Last reviewed:
Negative-Declaratory and Recovery Actions: Declaring Non-Liability and Recovering Money Paid
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, a negative-declaratory action is brought by a debtor who faces, or is likely to face, enforcement proceedings although not in fact indebted, to have it declared before or during enforcement that he is not liable (EBC art. 72). A recovery action is the action by which a person who had to pay money not owed under threat of compulsory enforcement claims it back within one year from the date of payment. A negative-declaratory action does not stop enforcement by itself: in an action brought before enforcement, the court may grant an interim injunction staying enforcement against security of at least 15% of the claim, whereas in an action brought after enforcement has begun the debtor may only ask that the money held by the enforcement office not be paid to the creditor. If the debt is paid while no injunction has been obtained, the negative-declaratory action continues as a recovery action. Recovering an overpayment made without a threat of compulsory enforcement is not a recovery action under EBC art. 72 but a claim based on unjust enrichment and the general provisions.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Negative-declaratory and recovery actions (EBC art. 72): declaring non-liability, actions before and after enforcement, an interim injunction staying enforcement against 15% security, the condition of recovery (payment under threat of compulsory enforcement) and its one-year period, burden of proof, competent court, and damages for bad-faith proceedings. With verified decisions of the General Assembly of Civil Chambers and the 3rd Civil Chamber.
A guide to the negative-declaratory (menfi tespit) and recovery (istirdat) actions in Turkish enforcement law: a declaration that no debt exists (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code, EBC art. 72), actions brought before or after enforcement proceedings, an interim injunction to stay enforcement against security of at least 15%, the condition for a recovery action (payment made under threat of compulsory enforcement) and its one-year period, burden of proof and written evidence, competent court, and damages for bad-faith proceedings, with verified decisions of the Court of Cassation General Assembly of Civil Chambers and 3rd Civil Chamber.
What Is a Negative-Declaratory Action?
A negative-declaratory action is the action a debtor brings to have it declared that he is not in fact indebted, where he faces — or is likely to face — enforcement proceedings based on a debt that does not truly exist or on an invalid legal relationship. It is governed by Article 72 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code (EBC). The debtor may seek this declaration before enforcement or during the proceedings, because enforcement proceedings do not conclusively establish the underlying substantive relationship between the parties.
The purpose is to establish that a legal relationship or right does not in fact exist. It is a special type of declaratory action: the judgment has the force of res judicata but does not by itself authorise compulsory collection; it establishes that the debtor is not liable.
“A debtor may bring a negative-declaratory action to prove that he is not indebted, before or during enforcement proceedings. The court hearing a negative-declaratory action brought before enforcement may, upon request, issue an interim injunction staying the enforcement proceedings against security of not less than fifteen per cent of the claim. In a negative-declaratory action brought after enforcement has begun, enforcement may not be stayed by way of an interim injunction. However, the debtor may — against security of not less than fifteen per cent of the claim and to cover damages arising from delay — request the court by way of interim injunction that the money in the enforcement office not be released to the creditor.”
What Is a Recovery Action? Difference From Negative Declaration
A recovery (istirdat) action is brought by a person who, although not indebted, was compelled to pay a sum under the threat of compulsory enforcement, in order to recover the amount paid. In a negative-declaratory action no payment has yet been made and a declaration of non-liability is sought; in a recovery action payment has already occurred and the aim is restitution.
The two actions are closely linked: if the debtor brought a negative-declaratory action but did not obtain an interim injunction and the debt is paid while the action is pending, the action continues as a recovery action (EBC art. 72/6). A person who was compelled to pay a sum he did not owe — because he did not object to the proceedings or his objection was lifted — may also bring an independent recovery action.
“If the debtor did not obtain an interim injunction in the negative-declaratory action and the debt has been paid, the action continues as a recovery action. A person who, because he did not object to the proceedings or his objection was lifted, was compelled to pay in full a sum he did not owe, may apply to the court within one year from the date of payment to recover the money under the general provisions. Negative-declaratory and recovery actions may be brought before the court of the place where the enforcement office conducting the proceedings is located, or before the court of the defendant’s domicile. In a recovery action the claimant need only prove that the money was not owed.”
Conditions of the Actions
1) Legal Interest (Condition of Action)
For the debtor to bring a negative-declaratory action, whether before or after enforcement, he must have a legal interest in the declaration of non-liability. Legal interest is a condition of action under CCP art. 114/1-h; absent it, the action is dismissed on procedural grounds without examining the merits. For a declaratory action three requirements must be met together: the claimant’s right must be threatened by a present danger, this danger must place his legal position in doubt in a way capable of causing harm, and the declaratory judgment must be apt to remove the danger. The General Assembly of Civil Chambers has held that even where the unsecured enforcement is stayed by the debtor’s objection, the debtor may have a legal interest in bringing a negative-declaratory action before the creditor files an action to set the objection aside.
2) A Non-Existent or Extinguished Debt
The action rests on the claim that the debt never arose (a bill left without consideration, an invalid legal relationship, forgery) or was subsequently extinguished by payment, set-off or release. The amount of the claim, the underlying instrument and the parties’ commercial or ordinary relationship define the scope of the action.
3) Payment Under Threat of Enforcement and the One-Year Period in Recovery
For a recovery action, the payment must have been made within a finalised enforcement and under the threat of compulsory enforcement. The recovery of overpayments made outside enforcement — voluntarily or without any threat of compulsory enforcement — is not a recovery action within the meaning of EBC art. 72, but a claim based on unjust enrichment and the general provisions. A recovery action must be brought within one year of the date of payment.
Interim Injunction: Staying Enforcement and the 15% Security
The most critical practical aspect of a negative-declaratory action is whether enforcement will be stayed. The rule is as follows:
In an action brought before enforcement, the court may, against security of at least 15% of the claim, issue an interim injunction staying the enforcement. In an action brought after enforcement has begun, enforcement may not be stayed by injunction; the debtor may only, against security of at least 15%, request that the money in the enforcement office not be released to the creditor. If the action succeeds for the debtor, enforcement is stayed and, once the judgment is final, enforcement is reversed; if it succeeds for the creditor, the injunction lapses and the creditor recovers, from the security provided, the damage caused by the delay in obtaining the claim.
Burden of Proof and Written Evidence
The burden of proof is allocated according to the nature of the claims. Where the debt is embodied in an instrument (a bill of exchange, a cheque) and it is alleged that the instrument was given as security or is without consideration, the party making that allegation must — given the amount on the instrument — in principle prove it by written evidence (CCP art. 200). For witnesses to be heard there must be a proper beginning of written evidence; such a beginning is a document that renders the alleged transaction probable and was given or sent by the person against whom it is invoked or his representative (CCP art. 202). Documents not satisfying these conditions (for example, expert reports in a criminal file not drawn up by the opposing party) are not a beginning of written evidence.
Competent Court and Jurisdiction
Territorial jurisdiction: Negative-declaratory and recovery actions may be brought before the court of the place of the enforcement office conducting the proceedings, or before the court of the defendant (creditor)’s domicile (EBC art. 72/8).
Subject-matter jurisdiction: The competent court is determined by the rules applicable to the substance of the dispute. As a rule the civil court of first instance is competent; where the relationship is commercial, the commercial court of first instance; where it is a consumer transaction, the consumer court; where it arises from an employment relationship, the labour court. The negative-declaratory claim is subject to a proportional fee on the value alleged not to be owed.
Time Limits and Forfeiture Period
No special forfeiture period is prescribed for the negative-declaratory action; it may be brought before enforcement or after enforcement has become final, provided the claim is not time-barred and a legal interest exists. By contrast, the recovery action must be brought by the person compelled to pay a sum he did not owe within one year of the date of payment (EBC art. 72/7).
An important distinction: the one-year period in EBC art. 72/7 applies only to the recovery of payments genuinely connected to enforcement (made under threat of compulsory enforcement). The recovery of payments made without any threat of compulsory enforcement is subject to the unjust-enrichment provisions (Code of Obligations art. 78), so the forfeiture period of EBC art. 72/7 does not apply (Court of Cassation, 3rd Civil Chamber, 2025/6082 E., 2026/1169 K., 03.03.2026).
Damages for Bad-Faith Proceedings
If the action succeeds for the debtor and it emerges that the proceedings that forced him to bring the action were unjust and in bad faith, the damage the debtor suffered by reason of the action is also collected from the creditor; this compensation may not be less than twenty per cent of the claim pursued. Conversely, if the action succeeds for the creditor, the creditor’s damage from the delayed recovery — again not less than twenty per cent — is met from the security provided by the debtor (EBC art. 72/4-5). This symmetrical regime deters both baseless proceedings and bad-faith negative-declaratory actions.
Court of Cassation Decisions
Definition of the Negative-Declaratory Action and the Legal-Interest Requirement
“An action brought by a person (the debtor) — who is likely to face, or has faced, enforcement proceedings on account of a debt that does not in fact exist or an invalid legal relationship — to prove that he is not truly indebted is called a negative-declaratory action. … Accordingly, for the debtor to bring a negative-declaratory action before or after enforcement, he must have a legal interest in the declaration that he is not indebted.” (unofficial translation)
Burden of Proof: Proving a Security/No-Consideration Claim by Written Evidence
“In the present case, the claimant who alleges that the bill subject to enforcement was given as security must, given the amount of the bill, prove this by written evidence (CCP arts 190, 200). … these documents neither render probable that the bill was given by way of security, nor are they documents given or sent by the defendant or his representative; accepting them as a beginning of written evidence is unlawful.” (unofficial translation)
Condition of Recovery: Payment Made Under Threat of Compulsory Enforcement
“the claimant’s request concerns not the recovery of money paid under threat of compulsory enforcement within a finalised enforcement, but the return of rent alleged to have been over-collected without legal cause within the lease relationship. The claimant’s having characterised the request as ‘recovery’ in the statement of claim does not bind the court; the legal nature of the request must be assessed not as a recovery action under Article 72 of Law No. 2004, but as a claim based on unjust enrichment and the return of the overpayment under the general provisions.” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a negative-declaratory action stay the enforcement?
Not automatically. In an action brought before enforcement the court may, against security of at least 15% of the claim, issue an injunction staying the proceedings. In an action brought after enforcement, the proceedings cannot be stayed by injunction; the debtor may only, against 15% security, request that the money not be released to the creditor.
What is the difference between a negative-declaratory and a recovery action?
In a negative-declaratory action no payment has yet been made and non-liability is sought. In a recovery action payment has been made under threat of compulsory enforcement and the aim is restitution. If a debtor who brought a negative-declaratory action obtained no injunction and then paid, the action continues as a recovery action.
Is there a time limit for a recovery action?
Yes. A person compelled to pay a sum he did not owe must bring the recovery action within one year of the date of payment (EBC art. 72/7). This period is for payments connected to enforcement (under threat of compulsory enforcement); the return of overpayments outside enforcement is subject to the unjust-enrichment provisions.
Who bears the burden of proof?
It depends on the nature of the claims. If the debt is embodied in an instrument and it is alleged to be without consideration or given as security, the party making that allegation must, in principle, prove it by written evidence (CCP art. 200). Without a beginning of written evidence, proof by witnesses may not be possible.
In which court are these actions brought?
As to territory, before the court of the place of the enforcement office or of the defendant’s domicile. As to subject matter, depending on the nature of the dispute, the civil, commercial, consumer or labour court.
Can I claim damages if the proceedings were unjust?
Yes. If the action succeeds for the debtor and the proceedings are found to be unjust and in bad faith, the debtor’s damage is collected from the creditor; this compensation may not be less than 20% of the claim pursued.
Because negative-declaratory and recovery actions are technical, with rules on time limits and security, conducting them with an enforcement and bankruptcy law lawyer helps avoid loss of rights.
- Negative Declaratory Action on Negotiable Instruments: Promissory Notes, Cheques and Bills of Exchange under Turkish Law
- Action for Annulment of Objection under Turkish Law: Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 67
- Removal of Objection under Turkish Law: Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Arts. 68, 68/a and 69
- Assignment of Claims (Transfer of Receivables)
Related Articles
- Negative Declaratory Action on Negotiable Instruments (Promissory Note, Cheque, Bill of Exchange)
- Action for Annulment of Objection (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 67)
- Removal of Objection (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Arts. 68, 68/a, 69)
- Assignment of Claims (Transfer of Receivables)
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Legislation Information System and the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Enforcement attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Enforcement & Bankruptcy Law
- How to Obtain a Stay of Enforcement Pending Appeal in Türkiye: Step-by-Step Procedure, Security, Time Limits
- Service on Persons Living Abroad under Turkish Law: Consular Service, Public Notice, Unnoticed Judgments
- Fees in Allowed Negative Declaratory Actions Await Finality: Turkish Court of Cassation; No Complaint Deadline
- Compensation in Title Deed Cases Enforceable Before Finality: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Negative-Declaratory and Recovery Actions: Declaring Non-Liability and Recovering Money Paid”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/negative-declaratory-recovery-actions

























