Last reviewed:
Sale after Financial Lease Termination in Türkiye: Who Pays the Price Difference? (Law No. 6361 Art. 33)
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: If the lessor terminates a financial lease and the returned asset is sold to a third party, the sale price is compared with a statutory total unless the contract agrees a different value. That total is the rentals not yet due plus any further loss of the lessor: if the sale price is lower, the lessee pays the difference; if it is higher, the lessor pays the difference. The same applies where the lessee terminates under the second paragraph of art. 30 of the Law and where the asset is re-leased (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). Art. 33/1 sets no market-value test; the Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber has, however, required in a pre-6361 contract containing a set-off clause that the sale be checked against the market value (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/3469, K. 2021/683, 01.02.2021). Where, in a dispute between the parties, the asset has been left to the lessor or a third party by an interim injunction, the lessor may dispose of it by depositing with the court security equal to its market value, and must compensate the lessee’s loss if the termination proves unjustified (Law No. 6361 art. 31/3). In actions filed on or after 31.07.2026 there is no action for an unquantified claim; the difference is claimed by a partial action, and the claim may be increased once in the same action until the end of the evidentiary stage (Code of Civil Procedure art. 109/4).
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
When a terminated lease asset is sold in Türkiye, the price is set against unpaid future rent and loss; the lessee pays a shortfall, the bank a surplus. The contract may agree another value (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). Covered: proving an undervalue sale, the art. 31/3 security, Law No. 3226 contracts, the right action and the effect of Law No. 7589 abolishing the unquantified-claim action, with court decisions.
Sale of the leased asset by a bank or leasing company after termination of a financial lease in Türkiye: the settlement under Law No. 6361 art. 33, refund of the surplus to the lessee, proving an undervalue sale, the security under art. 31/3, contracts from the Law No. 3226 era, the right type of action and Law No. 7589.
How Is the Price of an Asset Sold after Termination Settled?
If the contract is terminated by the lessor, or by the lessee under the second paragraph of art. 30 of the Law, the lessee must return the asset (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). It makes no difference that the lessor is a participation (interest-free) bank (katılım bankası); financial leasing transactions carried out by participation banks are also subject to this Law (Law No. 6361 art. 2/2). For the termination notice and the return action, see our article Financial Leasing in Participation Banks; this article deals with the sale after return and the price difference.
“Where the returned asset is sold to third parties, unless a different value has been agreed in the contract, if the sale price is lower than the total of the financial leasing payments not yet due and any loss of the lessor exceeding them, the difference shall be paid by the lessee to the lessor. Unless a different value has been agreed in the contract, if the sale price of the returned asset is higher than the total of the financial leasing payments not yet due and any loss of the lessor exceeding them, the difference shall be paid by the lessor to the lessee. The same principles apply where the returned asset is leased to third parties by way of financial leasing.”
On one side of the account is the sale price; on the other, the total of the rentals not yet due and any further loss of the lessor. The provision brings only these items into the comparison; rentals that fell due and remained unpaid before termination lie outside it and are separate contractual debts. Some contracts also bring these items into the account (see below).
Where the asset has been returned but not yet sold, art. 33/1 provides no separate accounting rule. In the lessee’s bankruptcy, the Court of Cassation’s 6th Civil Chamber reversed a judgment admitting a claim to the estate on the basis of an expert report that calculated amounts both due and not yet due as at the bankruptcy date, because it had been given without investigating whether the machine had been handed over to the lessor and without determining the claim recoverable under art. 33 (Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/3797, K. 2025/4496, 25.12.2025).
What If the Contract Agrees “a Different Value”?
Both rules in art. 33/1 apply “unless a different value has been agreed in the contract”; the Law does not define that value, so the termination and return clauses of the contract are examined first. In a contract examined by the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 17th Civil Chamber, the VAT-exclusive sale price was compared not only with the rentals not yet due and the further loss but also with overdue rentals, insurance premiums and their default interest, and the excess was paid to the lessee. The Chamber upheld the first-instance judgment that deducted the sale proceeds from the claim (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 17th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/411, K. 2026/350, 05.03.2026; subject to appeal).
An agreed value must be provable. In one case the lessee argued that, when returning the machines, the lessor had undertaken to settle on an appraisal value of USD 650,000 and not to sell below it, so that its remaining debt was USD 23,000. The first-instance court gave no credit to this claim in view of the contract and the statutory provision and because there was no evidence originating from the lessor’s authorised officers, and found the set-off of the sale proceeds against the debt lawful. The Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber dismissed all of the lessee side’s appeal grounds and upheld the regional court of appeal’s judgment, correcting it only as regards the mixed-up party designations in the paragraphs on costs and fees (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/410, K. 2025/5419, 17.09.2025).
The safe course is a written agreement on value, appraisal and method of sale, signed by authorised representatives, at the time of return. Where the lessee voluntarily returned the assets, consented to their sale and asked for the proceeds to be deducted from its debt, the regional court of appeal held that no special authority in the power of attorney was needed for this and dismissed on procedural grounds, for lack of legal interest, the return action later brought by the lessor; the Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber upheld that decision (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/5993, K. 2023/997, 20.02.2023).
If the Bank Sells the Asset Too Cheaply, What Must the Lessee Prove?
Art. 33/1 builds the settlement on the “sale price” (satış bedeli); it contains no test of market value, official valuation or method of sale. A limited search for this article did not identify a Court of Cassation decision deciding on the merits an undervalue-sale claim under Law No. 6361. The decision found concerns a contract dated 18.01.2006 that authorised the lessor to sell the asset at any value and to anyone it wished and to set the proceeds off against the debt. In the lessor’s appraisal the cutting bench had been valued at TRY 50,000, and at TRY 35,000 in a forced sale; it was sold for TRY 30,000 including VAT; the first-instance court had stated that this power of sale must not breach Civil Code art. 2 (Turkish Civil Code art. 2). The Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber required the value of the asset to be determined by checking the sale price against the market value and to be set off against the remaining rent debt, and reversed the judgment based on an inadequate expert report (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/3469, K. 2021/683, 01.02.2021).
In a negative declaratory action where one supplementary expert report valued the assets at TRY 850,000 and another at TRY 2,453,997, the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 16th Civil Chamber set the judgment aside mainly because of a contradiction between the reasoning and the operative part; “assuming acceptance” (kabule göre), it also stated that it had not been examined whether the amounts reported by non-party companies matched the market value or whether the assets had lost value as second-hand goods, and that, since the assets had been sold about 1.5 years after delivery to the lessor, the reasonable sale period and the second-hand value obtainable within it had to be determined by a verifiable report (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 16th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/1850, K. 2026/631, 16.04.2026).
Unless the law provides otherwise, each party must prove the facts on which it bases its right (Turkish Civil Code art. 6). Useful evidence for a lessee alleging an undervalue sale includes the return report and the appraisal at the time of return, sale advertisements and offers, the buyer’s relationship with the lessor, the time between return and sale, and comparable sales of the same model; as value requires technical knowledge, the court refers to an expert (Code of Civil Procedure art. 266/1). In the lessee’s bankruptcy, the Court of Cassation’s 12th Civil Chamber stated that a bankruptcy office which, when separating the leased assets from the estate (tefrik), had obtained a valuation and ruled that they should not be sold below TRY 3,760,000 ought to have confined itself to the separation decision; it reversed on the ground that the complaint had since become devoid of subject matter (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/10245, K. 2023/2746, 25.04.2023).
The same dispute has arisen over real estate in participation bank sale-and-leaseback transactions: before the Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal, 7th Civil Chamber, the lessee companies argued that a plot of about 30 decares transferred to a participation bank by sale and leaseback had been worth at least TRY 60,000,000 but had been sold for TRY 24,780,000; as the Chamber held the action devoid of subject matter because the concordat (konkordato) confirmation had been set aside, it did not examine this defence (Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal, 7th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/2579, K. 2024/252, 15.02.2024). For postponement of the return in concordat, see Return of the Leased Asset in Concordat.
Can the Lessor Sell the Asset While the Case Is Pending?
Where, while the dispute is pending, the asset has been left to the lessor or a third party by an interim injunction (ihtiyati tedbir), the lessor’s power of disposal is specifically regulated:
“(3) In disputes between the lessee and the lessor concerning the financial leasing contract, where the leased asset is left by the court to the lessor or to a third person by an interim injunction, the lessor may dispose of the asset by depositing with the court security equal to the market value of the asset. However, if it is decided that the termination of the contract was unjustified, the lessor shall be obliged to compensate the lessee’s loss.”
Unlike art. 33/1, this provision expressly uses market value as its measure. It therefore matters whether the asset reached the lessor through an injunction or by consent. In one case the regional court of appeal had upheld the return order for all the assets, holding that a delivery made under the injunction did not give the lessor a free power of disposal. The Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber, however, stated that the injunction had not been enforced, so that the assets delivered by the lessee during the proceedings were not within the injunction, and reversed on the ground that the action should have been dismissed as devoid of subject matter for those assets (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/179, K. 2024/8608, 03.12.2024). A lessee who learns that the asset has been sold while the case is pending should check the file to see whether delivery rested on an injunction and whether the lessor deposited security.
Is the Sale Price Deducted from the Rent Debt under Pre-2012 Contracts?
Law No. 6361 was published in the Official Gazette of 13.12.2012 and entered into force on publication (Law No. 6361 art. 53), repealing the Financial Leasing Law No. 3226 (Law No. 6361 art. 52/1). The Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber applies art. 25 of Law No. 3226, which was in force on the contract date: where the first-instance court had deducted the value of the machines from the rent debt on grounds of unjust enrichment and equity, it held that set-off inappropriate and reversed (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/4236, K. 2024/7999, 18.11.2024), and it upheld a dismissal based on the ground that the sale of the asset after its return gave the lessee no right to claim the price (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/8067, K. 2022/1383, 01.03.2022). If, however, the contract provides that the sale proceeds will be deducted from the debt, set-off is made (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/3469, K. 2021/683). For the fate of a down payment under older contracts, see our article on refund of the down payment in financial leasing.
Which Action Is Used to Claim the Difference, and What Did Law No. 7589 Change?
If the lessor has started enforcement proceedings for its remaining claim after the sale, the lessee may object to the payment order and raise the set-off as a defence in the action for annulment of the objection that the lessor will bring; it may also seek a declaration of non-indebtedness by a negative declaratory action. The USD 650,000 appraisal claim above was argued in such a negative declaratory action (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/410, K. 2025/5419). If the sale price exceeds the lessor’s claim, the lessee brings a receivable action for the difference. Actions arising from the rules on financial institutions are commercial cases (Commercial Code art. 4/1-f); in receivable, compensation, annulment of objection, negative declaratory and restitution actions whose subject is a sum of money, prior application to a mediator is a condition of action (Commercial Code art. 5/A).
The settlement is not made in the action for return of the asset. In an action, heard after the lessee’s bankruptcy, for the return of real estate and cancellation of the financial leasing annotation, the Court of Cassation’s 6th Civil Chamber rejected the bankruptcy administration’s appeal ground that the judgment should also order the surplus of the sale to be paid to the estate; stating that the art. 33 settlement can only be assessed when the claim is removed from the estate or in an action for cancellation of the registered claim, it upheld the return judgment (Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/3183, K. 2026/489, 11.02.2026).
Current position (November 2026): The difference often becomes clear only through an expert examination. Art. 107 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK), which governed the action for an unquantified claim (belirsiz alacak davası) used for such claims, was repealed by art. 19 of Law No. 7589 (Code of Civil Procedure art. 107); Law No. 7589 was published in the Official Gazette of 31.07.2026 and this article entered into force on publication (Law No. 7589 art. 26/1-c). Art. 107 continues to apply to actions filed before the date of repeal (Law No. 7589 provisional art. 1/10). In actions filed later, the lessee claims part of the difference by a partial action:
“Where only part of a receivable has been sued for, the subject of the claim may be increased once in the same action, without being subject to the prohibition on extending the claim, until the end of the evidentiary stage. In that case, limitation shall be deemed interrupted from the date of the action also in respect of the increased part.”
The lessee can thus increase its claim once in line with the difference revealed by the expert report. For time limits, see our article on limitation and preclusive periods.
Court of Cassation and Regional Court of Appeal Decisions
A limited search for this article did not identify a Court of Cassation or Assembly of Civil Chambers decision deciding on the merits an undervalue-sale claim under Law No. 6361; the first decision concerns a contract made under Law No. 3226 that contained a set-off clause.
The price of the lessor’s sale is checked against the market value
“the value of the asset sold must be determined by checking whether the sale price at which the defendant sold this asset to a third party matched the market value, it must be set off against the remaining rent debt, the creditor-debtor position as at the date of the enforcement proceedings must be determined, and a decision must be given accordingly.” (translation)
Under a contract from the Law No. 3226 era, the sale price is not automatically deducted from the rent debt
“Setting the sale price of the leased asset off against the rent debt without regard to the said statutory provisions was not found appropriate, and the judgment had to be reversed for this reason.” (translation)
The art. 33 settlement is not made in the action for return of the asset
“although Article 33 of Law No. 6361 … contains the provision, since this matter can only be assessed when the claim is removed from the bankruptcy estate by the bankruptcy administration or in an action for cancellation of the registered claim” (translation)
Where the sale was late, the second-hand value the asset would have fetched within a reasonable time is investigated
“the assets were sold about 1.5 years after delivery to the defendant, and in that situation, while a new verifiable expert report should have been obtained also to determine what the reasonable sale period would be and what the second-hand value would be if they had been sold within a reasonable period, giving judgment on incomplete examination based on inadequate main and supplementary expert reports was not found appropriate.” (translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
The leasing company or bank sold the asset cheaply; do I have to pay the difference?
Unless the contract agrees a different value, if the sale price is lower than the total of the rentals not yet due and any further loss of the lessor, the lessee pays the difference (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). You must prove that the sale fell below market value with appraisals, advertisements and comparable sales (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/3469, K. 2021/683).
If the sale price exceeds the remaining rentals, is the surplus paid to the lessee?
Yes. If the sale price is higher than the total of the rentals not yet due and any further loss of the lessor, the lessor pays the difference to the lessee; the same principles apply if the asset is re-leased (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). The contract may also bring overdue rentals, insurance premiums and interest into this account.
After taking the asset back, can the bank also claim all the remaining rentals?
If the asset is sold, the rentals not yet due are compared with the sale price and only the difference may be claimed for them; rentals that fell due and remained unpaid before termination are a separate debt (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). The Court of Cassation’s 6th Civil Chamber reversed a judgment admitting a claim to the estate given without investigating whether the machine had been handed over (Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/3797, K. 2025/4496). The rule differs for contracts from the Law No. 3226 era.
In 2026, can an action for an unquantified claim be brought for the leasing price difference?
No. Art. 107 of the Code of Civil Procedure was repealed by Law No. 7589 and applies only to actions filed before the date of repeal (Law No. 7589 provisional art. 1/10). In new actions the receivable is claimed by a partial action; the claim may be increased once in the same action until the end of the evidentiary stage, and limitation is deemed interrupted from the date of the action also for the increased part (Code of Civil Procedure art. 109/4). Prior application to a mediator is a condition of action (Commercial Code art. 5/A).
Can the bank sell the leased asset while the case is still pending?
If the asset has been left to the lessor or a third party by an interim injunction, the lessor may dispose of it by depositing with the court security equal to its market value, and must compensate the lessee’s loss if the termination proves unjustified (Law No. 6361 art. 31/3). Where the lessee voluntarily returned the asset and consented to its sale, it was held that the lessor had no legal interest in the return action it brought later (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/5993, K. 2023/997).
Disputes arising from the termination of financial leasing contracts, the sale of the asset and the settlement of the price difference fall within our firm’s Commercial and Corporate Law and Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law practice areas.
- Financial Leasing in Participation Banks: Rent, Ownership, Default, Termination and Return of the Asset
- Negative Declaratory and Restitution Actions: Declaration of Non-Indebtedness and Recovery of Money Paid
- Action for Annulment of Objection under Turkish Law: Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 67
- Limitation and Preclusive Periods: Differences, General and Five-Year Limitation, Suspension and Interruption
- Down Payment Refund in Turkish Financial Leasing: Can the Lessee Recover What It Paid the Seller after Termination?
- Sale and Leaseback or a Disguised Loan: Simulation (Muvazaa) and Fiduciary Transfer Claims under Turkish Law
Related Articles
- Katılım Bankalarında Finansal Kiralama (Leasing): Kira Bedeli, Mülkiyet, Temerrüt, Fesih ve Malın İadesi
- Menfi Tespit ve İstirdat Davası: Borçlu Olmadığının Tespiti ve Ödenen Paranın Geri Alınması
- İtirazın İptali Davası (İİK m.67)
- Zamanaşımı ve Hak Düşürücü Süreler: Farkları, Genel ve Beş Yıllık Zamanaşımı, Durma ve Kesilme Sebepleri
- Refund of the Down Payment in Financial Leasing under Turkish Law: Can the Lessee Recover What It Paid the Seller after Termination?
- Is Sale and Leaseback Really a Loan? Simulation (Muvazaa) and Fiduciary Transfer Claims under Turkish Law
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Commercial law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law
- When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye
- Appeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative Court
- Which Court Hears Commercial and Consumer Cases in Türkiye: Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya
- Arbitration Clauses under Turkish Law: Validity, the Arbitration Objection and Lawsuits Filed in Court
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Sale after Financial Lease Termination in Türkiye: Who Pays the Price Difference? (Law No. 6361 Art. 33)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/financial-lease-termination-sale-price-difference

























