Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Fees in Allowed Negative Declaratory Actions Await Finality: Turkish Court of Cassation; No Complaint Deadline

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, a negative declaratory judgment is a whole; the litigation costs and attorney’s fee awarded when the action is allowed cannot be the subject of enforcement proceedings based on the judgment until the judgment on the merits becomes final. The complaint against proceedings started before finality concerns public order and is not bound by the seven-day time limit in art. 16 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law; the enforcement court annuls the proceedings. The decision was given by majority.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, a negative declaratory judgment is a whole; the litigation costs and attorney's fee awarded when the action is allowed cannot be enforced until the judgment on the merits becomes final. The complaint against such enforcement concerns public order and is not bound by the seven-day time limit. The decision was given by majority.

A decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation on enforcing the litigation costs and attorney’s fee in a negative declaratory judgment before finality and on the time limit for the complaint (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 72/5, art. 16).

The Dispute

A negative declaratory action brought by a company against a bank was allowed on 09.04.2013, and the bank was ordered to pay litigation costs and an attorney’s fee. The bank stated that it had appealed. Without waiting for finality, the company started enforcement proceedings based on the judgment on 31.05.2013 to collect TRY 1,584.60 in litigation costs and TRY 10,050 in attorney’s fees.

The enforcement order was served on 05.06.2013; on 13.06.2013 the bank applied to the enforcement court, arguing that no enforcement could be pursued before the judgment became final. The enforcement court annulled the proceedings; the 8th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, however, reversed, stating that the seven-day complaint period had been missed. The enforcement court insisted on its decision, stating that enforcing a negative declaratory judgment before finality concerns public order and is subject to complaint without time limit.

Outcome of the Decision

On 18.05.2022 the Assembly of Civil Chambers dismissed the creditor’s appeal and upheld the decision to insist; the annulment of the proceedings stands. The decision was given by majority: the view that the claim being enforced was a monetary claim that did not concern public order was not accepted by the majority. The text of the decision contains no dissenting opinion and does not state the number of dissenting votes. Under art. 366/III of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, applied by reference of provisional art. 7 added to that Law by Law No. 5311, the decision was open to a request for rectification; no rectification decision in this file appears in the case-law database.

Reasoning

According to the Assembly, as a rule a judgment need not be final for enforcement based on it; some judgments, however, cannot be enforced until they become final. Under art. 72/5 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, a negative declaratory judgment, too, can be enforced only after it becomes final. As to the ancillary items, the Assembly stated:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“…the judgment is a whole, and the ancillary items in the judgment are subject to the same rule. Enforcement proceedings based on a judgment cannot be brought for the compensation and litigation costs that are ancillary to the judgment either, until the negative declaratory judgment becomes final”

As to the time limit, the Assembly recalled that one of the exceptions to the seven-day period in art. 16 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law is acts contrary to public order, and rejected a distinction that would treat the complaint as free of time limit only for judgments concerning rights in rem over immovables, the law of persons and family law:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“Since finality is an essential element of enforcement based on a judgment in all judgments that cannot be enforced before they become final, a defect in this element amounts to a serious breach of the law and must therefore be characterised as contrary to public order.”

In the case at hand, the Assembly concluded as follows:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“…the debtor’s application to the enforcement court is, as such, a complaint of non-conformity with the judgment and, since it concerns public order, is subject to complaint without time limit. … In the enforcement proceedings complained of, the litigation costs and attorney’s fee awarded in the negative declaratory judgment relied on were claimed; the finality and enforcement of these items depend on the judgment as a whole having become final. Accordingly, the part of the judgment concerning litigation costs and attorney’s fees cannot separately be made the subject of enforcement proceedings before the judgment on the merits becomes final.”

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision treats the litigation costs and attorney’s fee in a negative declaratory judgment not as an independent monetary claim but as ancillary to the judgment. The Assembly noted that this view had also been adopted in its decisions of 07.11.1990, 05.10.2005 and 09.03.2021. The winning party should wait for the judgment on the merits to become final before enforcing these items. According to the Assembly, the enforcement officer should reject such a request of its own motion; the debtor, for its part, may complain even if seven days have passed since service of the enforcement order. The Assembly applied the rule that the complaint has no time limit to all judgments for which finality is required.

In a later decision, the Assembly of Civil Chambers accepted that a judgment dismissing a claim for cancellation of title and registration and awarding compensation could be enforced before finality, stating that for the purposes of arts. 350/2 and 367/2 of the Code of Civil Procedure what matters is not the type of action but the nature of the ruling (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/654, K. 2026/406, 24.06.2026). The enforcement there also sought litigation costs and attorney’s fees; the Assembly upheld the decision to insist in its entirety without assessing those items separately. That decision does not address art. 72 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law or negative declaratory judgments; the costs there accompanied a compensation award enforceable before finality. In a negative declaratory judgment, by contrast, the main ruling is declaratory, and art. 72/5 ties restoration of the enforcement to finality. The two decisions do not conflict; nevertheless, since in the 2026 decision the Assembly dismissed the grounds of appeal of a debtor who argued that the judgment must be treated as a whole, whether this test based on the operative part will be applied to the attorney’s fee in a negative declaratory judgment should be watched.

Caution: The decision concerns a negative declaratory judgment allowing the action; a judgment dismissing the action was not examined in this decision. As to the effect of an appeal on enforcement, art. 443 of the former Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 1086) applied in the dispute by reference of provisional art. 3 of the current Code; the Assembly referred to it together with art. 367/2 of the current Code, and art. 72/5 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law remains in force. That the complaint has no time limit is not a reason to delay it; while the proceedings continue, steps such as attachment may be taken.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (Law No. 2004) art. 72/5 (Negative declaratory and recovery actions) (unofficial translation)

“If the action is decided in favour of the debtor, the enforcement proceedings stop immediately. Upon the judgment becoming final, the enforcement is restored to its former state, in whole or in part, according to its content and without the need for a further judgment. …”

Statutory Provision — Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (Law No. 2004) art. 16 (Complaint and conditions) (unofficial translation)

“Except for matters the law leaves to the court, a complaint may be made to the enforcement court against acts of the enforcement and bankruptcy offices on the ground that they are contrary to the law or not suited to the facts. The complaint shall be made within seven days of the date on which those acts were learned of.

A complaint may be made at any time on the ground that a right has not been fulfilled or has been left pending without cause.”

Statutory Provision — Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) art. 367 (Effect of appeal on enforcement) (unofficial translation)

“(1) An appeal on points of law does not stop the enforcement of the decision. …

(2) Decisions concerning the law of persons, family law and rights in rem over immovable property cannot be enforced until they become final.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the attorney’s fee awarded in a negative declaratory action be enforced before the judgment becomes final?

Under Turkish law, where the action has been allowed, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, no. The litigation costs and attorney’s fee are ancillary to the judgment; they cannot be the subject of enforcement based on the judgment until the judgment on the merits becomes final. A judgment dismissing the action was not examined in this decision.

What is the time limit for a complaint against enforcement started before finality?

According to the Assembly, the complaint concerns public order and is not bound by the seven-day time limit in art. 16 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law.

What happens if the complaint is upheld?

According to the Assembly, the enforcement court annuls the enforcement proceedings.

Which judgments cannot be enforced before they become final?

As a rule, an appeal (istinaf or cassation) does not stop enforcement (Code of Civil Procedure arts. 350/1 and 367/1). Decisions concerning the law of persons, family law and rights in rem over immovable property (arts. 350/2 and 367/2) and negative declaratory judgments (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 72) are among the exceptions; special laws contain further exceptions.

Was the decision unanimous?

No, it was given by majority; the view that the claim, being a monetary claim, did not concern public order did not obtain a majority.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Enforcement & Bankruptcy Law

All Enforcement & Bankruptcy Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Fees in Allowed Negative Declaratory Actions Await Finality: Turkish Court of Cassation; No Complaint Deadline”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/negative-declaratory-attorney-fees-enforcement-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›