Last reviewed:
General Assembly Annulment in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Time Limit, Mediation, Pre-Finality Enforcement
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, an action to annul a resolution of a joint-stock company’s general assembly must be brought within three months from the date of the resolution. The action concerns resolutions contrary to the law, the articles of association or the principle of good faith and is brought before the commercial court of first instance where the company has its seat (Turkish Commercial Code art. 445). Only the shareholders listed in art. 446, the board of directors and board members whose personal liability would arise from implementing the resolution may sue. Since mandatory mediation applies to commercial actions whose subject matter is a sum of money, no mediation is needed for the annulment claim; however, if compensation is also claimed from the directors in the same statement of claim, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation holds that mediation is a precondition for that claim. Bringing the action does not by itself stop the resolution from being implemented; the court may order suspension of its enforcement (art. 449). The annulment judgment takes effect for all shareholders once it has become final (art. 450); as it contains no performance order, it cannot be the subject of enforcement proceedings, and once final only the court costs and attorney’s fees can be collected through enforcement.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, an action to annul a joint-stock company's general assembly resolution must be brought within three months of the resolution before the commercial court of first instance at the company's seat and is not subject to mandatory mediation. The annulment judgment takes effect only once final and cannot be the subject of enforcement proceedings; Turkish Commercial Code arts. 445–451 and recent Court of Cassation decisions.
Actions for annulment and nullity against general assembly resolutions of a Turkish joint-stock company: who may sue, the three-month time limit, the competent court, mediation as a precondition, suspension of enforcement, the effect of the annulment judgment and whether it can be enforced before it becomes final; Turkish Commercial Code arts. 445–451 and Court of Cassation decisions.
What Is an Action to Annul a General Assembly Resolution in a Joint-Stock Company?
The general assembly decides on matters such as the financial statements, the distribution of profit, the election and discharge of the board of directors, amendments to the articles of association and capital increases. A resolution adopted by majority also binds the shareholders who voted against it. For this reason, the Turkish Commercial Code provides an action for annulment against unlawful general assembly resolutions.
“(1) The persons listed in Article 446 may, within three months from the date of the resolution, bring an action for annulment before the commercial court of first instance where the company has its seat against general assembly resolutions that are contrary to the provisions of the law or the articles of association and, in particular, to the principle of good faith.”
The Code groups the grounds for annulment under three headings: breach of the law, breach of the articles of association and breach of the principle of good faith. The last heading also covers resolutions which, although adopted in compliance with the formal rules, use the majority’s voting power against the minority. In the 2026 decision set out below, the court annulled the profit distribution resolution after finding that the rate of profit to be distributed had been kept very low without any concrete investment plan being shown.
“(1) Resolutions of the general assembly which, in particular;
a) restrict or abolish the shareholder’s rights to attend the general assembly, to a minimum vote, to sue and other inalienable rights arising from the law,
b) restrict the shareholder’s rights to obtain information, to inspect and to audit beyond the extent permitted by law,
c) destroy the fundamental structure of the joint-stock company or are contrary to the provisions on the protection of capital,
are null and void.”
The difference between a voidable resolution and a void resolution is decisive for the outcome. A voidable resolution remains valid until the annulment judgment becomes final and can be set aside only by an action brought within the three-month period. Article 447, by contrast, sets no time limit for nullity. In practice the concept of “non-existence” is also used for resolutions lacking a constitutive element. This three-way distinction is explained in detail in the article Limited Company General Assembly Resolutions: Annulment, Nullity, Three-Month Period and Recorded Dissent under Turkish Law; the same rules apply to limited companies by analogy.
“(1) The provisions of this Code on the nullity and annulment of general assembly resolutions of joint-stock companies also apply to limited companies by analogy.”
Who May Bring the Action?
Not everyone, but only the persons listed in the Code may sue:
“(1) a) Shareholders who attended the meeting, voted against the resolution and had their dissent recorded in the minutes,
b) Shareholders who, whether or not they attended the meeting and whether or not they voted against, allege that the meeting was not called in accordance with the procedure, that the agenda was not duly announced, that persons or representatives not authorised to attend the general assembly attended the meeting and voted, that they were unjustly not permitted to attend the general assembly and vote, and that the irregularities listed above affected the adoption of the general assembly resolution,
c) The board of directors,
d) Each member of the board of directors, if the implementation of the resolutions would give rise to his or her personal liability,
may bring an action for annulment.”
For a shareholder who attended the meeting, three conditions must be met together: attending the meeting, voting against the resolution and having the dissent recorded in the minutes. The dissent must be expressed for each agenda item challenged and during the vote; objecting only during the discussions may not be enough. If the shareholder attended through a representative, the representative’s vote against and the dissent he or she had recorded satisfy this condition.
A shareholder who did not attend or did not vote against may also sue. To do so, he or she must allege that the meeting was not properly called, that the agenda was not duly announced, that unauthorised persons attended and voted, or that he or she was unjustly kept out of the meeting or the vote, and that this irregularity affected the adoption of the resolution. The rules on the call and the agenda are set out in the article How Is the General Assembly of a Turkish Joint-Stock Company Convened?
The board of directors may sue as a body. Individual board members may sue on their own only if implementing the resolution would give rise to their personal liability; the action of a member who is not a shareholder and does not make this allegation is dismissed. Persons not listed in the Code have no right to bring an action for annulment.
Procedure: Court, Time Limit, Mediation, Suspension and Finality
Competent court, defendant and announcement
The action is brought before the commercial court of first instance where the company has its seat. The claim for annulment or nullity is directed at the company. If compensation is also claimed from the directors in the same statement of claim, that claim is directed at different defendants and is therefore treated as a separate action (see the Assembly of Civil Chambers decision below). Once the action is brought, the board of directors must announce that it has been brought and the hearing date and post them on the company’s website.
“(1) The board of directors duly announces that an action for annulment or nullity has been brought and the hearing date and posts them on the company’s website.
(2) In an action for annulment, the hearing may not begin before the three-month period of forfeiture has expired. Where more than one action for annulment is brought, the actions are joined and heard together.
(3) At the company’s request, the court may order the claimants to provide security against the company’s possible losses. The court determines the nature and amount of the security.”
Time limit for challenging a general assembly resolution: three months
The action for annulment must be brought within three months from the date of the resolution. The period runs from the day the resolution was adopted, not from the day the shareholder learned of it, and in the words of the Code it is a “period of forfeiture”. The Code prohibits the hearing from beginning before this period expires and provides for the joinder of annulment actions brought against the same resolution, so that all challenges are assessed in a single set of proceedings.
Two pitfalls stand out. First, an allegation of nullity does not always save the time limit: if the court finds that the ground relied on is in fact a ground for annulment, an action brought after three months is dismissed as out of time. Second, applying to a mediator although this is not mandatory, or relying on the judicial recess, may not extend the period as expected. Examples of both are in the decisions below.
Is mediation a precondition?
“(1) In commercial actions specified in Article 4 of this Code and in other laws, in actions for receivables, compensation, annulment of objection, negative declaration and restitution whose subject matter is a sum of money, having applied to a mediator before the action is brought is a precondition of the action.”
In commercial matters, mandatory mediation is limited to actions for receivables, compensation, annulment of objection, negative declaration and restitution whose subject matter is a sum of money. Annulment of a general assembly resolution, or a declaration of its nullity, is not a monetary claim; therefore there is no need to apply to a mediator before bringing an annulment action. The problem arises when a monetary claim is asserted together with the annulment claim. The Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation emphasised that, for several claims to be asserted in the same statement of claim by way of joinder of claims, they must be directed at the same defendant. If the annulment claim is directed at the company and the compensation claim based on directors’ liability at the directors, the claims are separated and mediation is required as a precondition for the compensation claim.
Is the resolution implemented while the action is pending? Suspension of enforcement
“(1) Where an action for annulment or nullity is brought against a general assembly resolution, the court may, after obtaining the opinion of the members of the board of directors, order that enforcement of the resolution in dispute be suspended.”
The Code does not attach to the bringing of an annulment or nullity action any effect that stops the resolution from being implemented; it leaves suspension of enforcement to the court’s discretion. A claimant who wishes to prevent the implementation of resolutions such as a capital increase, an amendment to the articles of association or the election of the board must ask the court for it. At the company’s request, security may also be required from the claimant (art. 448(3)).
Effect of the annulment judgment: can it be enforced before it becomes final?
“(1) A court judgment on the annulment or nullity of a general assembly resolution takes effect for all shareholders once it has become final. The board of directors must immediately have a copy of this judgment registered in the trade registry and posted on the website.”
A judgment of annulment or nullity binds, once it has become final, not only the claimant but all shareholders. Before it becomes final, the annulled general assembly resolution remains legally in force; the protective remedy during this period is suspension of enforcement.
“(1) An appeal on points of law does not stay the enforcement of the judgment. Article 36 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code on the stay of enforcement is reserved. Stay of enforcement may not be ordered for maintenance judgments.
(2) Judgments concerning the law of persons, family law and rights in rem relating to immovable property may not be enforced until they have become final.”
The general rule of civil procedure is that an appeal on points of law does not stay enforcement of the judgment. Enforcement, however, concerns judgments containing a performance order to be carried out. A judgment annulling a general assembly resolution does not order the company to pay any money. The 12th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that such judgments cannot be the subject of enforcement proceedings and that, once they become final, only court costs and attorney’s fees may be collected through enforcement. The answer to the question “can the annulment of a general assembly resolution be enforced before it becomes final?” is therefore no: the annulment judgment takes effect upon becoming final, and the duty to register it lies with the board of directors.
Bad-faith actions and security
“(1) Where an action for annulment or nullity is brought in bad faith against a resolution of the general assembly, the claimants are jointly and severally liable for the losses suffered by the company for that reason.”
Against the use of the annulment action to obstruct the company’s operations, the Code provides two safeguards: security may be required from the claimant at the company’s request, and those who sue in bad faith are jointly and severally liable for the loss the company suffers as a result. The Code links liability not to the dismissal of the action but to its having been brought in bad faith.
Evidence
The claimant should state specifically which rule the resolution breaches and why, and support this with the minutes, the list of attendees, the call announcements and the financial statements. In resolutions involving discretion, such as profit distribution or remuneration, courts obtain expert reports.
Annulment Actions in Court Decisions
Where the annulment claim is directed at the company and the compensation claim at the directors, mediation is required
The claimants sought, in the same statement of claim, a declaration that resolutions adopted at two general assemblies of the company were non-existent or null, failing which their annulment, and recovery of the company’s loss from the directors. The first-instance court separated the compensation claim and dismissed it on procedural grounds because no mediator had been approached. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed, holding that connected claims were not subject to mediation as a whole; the court insisted on its decision, and the Assembly of Civil Chambers unanimously upheld the decision of insistence.
“The precondition for bringing an action containing more than one principal claim by way of joinder of claims, within the same type of jurisdiction and before a court having common jurisdiction, is that the claims are asserted against the same defendant. … since it is established that the claims were not directed at the same persons and that the present action concerning the compensation claim based on directors’ liability was brought without applying to mediation as a precondition of the action, and since in this situation there can be no question of joinder of claims at the time the action was brought, each action must be heard separately and the preconditions of each action must be examined separately …” (translation)
The annulment action is not subject to mediation; mediation and the judicial recess did not save the time limit
Annulment was sought of resolutions adopted at a bank’s general assembly not to increase capital and on the distribution of profit. The first-instance court stated that the action was not subject to mandatory mediation. Even taking into account, in the claimant’s favour, the period during which the claimant had nevertheless applied to a mediator and an extension for the judicial recess, it found that the action had been brought after the three-month period. The decision was upheld on appeal and on appeal on points of law.
“The first-instance court held that the action was not subject to mandatory mediation, that the claimant applied to mediation on 30.06.2022, that the final report was drawn up on 03.08.2022, that the periods would continue to run from where they had stopped after that date, … that, even if the period falling within the judicial recess were deemed extended by one week from the end of the judicial recess under Article 104 of the Code of Civil Procedure (cited in the decision as ‘HKK’), the period expired on 08.09.2022, and that the present action was brought on 14.09.2022, after the period of forfeiture had expired, and it therefore dismissed the action.” (translation)
If an allegation framed as nullity is in fact a ground for annulment, the three-month period applies
A shareholder company established abroad sought a declaration that the resolution electing the board of directors was null, alleging that the call to the extraordinary general assembly had not reached it. The court held that the grounds relied on fell within voidability and that the action had to be dismissed because it was brought after three months; the decision was upheld.
“… taking into account that the claimant’s allegations of nullity fell within the scope of the sanction of voidability, the action was dismissed on the ground of the period of forfeiture, since it had been brought on 15.10.2022, after the three-month period of forfeiture running from the date of the resolution under Articles 445 and 446 of Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 had expired …” (translation)
Dissent must be expressed at the vote; a board member must allege personal liability
Annulment was sought of resolutions on profit distribution, board remuneration and the election of the independent auditor in a joint-stock company belonging to a group of companies. The court dismissed the action of the board member who was not a shareholder and made no allegation of personal liability; it examined on the merits the action of the shareholder who had attended through a representative, voted against and had the dissent recorded, and annulled the profit distribution and remuneration resolutions. The decision was upheld.
“… under paragraph (d) of the same article, a board member has the right to sue only if the implementation of the resolutions would give rise to his or her personal liability, whereas no such matter was alleged in the statement of claim or in the submissions during the proceedings … in order to bring an action for annulment under Article 446/1-a of TCC No. 6102, the conditions of attending the meeting, voting against the resolution and having the dissent recorded in the minutes must be met together, and the dissent required by that provision must be expressed not during the discussions on the agenda but specifically during the vote and in respect of the result of the vote …” (translation)
An annulment judgment cannot be the subject of enforcement proceedings; once final, only costs may be collected
Shareholders who had obtained a judgment annulling the general assembly’s resolutions on discharge, remuneration, amendment of the articles of association and permission to compete started enforcement proceedings on the judgment and asked for the annulment to be notified to the trade registry through the enforcement office. The enforcement office refused, and the complaint and the appeal were unsuccessful. The 12th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, correcting the reasoning of the regional court of appeal, found the outcome correct.
“What must not be overlooked here is that the judgments referred to in that provision are judgments carrying a clear order for collection (a performance order) whose enforcement requires no interpretation. Therefore, judgments relating to a ‘declaration’ that contain no performance order cannot be the subject of enforcement proceedings. However, once they become final, the liquidated amounts of attorney’s fees and court costs in such judgments may be enforced through enforcement proceedings.” (translation)
Practical Points
- Minutes: A shareholder attending the meeting should vote against each agenda item challenged, have the dissent recorded in the minutes and obtain a copy of the minutes.
- Time limit: The three months run from the day the resolution was adopted. An allegation of nullity, a non-mandatory mediation application or the judicial recess may not save the time limit; bringing the action within three months reduces the risk.
- Defendant and mediation: The claim for annulment or nullity is directed at the company. If compensation is also to be claimed from the directors, a mediator must first be approached for that claim.
- Suspension: The resolution may be implemented while the action is pending. Where the consequences would be hard to reverse, suspension of enforcement should be requested when bringing the action, bearing in mind that security may be required.
- Finality: The annulment judgment does not take effect before it becomes final and cannot be the subject of enforcement proceedings; once final, registration is the duty of the board of directors.
- Bad faith: If the action is brought in bad faith, the claimants are jointly and severally liable for the loss the company suffers as a result.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the time limit for challenging a general assembly resolution?
In a joint-stock company, the action for annulment must be brought within three months from the date of the resolution (Turkish Commercial Code art. 445). The period runs from the day the resolution was adopted and is a period of forfeiture. The Code sets no time limit for nullity under art. 447; however, if the ground relied on is in fact a ground for annulment, an action brought after three months is dismissed.
Is mediation mandatory in an action to annul a general assembly resolution?
No. Under Turkish Commercial Code art. 5/A, mandatory mediation applies to commercial actions whose subject matter is a sum of money; a claim for annulment or nullity is not of that kind. If compensation is also claimed from the directors in the same statement of claim, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation holds that the claims are separated because they are directed at different defendants, and mediation is a precondition for the compensation claim.
Can the annulment of a general assembly resolution be enforced before it becomes final?
No. The annulment judgment takes effect for all shareholders once it has become final (Turkish Commercial Code art. 450). As it contains no performance order, it cannot be the subject of enforcement proceedings; according to the 12th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, once final only court costs and attorney’s fees may be collected through enforcement. Having the judgment registered in the trade registry is the duty of the board of directors.
Does bringing the action stop the resolution from being implemented?
Not by itself. The claimant may ask the court to suspend enforcement of the resolution; the court decides after obtaining the opinion of the board members (Turkish Commercial Code art. 449) and, at the company’s request, may require security from the claimant (art. 448(3)).
Can a shareholder who did not attend the meeting sue?
Yes, but he or she must allege that the meeting was not properly called, that the agenda was not duly announced, that unauthorised persons voted or that he or she was unjustly kept out of the meeting, and that this irregularity affected the adoption of the resolution (Turkish Commercial Code art. 446/1-b). A shareholder who attended must vote against and have the dissent recorded in the minutes.
Can a board member sue against a general assembly resolution?
The board of directors may sue as a body. Individual members may sue on their own only if implementing the resolution would give rise to their personal liability (Turkish Commercial Code art. 446/1-d). The action of a member who is not a shareholder and does not make this allegation is dismissed.
- Limited Company General Assembly Resolutions: Annulment, Nullity, Three-Month Period and Recorded Dissent under Turkish Law
- Turkish Joint-Stock Company General Assembly: How It Is Convened, the Call, Agenda and Quorums
- Liability of Board Members in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Duty of Care, Liability Actions, Discharge and Limitation (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 369, 553–561)
Related Articles
- Annulment of a General Assembly Resolution in a Limited Company
- How Is the General Assembly of a Turkish Joint-Stock Company Convened? Call, Agenda and Quorums
- Liability of Board Members in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Duty of Care, Liability Actions, Discharge and Limitation (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 369, 553–561)
- Attaching Creditor Cannot Annul or Void a Capital Increase: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers on Annulment and Nullity
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Commercial law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law
- When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye
- Appeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative Court
- Which Court Hears Commercial and Consumer Cases in Türkiye: Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya
- Arbitration Clauses under Turkish Law: Validity, the Arbitration Objection and Lawsuits Filed in Court
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “General Assembly Annulment in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Time Limit, Mediation, Pre-Finality Enforcement”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-04, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-general-assembly-resolution-joint-stock-company

























