Last reviewed:
Case NoteUnapproved LLC Manager Pay Needs a Reasonableness Review: Turkish Appellate Court on General Assembly Approval
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: In a Turkish limited company, determining the manager’s remuneration is a non-transferable power of the general assembly (Turkish Commercial Code art. 616/1-f). According to the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, in a liability action against a manager who took a salary without a general assembly resolution, the court cannot decide without determining whether the sums received are consistent with the company’s business volume and the remuneration the manager received in the earlier period and are reasonable and, if not, what a reasonable monthly remuneration would be. The Chamber also stated that a company not named as a defendant in the statement of claim cannot later be made a party as a “joined defendant”. The decision is final; the action will be reheard by the first-instance court.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, according to the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, in a liability action against a limited company manager who took remuneration without a general assembly resolution, deciding without determining whether the payments are consistent with the company's business volume and earlier remuneration and are reasonable is an incomplete examination; in this file the Chamber required a supplementary expert report. The decision is final; the action will be reheard by the first-instance court.
Under Turkish law, the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal required that, in a liability action against a limited company manager who took remuneration without a general assembly resolution, whether the payments were reasonable be determined by a supplementary expert report.
The Dispute
The two partners of a limited company, which was not itself a party to the action, each held 50% of the shares and were managers with sole authority to represent the company. When one of the partners died in 2016, the share passed to the deceased’s spouse and child; the other partner continued to manage the company alone. The heir partners alleged that the manager had withdrawn money from the company under the name of salary without a general assembly resolution and had caused the company loss. According to the expert report, the manager had received payments under the name of remuneration of TRY 177,045.66 in 2018 and TRY 210,625.14 in 2019. The claimants sought the manager’s removal, the appointment of a trustee to the company and payment to the company of compensation, provisionally TRY 80,000.
For the purposes of the trustee claim, the Istanbul 20th Commercial Court of First Instance later joined the company to the action as a defendant. On 23.06.2022 the court dismissed the action on the ground, based on the expert report, that the remuneration was reasonable and that the company had suffered no loss. The claimants appealed, arguing that their objections to the report had not been addressed and that no supplementary report had been obtained.
Outcome of the Decision
On 16.04.2026, after examining the file without a hearing, the Chamber set aside the first-instance decision under art. 353/1-a-6 of the Code of Civil Procedure and sent the file back to the first-instance court for the action to be reheard. The decision was given unanimously and as final; it was not reviewed by the Court of Cassation. The removal, trustee and interim measure claims will be assessed in the new proceedings.
Reasoning
The Chamber recalled that, under art. 553/1 of the Turkish Commercial Code, applicable by reference of art. 644/1-a, a manager is liable for loss caused by a fault-based breach of their obligations; as regards the salary payments, it stated that the first-instance court had decided on the basis of an incomplete examination:
“In the present case, according to the expert report, the defendant, without any general assembly resolution, received payments totalling TRY 177,045.66 under the name of remuneration in 2018 and payments of TRY 210,625.14 in 2019; while a supplementary report should have been obtained to determine whether these sums, having regard to the company’s business volume, are consistent with the remuneration received in the period when the defendant previously worked together with the deceased and are reasonable, and, if not reasonable, what the reasonable monthly remuneration for those years could be, and a decision should have been given on the claimants’ claims according to the result, it was wrong to decide on the basis of an incomplete examination.”
On procedure, relying on decisions of the Court of Cassation, the Chamber stated that a company not named as a defendant in the statement of claim cannot later acquire party status as a “joined defendant”:
“If the court accepted that the claim for the appointment of a trustee to the company had to be directed against the company, it should have granted the claimants’ counsel time to bring an action against the company and, once that action was brought, given a decision after consolidating the two files; instead, granting party status to the company, which could not join the action as a joined defendant, by letting it take part in the action was found to be contrary to procedure.”
Significance and Practical Effect
The decision is consistent with the approach of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation. The Court of Cassation reversed, on this ground among others, a decision that treated the whole of TRY 700,000 withdrawn as “salary” without a general assembly resolution or a provision in the articles of association as company loss. According to that Chamber, given the prohibition of forced labour, it is inconceivable for the manager to work without remuneration; the remuneration of a person holding the same position in a similar company should be determined, only the excess received should count as loss, and “a remuneration in line with equity” should be determined (11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/1171, K. 2024/3951, 15.05.2024). The decision examined here, by contrast, emphasises the company’s business volume and the remuneration the manager received in the earlier period as the yardstick. Read together, the two decisions suggest that the reasonableness review should assess business volume, earlier remuneration and comparable remuneration together.
The parties are partners in two separate limited companies, and several actions have been heard between them. In an action concerning payments in 2016 and 2017, the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal had likewise required a supplementary report using the same yardstick by its decision of 26.06.2025; that decision is quoted in the reasoning of the decision examined. In another action concerning the 2016 and 2017 period, where the decisions do not show with certainty that the same company was concerned, however, the result was dismissal. The first-instance court accepted that the remuneration not based on a general assembly resolution rested on the agency relationship between the company and the manager, that under art. 502/3 of the Turkish Code of Obligations the agent is entitled to remuneration where there is a custom, and that, according to the third supplementary expert report, the remuneration was consistent with that received by the deceased partner and with the remuneration approved by the general assembly in past years and was not excessive. The regional court of appeal dismissed the appeal on the merits, and the Court of Cassation unanimously upheld the decision (11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/4613, K. 2026/4180, 13.07.2026). The two results do not conflict: in both, the decisive question is whether the remuneration is reasonable and consistent with earlier periods. In that file the question was answered by supplementary reports; in the file examined here, according to the Chamber, it was answered on an incomplete examination.
Caution: The custom reasoning belongs to the first-instance court; the Court of Cassation’s upholding with general reasoning is not a reasoned precedent holding that remuneration paid without a general assembly resolution is lawful in every case on the basis of custom.
In practice, setting the manager’s remuneration by a general assembly resolution reduces the risk of dispute; in companies with equal shareholdings, the inability to adopt a resolution leaves this assessment to the court. In a liability action, it matters that objections to the expert report target the yardstick by which reasonable remuneration was calculated.
Relevant Legislation
“(1) The non-transferable powers of the general assembly are as follows:
… f) Determining the remuneration of the managers and their release from liability.”
“(1) Founders, members of the board of directors, managers and liquidators are liable to the company, to the shareholders and to the company’s creditors for the loss they cause if they breach, through their fault, their obligations arising from the law and the articles of association …”
“Where there is an agreement or a custom, the agent is entitled to remuneration.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Who sets the salary of a manager in a Turkish limited company?
Under Turkish law, determining the remuneration of managers is one of the non-transferable powers of the general assembly (Turkish Commercial Code art. 616/1-f).
Can the entire salary taken without a general assembly resolution be reclaimed?
Under Turkish law, according to this decision and a 2024 decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, not automatically. The court determines through an expert examination whether the payments are reasonable; the loss is the part exceeding a reasonable remuneration.
Can a manager be entitled to remuneration even without a general assembly resolution?
The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that, because of the prohibition of forced labour, it is inconceivable for the manager to work without receiving any remuneration. In another action between the same parties, the first-instance court relied on the custom rule in art. 502/3 of the Turkish Code of Obligations; the dismissal survived appellate and Court of Cassation review with general reasoning.
When appointing a trustee to the company is sought, can the company be joined to the action later?
According to this decision, no: a company not named as a defendant in the statement of claim cannot later become a party as a “joined defendant”; if the claim must be directed against the company, a separate action should be brought and the actions consolidated.
- Company Manager Transfers Funds to a Personal Account: What Happens under Turkish Law? Liability Action, Evidence and Criminal Aspects
- Liabilities of the Authorised Company Director: Duty of Care, Damages Actions and Public Debts
- Removing a Limited Company Manager under Turkish Law: General Assembly Resolution and Court Action
Related Articles
- What Happens If a Company Manager Transfers Company Money to a Personal Account? Liability Action, Evidence and Criminal Aspects
- Liabilities of the Authorised Company Director: Duty of Care, Damages Actions and Public Debts
- How Is a Limited Company Manager Removed in Türkiye? General Assembly Resolution and Court Action
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Commercial law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law
- When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye
- Appeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative Court
- Which Court Hears Commercial and Consumer Cases in Türkiye: Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya
- Arbitration Clauses under Turkish Law: Validity, the Arbitration Objection and Lawsuits Filed in Court
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Unapproved LLC Manager Pay Needs a Reasonableness Review: Turkish Appellate Court on General Assembly Approval”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/turkish-llc-manager-salary-no-general-assembly-resolution

























