Last reviewed:
Case NoteAttaching Creditor Cannot Annul or Void a Capital Increase: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the Court of Cassation, a personal creditor who has attached a joint-stock company shareholder’s shares cannot seek the annulment of the general assembly resolution on a capital increase. The Assembly of Civil Chambers held that such a creditor cannot bring the action under art. 445 of the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK), because it is not a shareholder of the company and is not among the persons listed in art. 446 of the TTK. The Assembly did not uphold the nullity claim either: under art. 353, which applies through the reference in art. 456(4) of the TTK, no decision can be given on the nullity or non-existence of general assembly resolutions on a capital increase. The decision of resistance upholding the nullity claim was reversed by majority and with final effect; the file was sent to the regional court of appeal. The creditor’s other possible remedies were not considered in the decision.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that a personal creditor who has attached a shareholder’s shares cannot seek the annulment of the general assembly resolution on a capital increase, since it is not among the persons listed in art. 446 of the Turkish Commercial Code. Holding that, because art. 456(4) refers to art. 353, no decision can be given on the nullity or non-existence of such a resolution either, the Assembly reversed by majority the decision of resistance that had upheld the nullity claim.
A decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation on whether a creditor who has attached a shareholder’s shares may seek the annulment of, or a declaration of nullity of, a general assembly resolution on a capital increase (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 445–447, 456(4) and 353).
The Dispute
The plaintiff is a creditor of a shareholder holding 49% of the shares in the defendant joint-stock company; in enforcement proceedings, an attachment annotation was placed on that shareholder’s 245,000 shares in the company, and the attachment was entered in the share register. The company’s extraordinary general assembly of 16.07.2018 increased the share capital from TRY 500,000 to TRY 5,500,000. Alleging that the company had acted with the aim of harming it, the plaintiff sought a declaration that the resolution was null and void under art. 447 of the TTK.
The first-instance court (commercial court) dismissed the action: although the debtor shareholder’s percentage fell from 49% to 4.4%, its 245,000 shares were preserved as they were. The regional court of appeal, by contrast, found that the company had resorted to a capital increase although it did not need one and that the resolution was contrary to the principle of protection of capital, and it declared the resolution null and void.
The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed that decision. According to the Chamber, a shareholder’s personal creditor could seek neither annulment nor nullity, but only compensation for its loss arising from the difference in value of the attached shares before and after the increase. The regional court of appeal resisted (direnme), stating that nullity may be invoked by anyone and that the reversal would open the way to abuse in share attachments; the defendant company appealed.
Outcome of the Decision
By its decision of 16.09.2026, the Assembly of Civil Chambers reversed the decision of resistance on different grounds and reasons from those in the Chamber’s reversal decision; the file was sent to the regional court of appeal that had given the decision, under art. 373(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK). The decision was given by majority and is final; the text contains no dissenting opinion and does not state the number of dissenting votes. The view put forward during the deliberations that the decision of resistance should be upheld, because the increase was intended to harm the creditor, the significant fall in the debtor shareholder’s percentage was not consistent with the rule of good faith and permission was required under art. 94 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK), was not adopted by the majority of the Assembly.
Reasoning
The Assembly first distinguished the forms of invalidity (nullity: art. 447 of the TTK and art. 27 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK); voidability: art. 445 of the TTK) and explained who may invoke the nullity of a resolution as follows:
“This absolute invalidity is, as a rule, incapable of being remedied and may be invoked by anyone with a legal interest without being limited to any period of time.” (translation)
As regards the action for annulment, the Assembly assessed the plaintiff’s position against the list in art. 446 of the TTK:
“It is clear that, by virtue of its position, the plaintiff is not a shareholder of the defendant company, and that an attachment annotation exists in its favour, on account of its claim, over the share held by the defendant company’s shareholder in the company. In this context, it must be accepted that, since the plaintiff is not among the persons listed in art. 446 of the TTK, it cannot seek, under art. 445 of the same Law, the annulment of the defendant company’s general assembly resolution on the capital increase that is the subject of the action.” (translation)
The Assembly, however, did not consider sufficient the regional court of appeal’s reasoning that nullity may be invoked by anyone, because of the rule specific to capital increases:
“… as stated above, under art. 353 of the same Law, which applies through the reference in art. 456/4 of the TTK, no decision can be given on the nullity or non-existence of general assembly resolutions on a capital increase.” (translation)
Significance and Practical Effect
The decision shows that a creditor who has attached a shareholder’s shares faces two separate obstacles. For annulment, the obstacle is the plaintiff’s standing; the creditor is not on the list in art. 446 of the TTK. For nullity, the Assembly reached its result not from the plaintiff’s standing but from arts. 456(4) and 353 of the TTK. The majority’s reasoning does not discuss whether the increase was intended to harm the creditor.
The Assembly did not consider whether the creditor had any other remedy. Neither the compensation route pointed out by the Chamber nor the application by analogy to a capital increase of the action for dissolution in the second sentence of art. 353(1) appears in the reasoning; nor was the ground of appeal that the attachment had lapsed addressed.
For the time limit and effect of an annulment action, see the article on the action to annul a general assembly resolution. A search, through search summaries and using the words capital increase, attachment and nullity, of Court of Cassation decisions given after 16.09.2026 in the official case-law database found no decision departing from this standard; in the database, decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers appear up to 01.10.2026, while decisions of the 11th Civil Chamber given after the date of this decision do not yet appear.
Relevant Legislation
“(1) The persons listed in Article 446 may, within three months from the date of the resolution, bring an action for annulment before the commercial court of first instance where the company has its seat against general assembly resolutions that are contrary to the provisions of the law or the articles of association and, in particular, to the principle of good faith.”
“(1) a) Shareholders who attended the meeting, voted against the resolution and had their dissent recorded in the minutes,
b) Shareholders who, whether or not they attended the meeting and whether or not they voted against, allege that the meeting was not called in accordance with the procedure, that the agenda was not duly announced, that persons or representatives not authorised to attend the general assembly attended the meeting and voted, that they were unjustly not permitted to attend the general assembly and vote, and that the irregularities listed above affected the adoption of the general assembly resolution,
c) The board of directors,
d) Each member of the board of directors, if the implementation of the resolutions would give rise to his or her personal liability,
may bring an action for annulment.”
“(1) Resolutions of the general assembly which, in particular;
… c) destroy the fundamental structure of the joint-stock company or are contrary to the provisions on the protection of capital,
are null and void.”
“(4) Articles 353 and 354 and the first paragraph of Article 355 apply by analogy to all types of capital increase.”
“(1) No decision may be given on the nullity or non-existence of a joint-stock company. However, if, by acting contrary to the provisions of the law in the incorporation of the company, the interests of creditors, shareholders or the public have been significantly endangered or violated, the commercial court of first instance at the place of the company’s seat decides on the dissolution of the company at the request of the board of directors, the Ministry of Customs and Trade, the relevant creditor or shareholder. …”
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a creditor who has attached a shareholder’s shares seek the annulment of a general assembly resolution on a capital increase?
According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation, no; the creditor is not a shareholder and is not among the persons listed in art. 446 of the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK).
Can the creditor seek a declaration that the resolution is null and void?
In this case, no. According to the Assembly, under art. 353 of the TTK, which applies through the reference in art. 456(4), no decision can be given on the nullity or non-existence of general assembly resolutions on a capital increase.
Does the creditor have another remedy?
The Assembly did not consider this. Nor did it address the route pointed out by the Chamber, compensation for the loss arising from the difference in value of the attached shares.
Is the decision final, and what happened to the case?
The decision was given by majority and is final. The decision of resistance was reversed and the file was sent to the regional court of appeal.
- Action to Annul a General Assembly Resolution: Turkish Joint-Stock Companies, Time Limit, Mediation and Enforcement Before Finality
- Joint Suit Does Not Spare Director Claim from Mediation: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers on General Assembly Annulment
- Wrong Article in Minutes Alone Does Not Prove No Call: Turkish Court of Cassation on General Assemblies Without a Call
Related Articles
- Action to Annul a General Assembly Resolution in a Turkish Joint-Stock Company: Time Limit, Mediation and Enforcement Before Finality
- Joint Suit Does Not Spare Director Claim from Mediation: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers on General Assembly Annulment
- Wrong Article in Minutes Alone Does Not Prove No Call: Turkish Court of Cassation on General Assemblies Without a Call
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Commercial law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law
- When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye
- Appeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative Court
- Which Court Hears Commercial and Consumer Cases in Türkiye: Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya
- Arbitration Clauses under Turkish Law: Validity, the Arbitration Objection and Lawsuits Filed in Court
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Attaching Creditor Cannot Annul or Void a Capital Increase: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/share-attachment-creditor-capital-increase-annulment-turkiye

























