illness having been reported to it, the dispute, which concerns the execution of the sentence, must be resolved within the framework of private-law provisions under the legislation cited above, and it is understood that its resolution falls within the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts.”

The dissenting opinion, by contrast, held the administrative courts competent:

Council of State Decision (dissenting opinion)

“… since it is understood that the question whether the administration was at service fault in this dispute falls within the jurisdiction of the administrative courts, I do not agree with the Chamber’s contrary decision, being of the opinion that a decision should be given by examining the merits of the dispute.”

The administrative-court approach. After that decision the same Chamber continued to examine on the merits, without discussing jurisdiction, cases concerning supervision and health care. In a case alleging that treatment was not provided in time, it found the non-pecuniary damages too low and reversed the regional administrative court (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/2652, K. 2025/4344, 08.10.2025); it treated the failure to provide the necessary supervision and medical control in the face of a known risk as service fault (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/1068, K. 2025/6230, 18.12.2025); and in a death in which safety in the institution had not been ensured, it upheld the part concerning non-pecuniary damages (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/4396, K. 2025/6228, 18.12.2025).

In practice. The decisions do not clearly set out a criterion separating the two lines. In the ordinary-court decision the harm was attributed to the delay of a referral and the dispute was seen as one “concerning the execution of the sentence”; in the cases examined on the merits the claim rests on a malfunction in the operation of the service. The petition should therefore show that the harm rests not on a single enforcement act but on concrete shortcomings such as unanswered calls, absence of health staff, incomplete examination and failure to keep records. If an action brought before the ordinary courts is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, no prior application to the administration is required for the later administrative action (Law No. 2577 art. 13/2); interest then runs from the date of the action before the non-competent ordinary court (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2021/623, K. 2025/3285, 26.06.2025).

Time Limits: Prior Application, Date of Learning and Sixty Days

No action can be brought directly for harm caused by an administrative action; an application must first be made to the administration:

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 13/1 (Bringing a full-remedy action directly) (unofficial translation)

“Persons whose rights have been infringed by administrative actions must, before bringing an administrative action, apply to the administration concerned for redress within one year of learning of such actions through written notification or otherwise, and in any event within five years of the date of the action. If these requests are rejected in whole or in part, or if no reply is given within thirty days, an action may be brought within the time limit for bringing an action, starting from the day following notification of the decision on the request or from the expiry of that period.”

Failure to reply within thirty days counts as an implied rejection; this period was reduced from sixty to thirty days by Law No. 7331, and a transitional provision preserves the former period for applications made before the amendment (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2021/7253, K. 2024/6092, 11.12.2024). The time limit for bringing an action before the administrative courts is sixty days (Law No. 2577 art. 7).

When is bodily harm “learned”?

For bodily harm, the Council of State as a rule treats the date of learning as the date on which the final medical report is obtained:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2021/7411, K. 2024/3886, 09.10.2024 (the Chamber’s reversal reasoning; dismissals for being out of time were reversed)

“It is the settled case law of the Council of State that bodily harm caused by administrative actions is deemed to have been learned on the date when the treatment process is completed and the final medical report is obtained, and that the time limit laid down in the Law must start to run on the date when the final report is given to the person concerned. … It is clear that calculating the time limit in a way that eliminates the right of action, which becomes exercisable when the damage emerges, would be incompatible with the freedom to seek legal remedies.”

On the same approach, faced with reports valid for two years and not of a permanent nature, the Chamber reversed a judgment that had started the time limit from an earlier report (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2020/5188, K. 2023/5923, 25.10.2023). By contrast, for an injury whose harm was apparent at the time of the incident, it treated it as “indisputable” that the one-year period ran from the date of the incident (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2021/7253, K. 2024/6092, 11.12.2024). The final-report criterion therefore does not apply automatically; the nature of the harm is decisive.

The link attributing the action to the administration may also emerge later, for example through criminal proceedings. In such a case the Council of State required the one-year period to start from the date on which the decisions in the criminal case became final; it also stated, however, that preclusive time limits are to be applied “maintaining the balance between the freedom to seek legal remedies and the principle of administrative stability”, and that for continuing harm an action may be brought only for harm occurring or learned within one year before the application (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/4950, K. 2023/6676, 08.11.2023). It is safer to work from the earliest possible date than to rely on a late start of the period.

Application in time, action out of time: a common mistake

Applying to the administration in time is not enough. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State upheld the dismissal of an action as out of time where the application had been made in time but the time limit for suing after the implied rejection was missed:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2020/4072, K. 2022/4022, 10.06.2022 (the Chamber’s reasoned upholding decision; majority decision)

“… in order to bring an action for compensation of damage arising from an action or act of the administration, it is not sufficient to make the mandatory application to the administration within the time limit laid down in the Law; the action must be brought within the general time limit for bringing an action following the partial or full rejection or the implied rejection of the application.”

Service Fault and Contributory Fault

The Council of State treats late operation of the service and failure to keep medical records as service fault. In a case where a convict who had fallen ill was given only a painkiller before the team left, the Chamber’s own reasoning reads:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2019/10300, K. 2021/1336, 23.03.2021 (the Chamber’s reversal reasoning; majority decision)

“Service fault, which may be defined as an objective defect, malfunction or gap in the establishment, organisation or operation of a service that the administration is charged with providing, occurs where the service operates badly, operates late or does not operate at all, and gives rise to the administration’s obligation to compensate. … that the failure to keep the documents relating to the treatment applied to the claimants’ deceased relative (ECG, vital signs and other physical examination findings) constitutes service fault, … since the failure to produce the medical records and documents relating to the ECG also prevents the judicial review that could establish whether the administration is liable for the damage … that the Ministry of Health is also liable …”

The Chamber accepted that the administration providing the health service was also liable, but found the non-pecuniary damages increased by the regional administrative court too high.

In a case where, because no physician was present at the weekend, blood pressure was measured by a convict working in the infirmary and the referral could not be made because the institution’s ambulance had no assigned driver, service fault was found by the first-instance court; the Council of State upheld the part concerning the merits of pecuniary damages and found the non-pecuniary damages too low (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2019/10745, K. 2023/5840, 23.10.2023).

On a failure of supervision regarding a remand prisoner whose risk was known, the Chamber concluded:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/1068, K. 2025/6230, 18.12.2025 (the Chamber’s reversal reasoning on non-pecuniary damages)

“It is clear that the right to life has a more particular importance for convicts and remand prisoners and persons in custody, since these persons are under the control and supervision of the State and, given this vulnerable situation, must be protected more effectively as regards the right to life. … it has been concluded that, because the prison authorities were not more attentive and careful and did not ensure that he was kept under more effective and strict supervision and medical control than other prisoners, the defendant Ministry of Justice was negligent in the occurrence of the incident and was therefore at service fault.”

Contributory fault

The administration may seek a reduction by arguing that the person’s own conduct also contributed to the harm. In a case where the risk was foreseeable and no measures were taken, the Council of State found a fifty per cent reduction inequitable:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2024/6224, K. 2025/1927, 09.04.2025 (the Chamber’s reversal reasoning; majority decision)

“… it is concluded that, since a situation foreseeable by the administration existed and the measures that should have been taken until placement in the crowded ward were not taken, so that sufficient care and diligence were not shown, the administration’s service fault in the incident is complete, and that making a deduction from the calculated compensation on the ground that the deceased was 50% contributorily at fault is not equitable.”

Conversely, in a case where the harm arose largely from the person’s own conduct, it being accepted that the convict had obtained and used illegal drugs through unlawful means, the Chamber found it lawful to hold the administration thirty per cent and the deceased convict seventy per cent at fault (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2024/3808, K. 2024/4994, 18.11.2024).

Heads of Damage

The Turkish Code of Obligations lists bodily harm as treatment costs, loss of earnings, losses arising from reduced or lost working capacity and losses arising from impaired economic prospects (Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 54). The Council of State Assembly for the Unification of Judgments has described the tort provisions of the Code of Obligations (art. 49 et seq.) as a “framework norm”; the administrative courts draw on them by analogy when calculating bodily harm. In practice the following heads are claimed separately:

  • past and future treatment, medication and medical device costs,
  • transport and accompanying-person costs,
  • temporary and permanent carer costs,
  • temporary incapacity (loss of earnings),
  • permanent incapacity, that is loss of working capacity (effort),
  • loss arising from impaired economic prospects,
  • where necessary, costs of adapting a home and a vehicle,
  • in case of death, loss-of-support compensation and documented funeral costs.

While accepting that loss of effort is compensable even without loss of income but capped at the net minimum wage, the Council of State held that awarding a head not claimed in the petition exceeds the claim:

Council of State Decision

“It is undoubted that, as a result of the incident, the claimant will carry on daily life and work by expending more effort. However, it has been accepted in the case law of our Chamber that the pecuniary damage arising from this additional effort will amount at most to the net minimum wage. … awarding compensation for temporary carer costs in favour of the claimant is not legally correct, since, given that the claimant made no such request in the statement of claim, ruling on this would exceed the claimant’s request.”

In the same decision, the loss-of-earnings and treatment-cost heads, which had been claimed but not ruled upon, could no longer be examined because the claimant had not appealed.

For a person without income no temporary-incapacity loss arises, and the rate of lost working capacity is determined under the regulation in force at the date of the incident:

Council of State Decision

“… whereas the claimant’s rate of loss of working capacity should have been determined under the … Regulation in force on the date of the incident … Compensation for temporary incapacity is limited to the ‘treatment and recovery period’, during which working capacity is accepted as being lost at a rate of 100% because it cannot be used, and it aims to make good the loss of earnings suffered by a person who was working before the incident because he or she cannot continue working.”

The whole-body functional loss rate in disability health board reports and the rate of lost working capacity used to calculate damages are not always determined by the same criteria; which rate was determined under which regulation should be checked separately at the expert stage.

A particular risk for convicts and remand prisoners

For loss-of-support compensation in case of death, the Council of State took as the start of support not the date of conditional release but “the date on which release upon full service of the sentence will take place”, reversing a contrary calculation in favour of the administration (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/4396, K. 2025/6228, 18.12.2025). In a death in which service fault was accepted, the dismissal of the pecuniary claim was also found lawful in its outcome on the ground that the deceased could not have provided support by earning an income (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/1068, K. 2025/6230, 18.12.2025). Although these decisions concern support calculations, it should be borne in mind that the release date may also be disputed in the loss-of-earnings claim of a surviving convict.

Non-Pecuniary Damages and Costs

Non-pecuniary damages aim to alleviate, at least in part, the grief and suffering endured. The Council of State requires the amount to be balanced for both claimant and defendant:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/2652, K. 2025/4344, 08.10.2025 (the Chamber’s reversal reasoning; alleged delay in treatment)

“… it is clear that, in assessing non-pecuniary damages, care must be taken that, for the claimant, the amount is sufficient to provide a sense of moral satisfaction and to offset the effect and weight on the person of the grief and suffering caused by the harmful administrative activity, and, for the defendant, that it is at a reasonable level that does not exceed the bounds of equity, is proportionate, strikes a fair balance and does not create an excessive financial burden.”

Here the Chamber found the regional administrative court’s amount too low and the first-instance amount reasonable, reversed and sent the file back; in the case on lack of supervision the amount awarded was also found too low (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/1068, K. 2025/6230, 18.12.2025). On the other hand, the Chamber has also found an increased amount too high, stating that it should be “far from excessive” (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2019/10300, K. 2021/1336, 23.03.2021). The amount is discretionary and cannot be predicted in advance.

Costs where non-pecuniary damages are partly rejected

On costs, administrative procedure refers to the Code of Civil Procedure. Its rule that costs are divided according to the extent to which each party succeeds (Law No. 6100 art. 326/2) was annulled by the Constitutional Court as regards actions for non-pecuniary damages:

Constitutional Court Decision
Constitutional Court, E. 2024/29, K. 2024/226, 25.12.2024 (annulment on referral by courts; majority decision; Official Gazette 14.03.2025, No. 32841)

“… in principle it is not possible for the claimant in an action for non-pecuniary damages to foresee to what extent the claim brought before the court will be found justified. … For the reason explained, the rule is contrary to Articles 13 and 36 of the Constitution in respect of … It must be annulled.”

The annulment took effect nine months after publication in the Official Gazette, on 14.12.2025. Applying it, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State holds that no costs or attorney’s fees may be awarded against the claimant for the rejected part of a non-pecuniary claim (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/1068, K. 2025/6230, 18.12.2025). The annulment concerns non-pecuniary damages only; as the proportionality rule still applies to pecuniary damages, an unrealistic claim carries a risk of attorney’s fees.

Interest and Increasing the Amount Claimed

Because the amount of damages often becomes clear only after the expert examination, an action may be brought for a stated amount and increased later:

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 16/4 (Notification and reply) (unofficial translation)

“… However, in full-remedy actions, the amount stated in the statement of claim may be increased once only, until the final judgment, upon payment of the fee and irrespective of the time limit or other procedural rules, and the petition increasing the amount shall be notified to the opposing party for a reply within thirty days.”

Council of State decisions conflicted on the date from which interest runs on the increased part; some took the date on which the increase petition was notified to the administration, others the date on which it was registered with the court, and others the same date as for the amount originally claimed. The conflict was resolved as follows:

Council of State Assembly for the Unification of Judgments Decision

“… the claimant’s intention in bringing the action is, from the outset, compensation for the actual damage, and this intention also covers the part that was uncertain when the action was brought. … it was decided by majority on 24/10/2024 to unify the case law to the effect that, in full-remedy actions seeking compensation with interest for damage arising from administrative acts or actions, where the amount is increased, interest must be awarded on the increased amount from the same date as that from which interest is awarded on the amount claimed in the statement of claim.”

Since that decision the 10th Chamber has been reversing judgments that ran interest on the increased part from the notification date, and requires interest on the whole amount from the date of the application to the administration (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2021/623, K. 2025/3285, 26.06.2025). The Chamber had reached this result before the unification decision as well, in the case concerning the absence of a physician in a penal institution (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2019/10745, K. 2023/5840, 23.10.2023).

As a result, in full-remedy actions within the scope of the decision, claiming pecuniary damages at a low figure and increasing it after the expert report should no longer postpone the start of interest on the increased part. Because the increased part follows the interest start date of the original claim, it is important to request interest expressly in the statement of claim together with its start date; the right to increase may be used only once.

Practical Points

  • Dates: record the dates of the incident, the first health request, the referral and the final report, and the date and number of the application to the administration.
  • Application and action time limits: apply to the administration within one year of learning and in any event within five years of the action; if no reply comes within thirty days, the sixty-day time limit for bringing the action starts to run; do not wait for a late reply.
  • Service fault: show concretely unanswered calls, absence of a physician or health staff, incomplete examination, failure to keep records and delays in the referral chain; do not reduce the account to a single enforcement act.
  • Defendants: besides the administration to which the institution belongs, the liability of the administration providing the health service may also arise.
  • Heads of damage: claim every head, including carer costs, separately and by name; appeal where a head is not ruled upon.
  • Interest: request interest in the statement of claim from the date of the application to the administration; the amount may be increased once only, until the final judgment.
  • Evidence: ask early for the health monitoring card, infirmary records, call and duty logs, referral documents, ambulance and camera records to be obtained; where the access problem continues, also consider a complaint to the enforcement judge.

Frequently Asked Questions

In which court is an action brought for a convict or remand prisoner whose treatment in prison was delayed?

As a rule, a full-remedy action is brought before the administrative court. However, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State, treating the dispute as one concerning the execution of the sentence, held the ordinary courts competent in a case based on a delayed hospital referral; the same Chamber continues to examine on the merits cases based on fault in supervision and in the operation of the health service.

What are the time limits for applying to the administration and bringing an action?

An application must be made to the administration within one year of learning of the damage and in any event within five years of the date of the action. For bodily harm, the date of learning is as a rule the date on which the final report is obtained; for injuries whose harm was apparent at the time of the incident, the period runs from the date of the incident. If the administration does not reply within thirty days, the request is deemed rejected and the action must be brought within sixty days.

Which heads of damage may be claimed?

Treatment, medication and device costs, transport and accompanying-person costs, carer costs, temporary incapacity, loss of working capacity (effort), impaired economic prospects and, in case of death, loss of support may be claimed; non-pecuniary damages are claimed separately. Awarding a head that was not claimed is treated as exceeding the claim.

Do I lose interest if I increase the amount claimed later?

Under the decision of the Council of State Assembly for the Unification of Judgments, interest runs on the increased amount from the same date as on the amount in the statement of claim, as a rule the date of the application to the administration. The increase may be made once only, until the final judgment.

Do I pay attorney’s fees if part of my non-pecuniary claim is rejected?

The Constitutional Court annulled the rule dividing costs according to the extent of success as regards actions for non-pecuniary damages. The 10th Chamber of the Council of State therefore holds that no costs or attorney’s fees may be awarded against the claimant for the rejected part of a non-pecuniary claim. The proportionality rule still applies to pecuniary damages.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Administrative Law

All Administrative Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Damages for Delayed Healthcare in Turkish Prisons: Jurisdiction, Time Limits, Service Fault and Interest”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-06, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/delayed-prison-healthcare-state-liability-claim-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›