Last reviewed:
Case NoteMalpractice Time Limit Runs from End of Treatment: Turkish Council of State on Five-Year Full-Remedy Period
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish administrative procedure law, before a full-remedy action is brought for damage caused by an administrative action (idari eylem), an application must be made to the administration within one year of learning of that administrative action and in any event within five years of its date (Administrative Procedure Law art. 13). In its decision of 27.11.2023, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State (Danıştay) recalled, as settled case-law, that for bodily harm this period starts on the date on which the treatment process is completed and the final health report is given to the person concerned. Because the report relied on by the plaintiffs was valid for two years and was not of a permanent nature, treatment was accepted as continuing; the regional administrative court decision that calculated the five-year period from the date of birth was quashed unanimously and as a final decision. The quashing concerns the time limit only; the merits of the compensation claim will be examined by the regional administrative court in the appeal review.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State held unanimously, in a full-remedy action brought for a child whose treatment was continuing and where it was alleged that the necessary interventions had not been made in time before and during birth, that the period in Administrative Procedure Law art. 13 starts when treatment ends and the final health report is given, and quashed the decision that had calculated the five-year period from the date of birth.
Under Turkish law, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State held that, in a full-remedy action brought for a child patient whose treatment continued for a long time, the five-year period could not be calculated from the date of birth.
The Dispute
The plaintiffs are a mother and father acting on their own behalf and on behalf of their child under their custody. The child was born at a public hospital in 2006. Alleging that the necessary interventions before and during birth had not been made in time and that the child had therefore been left severely disabled, the plaintiffs claimed pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages from the defendant Ministry.
According to the facts set out in the decision, the child received treatment from 2008 onwards. The health board report relied on by the plaintiffs was issued in 2015 and was valid for two years. The plaintiffs filed an action in spring 2016; the court sent the petition to the administration (referral to the competent authority). When the administration gave no reply, the present action was brought in autumn of the same year. Some ten years had passed between the birth and the action.
The administrative court, relying on expert reports obtained from the Council of Forensic Medicine and from university faculty members, dismissed the action on the merits on the ground that there was no service fault and that the conditions of strict liability were not met either. The regional administrative court dismissed the appeals but changed the reasoning: since the action had not been brought in any event within five years of the birth, it should have been dismissed as time-barred; the dismissal was lawful in its result. The plaintiffs appealed on points of law, arguing that the damage had become complete with the 2015 report and that the five-year period should start from the date of that report.
Outcome of the Decision
On 27.11.2023 the 10th Chamber of the Council of State accepted the plaintiffs’ appeals; it quashed the regional administrative court decision that had dismissed the appeals with reasons and sent the file back to the regional administrative court for a new decision. The decision was given unanimously and as a final decision; there is no dissenting opinion. No new decision given after the quashing could be found; the compensation claim may not have been decided on the merits.
Reasoning
The Chamber first explained, through the concept of learning of the damage, when the period in Administrative Procedure Law art. 13 starts to run:
“For a full-remedy action to be brought, as provided in the Article, for compensation of damage suffered because of an administrative action, it is necessary that the administrative nature of the action causing the damage, and the material event and the damage it caused, have definitively emerged. Accordingly, it must be accepted that the damage is deemed to have been learned of only when sufficient circumstances and conditions have been learned that make it possible to bring an action concerning the existence, nature and essential elements of the damage, to support that action seriously and objectively and to state its grounds.” (unofficial translation)
For bodily harm, it laid down the test on the basis of settled case-law as follows:
“It is part of the settled case-law of the Council of State that bodily harm caused by administrative actions is deemed to have been learned of on the date on which the treatment process is completed and the final health report is obtained, and that the period laid down in the Law must be started on the date on which the final report is given to the person concerned. In fact, calculating the one-year and five-year periods laid down in Article 13 of Law No. 2577 without taking into account the date on which the administrative action was completed and the damage fully emerged would, in some cases, make it impossible to use the right to bring an action. It is clear that calculating the time limit in a way that removes the right to bring an action, which becomes usable once the damage emerges, would be incompatible with the freedom to seek legal remedies.” (unofficial translation)
In the present case, the decisive factor was the nature of the report relied on by the plaintiffs:
“In this situation; considering that the report on which the plaintiffs relied when bringing the action … was valid for two years and was not of a permanent nature, a decision should have been given on the merits of the event in dispute, taking into account that the treatment process was continuing; there was therefore no legal accuracy in dismissing the plaintiffs’ appeals on the ground that the action had been brought after the five-year period had expired.” (unofficial translation)
The Chamber treated the fact that the report had been issued for a fixed period as an indication that treatment was continuing and required the regional administrative court to decide on the merits of the case.
Significance and Practical Effect
The decision shows that, for bodily harm, the one-year and five-year periods in Administrative Procedure Law art. 13 cannot be calculated mechanically from the date of the event. The Chamber referred to this principle as the settled case-law of the Council of State. In the Council of State decisions accessible since this decision (up to February 2026), no decision departing from this test was found.
In practice, the decisive question is whether treatment has been completed and the damage has been established by a final health report. The time limit does not disappear; its starting point moves to the date on which the final report is given to the person concerned. After that date the period for applying to the administration runs; if the request is rejected or not answered, the action is brought within the sixty-day time limit in Administrative Procedure Law art. 7.
Note: the decision was quashed only on the time-limit point; accepting that the action was brought in time does not mean that compensation will be awarded, because the administrative court had found, on the basis of expert reports, that there was no service fault. The decision quotes the text of art. 13 in force on the date of the prior application; the administration’s period to reply was sixty days in that text and is thirty days in the current text. The one-year and five-year periods are unchanged.
Relevant Legislation
“Persons whose rights have been infringed by administrative actions must, before bringing an administrative action, apply to the administration concerned for redress within one year of learning of such actions through written notification or otherwise, and in any event within five years of the date of the action. If these requests are rejected in whole or in part, or if no reply is given within thirty days, an action may be brought within the time limit for bringing an action, starting from the day following notification of the decision on the request or from the expiry of that period.” (unofficial translation)
“Unless a separate time limit is laid down in special laws, the time limit for bringing an action is sixty days before the Council of State and the administrative courts and thirty days before the tax courts.” (unofficial translation)
“The administration shall be liable to compensate for damage arising from its own acts and actions.” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
When does the time limit start in a full-remedy action for medical error at a public hospital?
Under Turkish law, according to the 10th Chamber of the Council of State, for bodily harm the period in Administrative Procedure Law art. 13 starts on the date on which the treatment process is completed and the final health report is given to the person concerned.
Is the five-year period always calculated from the date of the event?
Not in this decision. The Chamber stated that calculating the one-year and five-year periods without taking into account the date on which the administrative action was completed and the damage fully emerged would be incompatible with the freedom to seek legal remedies.
Does a disability report valid for two years start the time limit?
In this decision, the Chamber treated the report, which was valid for two years and not of a permanent nature, as an indication that treatment was continuing, and quashed the decision based on the ground that the action had been brought after the five-year period. In another case the outcome depends on the nature of the report and the course of treatment.
Can an action be brought directly, or must an application first be made to the administration?
For damage caused by administrative actions, Administrative Procedure Law art. 13 requires a prior application to the administration. If the request is rejected or not answered within thirty days, the action is brought within the sixty-day time limit in art. 7.
Does this decision mean that the plaintiffs will receive compensation?
No. The decision was quashed only on the time-limit point; the administrative court had found that there was no service fault; the merits of the claim will be examined by the regional administrative court in the appeal review.
Related Articles
- The Physician's Liability in Medical Malpractice
- Damages for Delayed Healthcare in Turkish Prisons: Jurisdiction, Time Limits, Service Fault, Heads of Damage and Interest
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Health law and malpractice attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Health Law
- Lack of Informed Consent in Cosmetic Surgery in Türkiye: Surgeon's Liability, Proof, Limitation (TBK Art. 147)
- Medical Error in Turkish Public Hospitals: Full-Remedy Action, Prior Administrative Application, Time Limits
- Türkiye’s “Full-Time Law” for Physicians: Private Practice Restrictions from 1928 to 2026 and Today
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Malpractice Time Limit Runs from End of Treatment: Turkish Council of State on Five-Year Full-Remedy Period”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/public-hospital-malpractice-claim-five-year-time-limit

























