Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Amended Partial Claim Cannot Be Increased Again on Remand: Turkish Court of Cassation on LLC Withdrawal Suits

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a request to increase the claim filed after a reversal can be a second amendment (ıslah). That was so where an action to withdraw from a limited liability company and for the severance payment was brought as a partial action with further rights reserved, the claim was increased by amendment before the reversal, and the post-reversal request was filed under the title “petition for increase of the amount in an action for an unquantified claim”. Since amendment is possible only once in the same action (art. 176(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, HMK), judgment cannot be given on the increased amount; the Chamber therefore unanimously reversed the first-instance decision and the file returned to the first-instance court. The decision concerns an action filed before Law No. 7589; that Law repealed the action for an unquantified claim (art. 107 of the HMK) and regulated a one-time increase in a partial action in art. 109(4).

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that, in a withdrawal and severance payment action brought as a partial action with further rights reserved, where the claim was amended once before a reversal, an increase filed after the reversal under the title “increase of the amount in an action for an unquantified claim” is a second amendment. Since amendment cannot be made twice in the same action, the first-instance decision giving judgment on the increased amount was unanimously reversed.

A decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation on the nature of a post-reversal increase of the amount, in a withdrawal and severance payment action brought as a partial action and already amended before the reversal (Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) arts. 176–177).

The Dispute

The plaintiff holds 25% of the shares in the defendant limited liability company. Citing grounds such as lasting discord between the partners, the plaintiff sought the dissolution of the company for just cause or, failing that, permission to withdraw from the company and payment of the severance amount. Reserving further rights, the plaintiff claimed TRY 300,000 for now; by a petition of 14.01.2021 the plaintiff increased the claim by TRY 942,148.98 and asked that this be treated as an amendment if necessary.

After the Chamber’s earlier reversal, the plaintiff, relying on a new expert report, set the claim at TRY 17,785,051.98 by a “petition for increase of the amount in an action for an unquantified claim” dated 15.01.2025. Complying with the reversal, the first-instance court (sitting as a commercial court) did not uphold the dissolution claim; since the defendant company accepted the withdrawal request, it permitted withdrawal under art. 638(2) of the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK), set the severance payment at TRY 17,785,051.98 and ordered the company to pay it, and dismissed the action against the other defendants for lack of standing. The defendant company appealed.

Outcome of the Decision

On 05.02.2026 the Chamber unanimously accepted the defendant company’s grounds of appeal and reversed the first-instance decision; given the ground and manner of the reversal, it did not examine the company’s other grounds of appeal for the time being. The file was sent to the first-instance court and a copy of the decision to the regional court of appeal.

Reasoning

The Chamber first determined the type of action:

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5744, K. 2026/767, 05.02.2026 (characterisation as a partial action)

“… it is not necessary for the statement of claim to state expressly that the action brought is a partial action. If it is understood from the explanations in the statement of claim that the plaintiff’s claim is larger and the request section contains an expression such as “reserving its further rights” or “I am suing for this much of the claim for now”, this is regarded as sufficient for the action to be accepted as a partial action …” (translation)

The Chamber stated that not only the time but also the number of amendments is limited; it also cited art. 177(2), added by Law No. 7251, which permits amendment after a reversal:

Court of Cassation Decision

“Likewise, the number of amendments is also limited, and the second paragraph of art. 176 of Law No. 6100 provides that the parties may resort to amendment only once in the same action.” (translation)

In the case at hand, the Chamber looked not at the title of the petition but at how the action had been brought:

Court of Cassation Decision

“… that before the Chamber’s reversal the plaintiff amended the claim by a petition of 14.01.2021 by increasing the value of the action by TRY 942,148.98, … although it was stated in the petition of 15.01.2025 that, as a petition for increase of the amount in an action for an unquantified claim, its claims were set at TRY 17,785,051.98, given that, as explained above, the action was brought as a partial action, the request in question is in the nature of a second amendment, and giving judgment on the amounts increased by the second amendment without taking into account that amendment cannot be made twice in one action was found erroneous and required reversal.” (translation)

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision shows that the title given to a petition for increase does not change the result. The Chamber did not discuss whether the severance payment claim could have been brought as an action for an unquantified claim; it relied on the fact that the action had been brought as a partial action. Amendment after a reversal is possible under the condition in art. 177(2); however, if the single right of amendment was used before the reversal, on the Chamber’s approach no new increase can be made by that route. Since the Chamber did not examine the other grounds of appeal, it expressed no view on the first-instance court having the value of the share calculated as at the date closest to the decision.

Actions filed on or after 31.07.2026. By Law No. 7589, published in the Official Gazette of 31.07.2026, art. 107 of the HMK was repealed with effect from the date of publication (Law No. 7589 art. 26/1-c); art. 107 continues to apply to actions filed before that date. The fourth paragraph added to art. 109 of the HMK, for its part, allows the claim in a partial action to be increased once and until the end of the evidentiary stage.

The paragraph regulates this increase without mentioning amendment. Whether an increase under art. 109(4) uses up the single right of amendment in art. 176(2), whether an amendment may still be made after such an increase, and whether the increase may be used in an evidentiary stage that restarts after a reversal or in partial actions filed before 31.07.2026 are not expressly answered either in this decision or in the statutory texts reproduced here. In our assessment, since the action for an unquantified claim no longer exists in these actions, giving a petition for increase that title does not by itself provide a legal basis.

On the mediation question, see the article on withdrawal, severance payment and mediation. A search, through search summaries and using the Turkish words for second amendment, partial action, unquantified claim and severance payment, of Court of Cassation decisions given after 05.02.2026 in the official case-law database found no decision departing from this standard; in the database, decisions of the 11th Civil Chamber appear up to 16.09.2026 and decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers up to 01.10.2026.

Relevant Legislation

Relevant Statutory Provision — Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) art. 176 (Scope and number) (unofficial translation)

“(1) Each of the parties may amend, in part or in full, the procedural acts it has performed.

(2) In the same action, the parties may resort to amendment only once.”

Relevant Statutory Provision — Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) art. 177(1)–(2) (Time and form of amendment) (unofficial translation)

“(1) Amendment may be made until the end of the evidentiary stage.

(2) … Where, after a reversal decision of the Court of Cassation or a decision of annulment of the regional court of appeal, the file is sent to the first-instance court, amendment may also be made until the end of the evidentiary stage if the first-instance court takes a step relating to the evidentiary stage. However, the legal situation arising from compliance with the reversal decision cannot be eliminated.”

Relevant Statutory Provision — Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) art. 109(4) (Partial action) (unofficial translation)

“(4) … Where only part of a claim is brought before the court, the subject of the claim may be increased once in the same action, until the end of the evidentiary stage, without being subject to the prohibition on extending the claim. In this case, limitation is deemed interrupted from the date of the action also in respect of the increased part.”

In the official text, the annotations of addition at the beginning of art. 177(2) and art. 109(4) have been replaced by ….

Relevant Statutory Provision — Law No. 7589 provisional art. 1(10) (unofficial translation)

“(10) Article 107 of Law No. 6100, repealed by the Law establishing this article, continues to apply to actions filed before the date of repeal.”

Frequently Asked Questions

How many times can a claim in a partial action be increased by amendment?

Under Turkish law, only once in the same action (art. 176(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, HMK). In this decision, a later increase in a partial action already amended before the reversal was treated as a second amendment; judgment cannot be given on that basis.

Does it matter that the petition is called an “increase of the amount in an action for an unquantified claim”?

In this decision it did not. The Chamber relied on the fact that the action had been brought as a partial action with further rights reserved.

Can a party amend its claim after a reversal?

Under art. 177(2) of the HMK, amendment is possible until the end of the evidentiary stage if the first-instance court takes a step relating to that stage after the reversal. In this case, however, the single right of amendment had been used before the reversal.

What is the position in actions filed on or after 31.07.2026?

Art. 107 of the HMK was repealed by Law No. 7589 with effect from 31.07.2026; it continues to apply to actions filed before that date. Under art. 109(4), the claim in a partial action may be increased once; the relationship between this increase and amendment was not discussed in the decision.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Amended Partial Claim Cannot Be Increased Again on Remand: Turkish Court of Cassation on LLC Withdrawal Suits”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/llc-severance-claim-second-amendment-after-reversal-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›