Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 13 min read

Last reviewed:

Return of a Child under the Hague Convention in Türkiye: Application, One-Year Period, Grounds for Refusal

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, if a child is brought to Türkiye from the country of habitual residence, or retained in Türkiye, in breach of the other parent’s custody rights, a return action is brought. The action is based on the 1980 Hague Convention and Law No. 5717; in Türkiye these obligations are performed by the Central Authority through the chief public prosecutor’s offices, and the case is heard under the simple procedure, with priority and urgency (Law No. 5717, arts. 4 and 9). If the application is made before one year has passed since the child was moved, the child’s prompt return is the rule. Return may be refused only on the grounds listed in the Convention, such as a grave risk that return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or the objection of a child of sufficient maturity; the Court of Cassation holds that a child’s young age alone is not a ground for refusal and that a temporary custody order obtained in Türkiye after the return application does not prevent return (Law No. 5717, art. 13).

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the return action under the 1980 Hague Convention and Law No. 5717 where a child is brought to Türkiye, or taken from Türkiye, without the other parent's consent: the Central Authority and the prosecutor, the one-year period, grave risk and the child's objection, and the effect of custody orders, with Court of Cassation decisions.

Under Turkish law, the return of a child to the country of habitual residence under the 1980 Hague Convention and Law No. 5717 where one parent brings the child to Türkiye, or takes the child from Türkiye abroad, without the other parent’s consent: the application, the role of the Central Authority and the public prosecutor, the one-year period, grounds for refusing return, the effect of custody orders and time limits.

What Is International Child Abduction?

One of the most serious disputes in families living abroad is when one parent takes the child to another country without the other parent’s consent, or keeps the child in the country visited on holiday. Legally called “international child abduction”, it is usually a parent taking his or her own child; it differs from the concept of abduction in criminal law. Türkiye is a party to the 1980 Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction; the procedure for applying the Convention in Türkiye is governed by Law No. 5717.

The Convention aims to protect children under 16 from the harmful effects of wrongful removal and to secure their prompt return to the state of habitual residence. A return action is not a custody case: the court does not decide with which parent the child will live, but only whether the child returns to the country of habitual residence, where custody will be decided. For the general rules of Turkish law on custody and contact, see Custody and Personal Relationship (Contact).

Conditions for Return and the One-Year Period

Three elements are required:

  1. Habitual residence. The country where the child ordinarily lived before the removal is identified (for example, Switzerland or Germany, where the child lived with the family since birth).
  2. Wrongfulness. The removal or retention must breach the other parent’s custody rights under the law of the country of habitual residence (Convention art. 3). One parent settling the child in another country alone under joint custody falls into this category. Coming on holiday and not returning may also count as “retention”.
  3. Age. The Convention applies to children under 16.

The one-year period. If return is requested before one year has elapsed from the date of removal or retention, prompt return of the child is the rule (Convention art. 12/1). Return remains possible for applications made after one year; however, the Convention then allows an additional ground for refusal (art. 12/2). Applying without delay is therefore decisive.

Grounds for Refusing Return

The grounds for refusing return are set out in arts. 12/2, 13 and 20 of the Convention and are interpreted narrowly. Those most often argued in practice are the two grounds under art. 13/1-b: a grave risk that return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation, and the child’s objection to returning where the child has attained an age and degree of maturity at which it is appropriate to take account of his or her views. The risk must be shown by concrete evidence; the child’s young age, attachment to the mother or adaptation to the new environment are not in themselves considered sufficient (see the decisions below).

A temporary custody order obtained in divorce proceedings in Türkiye does not prevent return either:

Statutory Provision — Law on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (Law No. 5717) art. 13 (Effect of a custody order on the return action)

“(1) A custody order given after the application for the child’s return does not constitute a ground for refusing the request for the child’s return under this Law.”

Procedure: Central Authority, Prosecutor, Court and Time Limits

Statutory Provision — Law on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (Law No. 5717) art. 4 (Central Authority)

“(1) The obligations provided for in the Convention are performed by the Central Authority through the local chief public prosecutor’s offices.

(2) The Central Authority is authorised to carry out administrative and judicial acts on behalf of the applicant in order to secure the return of the child or the establishment of personal contact.”

The parent abroad may apply to the central authority of his or her own country or directly to the Central Authority in Türkiye. In Türkiye the action is brought by a statement of claim (davaname) filed by the chief public prosecutor’s office where the child is located; the parent may join the proceedings and be represented by a lawyer. The same route can be used to establish contact with the child (art. 4/2).

Statutory Provision — Law on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (Law No. 5717) art. 9 (Procedure)

“(1) The statement of claim for the return of the child is served on the parties together with the hearing date.

(2) All actions and matters arising from the application of this Law are heard under the simple procedure, with priority and urgency.”

In the decisions, the first-instance court is the family court (or, where there is none, the civil court of first instance sitting as a family court). These cases are heard during the judicial recess and time limits are not extended because of the recess; the time limit for appealing a regional court of appeal’s decision to the Court of Cassation is two weeks from service, and the Court of Cassation reviews the file without a hearing (see the 2025 decision below).

Costs. The action is brought by the chief public prosecutor’s office; nevertheless, the parent joining the case with a lawyer, translation and certification of documents and correspondence with authorities abroad may involve costs. For fee and cost amounts, check the tariff in force on the application date and the current announcements of the relevant authorities.

Step by Step: Two Scenarios

A. Your child was taken from abroad to Türkiye and is not returning (you are abroad):

  1. Apply immediately. File a return application with the central authority of your country or with the Central Authority in Türkiye; do not let the one-year period pass.
  2. Document habitual residence and your custody rights. The child’s birth and residence records, school or nursery registration, documents showing joint custody or your custody rights, and correspondence showing you did not consent.
  3. Follow the case in Türkiye. The action is brought by the prosecutor; joining the case with a lawyer in Türkiye matters for submitting evidence and objections in time. A power of attorney may be drawn up at a consulate or before a foreign notary and duly certified; for details see Legal matters for Turkish citizens living abroad.
  4. Do not miss time limits. The judicial recess does not extend time limits; appeal periods are short.

B. Your child was taken from Türkiye abroad (you are in Türkiye):

  1. Apply to the Central Authority in Türkiye. The application is forwarded to the central authority of the country where the child is; the return case is heard there, under that country’s procedure.
  2. Prepare and translate documents. Documents showing the child’s life in Türkiye and your custody rights, with translations.
  3. Consider a contact request too. The Convention allows applications not only for return but also for establishing contact with the child.

Court Decisions on the Return of Children

A child’s young age alone is not a ground for refusing return

A child born in Switzerland and living there with the family was brought to Türkiye for a three-week holiday; the mother did not return, filed for divorce in Türkiye and obtained temporary custody. The first-instance court and the regional court of appeal refused return, citing the child’s age and the temporary custody. The Court of Cassation first recalled the Convention’s one-year rule:

Court of Cassation Decision

“Where the return of a wrongfully removed or retained child is requested within less than one year from the date of removal or retention, the child must be returned promptly and without delay”

Referring also to the European Court of Human Rights’ decision of 03.05.2012, application no. 60328/09, the Chamber held that young age cannot be relied on without a concrete grave risk, and concluded:

Court of Cassation Decision

“Therefore, the child’s young age alone does not give a right to refuse return under art. 13/1-b of the Convention. Likewise, the fact that temporary custody of the child was given to the defendant in the divorce proceedings brought by the defendant in Türkiye has no significance under the provisions of that Convention.”

Where serious allegations exist, the related criminal file must be examined

In a case seeking return to Germany, the mother made a serious allegation against the father; the criminal case brought on that allegation later ended in acquittal. The regional court of appeal refused return relying only on the child’s statement. The Court of Cassation reversed:

Court of Cassation Decision

“Whereas the court should have obtained and assessed this criminal file and decided according to its outcome, dismissing the action with incomplete examination by relying solely on the child’s statement is wrong and requires reversal.”

The decision shows that an allegation of grave risk must be investigated seriously, but that the investigation must rest on concrete evidence and not on a single account.

Procedure: the judicial recess does not extend time limits; the appeal period is two weeks

Court of Cassation Decision
2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2025/7273, K. 2025/9561, 06.11.2025 (dismissal of the prosecutor’s appeal as out of time)

“actions for the return of wrongfully removed children to the country of their habitual residence are, under Law No. 5717, which regulates the procedures and principles for applying this convention, subject to the simple procedure and are urgent matters (art. 9/2); they are heard during the judicial recess, and the provisions on the extension of time limits because of the judicial recess do not apply to actions and matters arising from the application of this law (art. 16).”

In that case the regional court’s decision was served in early July and the appeal was filed in August; as the judicial recess did not extend the time limit, the appeal was dismissed as out of time.

Check for later developments: a search of the 2nd Civil Chamber’s decisions since 2019 for “child abduction” (14 results) shows a consistent line. In its decision of 01.11.2024, E. 2024/8322, K. 2024/8168, the Chamber again declined to treat the child’s adaptation to the new environment and age as grounds for refusal in themselves, requiring concrete proof of grave risk. The current texts of arts. 4, 9 and 13 of Law No. 5717 have been used. The Convention’s provisions are given as quoted in the decisions.

Points to Watch in Practice

  • Do not wait a year. Return is the rule for applications made within one year; delay widens the grounds for refusal.
  • Obtaining custody in Türkiye does not stop return. A custody order given after the return application is not a ground for refusal (Law No. 5717, art. 13).
  • “We went on holiday and did not return” is also retention. A child not returning after a visit with a set return date may amount to wrongful retention.
  • Prove grave risk with concrete evidence. General statements or the child’s account alone are not enough; reports, official records and criminal files are needed.
  • The judicial recess does not extend time limits. Calculate appeal periods in calendar days.
  • Return does not decide custody. Custody and contact are decided separately in the country of habitual residence.

Frequently Asked Questions

My spouse took our child to Türkiye and will not return; what can I do?

You can file a return application under the Hague Convention with the central authority of your country or with the Central Authority in Türkiye. In Türkiye the action is brought by the chief public prosecutor’s office and heard urgently under the simple procedure (Law No. 5717, arts. 4 and 9).

If a year has passed, can return no longer be requested?

It can; but for applications made within one year, prompt return is the rule. After one year the Convention allows an additional ground for refusal, so applying without delay matters.

I obtained custody in Türkiye; can a return order still be made?

Yes. A custody order given after the return application is not a ground for refusing return (Law No. 5717, art. 13). The Court of Cassation has held that temporary custody obtained in Türkiye is of no significance under the Convention.

When is return refused?

On the grounds listed in the Convention, most often a grave risk that return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm, or the objection of a child of sufficient age and maturity. The risk must be shown by concrete evidence; young age alone is not enough.

Does the return case stop during the judicial recess?

No. These cases are heard during the judicial recess and time limits are not extended because of it. The period for appealing a regional court of appeal’s decision is two weeks from service.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Family & Divorce Law

All Family & Divorce Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Return of a Child under the Hague Convention in Türkiye: Application, One-Year Period, Grounds for Refusal”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-13, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/hague-child-abduction-return-of-child-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›