Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Unauthorised Moratorium Debts Fall Under the Concordat: Turkish Court of Cassation on Partial Annulment

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, a claim arising from a contract that the concordat debtor signed during the moratorium without the commissioner’s permission is subject to the concordat under art. 308/c/2 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law. The holder of such a claim that is not paid under the project has a legal interest in seeking partial annulment of the concordat in respect of itself under art. 308/e. The Assembly required that whether a transaction counts as “routine” be assessed separately in each case, and it did not regard the sales contract worth EUR 526,320.00 as routine for the debtor. The decision of resistance that had dismissed the action for lack of legal interest was unanimously reversed; the regional court of appeal will assess the conditions for partial annulment.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that a claim arising from a contract made during the concordat moratorium without the commissioner’s permission is subject to the concordat under art. 308/c/2 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, and that the holder of such a claim not paid under the project has a legal interest in seeking partial annulment of the concordat in respect of itself under art. 308/e. The Assembly did not regard the sales contract worth EUR 526,320.00 as a routine commercial activity for the debtor and sent the file back to the regional court of appeal to assess the conditions for partial annulment.

A decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation on whether a claim arising from a sales contract made during the concordat moratorium without the commissioner’s permission is subject to the concordat, and on whether partial annulment of the concordat may be sought if that claim is not paid (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law arts. 308/c and 308/e).

The Dispute

A temporary moratorium had been granted to the defendant company on 27.12.2018 and a definitive moratorium on 30.05.2019. According to the Assembly’s findings, on 28.11.2019, during the moratorium and without the commissioner’s permission, the parties signed a contract worth EUR 526,320.00 for the sale of methyl ester product. According to the claimant, an advance payment had been made but the product was not delivered in full; the claim was established by an arbitral award dated 16.04.2021. The defendant’s concordat project was confirmed on 29.06.2021. Arguing that no payment had been made and that creditors who did not register their claims are also bound by the concordat, the claimant sought partial annulment of the concordat in respect of itself. The defendant argued that the claim fell outside the concordat because it arose after the concordat request, and that its signature did not appear on the contract.

The first-instance court annulled the concordat in respect of the claimant. The regional court of appeal set that judgment aside and dismissed the action on procedural grounds for lack of legal interest; in its reasoning, a claim arising from a contract made by the debtor in the course of its commercial activity during the moratorium was not subject to the concordat. The 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed that decision. The regional court of appeal resisted (direnme), on the ground that waiting for the commissioner’s permission for routine purchases and sales could run counter to the ordinary course of commercial life.

Outcome of the Decision

By its decision of 04.03.2026, the Assembly of Civil Chambers reversed the decision of resistance for the reasons set out in the Chamber’s reversal decision and sent the file to the regional court of appeal. The decision was given unanimously and is final.

Reasoning

According to the Assembly, a concordat that has become binding also binds creditors who did not register their claims with the commissioners. Having found that the claim arose after the temporary moratorium and before confirmation, the Assembly concluded:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“The claim in question is a claim arising from a contract signed during the moratorium without the permission of the concordat commissioner, and under the second paragraph of Article 308/c of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law it is a binding and mandatory claim within the scope of the concordat project.” (translation)

The Assembly answered the regional court’s “routine transaction” reasoning as follows:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“… whether the commercial dealings and transactions carried out by the party requesting the concordat during the moratorium are among the works defined as routine must be assessed separately in each specific case. … In this context, the price of the contract signed between the parties for the sale of methyl ester product is EUR 526,320.00, and having regard to the contract price thus set, it is not correct to accept that a contractual relationship of this size was a routine commercial activity for the defendant and that the commissioner’s permission was not needed.” (translation)

The Assembly’s conclusion is as follows:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“In that case, since the creditor, for whom the concordat is binding, has a legal interest in bringing an action for annulment of the concordat in respect of its unpaid claim, whereas a decision should have been given according to the outcome of an assessment of whether the conditions for partial annulment of the concordat are met in respect of the claimant creditor, it was not correct to dismiss the action on procedural grounds for lack of legal interest.” (translation)

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision shows the importance of the commissioner’s permission for a counterparty that contracts with the debtor during the moratorium: under art. 308/c/4 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law a permitted debt is not subject to the terms of the concordat in an ordinary concordat, whereas a claim arising without permission is subject to the terms of the project. The Assembly assessed whether the transaction counted as routine on the facts, taking the contract price into account; it did not separately decide how a claim arising from a transaction regarded as routine stands.

According to the first-instance court, the claim before the Assembly did not appear in the project’s payment schedule; it had been established by an arbitral award. In a later affirming decision (6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, E. 2026/334, K. 2026/1302, 08.04.2026), the 6th Civil Chamber, relying on the uncertainty as to whether such a claim really exists, the risk of fictitious claims being created and, for large claims, the risk that the project cannot be properly implemented, stated that a creditor who registered no claim at all cannot, as a rule, seek partial annulment, but may do so if the claim is established by a judgment in the action it brings and is not paid under the project despite a demand. The Assembly did not discuss this test; the defendant had also argued that annulment could not be sought without first bringing an action on the claim. In this article’s assessment the two decisions do not conflict; for a creditor who has not registered its claim, having the claim established by a judgment and demanding payment is important.

Note: The decision says that the creditor has a legal interest in bringing the action; it does not say that the conditions for partial annulment are met. A search, at summary level, of Court of Cassation decisions published in the official case-law database from the date of the decision to 07.11.2026 (Assembly of Civil Chambers decisions appear up to 01.10.2026 and 6th Civil Chamber decisions up to 17.07.2026) found no decision departing from this decision of the Assembly.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (Law No. 2004) art. 308/c (Effects of the concordat; second and fourth paragraphs) (unofficial translation)

“A concordat that has become binding is mandatory for all claims arising before the concordat request or arising during the moratorium without the commissioner’s permission.

… Debts contracted with the commissioner’s permission after the temporary moratorium decision, including loans extended by credit institutions, are not subject to the terms of the concordat in an ordinary concordat, may be made the subject of enforcement proceedings even during the moratorium in the event of default, and are paid immediately after the secured claims under Article 206 and before all other claims; …”

Statutory Provision — Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (Law No. 2004) art. 308/e (Partial annulment of the concordat) (unofficial translation)

“Every creditor towards whom performance has not been made under the concordat project may, while retaining the new rights acquired under the concordat, apply to the court that confirmed the concordat and have the concordat annulled in respect of itself. …”

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a claim arising from a contract made during the concordat moratorium without the commissioner’s permission subject to the concordat?

According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation, yes. Under art. 308/c/2 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, a concordat that has become binding is also mandatory for claims arising during the moratorium without the commissioner’s permission; debts contracted with the commissioner’s permission, by contrast, are not subject to the terms of the concordat in an ordinary concordat under art. 308/c/4.

Do “routine” commercial transactions during the moratorium also require the commissioner’s permission?

The Assembly did not answer this question in general terms. It required that whether a transaction counts as routine be assessed separately in each specific case, and it did not regard the sales contract worth EUR 526,320.00 as a routine commercial activity for the debtor.

Can a creditor who did not register its claim in the concordat seek partial annulment?

In this case the Assembly accepted the legal interest of a creditor whose claim is subject to the concordat and has not been paid under the project; that claim had been established by an arbitral award. According to a decision of the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 08.04.2026, however, a creditor who registered no claim at all cannot, as a rule, seek partial annulment; it may do so if the claim is established by a judgment in the action it brings and is not paid under the project despite a demand.

What is the effect of partial annulment of the concordat?

Under art. 308/e of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, the creditor has the concordat annulled in respect of itself only, while retaining the new rights acquired under the concordat. According to the Assembly, the creditor can thereby return, as regards itself, to the position before the concordat.

Was the concordat annulled in this case?

No. The Assembly reversed the decision of resistance; the regional court of appeal will assess whether the conditions for partial annulment are met.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Unauthorised Moratorium Debts Fall Under the Concordat: Turkish Court of Cassation on Partial Annulment”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/concordat-partial-annulment-unauthorised-moratorium-debt

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›