Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 25 min read

Last reviewed:

Expulsion from Cooperative Membership in Turkish Law: Notice Requirements, Competent Body and Annulment Action

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, a cooperative may expel a member only on grounds expressly set out in the articles of association; expulsion is decided by the general assembly on the proposal of the board of directors, and the articles of association may also authorise the board of directors (Cooperatives Law art. 16). A member who fails to pay dues and other monetary obligations must first be asked to pay within an appropriate period and, if the first request is not complied with, asked a second time with a one-month period (Cooperatives Law art. 27); according to the Court of Cassation, the debt stated in the two notices must be real and consistent, and the sanction for non-payment must be clearly indicated. The reasoned expulsion decision is served on the member through a notary; the member may bring an objection (annulment) action within three months of service and, if the decision was taken by the board of directors, may within the same period also object to the general assembly. This action is deemed a commercial case and is subject to simple procedure (Cooperatives Law art. 99); however, the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers has held that an annulment action brought by a member who had for a long time neither paid dues nor had any dealings with the cooperative was contrary to the rule of good faith.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

A guide to expulsion from cooperative membership in Turkish law: grounds that must be expressly set out in the articles of association and the expulsion procedure (Cooperatives Law art. 16), two requests and a one-month period for members who fail to pay dues and other monetary obligations (art. 27), an appropriate period where membership conditions are lost, the competent body (general assembly or board of directors), objection to the expulsion decision and the three-month period for the annulment action running from service, the one-month period for actions against general assembly resolutions (art. 53), settlement with the departing member (art. 17), the competent court and simple procedure (art. 99), proof, tacit withdrawal and legal interest, with verified decisions of the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers and its 6th and 11th Civil Chambers.

A guide to expulsion from cooperative membership in Turkish law: grounds set out in the articles of association and the expulsion procedure (Cooperatives Law art. 16), two requests and a one-month period for unpaid dues (Cooperatives Law art. 27), loss of membership conditions, the competent body, the three-month period for objection and annulment, general assembly resolutions, settlement with the departing member, the competent court, proof and tacit withdrawal, with verified decisions of the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers and its 6th and 11th Civil Chambers.

What Is Expulsion from Cooperative Membership?

A cooperative is a partnership with a variable number of members and variable capital that secures and protects its members’ economic interests through their labour and financial contributions by mutual assistance, solidarity and surety (Cooperatives Law art. 1). According to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, under the “open door principle” recognised in doctrine, those meeting the membership conditions are free to join and to leave, subject to the “principle of protecting the cooperative”, under which a departure must not harm the cooperative (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2023/1043, K. 2024/537).

Membership ends upon voluntary withdrawal (Cooperatives Law arts. 10-13), death or transfer of membership (Cooperatives Law art. 14), termination of the duty or service to which membership is tied (Cooperatives Law art. 15), expulsion on grounds set out in the articles of association (Cooperatives Law art. 16) and failure to meet monetary obligations (Cooperatives Law art. 27). Expulsion is the removal of a member against his or her will by a decision of a cooperative body; the articles of association must state the circumstances and conditions under which membership is acquired and lost (Cooperatives Law art. 4).

Expulsion differs from voluntary withdrawal: every member may withdraw, and any commitment never to withdraw is void (Cooperatives Law arts. 10-11). If the board refuses a resignation made in accordance with the articles, the member gives notice of withdrawal through a notary and withdrawal takes effect from that notice (Cooperatives Law art. 13). For commercial companies, see Expulsion and Withdrawal of Partners: Limited and Joint-Stock Companies under Turkish Law.

Grounds for Expulsion and the Articles of Association (art. 16)

First, the ground must be expressly set out in the articles of association; no member may be expelled on a ground not expressly set out there (Cooperatives Law art. 16/1). Board members who breach this rule face imprisonment and a judicial fine (Cooperatives Law additional art. 2).

Statutory Provision — Cooperatives Law (Law No. 1163) art. 16 (Principles of expulsion and objection) (unofficial translation)

“The grounds requiring expulsion from membership of the cooperative shall be expressly set out in the articles of association. Members may not be expelled from membership on grounds not expressly set out in the articles of association. Expulsion from membership shall be decided by the general assembly on the proposal of the board of directors. The articles of association may also authorise the board of directors in this respect, subject to the expelled member’s right to apply to the general assembly. The expulsion decision shall be recorded with its reasons in the minutes and also entered in the register of members. A certified copy of the decision shall be deposited with a notary within ten days for service on the expelled member. That member may bring an action of objection within three months from the date of service. If the decision served was made by the board of directors, the member may also object to the general assembly within the three-month period. This objection shall be made by a document served on the board of directors through a notary, for submission to the next general assembly. Where an objection is made to the general assembly, no action of objection may be brought against the board’s expulsion decision. The right to bring an action of objection against the decision given by the general assembly upon the objection is reserved. Expulsion decisions not challenged within the three-month period, by applying to the general assembly or to the court, become final. No new member may be admitted in place of members whose expulsion decision has not become final. The membership rights and obligations of such persons continue until the expulsion decision becomes final.”

Members are equal in rights and obligations within the principles of the Law (Cooperatives Law art. 23); according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, a member who performs his or her obligations may claim the rights granted to other members in the same position (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2023/1043, K. 2024/537).

Members Failing to Meet Monetary Obligations: Two Requests and Time Limits (art. 27)

For members who fail to pay capital contributions, dues and other payments, the Law provides a formal two-stage procedure:

Statutory Provision — Cooperatives Law (Law No. 1163) art. 27 (Time limit and lapse of membership) (unofficial translation)

“The articles of association shall specify the amount of money that members may pay for the shares they have undertaken. The cooperative shall request members who are in arrears with their capital undertakings or liable for other payments to fulfil their obligations, by hand-delivered written notice or by registered letter or, where this is not possible, by public announcement, specifying an appropriate period. The membership of those who do not comply with the first request and who do not fulfil their obligations within one month after the second request shall lapse automatically. The lapse of membership does not extinguish the debts of the person concerned arising from the articles of association or otherwise.”

Courts apply the statutory provision together with the expulsion clause of the articles. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the cooperative must first grant an appropriate period and then give a member who does not comply a second period of one month; the debt notified must reflect the member’s personal and actual debt, otherwise the member is not duly placed in default (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2013/1522, K. 2015/1196). The amounts in the two notices must match or any difference must be explained, and the sanction for non-payment must be clearly stated (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/1044, K. 2022/1890).

The 6th Civil Chamber held that granting 30 days instead of one month in the second request breached a mandatory provision and upheld the regional court judgment dismissing the appeal against the first-instance judgment that annulled the expulsion decisions; according to the first-instance court’s reasoning, the notice was served in August, a 31-day month, so the 30-day period operated to the member’s detriment (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/384, K. 2023/526). An upheld regional court judgment likewise held that no expulsion may rest on notices that do not clearly show the years and months of the debt and the split between principal and late-payment interest, or that do not match the actual debt (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/2295, K. 2023/2475).

Loss of Membership Conditions and an Appropriate Period

Articles of association may also make the later loss of membership qualifications a ground for expulsion; in the decisions below, these were engagement in maritime transport and ownership of a motor vehicle suited to the cooperative’s purpose.

Statutory Provision — Cooperatives Law (Law No. 1163) art. 8/2 (Investigation of membership conditions) (unofficial translation)

“The board of directors is obliged to investigate whether members and those applying for membership satisfy the membership conditions set out in the articles of association.”

Losing a condition does not, however, justify immediate expulsion. According to the 6th Civil Chamber, even where no notice is provided for, the requirement of an appropriate period in Cooperatives Law art. 27 applies by analogy; expulsion without notice and a reasonable period to satisfy the conditions is not justified (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/112, K. 2024/347). Membership may be transferred; the board admits a transferee who has the membership qualifications (Cooperatives Law art. 14).

Competent Body: General Assembly and Board of Directors

Expulsion is decided by the general assembly on the proposal of the board of directors; the articles of association may also authorise the board, subject to the expelled member’s right to apply to the general assembly (Cooperatives Law art. 16/2). The articles are decisive; absent such authority, the general assembly decides. Where authority exists, the general assembly’s status as the most authoritative body does not remove the board’s power: the 11th Civil Chamber reversed a judgment annulling an expulsion solely because the power lay with the general assembly, although the articles authorised the board (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2009/4119, K. 2010/10268).

If the board’s decision is later approved by the general assembly, the Assembly of Civil Chambers treats the action as a claim to annul the approving resolution (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2013/1522, K. 2015/1196). Where the general assembly has decided the expulsion, the 6th Civil Chamber upheld a regional court finding that the action is deemed brought against that resolution, whether or not the member used the objection route (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/2295, K. 2023/2475).

Objection and Annulment Action: The Three-Month Period

A certified copy of the reasoned expulsion decision is deposited with a notary within ten days; the member may bring an action of objection (in practice, an action to annul the expulsion decision) within three months from service. If the board made the decision, the member may within the same period also object to the general assembly by a document served on the board through a notary; if so, no action lies against the board’s decision, but the general assembly’s decision may be challenged in court. A decision not challenged in time becomes final (Cooperatives Law art. 16/3-4).

Time runs from due service. The Assembly of Civil Chambers held that service at an address other than the one the member notified to the cooperative leaves the decision neither served nor final, and treated the three-month period as a right-extinguishing time limit (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2013/1522, K. 2015/1196). If the general assembly resolution approving the expulsion was not served, the action is deemed timely (upheld regional court finding: Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/2295, K. 2023/2475).

Until the decision becomes final, no new member may be admitted in the member’s place and his or her rights and obligations continue (Cooperatives Law art. 16/5); breach of this ban is also criminally sanctioned (Cooperatives Law additional art. 2). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the rule on continuing obligations essentially concerns members who have the expulsion annulled and return; the monetary obligations of a member whose expulsion has become final end with the membership (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/855, K. 2021/281).

Actions Against General Assembly Resolutions (art. 53)

Actions against general assembly resolutions other than expulsion are governed by Cooperatives Law art. 53. Standing is granted to members who attended, voted against the resolution and had this recorded in the minutes or who allege the irregularities listed in the Law, to the board of directors and, where their personal liability is at stake, to board members and auditors.

Statutory Provision — Cooperatives Law (Law No. 1163) art. 53 (Annulment of resolutions and conditions) (unofficial translation)

“The persons listed below may apply, within one month starting from the day following the meeting, to the court of the place where the cooperative has its head office against general assembly resolutions, alleging that they are contrary to the law, the provisions of the articles of association or the principles of good faith. … The hearing may not begin before the one-month time limit referred to in the first paragraph has expired. … The annulment of a resolution has effect for all members.”

That the general assembly made or approved the expulsion does not subject the member to the one-month period: according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, actions against expulsion decisions are its sole exception and the period for them is three months (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2013/1522, K. 2015/1196). Matters not otherwise regulated by the Law are governed by the Turkish Commercial Code’s provisions on joint-stock companies (Cooperatives Law art. 98); on annulment actions in companies, see Limited Company General Assembly Resolutions: Annulment, Nullity, Three-Month Period and Recorded Dissent under Turkish Law.

Financial Consequences of Withdrawal and Expulsion (art. 17)

The Law sets out the principles of settlement with a departing member as follows:

Statutory Provision — Cooperatives Law (Law No. 1163) art. 17 (Settlement with withdrawing or expelled members) (unofficial translation)

“Whether members who withdraw or are expelled from the cooperative, or their heirs, have rights over the cooperative’s assets, and what those rights consist of, shall be set out in the articles of association. These rights shall be calculated, excluding reserve funds, on the basis of the balance sheet of the year in which the member leaves. Refunds and payments of a nature that would endanger the existence of the cooperative may be deferred by the general assembly for a period not exceeding three years, even if a shorter period has been fixed in the articles of association. In this case the cooperative’s right to claim fair compensation is reserved. The claims and rights of withdrawing or expelled members and their heirs become time-barred upon the expiry of five years from the day on which they can be claimed. Conditions providing that a withdrawing or expelled member shall be deprived, wholly or partly, of his or her capital or deposits are null and void.”

Reading Cooperatives Law art. 17 with the relevant clause of the housing cooperative’s articles, the Assembly of Civil Chambers held that an expelled member may claim not all dues paid but the balance left after deducting the share of expenses under the balance sheet of the year in which the expulsion became final, once one month has passed after the general assembly approved that balance sheet. Late-payment interest accrued during membership may not be set off against this claim, as that would breach the open-door and non-profit principles and equity (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/855, K. 2021/281).

In cooperatives that have achieved their purpose and entered dissolution, the dwelling or workplace of a withdrawing or expelled member cannot be taken back on that ground; such former members contribute to liquidation costs arising later (Cooperatives Law art. 81). Since Cooperatives Law art. 99 deems these cases commercial, applying to a mediator before suing is a condition of actions for a sum of money such as the departing member’s share (Commercial Code art. 5/A); an action to annul an expulsion is not among the actions listed there.

Competent Court and Procedure

Statutory Provision — Cooperatives Law (Law No. 1163) art. 99 (Nature of actions and procedure) (unofficial translation)

“Civil actions arising from matters regulated in this Law are deemed commercial cases regardless of whether the parties are merchants. Simple procedure applies in these actions.”

An action to annul an expulsion decision is therefore a commercial case subject to simple procedure. Unless otherwise provided, commercial cases are heard by the commercial court of first instance (Commercial Code art. 5/1); in a judicial district without such a court, failure to rely on the jurisdiction rule does not require a decision of lack of jurisdiction, and the civil court of first instance continues to hear the case (Commercial Code art. 5/4). Actions against general assembly resolutions are brought at the court of the cooperative’s head office (Cooperatives Law art. 53).

As far as the decision texts show, the reviewing chamber of the Court of Cassation has changed over time: the 2010 decision on the competent body is from the 11th Civil Chamber; the reversal behind the 2015 Assembly decision came from the 23rd Civil Chamber; the 2021 and 2024 Assembly decisions call it the “closed” 23rd Civil Chamber, and the 2021 decision sent a settlement file to the 15th Civil Chamber on the merits. The 2022–2026 chamber decisions cited here are from the 6th Civil Chamber, which also heard the appeal after compliance with the reversal in the file of the 2024 Assembly decision (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/1962, K. 2026/2215).

Burden of Proof

Unless the law provides otherwise, each party must prove the facts on which its right is based (Civil Code art. 6). For a cooperative relying on the conditions of expulsion, the decisive facts are: the ground in the articles of association; a reasoned decision of the competent body entered in the register of members; two requests sent in the statutory form and periods and reaching the member; a notified debt matching the actual debt; and notarial service of the decision at the address notified by the member. In an upheld decision, the actual debt was established from the register of members, account statements and the general assembly’s resolutions on dues, and an expert report found that it did not match the notices (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/2295, K. 2023/2475). For a tacit-withdrawal defence, the cooperative relies on facts showing long non-payment, no contact with the cooperative and no follow-up of the debt.

Tacit Withdrawal and Legal Interest

Even a procedurally defective expulsion is not always annulled. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, in settled Court of Cassation practice a member of a cooperative with dues obligations who for a long time does not visit it, does not follow up the dues and does not pursue activity in line with its purpose has tacitly accepted that the membership has ended and shown by conduct an intention to withdraw; such a member’s action breaches the rule of honesty (Civil Code art. 2), which the judge applies of his or her own motion. In that case the member had no contact for some thirteen years from admission to expulsion and seven years from expulsion to the action, remaining a “member on paper”; the majority rejected the view that the notices and service were unproven and that members in the same position had not been expelled, and reversed the insistence decision by majority vote (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2023/1043, K. 2024/537). Complying with the reversal, the first-instance court dismissed the action because the member no longer had any actual link with the cooperative or any interest in annulment, and that finding was upheld (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/1962, K. 2026/2215).

The limits of the defence depend on the facts: while confirming that tacit withdrawal is settled case law, the 6th Civil Chamber held that the period was not exceeded where the expulsion was dated 14.06.2010 and the action 22.01.2015; that counting from a date before the expulsion would disregard the will of the cooperative, which had treated the claimant as a member when expelling him; and, the notices also being defective, reversed, holding that the action should have been upheld (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/1044, K. 2022/1890). Cooperatives should therefore not rely on this defence to skip notice and service formalities, while members should sue within three months from service, keep payment records and notify any change of address.

Court of Cassation Decisions

Debts in the notices must be consistent and actual, and the sanction clearly stated

Court of Cassation Decision
6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/1044, K. 2022/1890, 05.04.2022 (the Chamber’s grounds for reversal)

“Under those provisions, for a member to be expelled, he or she must be given notice in accordance with the law and the agreement, and the debt that is the subject of the notice must reflect the truth. The amounts of debt stated in both notices served on the member must be the same or, if different, the reason must be explained in the notices, so that the member is not left in doubt as to the amounts owed, and the sanction to be applied in case of non-compliance must be clearly indicated in the notice. Otherwise, since it cannot be accepted that the member has defaulted in accordance with Articles 16 and 27 of Law No. 1163, the expulsion cannot be deemed lawful either.” (translation)

The three-month objection period runs from due service; expulsion is the sole exception to the one-month period of art. 53

Court of Cassation Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2013/1522, K. 2015/1196, 15.04.2015 (the Assembly’s own reasoning; the insistence decision was reversed on different grounds)

“the member must perform the monetary obligations determined under the articles of association; a member expelled for failing to do so is given the possibility of objecting within three months from the due service of the expulsion decision on him or her. … the sole exception to the one-month time limit for bringing an action against general assembly resolutions under Article 53 of the Law is actions brought against expulsion decisions, and in that case the period is three months.” (translation)

The appropriate period of art. 27 also applies by analogy when membership conditions are lost

Court of Cassation Decision
6th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/112, K. 2024/347, 24.01.2024 (the Chamber’s grounds for reversal)

“In cooperative articles of association, the loss of the qualities and conditions required for membership is regulated as a ground for expulsion. However, adopting the ‘immediate’ expulsion of members on this ground is incompatible with the basic logic and functioning of cooperatives. Although neither the articles of association nor Cooperatives Law No. 1163 provides for a notice to be sent before the expulsion of those who lose the membership conditions, the requirement of granting an appropriate period, sought for monetary obligations in Article 27 of Cooperatives Law No. 1163, must also be applied by analogy in this situation.” (translation)

If the articles of association so provide, the board may also decide on expulsion

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2009/4119, K. 2010/10268, 14.10.2010 (the Chamber’s grounds for reversal; the articles also gave the board power to expel)

“In fact, the general assembly, as the most authoritative body of the cooperative, is also the most authoritative body entitled to decide on expulsion, but this power of the general assembly does not remove the power of the board of directors to take an expulsion decision.” (translation)

An annulment action by a member who has had no contact for a long time breaches the rule of honesty

Court of Cassation Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2023/1043, K. 2024/537, 06.11.2024 (majority reasoning of the Assembly; the insistence decision was reversed by majority vote)

“In the settled case law and practice of the Court of Cassation, it is accepted as a principle that where, in a cooperative with dues obligations, a member does not visit the cooperative for a long time, does not follow up whether dues are owed and has for a long time not carried on activity in line with the cooperative’s founding purpose, he or she has tacitly accepted that the membership has ended, in other words has tacitly waived membership rights, and has shown by conduct an intention to withdraw, and that an action brought by such a member is contrary to the rule of honesty in Article 2 of Law No. 4721. … the claimant’s request for legal protection by bringing an action, although he knew that in the face of that intention he no longer had any interest worthy of protection in the annulment of the expulsion decision, was not found consistent with the rule of honesty in Article 2 of Law No. 4721.” (translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

On what grounds may a cooperative expel a member?

Only on grounds expressly set out in the articles of association (Cooperatives Law art. 16/1). For unpaid dues the two-request procedure of Cooperatives Law art. 27 applies; where membership conditions are lost, the member must also be given an appropriate period (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/112, K. 2024/347).

How many notices are required before expulsion for unpaid dues?

Two requests: the first with an appropriate period, the second with a one-month period (Cooperatives Law art. 27). Granting 30 days instead of one month in the second notice was held to breach a mandatory provision (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/384, K. 2023/526); the debt in the notices must be actual and consistent and the sanction clearly stated (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/1044, K. 2022/1890).

What is the time limit for challenging an expulsion decision?

Three months from due service of the decision through a notary (Cooperatives Law art. 16/3). The one-month period for general assembly resolutions does not apply to expulsion decisions, and service at an address other than the one notified by the member does not start the period (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2013/1522, K. 2015/1196).

Can the board of directors decide on expulsion?

As a rule the general assembly decides on the board’s proposal; the articles of association may also authorise the board (Cooperatives Law art. 16/2). In that case the general assembly’s power does not remove the board’s power (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2009/4119, K. 2010/10268).

Can an expelled member recover the payments made?

Yes; the rights are calculated, excluding reserves, on the balance sheet of the year of departure and become time-barred after five years (Cooperatives Law art. 17). The balance remaining after deduction of the share of expenses may be claimed, and late-payment interest may not be set off (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/855, K. 2021/281). Applying to a mediator before suing for the claim is a condition of the action (Commercial Code art. 5/A).

Can a member who has ignored the cooperative for a long time have the expulsion annulled?

An annulment action by a member who for a long time paid no dues and had no contact with the cooperative has been held contrary to the rule of honesty (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2023/1043, K. 2024/537). Whether the period is long enough depends on the facts; in one case more than four years between expulsion and action was not considered sufficient (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/1044, K. 2022/1890).

Expulsion from cooperative membership, annulment of expulsion decisions, actions against general assembly resolutions and claims for the departing member’s share fall within the firm’s Commercial & Corporate Law practice area.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Expulsion from Cooperative Membership in Turkish Law: Notice Requirements, Competent Body and Annulment Action”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-08, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/expulsion-from-cooperative-membership

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›