Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Wrong Article in Minutes Alone Does Not Prove No Call: Turkish Court of Cassation on Uncalled Assemblies

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a statement in the minutes that the meeting was held under Article 370 of the former Commercial Code is not enough, on its own, to treat the meeting as a general assembly without a call and to declare its resolutions non-existent. The meeting was held long after Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 entered into force, and the general assembly without a call is now governed by Turkish Commercial Code art. 416; it must therefore be taken into account that the article reference in the minutes is based on a material error. No decision can be given without also examining the company’s defence that the meeting was held with a call. The conditions of a general assembly without a call matter only if the meeting was in fact held without a call.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, according to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a statement in the general assembly minutes that the meeting was held under Article 370 of the former Commercial Code is not enough on its own to treat it as a general assembly without a call and its resolutions as non-existent; under Code No. 6102 the article reference must be regarded as a material error and the company’s defence that the meeting was called must be examined.

A decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation on whether a statement in the general assembly minutes that the meeting was held under Article 370 of the former Turkish Commercial Code No. 6762 is enough to treat the meeting as a general assembly without a call and its resolutions as non-existent (Turkish Commercial Code art. 416, Turkish Commercial Code art. 414).

The Dispute

The claimants are shareholders of the defendant joint-stock company. The minutes of the company’s ordinary general assembly meeting of 27.08.2020 state that the meeting was held under Article 370 of the Commercial Code and that all shareholders were present. The claimants alleged that two shareholders’ signatures were missing from the list of attendees, that the meeting was held without a call and that, since not all shareholders attended, no general assembly without a call had come into being; they sought a declaration that all resolutions adopted at that meeting were void. According to the claimants, one of the resolutions concerned the sale of two natural gas combined-cycle power plant engines, the company’s only assets. The defendant company did not file a response.

The İzmir 4th Commercial Court of First Instance, relying on the wording of the minutes, held that the general assembly had been held without a call and that, since two shareholders were not present, the procedure in Turkish Commercial Code art. 416 had not been followed, and declared the resolutions non-existent. The 20th Civil Chamber of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on the merits. The regional court also stated that the documents the company submitted on appeal, showing that the call had been sent to shareholders by registered post with return receipt, could not be submitted at that stage under Code of Civil Procedure art. 357(1).

Outcome of the Decision

By its decision of 10.09.2026, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed and set aside the regional court’s judgment; the decision was given unanimously. The file was sent to the first-instance court under Code of Civil Procedure art. 373(1), and the defendant’s other grounds of appeal were not examined for the time being. Whether the resolutions are non-existent will be determined in the renewed proceedings.

Reasoning

The Chamber first set out the content of the minutes and the positions of the parties.

Court of Cassation Decision

“The "Ordinary General Assembly Meeting Minutes" of the defendant company’s meeting of 27.08.2020 that is the subject of the action opened by stating that the meeting was held under Article 370 of the TTK, that since it was an Ordinary General Assembly all shareholders were present, that the meeting quorum existed and that there was no objection to holding the meeting, and the agenda was then taken up. … The defendant, on the other hand, argued that the meeting was held after proper calls had been made, but that some shareholders did not attend the meeting, and that the meeting and the resolutions adopted were valid.”

The crux of the dispute is whether the meeting was held without a call or with a call. The Chamber required that the article reference in the minutes be treated as resting on a material error and that the company’s defence of a called meeting also be assessed.

Court of Cassation Decision

“However, given that the meeting took place on 27.08.2020, long after the entry into force of TTK No. 6102, and that under the legislation in force the general assembly without a call referred to at the beginning of the meeting minutes corresponds to Article 416 of TTK No. 6102, it must be taken into account that the reference to an article in the disputed meeting minutes is based on a material error; moreover, whereas a decision should have been given according to the outcome reached by also assessing the defendant’s defence that the meeting was held with a call, it was not correct to accept the action, and the judgment had to be reversed.”

The reasoning that moved from the wording of the minutes to a meeting without a call, and from there to non-existence, was thus not accepted.

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision does not change the conditions of a general assembly without a call. Under Turkish Commercial Code art. 416(1), the holders or representatives of all shares may, unless one of them objects, meet as a general assembly without observing the calling procedure. The first-instance court had also treated these conditions as constitutive elements of the resolutions to be adopted at such a meeting; the Chamber did not discuss that approach. These conditions and the Court of Cassation’s other decisions on the subject are covered in the article How Is the General Assembly of a Turkish Joint-Stock Company Convened?

The question the decision answers comes one step earlier: was the meeting in fact held without a call? The article number written in the minutes, especially a reference to a repealed law, does not settle that question on its own. If a call complying with Turkish Commercial Code art. 414(1) was made, the requirement in art. 416 that all shareholders be present does not come into play, because that requirement applies to meetings held without observing the calling procedure.

Two practical consequences follow. A shareholder alleging that the meeting is non-existent should bear in mind that the wording of the minutes will not suffice and that whether a call was made will be examined separately. For the company, it is important to submit the website and Turkish Trade Registry Gazette announcements and the registered letters with return receipt during the first-instance proceedings; in this case the regional court did not consider the call documents submitted on appeal because of Code of Civil Procedure art. 357(1). The Chamber did not address that procedural assessment separately and confined itself to requiring that the defence of a meeting held with a call be examined. The decision is recent and is a single chamber decision; no later decision on the same issue was found in the decisions accessible.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Turkish Commercial Code (Law No. 6102) art. 416 (General assembly without a call) (unofficial translation)

“(1) The holders or representatives of all shares may, unless one of them objects, meet as a general assembly without complying with the procedure on calling, subject to the provisions on attending the general assembly and on holding general assembly meetings, and may adopt resolutions as long as the meeting quorum exists.

(2) At a general assembly meeting held without a call, items may be added to the agenda unanimously; any contrary provision of the articles of association is invalid.”

Statutory Provision — Turkish Commercial Code (Law No. 6102) art. 414(1) (Call; in general) (unofficial translation)

“(1) The general assembly is called to a meeting in the manner set out in the articles of association, by an announcement published on the company’s website and in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette. This call is made at least two weeks before the meeting date, excluding the days of the announcement and of the meeting. Shareholders registered in the share ledger and shareholders who have notified their addresses by previously giving the company share certificates or documents proving their shareholding are notified by registered letter with return receipt of the meeting date, the agenda and the newspapers in which the announcement was or will be published.”

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the conditions of a general assembly without a call?

The holders or representatives of all shares must be present and none of them may object; in that case the meeting may be held without observing the calling procedure, and resolutions may be adopted as long as the meeting quorum exists. Items may be added to the agenda only unanimously (Turkish Commercial Code art. 416).

Does a statement in the minutes that the meeting was held under Article 370 of the Commercial Code make it a general assembly without a call?

According to the Chamber in this decision, not on its own. If the meeting was held under Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, it must be taken into account that the reference to an article of the former code is based on a material error, and whether a call was made must be examined.

What happens to the resolutions if a shareholder does not attend a general assembly without a call?

In this case the first-instance court and the regional court of appeal had held that the resolutions were non-existent because two shareholders were not present. The Chamber did not discuss that principle; it required first a determination of whether the meeting was in fact held without a call.

How is it shown that the general assembly was called?

The call is made in the manner set out in the articles of association, by an announcement on the company’s website and in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette at least two weeks before the meeting; a registered letter with return receipt is sent to shareholders registered in the share ledger and to shareholders who have notified their addresses by previously giving the company share certificates or documents proving their shareholding (Turkish Commercial Code art. 414(1)). These announcement and mailing records are the documents of the call.

Did this decision bring the case to an end?

No. The decision is a reversal; the file was sent to the first-instance court. The court will decide again after assessing the defence that the meeting was held with a call.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Wrong Article in Minutes Alone Does Not Prove No Call: Turkish Court of Cassation on Uncalled Assemblies”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/general-assembly-without-a-call-minutes-wrong-article

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›