Last reviewed:
From PMF 1931 to TRH 2010: The Life Table in Bodily Injury and Loss-of-Support Damages under Turkish Law
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, damages for bodily injury and for loss of support are calculated over the remaining life expectancy of the injured person or of the deceased provider, and that period is taken from a life table. Instead of PMF 1931, which was built from French population data of 1931 and draws no distinction between women and men, the Court of Cassation applies the TRH 2010 table, which is specific to Türkiye and was prepared separately for women and men. In work-accident cases the Assembly of Civil Chambers adopted it unanimously on 02.12.2021, for an accident of 2009; in traffic cases the competent chambers have done so since 2021, and the Assembly of Civil Chambers followed the same line in its decision of 08.04.2026. The debate continues for older incidents: on 30.04.2025 the Assembly of Civil Chambers required, by majority, that PMF 1931 be applied to a traffic accident of 18.11.2010. Where a vested procedural right has arisen in respect of an earlier report based on PMF 1931, that report may set a limit; and since the Constitutional Court’s annulment decision of 2020, the 1.8% technical interest rate is, as a rule, no longer applied.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
The life table that fixes remaining life expectancy in bodily injury and loss-of-support damages under Turkish law: the chronology of the move from PMF 1931 to TRH 2010 in work-accident and traffic cases, a numerical comparison for a person aged 30, Assembly of Civil Chambers decision 2025/264 and the 2012 formula in its dissent, vested procedural rights and the 1.8% technical interest rate.
The life table that fixes the remaining life expectancy in bodily injury and loss-of-support damages under Turkish law: the move from PMF 1931 to TRH 2010, how the difference affects the calculation, and the debates that continue.
What Is a Life Table? PMF 1931 and TRH 2010
Under Turkish law, bodily injury and loss-of-support damages are calculated over the period the person was expected to live. In the words of the Assembly of Civil Chambers, “the period for which the real loss is to be calculated is one of the main elements of compensation”. That period (remaining life expectancy) is taken from life tables. The framework of the calculation is Article 55 of the Turkish Code of Obligations:
“Loss-of-support damages and bodily injury damages shall be calculated in accordance with the provisions of this Code and the principles of the law of liability. Social security payments that cannot be recovered by way of recourse, in whole or in part, and payments not made for the purpose of performance shall not be taken into account in determining such damages and shall not be deducted from the damage or the compensation. The compensation calculated may not be increased or reduced on equitable grounds by reference to its amount.”
PMF 1931, used for many years, was built from French population data of 1931 and gives a single value for women and men; the Assembly of Civil Chambers states that its legal basis was Article 22 of the repealed Social Insurance Law No. 506. TRH 2010 (the National Mortality Table) was prepared separately for women and men through the work of the Prime Ministry Undersecretariat of Treasury, the Department of Actuarial Sciences of Hacettepe University, BNB Consultancy, and Marmara and Başkent universities. The Assembly of Civil Chambers compares the two tables as follows:
“The PMF 1931 life table is a table that does not observe a gender distinction; no distinction between women and men is made. In this table the life expectancy of a newborn is accepted as 56.64 on average. In the TRH 2010 life table, by contrast, a twofold distinction between women and men has very rightly been made. In the TRH 2010 life table the life expectancy of a newborn is set at 78.02 for women and 71.93 for men. When the two tables are compared, differences of between 15 and 22 years arise at the start; although life spans converge in middle age, it is ultimately understood that probable life span and remaining life expectancy are shorter under the PMF 1931 table and longer under the TRH 2010 table.”
According to the same decision, this difference significantly affects the amount of compensation.
How the Choice of Table Affects the Calculation: A Numerical Example
Take a person born on 15.06.1990 who had an accident on 15.06.2020, at exactly 30 years of age. The TRH 2010 figures come from the calculation engine of the site’s bodily injury compensation calculator; the PMF 1931 figure is the value that is identical in two separate published copies of the table. The calculator rounds age at the accident date to the nearest whole year; in the example the accident falls on the birthday.
| Person aged 30 at the accident | Man | Woman |
|---|---|---|
| TRH 2010 remaining life expectancy | 44.45 years | 49.00 years |
| Probable end of life under TRH 2010 | age 74.45 (26.11.2064) | age 79.00 (15.06.2069) |
| PMF 1931 remaining life expectancy (no gender distinction) | 37.50 years | 37.50 years |
| Probable end of life under PMF 1931 | age 67.50 | age 67.50 |
| Difference (TRH 2010 minus PMF 1931) | 6.95 years | 11.50 years |
The difference affects the final years of the calculation. Under the settled method, where the retirement date is not known, earnings are calculated year by year as an active period up to age 60 and a passive period from 60 to the end of remaining life (the reversal reasoning summarised in Assembly of Civil Chambers decision 2021/1563). In the male example the period up to 60 is the same under both tables; the passive period is 14.45 years under TRH 2010 and 7.50 years under PMF 1931. For the woman the gap rises to 11.50 years, because PMF 1931 gives both genders the same value.
The effect is visible in real files as well: in a mining accident of 17.05.2010 the court expert calculated the support loss of the deceased worker’s mother as TRY 99,466.09 under the PMF table and TRY 108,676.77 under the TRH table (first-instance reasoning summarised in 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/12309, K. 2024/13137, 17.12.2024). The calculator computes with TRH 2010 in its work-accident, traffic-accident and other bodily injury modes and shows PMF 1931 for comparison only.
Since When, and by Which Decisions, Was TRH 2010 Adopted?
The transition did not happen on a single date; the table contains only entries verified from official texts.
| Date | Field | Development |
|---|---|---|
| 25.09.2012 | Social security | SGK Circular No. 2012/32: TRH 2010 for initial capitalised values (Assembly of Civil Chambers 2021/1563, § 47). |
| 01.06.2015 | Traffic insurance | New General Conditions: TRH 2010 in the calculation (Assembly of Civil Chambers 2025/264, §§ 10–12). |
| 08.10.2015 | Work accidents | The 21st Civil Chamber describes TRH 2010 as a table “not accepted by our Chamber” (Assembly of Civil Chambers 2021/1563, § 8). |
| 17.07.2020 | Traffic | Constitutional Court, E. 2019/40, K. 2020/40: the reference to the general conditions in art. 90 of the Highway Traffic Code is annulled. |
| 23.02.2021 | Work accidents | 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/9717, K. 2021/2003: TRH 2010 in work-accident and occupational-disease cases (by majority). |
| 01.03.2021 | Traffic | 17th Civil Chamber, E. 2019/6425, K. 2021/2044: TRH 2010 through a change in case-law; the 1.8% technical interest rate is not applied. |
| 21.10.2021 | Traffic | The 4th Civil Chamber moves to TRH 2010 (reversal decision summarised in Assembly of Civil Chambers 2025/263). |
| 02.12.2021 | Work accidents | Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1179, K. 2021/1563: TRH 2010 for an accident of 21.12.2009 (unanimous). |
| 08.03.2022 | Traffic | 4th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/11874, K. 2022/4160: TRH 2010 for an accident of 30.07.2017; the 1.8% technical interest rate is not applied. |
| 17.12.2024 | Work accidents | 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/12309, K. 2024/13137: TRH 2010 as the rule for an accident of 2010; PMF 1931 only because of a vested procedural right. |
| 30.04.2025 | Tort and traffic | Assembly of Civil Chambers: TRH 2010 in E. 2023/1155, K. 2025/263 (unanimous); on the same day, PMF 1931 for a traffic accident of 18.11.2010 in E. 2024/643, K. 2025/264 (by majority). |
| 08.04.2026 | Traffic | Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/488, K. 2026/223: TRH 2010 for an accident of 11.09.2017 (unanimous on this issue). |
The Transition in Work-Accident Cases
The (now closed) 21st Civil Chamber, which heard work-accident cases, relied on PMF 1931 for a long time and, in its reversal of 08.10.2015, did not accept a calculation made under TRH 2010. The first-instance court resisted, also pointing out that, since the Social Security Institution calculates the initial capitalised value under TRH 2010, it would not be equitable to determine the loss under PMF 1931 and then deduct that value. The Assembly of Civil Chambers upheld the resistance:
“… it being accepted that the claimant, who was 33 years old on the date of the accident, had a remaining life expectancy of 42 years and a probable end of life at age 75 under the TRH 2010 life table … As explained above, since the real-loss calculation is by its nature a calculation based on assumptions, and data closest to reality must therefore be used, it is appropriate to take as a basis, in determining the remaining life expectancy, the TRH 2010 life table, which contains current data specific to our country. … It was decided with finality and unanimously on 02.12.2021, the remedy of rectification of decision being closed.”
The Assembly of Civil Chambers drew no distinction by date of incident and sent the file to the 10th Civil Chamber for review of the amount. The 10th Civil Chamber, in its decision of 23.02.2021 (E. 2020/9717, K. 2021/2003), likewise accepted by majority that TRH 2010 is to be used in damages cases arising from work accidents and occupational diseases, applying it to an accident of 03.06.2011; the Chamber refers to this ruling in later decisions as a “precedent decision”. For an accident of 17.05.2010 it also treated TRH 2010 as the rule, applying PMF 1931 solely because of a vested procedural right (see below).
The Transition in Traffic Accidents and Other Torts
The General Conditions of Compulsory Motor Liability Insurance, in force since 01.06.2015, provided for TRH 2010 in the calculation; Article 90 of the Highway Traffic Code, as amended by Law No. 6704 on 14.04.2016, tied the damages covered by insurance to the general conditions. By its decision of 17.07.2020 (E. 2019/40, K. 2020/40), the Constitutional Court annulled the phrases “…and in the general conditions prepared within the framework of this Law…” in the first sentence and “…and in the general conditions…” in the second sentence of the article (Assembly of Civil Chambers 2025/264, § 12). The current text reads:
“Damages within the scope of compulsory motor liability insurance are subject to the procedures and principles laid down in this Law …. … As regards such damages and non-pecuniary damages, the provisions of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 of 11/1/2011 on torts shall apply to matters not regulated in this Law ….”
The places marked “(…)” in the official text correspond, when compared with the wording introduced by Law No. 6704, to the annulled phrases; the life-table and 2% discount rule added by Law No. 7327 on 09.06.2021 was also annulled by the Constitutional Court’s decision of 29.12.2022 (E. 2021/82, K. 2022/167). Thereafter the chambers of the Court of Cassation based the choice of table on their own case-law. The 17th Civil Chamber rejected the regional court’s approval of PMF 1931 for an accident preceding the amendment of 26.04.2016:
“… our Chamber has also decided that determining remaining life expectancy in damages calculations according to the TRH 2010 Table is more consistent with current data and with the realities of our country. In the present case, it is seen that in the actuarial report of 24.08.2017 on which the judgment was based, the probable remaining life expectancy of the provider and of the claimants was determined according to the PMF 1931 Life Table, and that the Regional Court held there was no error in using the PMF Table because the accident at issue occurred before the amendment of the Highway Traffic Code of 26.04.2016. As explained above, since the TRH 2010 Table must be used in damages calculations owing to the change in our Chamber’s case-law, the Regional Court’s acceptance is not correct.”
The 4th Civil Chamber likewise stated, in its decision of 08.03.2022, that TRH 2010 was required for an accident of 30.07.2017. In the most recent Assembly of Civil Chambers decision examined here, the life-table issue in a traffic accident of 11.09.2017 was resolved unanimously in favour of TRH 2010:
“… since the [real-loss] calculation is by its nature a calculation based on assumptions, and data closest to reality must therefore be used, the TRH 2010 life table, which contains current data specific to our country, must be taken as a basis in determining the remaining life expectancy. … That being so, as regards the second issue, the special chamber’s reversal decision, also adopted by the Assembly of Civil Chambers, should have been followed, and resisting with the earlier judgment was not correct. … It was decided with finality on 08.04.2026, by majority as regards issue (1) and unanimously as regards issues (2) and (3).”
The outcome is the same for other torts: in its decision of 30.04.2025 (E. 2023/1155, K. 2025/263) the Assembly of Civil Chambers unanimously adopted TRH 2010 for bodily injury from a fall into the shaft of a shop’s goods lift. It is also reported that the 10th Chamber of the Council of State relied on TRH 2010 in a loss-of-support decision of 17.06.2021 (Assembly of Civil Chambers 2025/264, § 14).
Issues Still in Dispute
Older incidents and Assembly of Civil Chambers decision 2025/264
In a fatal traffic accident of 18.11.2010, the 4th Civil Chamber reversed a calculation made under TRH 2010, relying on Assembly of Civil Chambers decision E. 1989/4-586, K. 1990/199 and on its settled case-law, on the ground that PMF 1931 was required “as at the date of the incident”. The first-instance court resisted, and the Assembly of Civil Chambers reversed the resistance decision by majority:
“Nevertheless, it is accepted that in damages actions arising from torts, the amount and scope of the loss are to be calculated according to the data as at the date of the incident. … The traffic accident at issue occurred on 18.11.2010. Since the real-loss calculation is by its nature a calculation based on assumptions, and data closest to reality must therefore be used, the calculation should have been made, in determining the remaining life expectancy, by applying the PMF 1931 life table and the progressive annuity technique as at the date of the incident; rendering judgment on the basis of a calculation using the TRH 2010 life table is not correct. … [it was decided] that the resistance decision be REVERSED by majority under Article 371 of the Code of Civil Procedure for the reasons stated in the special chamber’s reversal decision”
The majority reasoning sets no threshold date by day and month; the view put forward in favour of TRH 2010 during the deliberations was not adopted. The formula “PMF 1931 for incidents before 2012, TRH 2010 for later ones” appears not in the majority reasoning but in the dissenting opinion, which attributes that view to the majority and the Chamber and does not share it:
“Both the esteemed majority of the Assembly and the Chamber adopted the view that, because the incident date was 2010 and the said TRH-2010 table began to be accepted in the case-law of the Court of Cassation after 2012, the PMF-1931 life table should be applied to incidents occurring before 2012 and the TRH-2010 life table to incidents after 2012. … Life tables are not the legal norm by which the dispute is resolved, but instruments for establishing the nature and extent of the concrete event and facts.”
According to the dissent, the table that shows the loss closest to reality should be used, irrespective of the date of the incident. The following should also be taken into account:
- In decision 2025/263, given on the same day, TRH 2010 was adopted unanimously without discussing the date of the incident; the decision of 08.04.2026, in reaching the TRH 2010 conclusion, cites decisions 2025/263 and 2025/264 together.
- No distinction by date of incident is made in work-accident cases: TRH 2010 has been applied as the rule to accidents of 2009, 2010 and 2011.
- The 17th Civil Chamber did not accept an “older accident, PMF 1931” distinction based on the amendment of 26.04.2016.
The choice of table therefore remains disputed, particularly for traffic accidents in 2010 and earlier, and there is no fixed threshold date. For traffic incidents between 2011 and 2016, no direct Assembly of Civil Chambers ruling is among the decisions examined.
Vested procedural rights: an earlier report based on PMF 1931
Applying TRH 2010 as the rule does not mean that every file will be recalculated with the new table. Where a reversal decision has been complied with, or part of an earlier judgment became final without appeal, the calculation data of that stage may create a vested procedural right (usuli kazanılmış hak) in favour of the other party; the 10th Civil Chamber also refers to Article 281 of the Code of Civil Procedure regarding a vested procedural right arising from failure to object to an expert report. For that reason the Chamber upheld with corrections the judgment concerning the mining accident of 17.05.2010:
“… it is clear that the ‘TRH 2010’ table, which contains current data specific to our country, must also be taken into account in determining remaining life expectancy in pecuniary damages cases arising from work accidents and occupational diseases. … however, in this file, just as a vested procedural right arose in favour of the defendant with respect to the data used in the calculation report of 21.02.2014, and accordingly with respect to the PMF 1931 remaining life table used in that report …”
The same limit exists in traffic cases. When ordering a new TRH 2010 report, the 17th Civil Chamber required that the vested procedural rights of the appellant insurance company be observed; the 4th Civil Chamber’s reversal of 11.01.2024, summarised in Assembly of Civil Chambers decision 2026/223, also records a vested procedural right in favour of the defendant regarding the amount and the 1.8% technical interest rate.
The 1.8% technical interest rate, the progressive annuity and the Constitutional Court decision
Together with TRH 2010, the 2015 General Conditions had introduced, through their annexed tables, a method with a 1.8% technical interest rate. After the Constitutional Court’s annulment decision, the chambers of the Court of Cassation accepted that these tables and the 1.8% rate could no longer be applied, while TRH 2010 continues to apply as a table. The 4th Civil Chamber also ordered an additional report under PMF 1931 at the claimant’s express request:
“For this reason, in calculating damages for loss of working capacity, since it is not possible to use the tables annexed to the new ... General Conditions, and since the 1.8% technical interest was also introduced by those tables, it can no longer be applied. The damages must be calculated without applying 1.8% technical interest … whereas, for the claimant, although the calculation must be made according to the TRH 2010 Table as at the accident date, an additional report should have been obtained, having regard to the claimant’s request, from the expert who previously prepared the report, according to the PMF 1931 progressive annuity method, and a decision rendered on the result, rendering a decision as written with incomplete examination was not found correct.”
The reasoning of the Constitutional Court decision does not mention TRH 2010 or the 1.8% rate by name; these consequences were drawn by the chambers of the Court of Cassation. Today the future (unknown) period is calculated by the progressive annuity method, under which income is increased by 10% and discounted by 10% each year (17th Civil Chamber, E. 2019/6425, K. 2021/2044, 01.03.2021; the 4th Civil Chamber’s decision of 11.02.2026, E. 2023/1913, K. 2026/1414, applies the same method “in accordance with our Chamber’s case-law”). A 1.8% calculation arises only where it has become final through a party’s statement or has created a vested procedural right.
Practical Points
- Age at the accident: Remaining life expectancy follows age at the date of the incident, not at the date of the report.
- Gender: Check that the report uses the correct TRH 2010 column (women/men).
- Date of incident: In work-accident cases TRH 2010 applies irrespective of the date of the incident; for traffic incidents in 2010 and earlier, Assembly of Civil Chambers decision 2025/264 should be considered separately.
- Objection and appeal: If no timely objection is made to the table and technical interest choice in the report, or the judgment is not appealed on that point, a vested procedural right may stand in the way.
- Preliminary estimate: The bodily injury compensation calculator computes with TRH 2010 and shows PMF 1931 for comparison; it does not replace an actuarial report.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between PMF 1931 and TRH 2010?
PMF 1931 is a table built from French population data of 1931 that draws no distinction between women and men; it puts the average life expectancy of a newborn at 56.64 years. TRH 2010 was prepared from Turkish data separately for women and men (for a newborn, 78.02 years for women and 71.93 for men). Remaining life expectancy is shorter under PMF 1931.
Which life table is used in damages calculations today?
Under Turkish law, the Court of Cassation as a rule applies TRH 2010 in work-accident, traffic-accident and other tort cases. The exceptions are certain older traffic accidents, vested procedural rights and a party’s express request.
Does PMF 1931 apply to accidents before 2012?
There is no fixed threshold. The Assembly of Civil Chambers applied PMF 1931 by majority to a traffic accident of 18.11.2010; the “PMF before 2012, TRH after” formula appears in the dissenting opinion. In work-accident cases TRH 2010 has also been applied to incidents of 2009 and 2010.
Does the date of a work accident affect the choice of table?
The decisions examined draw no distinction by date of incident in work-accident cases; PMF 1931 was applied only where a vested procedural right existed.
What happens if an earlier report in the file used PMF 1931?
Judgments based on PMF 1931 reports are, as a rule, reversed; however, where a vested procedural right has arisen in favour of the other party regarding that report, that limit is observed. For this reason the 10th Civil Chamber, in its decision of 17.12.2024, relied on the amount in the PMF 1931 report.
Is the 1.8% technical interest rate still applied?
After the Constitutional Court’s decision of 17.07.2020 (E. 2019/40, K. 2020/40), the chambers of the Court of Cassation no longer apply the 1.8% technical interest rate and have the future period calculated with the progressive annuity (10% increase, 10% discount). A 1.8% calculation that has created a vested procedural right may be preserved.
Related Articles
- Calculation of Work-Accident Compensation (Actuarial Method)
- Damages in Fatal Work Accidents: Calculating Loss-of-Support Compensation
- Damages in Fatal Traffic Accidents: Loss of Support and Calculation Principles
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Work accident attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Work Accident Compensation Law
- SGK Recourse Against Employers for Work Accidents in Türkiye: Conditions, Fault, Amount and Limitation Period
- Work Accidents in Turkish Mines and Marble Quarries: Liability of Employer, Subcontractor, Licence Holder
- Work-Accident Compensation: Your Rights and Legal Remedies
- Is a Heart Attack at Work a Work Accident in Türkiye? Law No. 5510 Art. 13 and Court of Cassation Decisions
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “From PMF 1931 to TRH 2010: The Life Table in Bodily Injury and Loss-of-Support Damages under Turkish Law”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-13, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pmf-1931-to-trh-2010-life-table-compensation

























