Last reviewed:
Workplace Fire and the Insurer's Liability
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, in workplace fire insurance the insurer pays the actual loss arising from a covered fire that occurs during the policy period, up to the sum insured. The burden of proving that the risk falls outside the cover lies with the insurer (TCC Art. 1409), while the insured must prove that the fire occurred and the amount of the loss with documents such as commercial books, invoices and delivery notes. A fire caused intentionally by the insured is excluded and the insurer must prove the intent; absent an agreement to the contrary, fault falling short of intent does not remove the cover (TCC Art. 1429). Late notice of the fire does not eliminate the indemnity altogether, but it is a ground for reduction according to the degree of fault if it increased the indemnity payable (TCC Art. 1446). If the sum insured is below the actual value of the insured assets, a proportional indemnity is paid for under-insurance absent an agreement to the contrary, and the deductible in the policy is subtracted. The action is brought before the commercial court; claims arising from the insurance contract become time-barred two years after they fall due, and indemnity claims in any event six years after the fire (TCC Art. 1420).
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Fire-insurance indemnity after a fire at a workplace: the conditions of the insurer's liability and the scope of cover (Fire Insurance General Conditions); the burden of proving an exclusion lies with the insurer (TCC Art. 1409); the disclosure duty and pro-insured interpretation of the policy (TCC Art. 1423); notice of the fire and the consequence of late notice (TCC Art. 1446); intentional causation of the fire and the insurer's liability for negligence, including gross fault (TCC Art. 1429); calculation of the indemnity (actual/market loss, under-insurance proportional indemnity, deductible, business interruption); the competent court (commercial court) and the Insurance Arbitration Commission; the two-year and six-year limitation (TCC Art. 1420); and Court of Cassation decisions.
Fire-insurance indemnity after a fire at a workplace; the conditions of the insurer's liability and the scope of cover (Fire Insurance General Conditions), the burden of proving an exclusion lying with the insurer (TCC Art. 1409), the disclosure duty and pro-insured interpretation of the policy (TCC Art. 1423), notice of the fire and the consequence of late notice (TCC Art. 1446), proof of intent in causing the fire and the insurer’s liability for negligence, including gross fault (TCC Art. 1429), calculation of the indemnity (actual/market loss, under-insurance proportional indemnity, deductible, business interruption), the competent court (commercial court) and the Insurance Arbitration Commission, the two- and six-year limitation (TCC Art. 1420), and Court of Cassation decisions.
A fire at a workplace can destroy the building, machinery and installations, stock (goods) and fixtures, and on top of that cause turnover loss from a production stoppage. Fire insurance (a workplace/industrial policy) covers these losses. In practice, the most common problem is the insurer refusing to pay on grounds such as “exclusion”, “missing documents” or “the insured's fault”. This article addresses the conditions of the insurer's liability; the scope of cover and the burden of proof; the notice duty; the distinction between intent and negligence (including gross fault); the calculation of the indemnity; the competent court; limitation; and the settled criteria of the Court of Cassation.
What Is Workplace Fire Insurance and the Insurer's Liability?
Fire insurance is a loss insurance: where the risk provided in the contract (fire and the additional perils added to the policy) materialises, the insurer indemnifies the actual loss suffered by the insured, up to the sum insured. The basis of the insurer's liability is the Turkish Commercial Code provision on the duty to bear the risk.
“(1) The insurer is liable for the loss or the sum arising from the materialisation of the risk provided in the contract. (2) The burden of proving that any or some of the risks provided in the contract fall outside the insurance cover lies with the insurer.”
In workplace policies the scope of cover is set by the Fire Insurance General Conditions put into force by the insurance authority. While fire, explosion and lightning are within the basic cover, perils such as internal water, storm, flood/inundation, earthquake, strike-lockout-civil-commotion-popular-movements and terrorism are mostly added to the cover by additional agreement (additional premium).
Conditions of the Insurer's Liability
For the insurer to be liable for the fire indemnity, the following elements are required:
A valid insurance contract and an insurable interest
There must be an in-force fire policy covering the risk address and the insured assets; the insured must have a protectable (pecuniarily measurable) interest in those assets.
Materialisation of the risk within the insurance period
The fire must have occurred within the policy period.
The risk being within the scope of cover
The loss must arise from a risk within the policy and the Fire Insurance General Conditions. The key principle: an insurer alleging that a risk falls outside the cover must prove it (see the next section).
Exclusions and the Burden of Proof: The Insurer Must Prove
One of the strongest pro-insured rules of insurance law is that the burden of proving an exclusion lies with the insurer. If the insurer wishes to avoid paying, it must show that the risk falls within one of the exclusions listed in the policy or the general conditions. A risk not stated as excluded in the policy is, as a rule, within the cover.
By contrast, the insured too must prove that the risk (the fire) materialised and the amount of its loss; in workplaces/commercial establishments this is done with commercial books, invoices, delivery notes and other documents.
Notice of the Fire and the Insured's Duties
The insured/policyholder must notify the insurer without delay upon learning of the fire; must also take loss-mitigation measures and assist the insurer's investigation and requests for information/documents. Importantly, late or deficient notice does not by itself wholly extinguish the indemnity: failure to notify or late notice is a ground for a proportionate reduction according to the degree of fault, but only if it increased the indemnity payable.
“(1) The policyholder, upon learning that the risk has materialised, notifies the insurer without delay. (2) If the failure to give, or the late giving of, notice of the materialisation of the risk has caused an increase in the indemnity or sum payable, a reduction is made from the indemnity or sum according to the degree of fault. (3) If the insurer had already actually learned of the materialisation of the risk, it cannot benefit from the second paragraph.”
Intent and Gross Fault: Excluded?
The Fire Insurance General Conditions exclude a fire caused by the intent of the insured or the policyholder. But the burden of proving this exclusion (that the insured started the fire intentionally or intentionally brought about the risk) lies with the insurer; unless intent is proven, the insurer must pay the indemnity. The insured's fault, by contrast, does not as a rule remove the cover unless it amounts to intent: unless otherwise agreed, the insurer also indemnifies losses arising from the negligence of the insured and of persons for whose acts the insured is legally responsible, and is released from its obligation only where the risk was brought about intentionally (TCC Art. 1429). Where the fire arises from causes to which no fault can be attributed — such as the electrical panel, a short circuit, or overheating — no direct fault can be imputed to the insured.
Calculating the Indemnity: Actual Loss, Under-Insurance and Deductible
As fire insurance is a loss insurance, the insurer as a rule pays the actual (market) loss; the insured cannot be enriched by the insurance beyond its loss. The main mechanisms affecting the calculation are:
Under-insurance (proportional/co-insurance indemnity)
If the sum insured is set below the real value of the insured assets (the insured value), there is under-insurance. In that case, absent a contrary agreement, the insurer pays not the whole loss but the part calculated in proportion of the sum insured to the insured value. Declaring a low stock/fixtures value in workplaces leads to serious indemnity losses at the time of loss.
Deductible
Under the deductible clause frequently found in policies, a certain percentage of the sum insured (often with an upper limit) is left on the insured for each loss; the indemnity is paid after deducting this amount.
Business interruption (loss of profit) cover
If agreed as additional cover in the policy, where the commercial activity stops beyond a certain period due to the fire, business-interruption/loss-of-profit indemnity is also paid, subject to the policy's conditions and limits.
In disputes over the amount of loss, the examination by a court-appointed expert (a specialist panel where needed) is decisive; preserving post-fire damage assessment, photographs, invoices and stock records is therefore very important.
Payment of the Indemnity and Interpretation of the Policy
The insurer must, after the notice of the materialisation of the risk and the documents showing the loss/scope of cover are completed, finish the necessary investigation and pay the indemnity; if it defaults in payment, default interest runs. Because the policy terms are general transaction conditions unilaterally drawn up by the insurer, in case of doubt they are interpreted in favour of the insured. The insurer is also obliged to inform the policyholder before and during the contract, and bears the burden of proving that the disclosure was made.
“(1) The insurer and its agency, before the conclusion of the insurance contract — a necessary period for examination also being granted — notify the policyholder in writing of all information relating to the contract to be concluded, the insured's rights, the provisions to which the insured should pay particular attention, and the notification duties depending on developments. They also explain in writing to the insured, independently of the policy, the events and developments that may be considered important for the insurance relationship during the term. (2) If the disclosure statement is not given and the policyholder does not object to the making of the contract within fourteen days, the contract is deemed made on the terms written in the policy. The burden of proving that the disclosure statement was given lies with the insurer.”
Competent Court and the Insurance Arbitration Commission
Because insurance contracts are commercial transactions, the competent court in fire-insurance indemnity actions is the commercial court of first instance. Where the insurer is a member of the Insurance Arbitration Commission system, the insured may, if it wishes, bring the dispute before the faster-resolving Insurance Arbitration Commission. As to venue, alongside the general rules, the courts of the policyholder's/insured's domicile and of the place where the risk materialised may also come into play.
Limitation Period
Claims arising from an insurance contract are, as a rule, subject to a two-year limitation; claims for the insurance indemnity are in any event subject to a six-year limitation from the date the risk materialised. Tracking the period from the date of the fire is therefore critical.
“(1) All claims arising from the insurance contract become time-barred two years from the date the claim falls due and, subject to Article 1482, claims for the insurance indemnity and the sum insured in any event six years from the date the risk materialised. (2) The provisions in other laws are reserved.”
Court of Cassation Decisions
A risk not stated as excluded in the policy is within the cover; the insurer bears the burden of proving the exclusion (TCC Art. 1409/2)
“… given that hail damage is not shown among the exclusions in the policy, under Article 1409/2 of Law No. 6102 the defendant, who bears the burden of proving that the risk is excluded, failed to discharge that burden. In that case the court should have held the loss to be within the cover and determined the amount for which the insurer would be liable, rather than dismissing the case, and the judgment must therefore be reversed.” (unofficial translation)
Allocation of the burden of proof: the insurer proves the exclusion, the insured proves the occurrence and the amount of loss
“As a rule, just as the insurer is liable for risks arising after a valid insurance relationship is established, the allegation that the risk falls outside the cover must also be proven by the insurer. However, the insured too must prove that the risk occurred and the amount of loss resulting from the risk. Especially in commercial establishments, the burden of proof must be discharged with commercial books, invoices, delivery notes and other evidence. That said, the policyholder is under no obligation to have the existence of the goods present at the workplace determined immediately after the event by the court, the police, or the insurance company.” (unofficial translation)
The insurer's disclosure duty and pro-insured interpretation of the policy (TCC Art. 1423) — a determination upheld by the Court of Cassation
“… under Article 1423 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 the insurer is obliged to inform the policyholder both before and during the contract, and the content of the policy must be interpreted in favour of the insured …” (unofficial translation)
Unless otherwise agreed, the insurer also pays for loss caused by the fault of the insured and of persons for whom the insured is responsible; it is released only where the risk was brought about intentionally (TCC Art. 1429)
“… this provision provides that, on condition that it does not arise from the intent of the policyholder or of the person benefiting from the insurance, losses arising from the fault of the policyholder, of the person benefiting from the insurance or of persons for whose acts these two are legally responsible are also to be indemnified by the insurer, while stating that the parties may agree otherwise. … it is not possible to speak of intentional conduct, within the meaning of Article 1429 of Law No. 6102, on the part of the defendant, for whose acts the non-party insured is responsible. Moreover, it is clear that the circumstances set out in Article A-4 of the Fire Insurance General Conditions which would place the loss outside the cover under the Leasing All Risk insurance did not exist in the present case.” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
The insurer refuses to pay, saying the loss is “excluded”; what can I do?
The burden of proving an exclusion lies with the insurer (TCC Art. 1409/2). A risk not stated as excluded in the policy is, as a rule, within the cover. If the insurer cannot prove the exclusion, it must pay; if the refusal is unjustified, you may sue or go to Insurance Arbitration.
I notified the insurer of the fire late; do I lose my indemnity entirely?
No. Late or deficient notice is a ground for a proportionate reduction according to the degree of fault, and only if it increased the indemnity payable; it does not wholly extinguish the indemnity. If the insurer had already actually learned of the fire, it cannot benefit from this reduction (TCC Art. 1446).
The insurer claims I started the fire; who must prove it?
The insured's intent is an exclusion that removes the cover, and the burden of proving it lies with the insurer; unless intent is proven, the insurer must pay. Fault (negligence) falling short of intent does not, unless otherwise agreed, remove the cover (TCC Art. 1429). Nor can direct fault be imputed to the insured where the cause is one to which no fault can be attributed, such as electrical/short-circuit.
I had declared a low stock value; will I receive full indemnity?
If the sum insured is below the real value, there is under-insurance and, absent a contrary agreement, the insurer pays the loss in proportion of the sum insured to the insured value. It is therefore important to set the sum insured in line with the real value.
My workplace closed because of the fire; can I claim turnover/profit loss?
If business-interruption (loss-of-profit) cover was added to the policy, where the activity stops beyond the period stated in the policy, this indemnity is also paid, subject to the policy's conditions and limits.
By when must I file the indemnity action?
Claims arising from the insurance contract are subject to a two-year limitation; claims for the insurance indemnity are in any event subject to a six-year limitation from the date the risk (the fire) materialised (TCC Art. 1420).
Within Insurance Law, Çapar Law Office handles the collection of insurance indemnity in workplace fires and other risks, actions against exclusion objections, and Insurance Arbitration applications.
Related Articles
- Rights in a Property-Damage Traffic Accident
- Vehicle Diminished-Value Compensation After a Traffic Accident
- Motor Own-Damage (Kasko) Insurance Disputes in Turkish Law: Exclusions, Alcohol, Total Loss and Diminished Value, Recourse, Limitation and the Insurance Arbitration Commission
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Insurance attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Insurance Law
- Breach of the Duty of Disclosure in Turkish Insurance: Can the Insurer Refuse the Claim? (TCC Arts. 1435–1440)
- Recourse in Turkish Traffic Insurance: Claims Against Insured and Driver, Exclusive Causation, Limitation
- Claiming from the Guarantee Fund in Türkiye: Uninsured, Hit-and-Run or Stolen Vehicles (Law 5684 Art. 14)
- Knee Pads Not Required, No Contributory Fault Reduction: Turkish Court of Cassation on a Motorcyclist
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Workplace Fire and the Insurer's Liability”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/workplace-fire-insurers-liability

























