Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 20 min read

Last reviewed:

Return of Leased Assets in a Turkish Concordat: Can It Be Postponed? (EBL Arts. 307 and 294/7)

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Yes, but only in the decision confirming the concordat, at the debtor’s request and for no more than one year from that decision. All five conditions of art. 307/3 must be met: the debtor must have assumed performance in kind of the leasing contract under art. 294/7 with the commissioner’s approval, the rent receivable must have arisen before the concordat request, the unpaid rent must not exceed three months’ rent, any loss from depreciation of the asset must be secured, and the debtor must have shown on a balance of probabilities that the asset is indispensable to the business and that its return would endanger the debtor’s economic existence (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/3). A concordat request and the moratorium do not by themselves stop the return: the lessor cannot terminate the contract because the lessee applied for a concordat (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 296/1), but if rent is not paid it may, after a proper notice and termination, sue for return of the asset it owns; the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation affirmed a return judgment based on the reasoning that the postponement had not been proven and that the outcome of the concordat case need not be awaited (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/3472, K. 2025/1972, 19.03.2025). Where the concordat court has, before confirmation, prevented the return of leased assets by an interim measure, the 44th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal held that no contrary delivery injunction may be granted (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/745, K. 2025/976, 03.07.2025).

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

In a Turkish concordat, return of a leased asset can be postponed only in the confirmation decision, at the debtor’s request, for up to one year, if all five conditions of Enforcement Law art. 307/3 are met. Filing alone does not stop a return action. The article covers the conditions, assumption of performance, termination and interim measures in the moratorium, sale-and-leaseback factories and 2023–2026 case law.

Return of leased machinery and real estate in a concordat (konkordato) under Turkish law: the postponement conditions of Article 307/3 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, assumption of performance in kind (art. 294/7), termination and interim measures during the moratorium, the action for return, sale-and-leaseback factories and Court of Cassation decisions.

Does the Concordat Moratorium Stop the Return of a Leased Asset?

Not by itself. The consequences of the definitive moratorium (kesin mühlet) for creditors are framed in terms of enforcement proceedings and interim injunctions against the debtor; the temporary moratorium (geçici mühlet) has the same effects as the definitive one (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 288/1).

Statutory Provision — Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004, art. 294/1 (Consequences of the definitive moratorium for creditors) (unofficial translation)

“During the moratorium no enforcement proceedings may be brought against the debtor … and proceedings already commenced are stayed, interim injunctions and interim attachment orders are not executed, and limitation and forfeiture periods that can be interrupted by an enforcement step do not run.”

Ownership of a leased asset, however, belongs to the lessor (Law No. 6361, art. 23/1), and if the lessor terminates the contract the lessee must return the asset (Law No. 6361, art. 33/1). According to the 44th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal (Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi), because ownership remains with the lessor, return of the asset may as a rule be claimed even in a concordat; the Chamber upheld a return judgment in a case where the moratorium decision contained no postponement under art. 307/3 and the contract had not been terminated because of the concordat request (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/596, K. 2025/1223, 02.10.2025). The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) also affirmed an appellate judgment stating that the lessor’s right to return arose on termination of the contract and that the postponement had not been proven (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/3472, K. 2025/1972, 19.03.2025; affirmed).

Can the Lessor Terminate the Contract During the Moratorium?

A concordat application is not in itself a ground for termination. Contracts important for the continuation of the business are protected during the moratorium:

Statutory Provision — Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004, art. 296/1 (Consequences of the definitive moratorium for contracts) (unofficial translation)

“Regardless of whether the counterparty is affected by the concordat project, contracts to which the debtor is a party and which are important for the continuation of its business shall, as a rule, continue. … Even if the contract contains no such provision, the contract may not be terminated on the ground that the debtor has applied for a concordat. … Obligations owed under contracts continuing during the temporary and definitive moratorium within the scope of this paragraph shall be performed reciprocally.”

If rent is not paid, the termination route of Law No. 6361 remains open: the lessor gives the defaulting lessee thirty days to pay; if the contract provides for transfer of ownership to the lessee at the end of the term this period may not be shorter than sixty days, and if no payment is made within the period the contract may be terminated (Law No. 6361, art. 31/1). In the appellate judgment affirmed by the 11th Civil Chamber, the right of termination was held to have been exercised lawfully despite the objection that the sixty-day period in the notice coincided with the temporary moratorium, and it was stated that rent left unpaid during the moratorium must be paid in full without being subject to the concordat terms (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/3472, K. 2025/1972, 19.03.2025; affirmed).

The Law lays down a similar rule for continuing obligations whose counter-performance has been accepted with the commissioner’s permission: the counter-performances owed under such relationships to which the debtor is a party are not subject to the concordat terms and, in case of default, may be enforced even during the moratorium (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 308/c/4). Rent receivables that arose before the concordat request, on the other hand, are among the claims bound by the concordat once it becomes binding (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 308/c/2). In the limited search carried out for this article, no Court of Cassation decision was found that directly examines a termination based solely on non-payment, during the moratorium, of rent that fell due before the request.

Under What Conditions Is the Return Postponed Under Article 307?

In the words of the 45th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, art. 307 is the “only special provision” on leased assets and lease receivables in the concordat process (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 45th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/1966, K. 2023/161, 01.02.2023).

Statutory Provision — Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004, art. 307/3 (Postponement of the safekeeping and sale of pledged assets and of the return of leased assets) (unofficial translation)

“At the debtor’s request, the return of leased assets may be postponed in the confirmation decision, for a period not exceeding one year from the decision, on the following conditions. a) The debtor must have assumed performance in kind of the financial leasing contract under the seventh paragraph of Article 294. b) The rent receivable arising from the financial lease must have arisen before the concordat request. c) The unpaid rent must not exceed three months’ rent. d) Any loss that may result from the depreciation of the leased asset due to the postponement must have been secured. e) The debtor must have shown on a balance of probabilities that the leased asset is indispensable to the operation of the business and that its return would endanger the debtor’s economic existence.”

The conditions are cumulative. The 44th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal states that postponement requires the debtor’s request and fulfilment of all statutory conditions, and that if the confirmation decision contains no such order, the return cannot be blocked on the ground that the debtor’s assets must be preserved for the project (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/745, K. 2025/976, 03.07.2025; to the same effect E. 2023/596, K. 2025/1223, 02.10.2025). A mere concordat request does not require postponement either; the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation affirmed, on the lessor’s appeal, an appellate judgment containing this reasoning (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/3151, K. 2025/1573, 06.03.2025; affirmed).

The indispensability condition is applied strictly. Applying the similar condition in the first paragraph of the same article on pledged assets, the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation excluded from the postponement an independent unit used as a residence that was not indispensable to the business (Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/1382, K. 2025/2161, 22.05.2025; affirmed as corrected). The Law does not specify the date by reference to which the “unpaid rent” is to be calculated; in the limited search carried out for this article, no Court of Cassation decision clarifying this point was found.

What Does Assuming Performance in Kind (Article 294/7) Mean?

The first postponement condition refers to the seventh paragraph of art. 294:

Statutory Provision — Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004, art. 294/7 (Consequences of the definitive moratorium for creditors) (unofficial translation)

“Non-monetary claims shall be converted by the creditor into a monetary claim of equal value and notified to the commissioner. However, the debtor is free, with the commissioner’s approval, to assume performance of the undertaking in kind.”

Accordingly, the lessee must undertake, with the commissioner’s approval, to continue the leasing contract on its existing terms; without that approval condition (a) of art. 307/3 is not met. Since obligations under contracts continuing during the moratorium are performed reciprocally (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 296/1) and counter-performances under continuing relationships accepted with the commissioner’s permission are not subject to the concordat terms (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 308/c/4), a lessee that assumes performance in kind should pay the rent falling due during the moratorium as the contract provides. The undertaking and the commissioner’s approval should be documented in the concordat file before the confirmation hearing.

Can the Concordat Court Stop the Return by an Interim Measure Before Confirmation?

Art. 307/3 ties postponement to the confirmation decision; there is no leasing-specific provision for the moratorium stage. With the temporary moratorium decision the concordat court takes all measures it considers necessary to preserve the debtor’s assets, and no appeal lies against decisions on such measures (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 287/1 and art. 287/last paragraph). Whether leased assets can be the subject of such measures is not expressly regulated in the Law; the appellate decisions reviewed do not rule out such a measure:

The 45th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal set aside an interim decision of the concordat court refusing to extend the measures to leased assets on the ground that ownership lay with the lessor; it held that interim measures not provided for in the Law may also be ordered, and required that, for each contract, the commissioner panel and experts establish whether the asset is used in the business and is needed for the project, and that the request be decided under art. 389 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) applying art. 307 by analogy (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 45th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/1966, K. 2023/161, 01.02.2023). The 44th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, in a case where the concordat court had by a supplementary decision of 19.03.2025 prevented the return of leased machinery to the lessor, lifted the delivery injunction granted in the action for return (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/745, K. 2025/976, 03.07.2025). In a case with no such measure, the same Chamber upheld the return (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/596, K. 2025/1223, 02.10.2025).

In the limited search carried out for this article, no decision of the 6th or 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation was found that directly resolves whether interim measures may be ordered over leased assets during the moratorium.

What Does the Court Examine in the Lessor’s Action for Return?

The court first examines the conditions of termination: the existence of the rent debt, a proper notice and expiry of the period granted (Law No. 6361, art. 31/1). If the lessee is in a concordat, the court must also examine the concordat file. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed, for incomplete examination, a return judgment given without any assessment of the lessee’s objections that the claim had been entered in the concordat list of creditors and that the asset had been sold and the claim collected, and required that the concordat file be obtained and, if necessary, a report be taken from an expert panel (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/5264, K. 2024/8292, 26.11.2024).

The existence of a postponement, by contrast, must be proven by the lessee. During the moratorium interim injunctions against the debtor are not executed (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 294/1); in this search no Court of Cassation decision was found that directly resolves whether a delivery injunction obtained by the lessor in the action for return falls within this prohibition. In the case affirmed by the 11th Civil Chamber, the definitive moratorium had been granted on 18.04.2019 and part of the assets had been delivered to the lessor under an interim injunction obtained on 29.04.2019; the appellate court stated that delivery under an injunction does not render the action devoid of subject matter (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/3472, K. 2025/1972, 19.03.2025; affirmed). The sale of the asset after termination and the settlement with unaccrued rent are the subject of a separate article (Law No. 6361, art. 33/1).

How Can the Postponement Be Challenged, and When Does It End?

A lessor affected by a postponement request is invited to submit its written opinion before the confirmation hearing and is summoned to that hearing (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/4). The 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that a decision postponing the sale of a pledged asset is subject to appeal and cassation review together with the confirmation decision, and that the bank holding a mortgage over the property whose sale was postponed has a legal interest in appealing it (Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/743, K. 2026/1035, 25.03.2026). The decision concerns a pledged asset; since the leasing postponement is governed by the same article and is also given in the confirmation decision, the same conclusion may be reached for the lessor, but in this search no Court of Cassation decision was found that says so expressly for leasing.

If the debtor voluntarily transfers the leased asset, goes bankrupt or dies, the postponement automatically becomes void (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/5). The court that confirmed the concordat, at the lessor’s request and after inviting the debtor, lifts the postponement if it is shown on a balance of probabilities that the postponement was obtained by giving false information, that the debtor’s wealth and income have increased so that it can pay the debt without endangering its economic existence, or that the return no longer endangers the debtor’s economic existence (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/6). In no case may the postponement exceed one year from the confirmation decision.

What Changes for a Factory or Real Estate Under Sale and Leaseback?

In a sale and leaseback (satıp geri kiralama), the lessor buys the asset from the lessee itself (Law No. 6361, art. 18); here too ownership has passed to the lessor. Art. 307/3 speaks of “leased assets” and draws no distinction between movables and immovables; postponement for a factory building or production facility is subject to the same five conditions. For high-rent facilities, the three-month rent limit and proof on a balance of probabilities, through the commissioner’s report and financial data, that the facility is indispensable to the business carry particular weight.

For real estate, proper service of the termination notice is also decisive. The 7th Civil Chamber of the Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal, in a case where the lessor was a participation bank and the return of two immovables was sought, refused a delivery injunction because service of the notice was unclear and default had therefore not been shown on a balance of probabilities; it did not adopt the first-instance court’s additional, concordat-based reasoning (Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal, 7th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/2263, K. 2025/225, 03.02.2025). The claim that a leaseback was in reality security for a loan is discussed in the article on sham transactions and fiduciary transfers, and deductions by a bank from the company’s account during the moratorium in the article on bank deductions in a concordat.

Court of Cassation and Regional Court of Appeal Decisions

The decisions below are 2024–2026 decisions of the 6th and 11th Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation and of the 44th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal. In affirming decisions, the quotation is taken from the reasoning of the affirmed appellate judgment as reproduced in the Court of Cassation decision.

As ownership belongs to the lessor, return may be claimed; the lessee must prove the postponement and the outcome of the concordat case need not be awaited

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/3472, K. 2025/1972, 19.03.2025 (affirmed; lessee’s appeal; unanimous)

“since ownership of the leased asset belongs to the plaintiff financial leasing company, the plaintiff has the right to claim return of the asset upon termination of the contract; the defendant has not alleged and proven that the concordat was confirmed or that the return of the leased assets was postponed in the confirmation decision under Article 307 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law; moreover, there is no need to await the outcome of the concordat case” (translation)

In an action for return, judgment may not be given without obtaining the concordat file and examining the lessee’s objections

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/5264, K. 2024/8292, 26.11.2024 (Chamber’s reasoning for reversal; unanimous)

“It is seen that both the first-instance court and the regional court of appeal gave judgment without making any assessment of the defendant company’s serious objections set out above or of the concordat case. … giving judgment as written on the basis of incomplete examination was not correct, and the judgment had to be reversed in favour of the defendant.” (translation)

A postponement under Article 307 is subject to appeal and cassation review together with the confirmation decision

Court of Cassation Decision
6th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/743, K. 2026/1035, 25.03.2026 (Chamber’s reasoning for reversal; postponement of the sale of a pledged asset; unanimous)

“Accordingly, although the decision on postponing the safekeeping and sale of pledged assets is subject to appeal and cassation review together with the confirmation decision, the regional court of appeal’s acceptance, by broadly interpreting Article 341 of the Code of Civil Procedure and Article 287/last paragraph of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law on the temporary moratorium, that it is not subject to appellate review was not found correct.” (translation)

If the concordat court’s interim measure covers the leased assets, no contrary measure may be granted in the action for return

Regional Court of Appeal Decision
Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/745, K. 2025/976, 03.07.2025 (appellate decision; interim injunction lifted; final; unanimous)

“However, if there is a concordat interim measure covering the leased assets as described, there will be no legal basis for ruling contrary to that measure on the ground that ownership of the leased asset belongs to the lessor.” (translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

Can leased machinery be taken back from a company in concordat?

If rent has not been paid and the contract has been terminated by a proper notice, the lessor can bring an action for return; the concordat moratorium alone does not prevent this (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/3472, K. 2025/1972). However, if the concordat court has issued a measure preventing the return of the machinery, a contrary delivery injunction may not be granted in the action for return (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/745, K. 2025/976).

For how long can the return of a leased asset be postponed in a concordat?

For at most one year from the confirmation decision. The postponement is ordered in the confirmation decision at the debtor’s request and depends on all five conditions of art. 307/3 (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/3). If the debtor voluntarily transfers the asset, goes bankrupt or dies, the postponement automatically becomes void (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/5).

Is postponement possible if more than three months of lease rent is unpaid?

No. The Law lists as a condition of postponement that the unpaid rent must not exceed three months’ rent (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/3-c). This condition applies together with the other four; the absence of any one prevents postponement.

Can a leasing company terminate the contract because the company applied for a concordat?

No. The contract may not be terminated on the ground that the debtor applied for a concordat, and obligations under contracts continuing during the moratorium are performed reciprocally (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 296/1). If rent is not paid, however, the notice and termination route of Law No. 6361 applies (Law No. 6361, art. 31/1).

Termination of leasing contracts, actions for return and postponement requests under art. 307 in the concordat process fall within the firm’s Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law and Commercial and Corporate Law practice areas.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Enforcement & Bankruptcy Law

All Enforcement & Bankruptcy Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Return of Leased Assets in a Turkish Concordat: Can It Be Postponed? (EBL Arts. 307 and 294/7)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-14, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/return-leased-assets-postponed-concordat

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›