Last reviewed:
Medical Error in Turkish Public Hospitals: Full-Remedy Action, Prior Administrative Application, Time Limits
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, an action for harm caused by medical treatment in a public hospital is, as a rule, brought not against the physician but against the administration running the service, as a full-remedy action before the administrative courts (Constitution art. 129/5; Law No. 657 art. 13). Before suing, the claimant must as a rule apply to the administration: within one year of learning of the act and in any event within five years of the act (Law No. 2577 art. 13). If the administration refuses or does not reply within thirty days, the time limit for bringing the action starts to run; unless a special law provides otherwise, that limit is sixty days before the administrative court (Law No. 2577 art. 7). In its decision of 25.01.2022 (given with rectification of the decision still available; it may not be final), the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that in a claim of faulty treatment connected with the duty the proper defendant is the administration, not the physician, and that this protection does not cover personal fault separable from the duty. Compensation requires a service fault of the administration.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, an action for harm caused by medical treatment in a state or university hospital is as a rule brought against the administration, not the physician, as a full-remedy action before the administrative courts, as a rule after a prior application to the administration within one year and in any event five years. The article explains the proper defendant, the time limits in Law No. 2577 art. 13, the competent administrative court, expert reports, non-pecuniary damages and recourse against the physician, with Council of State, Court of Cassation and Constitutional Court decisions.
The administrative court route under Turkish law for those harmed by medical treatment in a state, university or city hospital: the defendant, the prior application, time limits, the competent court, expert evidence, non-pecuniary damages and recourse.
What Is a Medical Error Action against a Public Hospital?
A person harmed by a wrong diagnosis, a delayed intervention or inadequate follow-up during health care provided in a state hospital or in the hospital of a state university in Türkiye claims compensation from the administration running the service. The route is a full-remedy action before the administrative courts. Its basis is in the Constitution:
“The administration is liable to compensate for damage arising from its own acts and actions.”
In its decision of 25.09.2024 quoted below, the Council of State Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers defined full-remedy actions as compensation actions brought against the administration by those whose rights have been directly harmed by its activities. Actions against a private hospital or a self-employed physician are outside the scope of this article; that subject is covered in the article The Physician’s Liability in Medical Malpractice.
Conditions for Compensation: Service Fault, Harm and Causation
Not every treatment that ends badly gives rise to compensation. Council of State decisions look for three things: a service fault of the administration, harm, and a causal link between the two. The Assembly explained service fault as follows:
“Service fault, which may be defined as an objective defect, malfunction or gap in the establishment, organisation or operation of a service the administration is charged with running, occurs where the service operates badly, operates late or does not operate at all. … In the health service, where the injured person is a user of the service and the service is inherently risky, the administration’s duty to compensate arises only if the harm has resulted from the administration’s service fault.”
In that case a baby suffered nerve damage during delivery. The Forensic Medicine Institute report treated this as an unforeseeable and unavoidable complication. The Assembly, however, held that failing to recommend a caesarean section to a diabetic mother whose baby’s estimated weight exceeded 4,000 grams, contrary to the Ministry of Health’s delivery management guide, was a service fault. Only non-pecuniary damages were before the Assembly; the dismissal of the pecuniary claim had already been upheld by the Chamber. The decision is specific to its facts; it carries one dissenting opinion (that the decision to persist should have been upheld) and one opinion dissenting only as to the reasoning.
Whom to Sue: the Physician or the Administration?
The Constitution and Law No. 657 make the administration the defendant:
“Actions for damages arising from faults committed by civil servants and other public officials in the exercise of their powers may be brought only against the administration, subject to recourse against them and in accordance with the form and conditions prescribed by law.”
“For damage they suffer in connection with duties subject to public law, persons bring an action not against the personnel performing those duties but against the institution concerned. … The institution’s right of recourse against the responsible personnel under the general provisions is reserved.”
The Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers applied these provisions in a faulty-treatment case. The claimants had sued the physicians before the civil courts over the death of a relative operated on in a public hospital. The Assembly unanimously quashed the first-instance court’s decision to persist in a judgment ordering one physician to pay non-pecuniary damages:
“Bringing such an action against the administration is limited to conduct that stems from service fault and has not lost its character as an administrative act or action. … since the act occurred during and in connection with the duty and has the character of service fault, in the present case standing to be sued lies not with the public official but with the administration. The action must therefore be brought against the administration and directed at the administration.”
The exception: personal fault. According to the same decision the protection is not unlimited. Where a public official causes harm entirely of his or her own will, intentionally or by a criminal act going beyond the express provisions of the laws, no link is accepted between the act and the performance of the public duty; an action based on personal fault that is clearly and easily separable from the duty is brought against the official personally, before the civil courts. An allegation of faulty treatment, by contrast, was treated in this decision as a fault committed in the course of duty.
Which administration is the defendant? In the decisions examined, for a delivery in a hospital attached to the Ministry of Health the application was made to the Ministry of Health and the action was heard against the Ministry; for a procedure in a state university hospital the defendant was the university rectorate. For city hospitals there is no separate discussion of the proper defendant among the decisions read; the test is which administration runs the medical service (this is the article’s own inference).
If the action was brought in the wrong branch of the judiciary, the right is not automatically lost. Under Law No. 2577 art. 9, if an action brought before the civil courts is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, an action may be brought before the competent court within thirty days from the day following the date on which that decision becomes final; in that situation the prior application to the administration is not required either (Law No. 2577 art. 13/2). Even if thirty days have passed since the decision declining jurisdiction became final, the action may still be brought within the time limit for administrative actions if that limit has not yet expired (Law No. 2577 art. 9/2). The provision governs dismissal for lack of jurisdiction; other outcomes, such as dismissal because the wrong defendant was sued, must be assessed separately.
Application to the Administration and Time Limits
For harm caused by medical treatment one does not go straight to court; an application to the administration comes first. The route is in art. 13 of Law No. 2577, which governs harm arising from administrative actions:
“Those whose rights have been infringed by administrative actions must, before bringing an administrative action, apply to the administration concerned and request that their rights be satisfied, within one year from the date on which they learned of these actions by written notification or otherwise and in any event within five years from the date of the action. If these requests are refused in whole or in part, an action may be brought within the time limit for bringing an action, starting from the day following notification of the act on this matter or, if no reply is given to the request within thirty days, from the date on which that period expires.”
The sequence is as follows:
- Written application to the administration. It is made within one year of learning of the act and in any event within five years of the act.
- The administration’s reply or silence. If the request is refused, the time limit runs from the day following notification of the refusal; if no reply is given within thirty days, from the date on which those thirty days expire.
- The action. The time limit is set out in art. 7 of Law No. 2577.
“The time limit for bringing an action is, where no separate period is specified in the special laws, sixty days before the Council of State and the administrative courts and thirty days before the tax courts.”
The thirty-day reply period is the current text. Under provisional article 10, added by Law No. 7331 of 08.07.2021, the periods in force before the amendment apply to applications made under art. 13 before that article entered into force.
When the one-year and five-year periods start to run in cases of bodily harm is a separate question; the decision of the Council of State 10th Chamber of 27.11.2023 is examined in the case note Malpractice Time Limit Starts When Treatment Ends.
Relationship with art. 12 of Law No. 2577
If the harm arises not from an administrative action but from an administrative act, a different provision applies:
“Those concerned may, on account of an administrative act infringing their rights, bring a full-remedy action directly before the Council of State and the administrative and tax courts or bring annulment and full-remedy actions together, or they may first bring an annulment action … and bring a full-remedy action within the time limit for bringing an action.”
Article 12 governs harm arising from an act, article 13 harm arising from an action. In three of the Council of State decisions read for this article it appears that an application was made to the administration before the action; the route followed is art. 13. Which provision applies depends on the source of the harm.
The Competent Court
In all the Council of State decisions examined, the action was heard at first instance by an administrative court. Which administrative court has territorial jurisdiction is determined by art. 36 of Law No. 2577:
“In full-remedy actions other than those arising from administrative contracts, the competent court is, in order:
a) the administrative court competent to resolve the administrative dispute giving rise to the harm,
b) if the harm arose from a service such as public works and transport or from any action of the administration, the administrative court of the place where the service was provided or the action was carried out,
c) in other cases, the administrative court of the place of the claimant’s residence.”
For harm caused by medical treatment, sub-paragraph (b) comes to the fore: the competent court is the administrative court of the place where the service was provided, which is as a rule where the hospital is located. This is the conclusion this article draws from the text of the provision. The claimant’s place of residence comes in only if the first two sub-paragraphs cannot be applied.
Expert Evidence, the Forensic Medicine Institute and Causation in Case Law
Whether there is a service fault is a medical question, and the courts put it to experts. The Council of State 10th Chamber set out the quality the report must have:
“the expert must, using the concrete medical data and drawing on his or her medical knowledge, reach an objective conclusion free from all doubt and state an opinion with concrete reasons accordingly; … in the report, the answers to the questions must be clear so as to leave no room for doubt, and the content of the report must be capable of forming the basis of the judgment.”
In that case a lesion on the claimant’s foot was treated as a callus for months, and skin cancer was diagnosed later. The administrative court dismissed the action on the basis of a Forensic Medicine Institute specialised board report that attributed no medical error to the physicians, and the appeal was also rejected. The Chamber found that the report did not give sufficient reasons on the allegations of delay and held that a new report, clearly answering the parties’ allegations, had to be obtained from the Higher Board of Forensic Medicine. Quashing does not mean the action has been won; fault will be determined by the new report.
A report finding no fault or no causation has not always led to dismissal. In a case where a child taken to health institutions twice with a high fever died, the Forensic Medicine Institute stated that it was not certain the child would have survived even without the physician’s deficient conduct. The regional administrative court therefore rejected the pecuniary claim and persisted in its decision. The Assembly quashed the decision to persist:
“Although both reports obtained from the Forensic Medicine Institute expressed the view that no certain, absolute causal link capable of producing this result could be established between the deficient conduct attributed to the emergency physician and the death giving rise to the pecuniary claim, it is clear that, despite the child having been taken to health institutions twice within a period of about 12 hours, there is no record that the child underwent a systemic examination in those institutions, that no test or consultation was requested to investigate the source of the fever, and that accordingly the medical care that would have enabled the child to obtain a correct diagnosis and treatment was not shown.”
The members who dissented considered that the decision to persist should have been upheld. In this case the physician had also been convicted of neglect of duty, with the pronouncement of the judgment deferred, and that decision had become final; the outcome should not be read as a general rule.
Gaps in medical records have also been held against the administration. In an action against a university hospital, where and by whom a device allegedly placed in the patient had been inserted could not be established because of missing records. The administrative court looked for “gross service fault”, dismissed the action and persisted in its decision. The Assembly, stating that keeping, recording and preserving medical information and documents accurately and completely is an obligation of the administration, quashed the decision to persist by majority (Council of State, Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2024/2915, K. 2025/597, 17.03.2025; given with rectification of the decision still available, it may not be final). The Assembly did not use the qualification “gross” in its own reasoning.
The Constitutional Court has also reviewed the full-remedy action itself in an individual application. The action brought by the relatives of a patient who died after stomach reduction surgery had been dismissed without an additional report addressing their objections, and the proceedings had lasted 6 years, 8 months and 23 days:
“in applications made on the allegation of medical negligence, what must be done when examining the procedural aspect of the right to life is to determine whether the full-remedy or compensation action that is the subject of the application made it possible to clarify the course of the event that resulted in death and the possible responsibility of the health personnel”
The Court held that the substantive aspect of the right to life had not been violated but that its procedural aspect had; it ordered a retrial and awarded non-pecuniary compensation. According to the same decision, the duty of careful examination does not require an outcome in favour of the victims in every case.
The Supreme Health Council (Yüksek Sağlık Şûrası). In the 2003 events behind the Assembly of Civil Chambers decision above, the claimants relied on a decision of the Supreme Health Council alongside the Forensic Medicine Institute report. Today article 21 of Decree-Law No. 663, headed “Supreme Health Council”, stands repealed by Decree-Law No. 703 of 02.07.2018. In the current Council of State decisions read, expert evidence came from the specialised boards of the Forensic Medicine Institute and the Higher Board of Forensic Medicine.
Non-Pecuniary Damages
The Council of State 10th Chamber has defined non-pecuniary harm as follows:
“the distress and anxiety felt by those concerned because they could not receive adequate service, owing to the administration’s failure to provide properly and completely the public service it is obliged to run, is also sufficient for the existence of non-pecuniary harm and for an award of non-pecuniary damages. Non-pecuniary damages are not a means of compensation aimed at covering a reduction in assets, but a means of moral satisfaction.”
The Chamber applied this principle to the case as follows: even if, on the basis of the new report to be obtained, service fault cannot be clearly established and the conditions for pecuniary damages are not met, the fact that the lesion was not described in detail in the medical documents at the first examination and that the records were not duly kept would cause the claimant anxiety and distress, so reasonable non-pecuniary damages must be awarded. As to the amount, the test is the same in this decision and in the Assembly decision of 25.09.2024: the sum must reflect the gravity of the event, the harm and the fault, and must be a deterrent, but must not exceed an equitable and reasonable amount.
Recourse against the Physician and the Professional Liability Board
Constitution art. 129/5 provides for the action to be brought against the administration “subject to recourse against them”; art. 13 of Law No. 657 likewise reserves the institution’s right of recourse. For members of the health professions, who decides on recourse is regulated in the article added to Law No. 3359 by Law No. 7406 of 12.05.2022:
“Whether recourse is to be had against the person concerned for compensation paid by the administration on account of medical procedures and practices relating to examination, diagnosis and treatment carried out, within the practice of the health profession, by physicians, dentists and other members of the health professions working in public institutions and organisations and state universities, and the amount of such recourse, shall be decided by the Professional Liability Board within one year, having regard to whether the person concerned abused his or her office by acting contrary to the requirements of the duty and to the degree of fault.”
Under the additions made by Law No. 7496 of 21.02.2024, for those working in state universities the final decision is taken by the university within six months. In addition, after paying compensation awarded by a final court judgment, the administration is subrogated to the health professional working in a public institution or state university who holds compulsory professional liability insurance, and claims the compensation paid, including attorney’s fees and litigation costs, from the insurance company in proportion to the professional’s fault and within the insurance cover. The first paragraph of the article concerns criminal investigation: except for those subject to the procedure in article 53 of the Higher Education Law, Law No. 4483 applies to investigations on account of medical procedures and practices and authorisation is given by the Professional Liability Board.
Recourse is a relationship between the administration and its personnel; it does not change the defendant in the patient’s action (this is the article’s own inference). The physician may nonetheless not remain outside the action: in its decision of 14.01.2026 the Council of State 10th Chamber stated that the persons against whom a recourse relationship with the administration may arise must be identified and the action notified to them by the court of its own motion.
Practical Points
- Identify the right defendant. In a claim of faulty treatment connected with the duty, the action is directed at the administration; an action brought against the physician before the civil courts may be dismissed because the wrong party was sued.
- Apply to the administration first and document the date of the application. The thirty-day reply period is calculated from that date; if the administration does not reply, the time limit for the action runs from the date the thirty days expire.
- Request the complete medical records. Missing records have been held against the administration in the decisions.
- Object to the expert report in concrete terms. Point out one by one the allegations the report does not answer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Under Turkish law, is an action for medical error in a state hospital brought against the doctor or the administration?
As a rule, against the administration. Under Constitution art. 129/5 and Law No. 657 art. 13, an action for damages arising from a fault committed by a public official while performing the duty is brought against the administration running the service, as a full-remedy action before the administrative courts. In its decision of 25.01.2022 (given with rectification of the decision still available; it may not be final), the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that in a claim of faulty treatment connected with the duty the proper defendant is the administration, not the physician. According to the same decision this protection does not cover personal fault clearly separable from the duty; in that case the action is heard against the physician before the civil courts.
What is the time limit for a full-remedy action for medical error in a public hospital in Türkiye?
An application to the administration comes first: within one year of learning of the act and in any event within five years of the act (Law No. 2577 art. 13). If the administration refuses, the time limit for the action runs from the day following notification of the refusal; if it does not reply within thirty days, from the date on which that period expires. Unless a special law sets a separate period, the time limit is sixty days before the administrative court (Law No. 2577 art. 7).
Which court hears a medical error action against a public hospital in Türkiye?
The administrative court. Under Law No. 2577 art. 36/b, if the harm arose from an action of the administration, the competent court is the administrative court of the place where the service was provided or the action was carried out; as a rule this is where the hospital is located (the conclusion this article draws from the text of the provision). If the action is mistakenly brought before the civil courts and dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, an action may be brought before the administrative court within thirty days from the day after that decision becomes final (art. 9), and the prior application to the administration is not required (art. 13/2).
Is a medical error action against a public hospital in Türkiye dismissed if the Forensic Medicine Institute report finds no fault?
Not always. In its decision of 14.01.2026 the Council of State 10th Chamber quashed a dismissal based on a report that answered the parties’ allegations without sufficient reasons and required a new report from the Higher Board of Forensic Medicine. In its decision of 06.11.2025 the Council of State Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers likewise concluded, by majority, that the required medical care had not been shown although the reports stated that no certain causal link could be established. These decisions are specific to their facts; quashing does not mean the action will be upheld.
Under Turkish law, can the administration recover from the physician the compensation it paid for a medical error?
It can, but the decision is taken by the Professional Liability Board. Under additional art. 18 of Law No. 3359, the Board decides within one year whether recourse is to be had and in what amount, having regard to whether the person concerned abused his or her office by acting contrary to the requirements of the duty and to the degree of fault. For those working in state universities the final decision is taken by the university within six months.
- The Physician’s Liability in Medical Malpractice
- Malpractice Time Limit Starts When Treatment Ends: The Turkish Council of State on the Five-Year Period in Full-Remedy Actions for Medical Error
- Damages for Delayed Healthcare in Turkish Prisons: Jurisdiction, Time Limits, Service Fault, Heads of Damage and Interest
Related Articles
- The Physician’s Liability in Medical Malpractice
- Malpractice Time Limit Starts When Treatment Ends: The Turkish Council of State on the Five-Year Period in Full-Remedy Actions for Medical Error
- Damages for Delayed Healthcare in Turkish Prisons: Jurisdiction, Time Limits, Service Fault, Heads of Damage and Interest
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Health law and malpractice attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Health Law
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Medical Error in Turkish Public Hospitals: Full-Remedy Action, Prior Administrative Application, Time Limits”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/medical-error-public-hospital-full-remedy-action-turkiye

























