Last reviewed:
Down Payment Refund in Turkish Financial Leasing: Lessee's Recovery of Payments to the Seller on Termination
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: The Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber holds that, where certain conditions are all met, an amount the lessee paid directly to the seller must be awarded against the lessor. The conditions are that the lessee paid that part of the asset’s price directly to the seller before the contract was signed and before ownership passed to the lessor, that the lessor did not finance that part, and that the asset was returned to the lessor after termination; the Chamber holds that the financial leasing was then made only for the remaining price (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900, 13.02.2025). The decision concerns a contract made in 2007, during the period of the repealed Financial Leasing Law No. 3226; the Chamber did not separately name the legal basis of the refund, and the lessee had also relied, in the alternative, on unjust enrichment. The financial leasing provisions of Law No. 6361 do not separately regulate a payment made by the lessee to the seller; where the Law contains no provision, the general provisions apply (Law No. 6361 art. 2/6), and an enrichment based on a cause that is invalid, has not materialised or has ceased to exist must be returned (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 77). A claim based on unjust enrichment becomes time-barred two years after the claimant learns of the right to reclaim and in any case ten years after the enrichment (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 82/1).
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
A down payment the lessee paid directly to the seller, if not financed by the lessor, is recoverable once the asset is returned (Court of Cassation, 2025). The decision concerns a 2007 contract under the repealed Law No. 3226; the article also covers the provisions available under Turkish Law No. 6361 (arts. 2/6, 33/1; Code of Obligations art. 77), evidence, release protocols and limitation.
Refund of the down payment (peşinat) in financial leasing under Turkish law: whether the part of the price that the lessee paid directly to the seller and the lessor did not finance can be claimed from the lessor after termination and return of the asset; the 2025 decision of the Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber, the period of the repealed Law No. 3226, the settlement under art. 33 of Law No. 6361, unjust enrichment (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 77) and limitation.
What Is a Down Payment in Financial Leasing, and What Does the Lessor Finance?
In financial leasing (finansal kiralama) the lessor buys or otherwise obtains the asset chosen by the lessee and leaves its possession to the lessee against rent; ownership stays with the lessor throughout the contract (Law No. 6361 art. 23/1).
“(1) A financial leasing contract is a contract under which the lessor, at the lessee’s request and choice, leaves to the lessee, against rent and for the purpose of deriving every benefit, the possession of an asset that it has bought from a third party or from the lessee itself, or has otherwise obtained, or has previously acquired in ownership.”
The leasing payment and the payment periods are set by the parties (Law No. 6361 art. 20/1). “Down payment” (peşinat) is not a concept separately regulated in the Law’s financial leasing provisions; in the text of the Law the word appears only in provisional article 9 on savings financing companies. In the Court of Cassation decisions examined for this article the down payment appears in two forms: an amount paid by the lessee to the lessor at the start of the contract (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/8251, K. 2022/2555, 29.03.2022), or the part of the asset’s price paid to the seller by the lessee, directly or through the lessor (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900, 13.02.2025; Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/6932, K. 2025/6071, 09.10.2025).
What Were the Facts in the 11th Civil Chamber’s 2025 Decision?
The lessee company concluded a financial leasing contract dated 08.06.2007 with a financial leasing company for an immovable with a factory building on it. According to the findings of the first-instance court, the contract value was USD 1,500,000; USD 600,000 of the factory’s sale price was paid by the lessee to the co-owners of the immovable, this payment was found established by bank receipts bearing explanations, and a five-year payment plan was made for the remaining USD 900,000. The Court of Cassation found that the USD 600,000 was paid to the owners of the immovable before the title was transferred to the financial leasing company and before the contract date (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900, 13.02.2025).
The lessee defaulted on payments; by a notice dated 27.10.2008 the lessor stated that if the debt was not paid within 60 days the contract would be deemed terminated without further notice. The lessee side claimed that the contract was in reality a sham commercial loan and sought its annulment and, failing that, alleging that the lessor had been unjustly enriched, sought payment of USD 900,000 for the time being. By a counterclaim the lessor sought the return of the immovable in kind and the cancellation of the contract annotation in the land register.
The first-instance court dismissed the main action and upheld the counterclaim; the appeal was dismissed on the merits. The Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber upheld the decision on the counterclaim, reversed the decision in the main action in respect of the price the lessee had paid to the sellers, and dismissed the other grounds of appeal falling outside the reversal. The decision was given unanimously on 13.02.2025 (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900).
Why Did the Chamber Order the Refund of the Down Payment?
Referring to the Assembly of Civil Chambers (Hukuk Genel Kurulu), the Chamber describes financial leasing as a three-party relationship in which the seller issues the invoice in the name of the financial leasing company and collects the price of the asset from it (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1647, K. 2020/88, 06.02.2020). In this case, however, since the USD 600,000 was paid by the lessee, the lessor provided no financing whatsoever for that part. The Chamber assessed three facts together: the payment of that amount by the lessee to the owners of the immovable, the fact that the lessor did not finance that part, and the counterclaim judgment ordering the return of the immovable to the lessor in kind. From these facts it concluded that the financial leasing contract had been made for the remaining price, and stated that the amount paid by the lessee should have been awarded against the lessor (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900).
The regional court of appeal had taken the opposite view: noting that the contract treated the amount the lessee paid to the sellers as an advance payment, that this payment was aimed at setting the instalments at a more reasonable level, and that the balance claimed by the lessor did not mean the lessee paying the same amount a second time, it concluded that there was no unjust enrichment. The Chamber did not find the dismissal of the entire main action on that reasoning correct. The Chamber did not separately name the legal basis of the refund in its decision; the lessee’s alternative claim also rested on unjust enrichment (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900).
The same Chamber has also accepted a claim for the return of a down payment as unjust enrichment in a case where no valid financial leasing contract had been formed. It had been established by a final judgment that there was no valid contract, because the vehicles subject to the contract dated 18.05.2006 had been seized before the contract date and could not be delivered; the Chamber made it a ground for reversal that, although the reasoning stated that the claim for the return of the EUR 12,560 down payment paid at the start of the contract arose from the lessor’s unjust enrichment, no ruling on it was made in the operative part (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/8251, K. 2022/2555, 29.03.2022).
The Decision Belongs to the Period of the Repealed Law No. 3226: What Difference Does That Make?
The contract in the 2025 decision dates from 2007; the first-instance court applied articles 24 and 25 of the repealed Financial Leasing Law No. 3226 (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900). Law No. 3226 was repealed by Law No. 6361 (Law No. 6361 art. 52/1). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, Law No. 6361 entered into force on 13.12.2012, and disputes concerning financial leasing contracts made before that date are governed by Law No. 3226 and the earlier regulations (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1647, K. 2020/88).
The difference between the two periods is clear in the consequences of termination. Under art. 25 of Law No. 3226, as quoted by the Assembly of Civil Chambers, if the lessor terminates the contract the lessee returns the asset and pays the rentals not yet due, and is also liable for any further loss of the lessor (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1647, K. 2020/88). Relying on that provision, the Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber on 18.11.2024 reversed a decision which, in a contract made in the Law No. 3226 period, had deducted the value of the returned machines from the rent debt on grounds of unjust enrichment and equity (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/4236, K. 2024/7999, 18.11.2024). Under Law No. 6361, by contrast, the sale price of the returned asset enters the settlement and, if the sale price is higher, the difference is paid to the lessee (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1).
The Assembly of Civil Chambers notes a further difference: under the repealed Law the lessor had to obtain the asset from a third party, whereas Law No. 6361 abolished this compulsory three-party relationship (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1647, K. 2020/88); today the lessor may also buy the asset from the lessee itself (Law No. 6361 art. 18/1). The Chamber’s reasoning on the down payment does not cite any article of Law No. 3226; it rests on the fact that the lessor did not finance that part of the price (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900).
Under Law No. 6361, Which Provisions Support the Same Result?
The financial leasing provisions of Law No. 6361 do not separately regulate a payment made by the lessee directly to the seller. Where the Law contains no provision, the general provisions apply (Law No. 6361 art. 2/6). One of the general provisions that can be invoked in that case is unjust enrichment:
“A person who is enriched from another’s assets or labour without just cause is obliged to return that enrichment. This obligation arises in particular where the enrichment is based on a cause that is invalid, has not materialised or has ceased to exist.”
For a contract made under Law No. 6361, the same result may therefore be argued by relying together on Law No. 6361 art. 18/1, which defines the lessor as buying or otherwise obtaining the asset and leaving it to the lessee, and Turkish Code of Obligations art. 77, and on the non-financed-part criterion of the 2025 decision. A limited search for this article did not identify a Court of Cassation decision that directly resolves, for a contract made under Law No. 6361, the refund after termination of an amount the lessee paid to the seller and the lessor did not finance.
On termination, art. 33/1 of Law No. 6361 provides for a separate settlement: the lessee returns the asset; if the asset is sold to a third party or leased again by way of financial leasing, the sale price is compared with the total of the rentals not yet due and any further loss of the lessor. The provision does not separately mention a payment made by the lessee to the seller before the contract, and the parties may also agree on a different value in the contract (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). No decision resolving whether the down payment enters this settlement was identified either; the details of the settlement are discussed in the article on the post-termination sale and the value difference.
A refund may also be claimed where the cause of the payment later falls away: the Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber upheld the dismissal of the appeal against a first-instance decision accepting that a lessee who terminated the contract on 28.12.2015, because a lawsuit seeking registration of the immovable in the name of the Treasury was pending, could reclaim its down payment and instalments under the rules of unjust enrichment (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/879, K. 2025/6053, 09.10.2025; upheld).
If the asset is not delivered because of the lessor’s fault or negligence, arts. 123, 125 and 126 of the Turkish Code of Obligations apply (Law No. 6361 art. 25). In a case based on a contract dated 25.02.2015, a down payment of EUR 600,000, being 30% of the machinery price, was paid to the seller and the machines were not delivered; the first-instance court and the regional court of appeal found the bank at fault for not obtaining a guarantee or counter-guarantee against the payment to the manufacturer and ordered the refund of EUR 600,000. The Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber reversed that decision because it had been given without assessing the release and termination protocol dated 02.06.2016 relied on by the bank (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/6932, K. 2025/6071, 09.10.2025). In a case where the lessor had paid the seller on time and was not, under the contract, responsible for delivery, the Chamber upheld the dismissal of the action against the financial leasing company; there, the manufacturer had refunded the down payment paid to it before the action was brought (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/2600, K. 2020/5012, 12.11.2020; upheld).
How Is the Refund Claimed: Evidence, the Sham-Transaction Allegation and Limitation
Evidence: In the case decided in 2025, the lessee’s payment to the sellers was found established by bank receipts bearing explanations. How the payment was shown in the payment plan was also disputed: the lessee claimed that the USD 600,000 was shown in the payment plan sent to it as if it were a paid instalment, while the lessor argued that the amount had been taken as a down payment and set off against what appears as rent (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900).
Difference from the sham-transaction allegation: A claim for the refund of the down payment is separate from the allegation that the contract is in reality a loan. In the case decided in 2025, the regional court of appeal stated that a party cannot claim rights by relying on its own sham transaction (muvazaa) and that it was contrary to good faith for a lessee in default to allege invalidity three years after the contract; the Court of Cassation dismissed the grounds of appeal outside the reversal (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900). The sham-transaction and fiduciary-transaction allegation is the subject of the article on sale and leaseback and sham transactions.
Limitation: If the claim rests on unjust enrichment, the special limitation provision of the Turkish Code of Obligations applies:
“The right to claim arising from unjust enrichment becomes time-barred on the expiry of two years from the date on which the right-holder learned of the right to reclaim and, in any case, of ten years from the date on which the enrichment occurred.”
Condition of action: Actions arising from matters relating to the commercial enterprises of both parties are commercial cases (Commercial Code art. 4/1); in commercial cases concerning a receivable for a sum of money, applying to a mediator before the action is brought is a condition of action (Commercial Code art. 5/A/1). The competent court is discussed in the article on financial leasing by participation banks.
Court of Cassation Decisions
The 2020–2025 decisions below do not state that the lessor was a participation bank; financial leasing transactions carried out by participation banks are also subject to Law No. 6361 (Law No. 6361 art. 2/2).
A price paid by the lessee to the seller and not financed by the lessor is payable to the lessee once the asset is returned to the lessor
“In other words, the company ..., defendant in the main action and claimant in the counterclaim, provided no financing whatsoever for that part. Having regard to the fact that the USD 600,000.00 relating to the price of the immovable … was paid to the owners of the immovable, that it was not financed by the financial leasing company, and that in the counterclaim the return in kind of the immovable subject to the financial leasing was ordered, while it should have been accepted that the financial leasing contract was made for the remaining price and … ordered to be collected, the dismissal of the main action in its entirety on the reasoning given was not found correct” (translation)
Where no valid contract was formed, the claim for the return of the down payment paid at the start must be ruled on
“in that case, although it was stated in the reasoning that the claimant’s claim for the return of EUR 12,560, the down payment it paid at the start of the contract and accepted by the parties, gave rise to the unjust enrichment of the defendant company ..., the failure to rule on that matter in the operative part was not correct.” (translation)
Contracts made before Law No. 6361 are governed by Law No. 3226
“Since, under provisional articles 1, 2 and 4 of Law No. 6361, the previous legislation is to be applied to disputes concerning financial leasing contracts made before that Law entered into force, the repealed Law No. 3226 and the earlier regulations in force before that Law are to be applied to the present dispute.” (translation)
In the Law No. 3226 period, where the lessor terminates, the sale price of the returned asset is not deducted from the rent debt
“Since setting off the sale price of the leased asset against the rent debt without regard to the said provisions of the Law was not found correct, the decision had to be reversed for that reason.” (translation)
In an action to recover a down payment paid to the seller, a release and termination protocol between the parties must be assessed
“Accordingly, ruling as written without making any positive or negative assessment of the release/termination protocol dated 02.06.2016, on which the defendant’s counsel had relied from the reply petition onwards, was not found correct and requires reversal.” (translation)
The lessor had argued that the parties had mutually withdrawn from the contract by the protocol; a release protocol signed before the down payment issue is settled may be raised against the lessee in a refund action.
Frequently Asked Questions
If the leasing contract is terminated, can I get my down payment back?
It depends on to whom and on what basis the payment was made. According to the Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber, a price the lessee paid directly to the seller and the lessor did not finance can be claimed from the lessor once the asset is returned to the lessor (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900). If no valid contract was ever formed, a down payment paid to the lessor can be reclaimed as unjust enrichment (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/8251, K. 2022/2555).
If the asset is never delivered, from whom is the down payment paid to the seller claimed?
If the asset was not delivered because of the lessor’s fault or negligence, arts. 123, 125 and 126 of the Turkish Code of Obligations apply (Law No. 6361 art. 25). In a case where the lessor had paid the seller on time and was not, under the contract, responsible for delivery, the Court of Cassation upheld the dismissal of the action against the financial leasing company (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/2600, K. 2020/5012). If the parties signed a release and termination protocol, the court must assess it (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/6932, K. 2025/6071).
Does Law No. 6361 contain an article on refunding the down payment?
No. The Law’s financial leasing provisions do not separately regulate a payment made by the lessee to the seller; where there is no provision the general provisions apply (Law No. 6361 art. 2/6), and an enrichment whose cause has not materialised or has ceased to exist must be returned (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 77).
Within how many years must an action for the refund of a down payment be brought?
If the claim rests on unjust enrichment, it becomes time-barred two years after the date on which the right to reclaim was learned and in any case ten years after the date on which the enrichment occurred (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 82/1). In commercial cases for a sum of money, applying to a mediator before bringing the action is a condition of action (Commercial Code art. 5/A/1).
Which law governs a leasing contract made in 2007?
According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, disputes concerning contracts made before 13.12.2012, when Law No. 6361 entered into force, are governed by the repealed Law No. 3226 and the earlier regulations (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1647, K. 2020/88). The Court of Cassation’s 19th Civil Chamber treated a judgment based on an expert report calculating under art. 33 of Law No. 6361 for such a contract as a ground for reversal (Court of Cassation, 19th Civil Chamber, E. 2016/7173, K. 2017/2999).
Disputes over down payments, termination and the return of the asset in financial leasing fall within the firm’s Commercial and Corporate Law and Real Estate Law practice areas.
- Financial Leasing by Participation Banks in Türkiye: Rent, Ownership, Default, Termination and Return of the Asset
- Negative Declaratory and Restitution Actions: Declaration of Non-Indebtedness and Recovery of Money Paid
- Limitation and Forfeiture Periods: Differences, General and Five-Year Limitation, Suspension and Interruption
- Sale and Leaseback or a Disguised Loan: Simulation (Muvazaa) and Fiduciary Transfer Claims under Turkish Law
- Sale of the Asset after Financial Lease Termination: Who Pays the Price Difference under Turkish Law? (Law No. 6361 Art. 33)
Related Articles
- Katılım Bankalarında Finansal Kiralama (Leasing): Kira Bedeli, Mülkiyet, Temerrüt, Fesih ve Malın İadesi
- Menfi Tespit ve İstirdat Davası: Borçlu Olmadığının Tespiti ve Ödenen Paranın Geri Alınması
- Zamanaşımı ve Hak Düşürücü Süreler: Farkları, Genel ve Beş Yıllık Zamanaşımı, Durma ve Kesilme Sebepleri
- Is Sale and Leaseback Really a Loan? Simulation (Muvazaa) and Fiduciary Transfer Claims under Turkish Law
- Sale of the Leased Asset after Termination of a Financial Lease under Turkish Law: Who Pays the Price Difference? (Law No. 6361 Art. 33)
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Commercial law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law
- When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye
- Appeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative Court
- Which Court Hears Commercial and Consumer Cases in Türkiye: Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya
- Arbitration Clauses under Turkish Law: Validity, the Arbitration Objection and Lawsuits Filed in Court
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Down Payment Refund in Turkish Financial Leasing: Lessee's Recovery of Payments to the Seller on Termination”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/refund-down-payment-financial-leasing

























