Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 9 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Missing Rules on Deleting Student Penalties Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Disciplinary Records

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: In its decision of 30.12.2025, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State (Danıştay) found that the absence of a clear rule in the legislation on keeping higher education students’ disciplinary penalties on record and deleting them after certain conditions and a certain period breaches the principles of legal security, legal certainty and proportionality. The implied refusal of the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) to make rules, and the dean’s act based on it, were annulled. The Chamber did not itself order the penalty to be deleted; it held that the gap should not be applied to the detriment of students. The decision was given at first instance and by majority; since an appeal is open, it may not be final.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, ruling at first instance and by majority, held that the absence of a clear rule on keeping higher education students’ disciplinary penalties on record and deleting them after certain conditions and a certain period breaches legal security, legal certainty and proportionality, and annulled the implied refusal of the application asking the Council of Higher Education to regulate the matter and the dean’s act based on it.

Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held unlawful the absence of any rule on how long students’ disciplinary penalties are kept on record and when they are deleted.

The Dispute

The claimant is a student at the faculty of law of a foundation university. A warning disciplinary penalty (uyarma) was notified to the claimant by a letter dated 28.06.2019; according to the claimant, it was imposed for cheating. The rectorate refused the request to delete the penalty from the record. The Ombudsman Institution (Kamu Denetçiliği Kurumu) issued a recommendation on 17.03.2020; the request to implement it was refused by the dean’s office. In April 2020 the claimant asked YÖK to make the necessary amendment to the Regulation on Student Discipline; the application was impliedly refused. The action for annulment of these two acts was heard at first instance by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State.

YÖK argued that the administration cannot be compelled through the courts to make rules and that deletion must be regulated by statute; it also stated that it had decided that disciplinary penalties should not appear in documents issued to students, but would be disclosed if requested by the relevant public bodies. The university argued that the action had not been brought in time.

Outcome of the Decision

The Chamber rejected the time-limit objection, finding that the applications had followed one another within the statutory periods. On the merits it annulled the dean’s act and the implied refusal of the application to YÖK, and ordered the defendant administration to bear the costs. The decision was given on 30.12.2025 by majority; it left an appeal open to the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State within 30 days of notification, so it may not be final.

The decision contains one dissenting opinion; it is written in the plural, which indicates that more than one member joined it, but the number cannot be determined from the text. According to the dissent, since the rules on student discipline were re-enacted in Article 54 of Law No. 2547 by Law No. 7437 in 2023, the deletion of penalties from the record can likewise only be regulated by statute, and there was no need to decide on a case devoid of subject matter.

Reasoning

The Chamber examined the merits because, although the Regulation on Student Discipline had been repealed in 2023, it continued to affect the claimant’s rights. It found that the Regulation contained no clarity on how, where and for how long penalties would be kept, and that the Records Regulation under which student records were kept merely stated that penalties would be entered on a record card and kept in the file:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2022/2815, K. 2025/10571, 30.12.2025 (the Chamber’s finding on the Records Regulation)

“… there are no clear provisions on the manner and duration of the storage and use of disciplinary offences and penalties, on when and how they will be deleted or removed from the record, or on their not being disclosed when requested; in a sense, it is seen that persons studying in higher education and pursuing their academic life with student status are left unprotected with respect to the disciplinary penalties they incur during this time.” (unofficial translation)

The core of the decision rests on the principles of proportionality, legal security and legal certainty:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2022/2815, K. 2025/10571, 30.12.2025 (the Chamber’s assessment of proportionality and legal security)

“It is understood that there is nothing understandable or acceptable about disciplinary penalties received by university students because of momentary mistakes being kept in student files almost for a lifetime, and that the lack of regulation is also contrary to the principles of legal security and legal certainty. Indeed, considering that even criminal record entries are regulated under the heading ‘Deletion of criminal record and archive information’ of the Criminal Records Law No. 5352 and are removed from the criminal record archive after a certain period, it is concluded that the legal gap concerning the procedures and principles for the use, removal and deletion of disciplinary penalties should not be applied to the detriment of students.” (unofficial translation)

The Chamber also found the lack of regulation contrary to Articles 2 and 13 of the Constitution and to Article 2 of Protocol No. 1 to the European Convention on Human Rights; it stated that penalties kept indefinitely and disclosed to other bodies on request may lead to the rejection of the student’s applications and undermine equality with other candidates. It concluded as follows:

Council of State Decision

“… since there is no clear rule in the legislation on keeping the disciplinary penalties received by students of higher education institutions on record and deleting them from the record after certain conditions and a certain period, … it has been concluded that the act in dispute concerning the implied refusal of the application made to the Presidency of the Council of Higher Education is not lawful.” (unofficial translation)

Since that refusal was held unlawful, the dean’s act based on it was also annulled.

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision treats the indefinite storage of students’ disciplinary penalties as an issue of legal security and proportionality; however, it is a first-instance decision given by majority. No decision of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers in this file could be found. In the Council of State decisions after the date of the decision (those accessible up to 03.03.2026 for the 8th Chamber and up to 15.01.2026 for the Assembly), no contrary decision on the same issue was found.

The gap appears to persist today. Since 2023, student disciplinary matters have been governed by Article 54 of Law No. 2547; the current text states that penalties are entered in the student’s file but contains no provision on how long they are kept or when they are deleted. Article 63 still provides that student records are kept in accordance with the principles of a regulation to be prepared by YÖK; no YÖK regulation governing this matter was found in a search of the legislation.

Under the current Article 54, attempting to cheat calls for a reprimand, while cheating or helping others cheat calls for suspension for one semester; the warning penalty imposed in this case no longer appears in the list. A student whose request for deletion is refused may rely on this decision; however, if the decision has been appealed, it is not yet known how the Assembly will approach the dissent’s view that the matter must be regulated by statute.

Relevant Legislation

The provisions of the Law currently in force are set out below. At the time of the acts in dispute, the types of penalty were listed in the then text of Article 54 and the details were governed by the Regulation; that text, as quoted in the decision, provided that penalties were entered in the student’s “file and record”, whereas the current text does not contain the word “record”.

Statutory Provision — Higher Education Law (Law No. 2547) art. 54/10(ç) (Disciplinary matters of students) (unofficial translation)

“ç) An objection may be lodged with the university board of directors within fifteen days against disciplinary penalties imposed by disciplinary superiors and boards. … Penalties are entered in the student’s file.”

Statutory Provision — Higher Education Law (Law No. 2547) art. 63 (Records) (unofficial translation)

“The records of teaching staff, civil servants and other personnel working in higher education institutions and organisations and in the supreme bodies, and of students, are kept in accordance with general provisions and the principles of the regulation to be prepared by the Council of Higher Education. These records form the basis for all kinds of appointments, promotions, acquisition of academic titles and other personnel matters.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a disciplinary penalty received at university deleted from the record?

Under Turkish law, Law No. 2547 contains no clear provision on how long a penalty is kept or when it is deleted; Article 54 only states that penalties are entered in the student’s file. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State held that this gap should not be applied to the detriment of students; the decision may not be final.

Is a penalty for cheating entered in the student’s file?

Yes. Under Article 54 of Law No. 2547, disciplinary penalties are entered in the student’s file. Under the current text, attempting to cheat in an exam calls for a reprimand, while cheating or helping others cheat calls for suspension for one semester, and cheating by threats for two semesters.

Did the Council of State order the penalty to be deleted?

No. The Chamber annulled YÖK’s implied refusal of the request to regulate the matter and the dean’s refusal of the request to implement the Ombudsman Institution’s recommendation; it did not itself rule that the penalty be deleted.

Is the decision final?

The decision was given at first instance, with an appeal open to the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State within 30 days of notification. No decision of the Assembly in this file could be found; the decision may not be final.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Higher Education Law

All Higher Education Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Missing Rules on Deleting Student Penalties Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Disciplinary Records”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/student-disciplinary-penalty-record-deletion

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›