Last reviewed:
Rights in a Property-Damage Traffic Accident
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, the injured party in a property-damage traffic accident may claim the repair cost and the vehicle’s diminished value. The injured party may also claim the replacement-vehicle or loss-of-use cost for the period the vehicle is under repair, loss of earnings for commercial vehicles and necessary expenses such as towing and appraisal. If the vehicle is an economic total loss, the loss is its market value less the salvage value. Compensation may be claimed jointly and severally from the operator, who bears strict (hazard-based) liability, from the driver at fault and, up to the policy limit, from the traffic insurer (Highway Traffic Law No. 2918, Arts. 85 and 91). Before suing the insurer, a written application to the insurance company is a condition of the action; if the company does not reply within 15 days or its reply does not meet the claim, the injured party may sue or apply to insurance arbitration (Art. 97). Claims become time-barred two years after the injured party learns of the loss and the person liable and in any event ten years after the accident; if the act is a crime for which criminal law provides a longer period, that period applies (Art. 109).
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
A comprehensive guide to the injured party's rights in a property-damage traffic accident: the claimable losses (repair cost, diminished value, replacement vehicle/loss of use, loss of earnings, economic total loss/salvage); the operator's strict (hazard-based) liability (Law No. 2918, Art. 85); fault and contributory-fault reduction (Art. 86); compulsory financial-liability (traffic) insurance and the insurer's liability up to the policy limit (Art. 91); the written application to the insurer as a condition of the action and insurance arbitration (Art. 97); the complementary application of the Code of Obligations on torts (Art. 90); the calculation of diminished value; limitation (Art. 109); the competent court (Art. 110); and decisions of the 17th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation.
A guide to rights in a property-damage traffic accident; the claimable losses (repair cost, vehicle diminished value, replacement vehicle/loss of use, economic total loss), the operator's strict (hazard-based) liability (Highway Traffic Law No. 2918, Art. 85), fault and contributory fault reduction (Art. 86), compulsory financial-liability (traffic) insurance and the insurer's liability up to the policy limit (Art. 91), the written application to the insurer as a condition of the action and insurance arbitration (Art. 97), the complementary application of general provisions (Turkish Code of Obligations on torts) (Art. 90), the calculation of diminished value, limitation (Art. 109 — two/ten years, criminal limitation), the competent court (Art. 110), and decisions of the Court of Cassation (17th Civil Chamber).
Where, in a traffic accident, only vehicles have collided and been damaged, with no loss of life or injury, this is a “property-damage traffic accident”. Here the injured party's rights are not limited to the repair cost; the vehicle's diminished value, the replacement (rental) vehicle cost for the period of deprivation, and, for commercial vehicles, loss of earnings may also be claimed. This article addresses which losses may be claimed, from whom and by what procedure; the nature of the operator's liability; the liability and limit of the traffic insurer (MTPL); the calculation of diminished value; limitation; and the competent court, with the settled criteria of the Court of Cassation.
Which Losses Can Be Claimed in a Property-Damage Accident?
The injured party's aim is to restore its assets as if the accident had never happened (full reparation). Accordingly, the principal heads of claim are: the repair cost; the diminished value remaining in the vehicle even after repair (the drop in second-hand market value); the replacement-vehicle / loss-of-use cost for the period the vehicle is under repair; loss of earnings for commercial vehicles; and necessary expenses such as towing and expert appraisal. For vehicles that are uneconomical to repair (total loss), the loss is the difference between the vehicle's market value and its salvage value.
From Whom Is It Claimed? Operator, Driver and Insurer
The injured party may, as a rule, claim compensation jointly (severally) from: the vehicle's operator (usually the registered owner), the driver at fault, and the vehicle's compulsory financial-liability (traffic) insurer. The operator's liability is not based on fault but on the hazard created by the motor vehicle — a strict (hazard-based) liability; the operator is liable for the fault of its driver and auxiliary persons as for its own.
“If the operation of a motor vehicle causes the death or injury of a person or damage to a thing, where the motor vehicle is operated under the title or trade name of an enterprise or by a ticket issued by that enterprise, the operator of the motor vehicle and the owner of the enterprise to which it is attached are jointly and severally liable for the loss arising. … The operator and the owner of the operating enterprise are liable for the fault of the vehicle's driver or of the auxiliary persons participating in the use of the vehicle as for their own fault.”
Fault and Contributory Fault (Reduction)
Compensation is determined according to the parties' degrees of fault, established as a rule by the accident report and an expert examination. The operator is released from liability only if it proves that the accident resulted from force majeure or from the gross fault of the injured party or of a third person. Even if it cannot prove this, if it proves that the injured party was at fault (contributory fault) in the occurrence of the accident, the judge may reduce the amount of compensation.
“The operator, or the owner of the enterprise to which the vehicle operator is attached, is released from liability if — without fault on its part or on the part of the persons for whose acts it is responsible, and without a defect in the vehicle having affected the accident — it proves that the accident resulted from force majeure or from the gross fault of the injured party or of a third person. The operator who is not released from liability, if it proves that the injured party was at fault in the occurrence of the accident, the judge may reduce the amount of compensation according to the circumstances.”
Traffic Insurance (MTPL): The Insurer's Liability, Limit and Application Condition
Every motor-vehicle operator is obliged to take out compulsory financial-liability insurance (traffic insurance). The insurer covers the liability falling on the operator of the vehicle at fault up to the policy (compulsory-insurance) limit; in this respect the insurer's liability is limited both by the degree of fault and by the policy limit. The injured party may apply directly to the insurer and bring suit; however, making a written application to the insurer before suing is a condition of the action. If the insurer does not reply within 15 days or its reply does not meet the claim, the injured party may sue in court or apply to the Insurance Arbitration Commission. For property losses caused by uninsured or untraced (hit-and-run) vehicles, the Assurance Account may come into play.
“Operators are obliged to take out financial-liability insurance to ensure that their liabilities under the first paragraph of Article 85 of this Law are met. … Vehicles without compulsory financial-liability insurance for valid coverage amounts are barred from traffic.”
“Before going to court within the limits provided in the compulsory financial-liability insurance, the injured party must make a written application to the relevant insurance institution. If the insurance institution does not answer the application in writing within at most 15 days of the date of application, or there is a dispute that the answer given does not meet the claim, the injured party may bring an action or apply to arbitration under Law No. 5684.”
How Is a Vehicle's Diminished Value Calculated?
A vehicle's diminished value is the permanent drop in its second-hand market value remaining even after the accident is repaired. According to the settled criterion of the Court of Cassation, diminished value is calculated as the difference between the vehicle's undamaged second-hand market value at the date of the accident and its second-hand value after repair. The calculation takes into account the vehicle's make, model, age and mileage at the accident date, the nature and extent of the damage, and any prior (old) damage; for this reason the calculation must be made by an expert (mechanical engineer). Diminished value is claimed from the driver at fault and its traffic insurer (within the policy limit).
Repair or Total Loss? (Economic Total Loss / Salvage)
If repair of the vehicle is technically or economically impossible (the repair cost exceeds the vehicle's market value), the vehicle is treated as an economic total loss. In that case the loss is not the repair cost but the amount found by deducting the salvage value from the vehicle's market value at the date of the event. Thus the injured party cannot be enriched by keeping the salvage and also receiving the full value of the vehicle; the compensation covers the actual loss.
General Provisions: TCO Torts and Full Reparation
Liability arising from a traffic accident is essentially a tort liability. On matters not regulated in the Highway Traffic Law, the provisions of the Turkish Code of Obligations on torts (full reparation, determination of loss and fault, set-off of advantages, etc.) apply in a complementary manner.
“Compensation within the scope of compulsory financial-liability insurance is subject to the procedure and principles provided … in this Law. … As regards the said compensation and non-pecuniary damages, matters not regulated … in this Law are governed by the provisions of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 of 11/1/2011 on torts.”
Limitation
Claims for the compensation of property losses arising from motor-vehicle accidents become time-barred within two years of the date the injured party learns of the loss and the person liable, and in any event within ten years of the day of the accident. If the accident also constitutes a crime (for example, negligent injury) and the criminal law provides a longer limitation period, this extended (criminal) limitation also applies to property-compensation claims. Limitation interrupted against the person liable is deemed interrupted against the insurer as well.
“Claims for the compensation of property losses arising from motor-vehicle accidents become time-barred within two years from the date the injured party learns of the loss and the person liable for compensation, and in any event within ten years from the day of the accident. If the action arises from an act requiring punishment and the criminal law provides a longer limitation period for that act, this period also applies to property-compensation claims.”
Competent Court and Venue
Liability actions arising from the Highway Traffic Law — even where the vehicle's operator is the State or a public body — are heard in the civil courts. The competent court is determined by the defendant: an action in tort against only the driver/operator at fault is, as a rule, heard in the civil court of first instance; actions against an insurance company, being commercial matters, are heard in the commercial court of first instance. As to venue, the action may be brought in the courts of the place of the insurer's branch or the agency and of the place where the accident occurred; the court of the injured party's domicile is also competent.
“Liability actions arising from this Law, including those concerning losses caused by vehicles whose operator or owner is the State and other public bodies, are heard in the civil courts. … Actions concerning civil liability for motor-vehicle accidents may be brought in one of the courts of the place of the insurer's branch or of the agency that concluded the insurance contract, or in the court of the place where the accident occurred.”
Decisions of the Court of Cassation
The decisions below concern the calculation of a vehicle's diminished value, the determination of loss in an economic total loss (salvage), and the traffic insurer's liability up to the policy limit. Traffic-accident compensation actions were for many years heard in the 17th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation; after that chamber was closed, these matters were transferred to other civil chambers by the Court's current division-of-work decisions. All the decisions were verified in full text from the official case-law database.
Calculation of diminished value (market-value difference method), replacement vehicle, and the claim not being liquidated
“The action concerns the annulment of an objection to enforcement proceedings initiated for the collection of the vehicle's diminished value and loss-of-use cost arising from a traffic accident. … the court should — after investigating the prior damage of the claimant's vehicle and obtaining the necessary documents — obtain from another mechanical-engineer expert competent to make the calculation, by separately calculating the repair cost of the damage to the claimant's vehicle and taking into account the nature and extent of the damage, the vehicle's model, make, age and mileage at the accident date, a report determining, as the diminished value, the difference between the second-hand market value (in undamaged condition) at the accident date and the second-hand market value after the damage is repaired … and decide accordingly; whereas deciding as written was not found correct.” (unofficial translation)
The insurer's liability is limited to the policy (compulsory-insurance) limit
“Article 91 of Highway Traffic Law No. 2918 and Article A-1 of the General Conditions of Compulsory Financial-Liability Insurance provide that the insurer covers, up to the compulsory-insurance limits, the legal liability falling on the operator under Highway Traffic Law No. 2918 by reason of having caused, during the operation of the vehicle stated in the policy, the death or injury of a person or damage to a thing. Under the Highway Traffic Law, taking out compulsory financial-liability insurance is obligatory.” (unofficial translation)
If repair is impossible, the loss is the market value less the salvage value
“… whereas, in relation to the traffic accident in question, the salvage value should have been determined and judgment given on the basis of a detailed, reasoned and reviewable supplementary report calculating the loss by deducting the salvage value from the market value determined as of the date of the event, deciding as written was not found correct.” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
Besides the repair cost, what else can I claim in a property-damage accident?
In addition to the repair cost, you may claim the diminished value remaining in your vehicle, the replacement (rental) vehicle or loss-of-use cost for the period the vehicle is under repair, loss of earnings for a commercial vehicle, and necessary expenses such as towing and appraisal. If the vehicle is an economic total loss, the loss is the difference between the market value and the salvage value.
From whom do I claim the vehicle's diminished value?
Diminished value may be claimed from the driver at fault, the vehicle's operator, and their compulsory traffic insurer (limited to the policy limit). If the application to the insurer is rejected, you may go to court or to the Insurance Arbitration Commission.
How is diminished value calculated?
According to the Court of Cassation's criterion, diminished value is the difference between the vehicle's undamaged second-hand market value at the accident date and its second-hand value after repair. The calculation takes into account the vehicle's make, model, age, mileage, the extent of the damage and any prior damage; an expert (mechanical engineer) report is therefore required.
Must I apply to the insurance company before suing?
Yes. Before bringing an action against the compulsory financial-liability (traffic) insurer, making a written application to the insurance company is a condition of the action. If the insurer does not reply within 15 days or its reply does not meet the claim, you may sue or apply to the Insurance Arbitration Commission (Art. 97).
What if the other party has no traffic insurance or fled the scene?
For bodily injury caused by uninsured or untraced (hit-and-run) vehicles, the Assurance Account comes into play; for property (material) losses the Assurance Account's liability is limited. In that case compensation is sought primarily from the driver and operator at fault; the specific situation must be assessed separately.
What is the limitation period for a compensation claim?
For property losses, as a rule, a two-year period from learning of the loss and the person liable, and in any event a ten-year period from the day of the accident, applies. If the accident also constitutes a crime and the criminal law provides a longer period, this extended (criminal) limitation also applies to property compensation (Art. 109).
Within Traffic Accident Compensation Law, Çapar Law Office fully pursues, in property-damage accidents, claims for repair cost, vehicle diminished value, replacement vehicle and loss of earnings, and the injured party's rights — including the application to the insurance company, insurance arbitration and litigation.
- Vehicle Diminished-Value Compensation: How to Claim It After a Traffic Accident under Turkish Law
- Workplace Fire and the Insurer's Liability
- Damages in Fatal Traffic Accidents: Loss of Support and Calculation Principles
- Recourse in Traffic Insurance: The Insurer’s Claim Against the Insured and the Driver, Exclusive Causation and Limitation
Related Articles
- Vehicle Diminished-Value Compensation After a Traffic Accident
- Damages in Fatal Traffic Accidents: Loss of Support and Calculation Principles
- Workplace Fire and the Insurer's Liability
- Recourse in Traffic Insurance: The Insurer’s Claim Against the Insured and the Driver, Exclusive Causation and Limitation
- Knee Pads Not Required, No Contributory Fault Reduction: Turkish Court of Cassation on a Motorcyclist’s Compensation
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Traffic accident compensation attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Traffic Accident Compensation Law
- Knee Pads Not Required, No Contributory Fault Reduction: Turkish Court of Cassation on a Motorcyclist
- From PMF 1931 to TRH 2010: The Life Table in Bodily Injury and Loss-of-Support Damages under Turkish Law
- Motor Own-Damage (Kasko) Insurance Disputes in Türkiye: Exclusions, Alcohol, Total Loss, Recourse, Limitation
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Rights in a Property-Damage Traffic Accident”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/rights-property-damage-traffic-accident

























