Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 34 min read

Last reviewed:

Challenging a Refusal of Veteran or Martyr Status in Türkiye: Disability, Laws No. 3713 and 2330, Time Limits

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: The rights attached to “martyr” and “veteran” status do not flow from a single decision; they depend on separate administrative acts concerning distinct statuses such as service or war disability, a link to counter-terrorism duty and cash compensation. As a rule, an action against these acts is brought before the administrative courts within sixty days of written notification (Law No. 2577 art. 7). However, service-disability disputes between the Social Security Institution (SGK) and personnel first insured as public servants after 2008 are heard by the labour courts (Law No. 5510 art. 101). For service-disability claims concerning conscripts who died during military service, the Court of Cassation upheld in 2026 a judgment holding that the administrative courts have jurisdiction (Court of Cassation, 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/17254, K. 2026/5972, 29.04.2026). For those injured in counter-terrorism duty but not classified as disabled, Law No. 3713 Provisional art. 20, added by Law No. 7594, introduced a new monthly payment for incidents before 18.08.2026, subject to a one-year application window.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Challenging refusals of service-disability, martyr or veteran status in Türkiye: Laws No. 3713, 2330, 5510 and 5434, the 2026 amendments by Law No. 7594, administrative versus labour courts, time limits and case law.

A guide to challenging a refusal of martyr (şehit) or veteran (gazi) status in Türkiye: service and war disability (Law No. 5510 art. 47), death and injury in counter-terrorism duty (Law No. 3713 art. 21), the 15 July veteran title, cash compensation, the 2026 amendments made by Law No. 7594, the line between administrative and labour courts, territorial jurisdiction, time limits, full-remedy actions, decisions of the Council of State and the Court of Cassation, and the Constitutional Court and ECtHR dimension.

When the family of someone who died on duty is told that the death “does not qualify as service disability”, or an injured officer is told that the incident “falls outside counter-terrorism duty” or that “a martyrdom certificate cannot be issued”, it is often unclear which authority decided what, and where and within what time an objection must be lodged. This article brings together the current legislation and the case law.

What “Martyr” and “Veteran” Mean in Law

The word “martyr” appears in some statutes; Law No. 3713 art. 22, for example, refers to covering the education costs of “children of martyrs” from the Social Assistance and Solidarity Fund. Yet the pensions, compensation, employment and social rights granted to martyrs’ families and veterans are tied not to the word itself but to specific statutory statuses. In a case examined by the Constitutional Court, the administrative court likewise noted that there is no statutory definition of martyrdom and assessed the request within the rights under service disability and Laws No. 2330 and 3713 (Constitutional Court, Mustafa İlter and Saime İlter, App. No. 2021/5840, 14.01.2025).

What is described as “not being recognised as a martyr or veteran” therefore usually corresponds in law to one of the acts listed below. Each is a separate administrative act and may be the subject of a separate action; rights such as a martyrdom certificate, the State Medal of Honour, public employment (Law No. 3713 Additional art. 1) and identification cards also mostly depend on one of these statuses. The proper court must be determined in each case according to the social security regime applicable to the person.

StatusLegal basisDeciding authorityCommon ground for refusalCourt
Service disability (persons first insured as public servants after 2008)Law No. 5510 art. 47SGK (Service Disability Determination Board)Incident outside duty; statutory exclusions such as attempted suicideLabour court
Service disability (Law No. 5434 regime; conscripts under arms and reserve officer cadets)Law No. 5434 art. 56SGKNo causal link with dutyAdministrative court
War disability (war, internal pacification and border operations, overseas duty)Law No. 5510 art. 47; repealed Law No. 5434 art. 64SGKInjury not caused by such operationsDepends on the person’s regime
Counter-terrorism coverageLaw No. 3713 art. 21SGK; for civilians, the Cash Compensation CommissionIncident not a terrorist act or not linked to counter-terrorism dutyAdministrative court
Cash compensation (internal security, smuggling, traffic, explosives disposal, forest fires)Law No. 2330 art. 2Ministry Cash Compensation CommissionDuty outside the scope of the LawAdministrative court
Terrorism-related injuries not classified as disabilityLaw No. 3713 Additional art. 3 and Provisional art. 20Institution of service at the time and SGKInjury below the statutory threshold or no causal linkAdministrative court as a rule
15 July veteran titleLaw No. 7082 art. 14Ministry of Family and Social ServicesNo link with the coup attempt or its continuationAdministrative court

Legal Basis and the 2026 Amendments

The core provision for terrorism-related deaths and injuries is Law No. 3713 art. 21. It applies the Cash Compensation Law (No. 2330) to public servants targeted by terrorist acts because of their duties, and it also covers accidents while travelling to and from such duties and incidents involving explosives.

Statutory Provision — Anti-Terror Law (Law No. 3713) art. 21 (Assistance) (unofficial translation)

“… public servants who, while performing their duties at home or abroad, or because of having performed those duties even after their capacity has ended, are wounded, become disabled, die or are killed as targets of terrorist acts shall be subject to the provisions of Law No. 2330 on Cash Compensation and Monthly Pensions. … Public servants and persons within subparagraphs (h) and (j) of the first paragraph who are wounded, become disabled, fall ill or lose their lives as a result of incidents involving any kind of explosive substance for the purpose of preventing terrorist incidents, or as a result of accidents occurring in whatever manner during duties performed to prevent, pursue or neutralise terrorist incidents or while travelling to and from such duties, shall benefit from the provisions of the first paragraph appropriate to their situation.”

The article also provides that the pension of disabled persons and of the widows and orphans of the deceased may not be lower than that of serving counterparts, that a retirement bonus is paid as if thirty years had been served, and it regulates ten years’ use of public housing or rent support and medical expenses. Separate rules apply to conscripts and village guards (subparagraph h), military and police cadets (subparagraph i) and civilians who helped uncover a terrorist act (subparagraph j); the civilians’ position is decided by the Cash Compensation Commission on the governor’s proposal. For deaths in duties covered by Law No. 2330, the legal heirs receive cash compensation equal to one hundred times the highest gross civil-service salary (Law No. 2330 art. 3), and pensions are increased by twenty-five per cent (Law No. 2330 art. 4).

For service disability during military service, Law No. 5434 art. 56 remains in force; Law No. 5510 art. 47 also refers to persons found to be service-disabled under that article.

Statutory Provision — Civil Servants’ Pension Fund Law (Law No. 5434) art. 56 (Service disability of conscripts) (unofficial translation)

“Where regular, reserve and volunteer privates become service-disabled while under arms or while being dispatched on call-up or discharge (including free dispatch), and reserve officer and reserve non-commissioned officer cadets either at school or in the preparatory unit before school, they shall be granted a monthly pension, according to their education, …”

One of the provisions expressly regulating “veteran” as a title concerns the coup attempt of 15 July 2016. The veteran title is granted regardless of the degree of injury; the procedure is set by the Ministry of Family and Social Services (named in the text by its former title, the Ministry of Family and Social Policies).

Statutory Provision — Law on the Adoption of the Decree-Law on Certain Measures under the State of Emergency (Law No. 7082) art. 14 (Persons granted the veteran title) (unofficial translation)

“(1) Public servants and civilians who became disabled because of the coup attempt and terrorist act carried out on 15/7/2016 and acts constituting its continuation, and public servants and civilians who were wounded while helping and being useful in uncovering, mitigating or eliminating the effects of acts constituting the continuation of those acts, shall be granted the veteran title regardless of the degree of injury. The procedures and principles for the implementation of this paragraph shall be determined by the Ministry of Family and Social Policies.”

Amendments made by Law No. 7594 (Official Gazette, 18.08.2026)

Law No. 7594 on Amendments to Certain Laws, adopted on 9 August 2026 and published in Official Gazette No. 33344 of 18 August 2026, contains the latest changes in this field:

  1. A new paragraph added to Law No. 3713 art. 21 sets a floor for pensions under subparagraphs (h), (i) and (j): the pension may not be lower than the service-disability pension calculated by reference to the first step of the eighth grade for graduates of at least four-year higher education and of the tenth grade for others, nor, in total, lower than the product of indicator 35,398 and the civil-service salary coefficient.
  2. The degree indicators in Law No. 3713 Additional art. 3 were updated (27,288 for the first degree, 17,820 for the sixth), and recipients of that pension who fall outside Law No. 7082 art. 14 now benefit, except as regards pensions, from the other rights granted to persons covered by Law No. 1005.
  3. The new Law No. 3713 Provisional art. 20 grants SGK a pension based on indicator 17,135 to military personnel (including conscripts), National Intelligence Organisation members, Security Services Class police officers and security guards who, during counter-terrorism duty, suffered injuries that are not minor under Forensic Medicine Institute criteria from firearms, explosives or close-combat attacks, with causation established by a medical board including at least one forensic medicine specialist, but who were not classified as disabled or given a degree; they also benefit from the other rights under Law No. 1005. It applies once, only to incidents before its entry into force, and the application must be made within one year of entry into force to the institution of service at the time of the incident.
  4. A second paragraph added to Law No. 7082 art. 14 provides a pension based on indicator 17,135 for those 15 July wounded holding the veteran title who were not classified as disabled or given a degree.
  5. In Law No. 5434 art. 72, the reference limited to the mother or father of conscripts and reserve officer cadets was generalised to “mothers and fathers”, and in Law No. 5434 Additional art. 77 the words “twice” were replaced by “two and a half times”.

The pension and indicator changes entered into force on 18.08.2026 with effect from the following payment period, and the provisional article entered into force on the same date with effect from 01.09.2026. The last day of the one-year window should be confirmed with the receiving institution, and the application should not be left to the last day.

The Constitutional Court’s annulment concerning cash compensation

The words “and non-pecuniary” in the provision governing the effect of cash compensation in full-remedy actions were annulled by the Constitutional Court, with effect from 21.08.2025 (Constitutional Court, E. 2024/15, K. 2024/159, 24.09.2024). The current text reads as follows; the gaps mark the annulled words:

Statutory Provision — Law on Cash Compensation and Monthly Pensions (Law No. 2330) art. 6 (Effect of cash compensation and pension) (unofficial translation)

“The cash compensation to be paid and the pension to be granted under this Law constitute consideration for the pecuniary … damage suffered. In calculating the compensation that institutions are ordered by judicial authorities to pay for pecuniary … damage, the cash compensation paid and the pensions granted under this Law shall be taken into account.”

Cash compensation and the pension are now taken into account only as consideration for pecuniary damage. As judgments delivered before the annulment took effect may reflect a different calculation, the text applicable to pending cases should be assessed separately.

Requirements and Typical Grounds for Refusal

For personnel covered by Law No. 5510, the definition of service disability and its exclusions are set out below. Under the Law No. 5434 regime, the repealed Law No. 5434 art. 45 and art. 48, as quoted in Council of State decisions, laid down the same criteria and exclusions in similar terms.

Statutory Provision — Social Insurance and General Health Insurance Law (Law No. 5510) art. 47 (Service disability) (unofficial translation)

“For persons insured for the first time under subparagraph (c) of the first paragraph of article 4 after the entry into force of this Law, the provisions on service disability shall apply in the following cases. Where the disability referred to in article 25 arises from work performed by the insured persons while carrying out their duties, or while doing other work for any public administration to which they were assigned by their administration outside their duties, or while doing work to protect the interests of their institution, or from an accident occurring while commuting to and from work in a vehicle provided by their administration or at the workplace, this is called service disability and those affected are called service-disabled. Service disability provisions shall not apply to persons whose disability arises from: a) use of intoxicating drinks and substances of any kind, b) acting contrary to legislation and orders, … c) committing prohibited acts, d) attempted suicide, e) the aim of obtaining a benefit for, or causing harm to, oneself or others in any way.”

Occurrence during duty and under its influence

Most refusals rest on the absence of a causal link with duty. The Council of State requires that the disability arise both during duty and under its influence, but it does not interpret this narrowly. In the decision quoted below, the death of a physician from an aortic rupture under heavy workload and the stress of a night shift was held to have been caused and influenced by duty.

Accidents and travel to duty

Law No. 5510 art. 47 covers commuting only when made “in a vehicle provided by the administration”. The Court of Cassation therefore held that the conditions were not met for a police officer who, having finished his shift and obtained leave, died in an accident while driving home in his own car, and reversed the judgment that had upheld the claim (Court of Cassation, 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/10244, K. 2024/3375, 28.03.2024). In counter-terrorism duty, by contrast, Law No. 3713 art. 21 expressly covers accidents while travelling to and from duty; the decision concerning an officer who fell ill after operations and had an accident while returning from hospital to his unit is quoted below.

Illness

Illnesses arising or worsening during duty may also amount to service disability. In such cases the period for notifying SGK runs from the approval date of the final report stating that treatment is impossible (Law No. 5510 art. 47). The Council of State likewise held that an officer diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder after counter-terrorism operations learned of the damage and the causal link at the latest through the medical report establishing final disability, and reversed a time-bar ruling (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2017/2931, K. 2022/3448, 22.06.2022).

Suicide

Because disability resulting from attempted suicide is excluded by law, applications concerning suicides during military service are usually refused. The Council of State upheld a refusal concerning a conscript with several suicide attempts and psychiatric diagnoses, where the lower court found that keeping him on duty instead of discharging him might amount to service fault but did not by itself trigger service-disability provisions (Council of State, 12th Chamber, E. 2023/876, K. 2023/3660, 22.06.2023). Conversely, it upheld the annulment of a refusal where a corporal detained the previous day for drugs and returned to barracks at night was put on armed guard duty without medical examination and took his own life on that duty, on grounds of service fault and the unity of the administration (Council of State, 12th Chamber, E. 2018/5451, K. 2021/6517, 09.12.2021). Where the cause of death has not been clarified, a refusal based on an assumption of suicide or accident may also be unlawful.

Terrorist character and link to counter-terrorism duty

Law No. 3713 art. 21 requires that the person be targeted by a terrorist act because of duty, or that the incident be linked to the prevention, pursuit or neutralisation of terrorist incidents. For civilians, it further requires that they helped uncover or mitigate a terrorist act and a decision of the Cash Compensation Commission; without these, a death caused by a terrorist act does not by itself give rise to a pension under that article. Council of State files include cases where the administration characterised the incident as a “training accident” or “anti-smuggling work”; that characterisation is subject to judicial review in the light of the location, purpose of the duty and conditions of the region.

Degree of disability and the medical board report

Disability and its degree are determined under the Regulation on the Types and Degrees of Service Disabilities put into force by Council of Ministers Decision No. 4/1053. Where a person injured in a terrorist act is not classified as disabled but a degree is determined under that Regulation, a pension is granted under Law No. 3713 Additional art. 3; if no degree is determined either, the new route under the provisional article becomes relevant. The board that issued the report and the medical records relied on are among the most disputed points.

The Administrative Stage: Notification, Application and Decisions

Under Law No. 5510 art. 47, public administrations must notify the competent authorities immediately and SGK within fifteen working days of an incident causing service disability; the insured or the beneficiaries may also notify. Where notification is late, a pension is granted on subsequent notification provided service disability is documented, subject to the limitation rules. SGK’s decision is in practice taken by its Service Disability Determination Board.

Other statuses involve different authorities. Cash compensation is decided by the Cash Compensation Commission within the relevant ministry; Council of State decisions show the Ministry of National Defence Cash Compensation Commission deciding on payment to the relatives of a worker killed in a terrorist attack. Martyrdom certificate requests are in practice decided by the relevant force command or the Ministry of National Defence; in the case before the Constitutional Court the refusal was issued by the Land Forces Command Martyrs and Veterans Section. Eligibility for public employment is determined by the Ministry of Family and Social Services and appointments are made by lot. For the provisional article, the institution refers the person to hospitals designated by the Ministry of Health if the injury may qualify; if the free medical board report is positive, the documents are sent to SGK for the pension.

If an application is not answered within thirty days, it is deemed rejected and the time limit for bringing an action starts to run. Dated copies of the application and of notifications should therefore always be kept.

Jurisdiction: Competent Court and Venue

Annulment and full-remedy actions against administrative acts are heard by the administrative courts (Law No. 2577 art. 2). For social security disputes, however, Law No. 5510 sets its own route:

Statutory Provision — Social Insurance and General Health Insurance Law (Law No. 5510) art. 101 (Forum for disputes) (unofficial translation)

“Unless otherwise provided in this Law, disputes arising from the application of the provisions of this Law shall be heard by the labour courts.”

Read together, these rules produce the following practice:

  • Personnel covered by Law No. 5510 art. 47: Service-disability disputes are heard by the labour courts. The Court of Cassation examined on the merits, through this route, a dispute concerning the death of a public servant appointed as a police officer in 2012; according to the claimants, the administrative court had earlier declined jurisdiction (Court of Cassation, 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/10244, K. 2024/3375, 28.03.2024).
  • Conscripts under arms and persons under the Law No. 5434 regime: An action brought before a labour court for recognition of a soldier who died of gunshot wounds while doing military service in 2009 was dismissed on the ground that the dispute belongs to the administrative courts, and the Court of Cassation upheld that judgment (Court of Cassation, 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/17254, K. 2026/5972, 29.04.2026).
  • Acts under Laws No. 3713 and 2330, the veteran title, martyrdom certificates, medals and employment: Actions are brought before the administrative courts.

Choosing the wrong court does not always mean losing the right: where an action before the ordinary courts is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, an action may be brought before the competent administrative court within thirty days of that decision becoming final (Law No. 2577 art. 9).

Abolition of the Supreme Military Administrative Court and venue

The constitutional amendment by Law No. 6771, in force on 27.04.2017, abolished military jurisdiction; cases pending at the Supreme Military Administrative Court at the appeal stage were sent to the Council of State and the rest to the competent administrative courts (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2017/2931, K. 2022/3448, 22.06.2022). Cases concerning military service are now heard by the ordinary administrative courts under a special venue rule:

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 20/C (Disputes concerning military service) (unofficial translation)

“This article applies to disputes arising from administrative acts and actions relating to military service that concern public servants employed in the cadres of the Ministry of National Defence and reserve officers, reserve non-commissioned officers, privates and corporals performing military service under the Military Service Law No. 7179 of 25/6/2019. … The administrative court located where the regional administrative court to which the person’s place of duty is attached for administrative jurisdiction purposes is situated shall have jurisdiction over these disputes.”

The Council of State applied this rule in a case brought against the Ministry of National Defence by a conscript, wounded in a terrorist attack during military service in Şırnak and recognised as service-disabled by court decision, seeking the State Medal of Honour and certificate, and held the Gaziantep Administrative Court competent (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2023/6423, K. 2024/119, 13.02.2024). Outside this rule, for other public servants the court of the last place of duty is competent in cases concerning retirement (Law No. 2577 art. 33), and in full-remedy actions, in order, the court competent for the underlying administrative dispute or the court of the place where the service was performed or the action took place (Law No. 2577 art. 36).

Where annulment of the refusal of a martyrdom certificate and compensation for the death are sought in one petition, the Council of State held that there is no factual or legal connection between the claims and that the petition must be rejected so that the claims are separated (Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/1069, K. 2022/1049, 02.03.2022; Law No. 2577 art. 5). Claiming monetary rights directly linked to the refusal, such as the pension lost, together with the annulment action is, however, possible (Law No. 2577 art. 12).

Which chamber of the Council of State decides?

As far as can be traced from the case references, in 2020–2025 appeals in annulment cases on service disability and under Laws No. 3713 and 2330 were examined by the 12th Chamber of the Council of State, while full-remedy actions arising from such incidents and venue disputes were decided by the 10th Chamber. A 2014 service-disability decision was given by the 11th Chamber. Conflicts between regional administrative court decisions go to the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers (Law No. 2576 art. 3/C). As the division of work between chambers may change over time, the period and chamber of any earlier decision relied on should be noted.

Time Limits, Prior Application and Stay of Execution

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 7 (Time limit for bringing an action) (unofficial translation)

“Unless a different time limit is set in special laws, the time limit for bringing an action is sixty days before the Council of State and the administrative courts and thirty days before the tax courts. … These time limits begin: a) in administrative disputes, on the day following the written notification, …”

In many files the administration never answers the application. The rule on implied rejection then applies:

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 10 (Silence of administrative authorities) (unofficial translation)

“If no reply is given within thirty days, the request shall be deemed rejected. The persons concerned may bring an action before the Council of State or the administrative or tax courts, as appropriate, within the time limit for bringing an action starting from the end of the thirty days. If the reply given by the administration within thirty days is not final, the person may treat it as a rejection and bring an action, or may wait for the final reply. In that case the time limit does not run. However, the waiting period may not exceed four months from the date of application.”

After a refusal, an application may be made within the time limit to the superior authority or, if none, to the authority that issued the act; this suspends the running time limit, the request is deemed rejected if not answered within thirty days, and the time limit then resumes, counting the period that had already elapsed (Law No. 2577 art. 11).

If the incident causing death or injury is an administrative action and compensation is sought, a prior application to the administration and special time limits apply:

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 13 (Bringing a full-remedy action directly) (unofficial translation)

“Persons whose rights have been infringed by administrative actions must, before bringing an administrative action, apply to the administration concerned for redress within one year of learning of such actions through written notification or otherwise, and in any event within five years of the date of the action. If these requests are wholly or partly rejected, an action may be brought within the time limit for bringing an action from the day following notification of that decision or, if no reply is given within thirty days, from the end of that period.”

These periods run not from the date of death or injury but from the date on which the administrative nature of the action and the damage became known. In a final 2025 decision, the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers held that, for deaths during military service whose administrative character had not been known earlier, the one-year and five-year periods run from notification of the annulment judgment on service disability (quoted below). In the files underlying that decision, administrative courts had annulled refusals of service-disability applications made more than thirty years after the deaths; the dissent notes that one of those judgments was later set aside on appeal.

A stay of execution requires both that implementing the act would cause damage that is difficult or impossible to remedy and that the act is clearly unlawful (Law No. 2577 art. 27). These conditions are hard to meet for refusals such as the denial of a pension; for acts such as cancelling an appointment based on a status or stopping a pension already granted, a stay request should be assessed separately.

Proof: Incident Records, Investigation File and Medical Board Report

The outcome of these cases often depends on how the incident was documented. The court conducts all examinations of its own motion and may request information and documents (Law No. 2577 art. 20); even so, the claimant’s concrete indication of which documents should be obtained shapes the case. The main evidence is:

  • Incident and assignment records: incident report, guard roster, duty order, vehicle allocation records. In the Court of Cassation’s police officer decision, the time at which the shift ended was decisive.
  • The military or judicial investigation file and autopsy report. A decision not to prosecute may not be decisive on its own; in an annulment judgment upheld by the Council of State, service fault was accepted although such a decision was relied on.
  • Medical records and board reports. For Law No. 3713 Provisional art. 20, a medical board report including at least one forensic medicine specialist is a statutory requirement.
  • The person’s social security record: the date and status of first insurance determine both the applicable provision and the competent court.

An important principle applies to deaths during military service in an area under State control: if the cause of death has not been clarified, the State bears the burden of providing a plausible explanation, and it cannot be accepted on an assumption that the death was unrelated to duty. The Council of State applied this principle relying on the ECtHR’s Beker v. Turkey judgment (quoted below). In an administrative court judgment quoted in the 2025 decision of the Plenary Session, the Ministry of National Defence’s failure to produce information on access to clean water and food was decisive for a soldier who died of an infection contracted during an exercise.

Full-Remedy Actions, Cash Compensation and Service Fault

A status dispute and a compensation dispute are distinct. Annulment of a refusal of service disability secures the pension and rights under social security law; if the administration is liable for the incident, compensation for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage is the subject of a full-remedy action. As the suicide decision upheld by the Council of State shows, service fault may not by itself result in service disability, but that does not automatically close the route to compensation.

In a full-remedy action, the cash compensation paid under Law No. 2330 and the twenty-five per cent increase in the pension are deducted from pecuniary damage as benefits obtained because of the incident. At the end of 2025 the 10th Chamber treated the failure to deduct these items in the expert report as a ground for reversal, while upholding the part on non-pecuniary damages (quoted below). Since, after the Constitutional Court’s annulment, cash compensation counts only against pecuniary damage, the earlier practice of deducting it from non-pecuniary damages should no longer be relied on. As to time limits, it should not be assumed that the compensation route is closed for a death or injury many years ago without examining when the relevant facts became known.

Council of State Decisions

Sudden death on duty: disability arising during duty and under its influence

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 12th Chamber, E. 2018/4000, K. 2021/289, 01.02.2021 (the Chamber’s reversal reasoning; physician who died of aortic rupture under heavy workload and night-shift stress; majority decision)

“for a person to be regarded as service-disabled, the disability must have arisen both while the duty was being performed and under the influence of the duty performed. … it must be accepted that the death of the claimant’s spouse, caused by the rupture of the aorta while performing his duty, was caused and influenced by the duty.” (translation)

Unexplained death during military service: the State must provide a plausible explanation

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 11th Chamber, E. 2011/3388, K. 2014/2674, 05.05.2014 (the Chamber’s reversal reasoning on rectification; relying on Beker v. Turkey; majority decision)

“In that case, although the claimant’s son was found dead while on guard duty as …, the cause of death was not clarified, and it was not shown that the death did not occur under the influence and effect of duty, the impugned act, based on the assumption that the death — for which the State bears the obligation to provide a plausible explanation — resulted from suicide or accident, and the judgment dismissing the action on the ground that service-disability provisions could not apply, are not legally correct.” (translation)

Counter-terrorism: accident while returning from hospital to the unit

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 12th Chamber, E. 2018/3121, K. 2021/5528, 09.11.2021 (the administrative court’s annulment reasoning, upheld after SGK’s appeal was dismissed)

“since the claimant, who fell ill after remaining on snow for a long time during counter-terrorism operations, went to hospital for treatment and had a traffic accident while returning from hospital to his unit, that is, his place of duty, the incident causing his disability cannot be regarded as outside duty, and it is understood that the disability arose from the cause and effect of terrorist incidents and that the claimant became disabled within counter-terrorism duty” (translation)

Deduction of cash compensation and the increased pension in a full-remedy action

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 10th Chamber, E. 2022/6895, K. 2025/6681, 25.12.2025 (the Chamber’s reversal reasoning; damages claim by relatives of a worker killed in a terrorist attack; the part on non-pecuniary damages upheld)

“In this context, the value of the cash compensation paid to the claimants under Law No. 2330, updated with statutory interest to the date of the report, and, of the pensions and income granted by SGK, the part of the work-accident death income subject to recourse and the 25% increased part of the death pensions under Law No. 2330, must be regarded as benefits obtained because of the incident and deducted from the pecuniary damage calculated.” (translation)

A service-disability judgment starts the time limit for compensation

Council of State Decision
Council of State, Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2025/58, K. 2025/46, 24.09.2025 (resolution of conflicting regional administrative court decisions; final; majority decision)

“In conclusion, in disputes where the administrative character of the action was not learned in any way beforehand, the annulment judgment of the administrative court on service disability must be taken into account as a fact revealing the administrative character of the action, and the one-year and five-year periods in article 13 of Law No. 2577 must be calculated from notification of that judgment.” (translation)

The Constitutional Court and ECtHR Dimension

Once ordinary remedies are exhausted, an individual application may be lodged with the Constitutional Court. Findings of violation in this field mainly concern the right to a reasoned decision and equality of arms:

The European Court of Human Rights also found a violation of the right to life concerning a soldier found dead in barracks, noting that the State had failed to provide a plausible explanation for the death (ECtHR, Beker v. Turkey, App. No. 27866/03, 24.03.2009). An individual application does not, however, suspend the act or judgment: the Council of State upheld a judgment finding lawful the cancellation of the public appointment of a sibling, appointed under Law No. 3713 Additional art. 1 on the strength of a service-disability annulment that was later set aside on appeal, although an individual application had been lodged (Council of State, 12th Chamber, E. 2024/6336, K. 2025/1534, 18.03.2025).

Practical Points

  1. Identify which act was refused. Service disability, counter-terrorism coverage, cash compensation, the veteran title, the martyrdom certificate and employment are separate acts; obtaining one does not automatically secure another.
  2. Determine the social security regime. The date and status of first insurance (conscript, corporal, specialist sergeant, officer, police, civilian) determine the applicable provision and the choice between administrative and labour courts.
  3. Document the dates. The sixty-day limit runs from written notification and, for implied rejection, from the end of the thirty days; an application to the superior authority only suspends it. The one-year window for the provisional article must be tracked separately.
  4. Request the full incident file. The incident report, duty order, investigation file, medical records and board report should be listed in the petition and their production requested.
  5. Be cautious with rights based on non-final judgments. Employment or pension rights obtained on the basis of a first-instance annulment may be withdrawn if that judgment is set aside on appeal.
  6. Consider compensation and reasoning objections separately. Even if the status is refused, a full-remedy action may be available where there is service fault. Raising arguments decisive for the outcome clearly and concretely in the petition and appeal is also decisive for any Constitutional Court stage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which court hears a challenge to a refusal of martyr or veteran status?

As a rule, the administrative court. However, service-disability disputes of persons first insured as public servants after 2008 are heard by the labour courts under Law No. 5510 art. 101. Service-disability claims of conscripts who died during military service and acts under Laws No. 3713 and 2330, the veteran title, martyrdom certificates, medals and employment belong to the administrative courts. In cases concerning military service, the competent court is the administrative court located where the regional administrative court of the person’s place of duty sits.

What is the time limit for bringing an action?

Sixty days from written notification of the refusal. If an application is not answered within thirty days, it is deemed rejected and the sixty days run from then. For compensation claims, the administration must be approached within one year of learning of the action and in any event within five years; the Council of State accepts that these periods may run from the date the administrative character became known, for example from notification of a service-disability annulment judgment.

Can relatives of a conscript who took his own life benefit from service-disability rights?

As a rule no, because disability resulting from attempted suicide is excluded by law. However, the Council of State has held that an assumption of suicide cannot be relied on where the cause of death was not clarified, and that the State bears the burden of a plausible explanation. It has also upheld the annulment of a refusal where there was service fault, such as putting a soldier detained for drugs on armed guard duty without examination. The outcome depends on the facts.

What changed in 2026 for those injured in counter-terrorism duty but not classified as disabled?

Law No. 7594 raised the indicators for degree-based pensions under Law No. 3713 Additional art. 3 and extended to their recipients the other rights granted under Law No. 1005. In addition, under the new Law No. 3713 Provisional art. 20, personnel not classified as disabled and given no degree, who suffered non-minor injuries from firearms, explosives or close-combat attacks, may receive a pension based on indicator 17,135. The application must be made within one year of entry into force to the institution of service at the time.

Does receiving cash compensation prevent a separate damages action?

No. If the administration is liable, a full-remedy action may be brought. However, the updated value of the cash compensation paid under Law No. 2330 and the twenty-five per cent increased part of the pension are deducted from pecuniary damage. After the Constitutional Court’s annulment, cash compensation counts only against pecuniary damage and is not deducted from non-pecuniary damages.

Status, pension and compensation disputes of martyrs’ families and veterans fall within our firm’s Administrative Law practice area; files in which service disability is heard by the labour courts are handled together with the Labour and Social Security Law area.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Administrative Law

All Administrative Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Challenging a Refusal of Veteran or Martyr Status in Türkiye: Disability, Laws No. 3713 and 2330, Time Limits”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-06, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/challenging-refusal-veteran-or-martyr-status

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›