Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 12 min read

Last reviewed:

Metabolite Findings in Drug-Use Offences: The Evidentiary Force of Blood and Urine Tests

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, the detection of a narcotic’s active substance or its metabolite in a blood or urine sample taken at the time of the offence establishes use by technical means. As applied by the Court of Cassation, unless a justified contrary explanation is proven, this is sufficient to prove the offence; a positive test may ground a conviction even if no substance was found on the person. Conversely, where no substance was seized and the test detected no active substance or metabolite, a bare confession is not enough for a conviction and the in dubio pro reo principle applies. Defences such as the substance having been mixed into food or drink without the person’s knowledge, passive exposure or the use of prescribed medication have no effect unless they are supported by concrete facts. A positive metabolite test during the deferral of prosecution counts as a breach and leads to a public prosecution, but that use is not investigated as a separate offence (Criminal Code art. 191/4-5). A Forensic Medicine Institute report may be challenged as to the panel screened, the chain of custody, the type of metabolite and its link to the date of the offence; even where a metabolite is found in urine, the conditions of effective remorse under Criminal Code art. 192/2 must still be examined.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

The evidentiary force of metabolite findings in the Turkish drug-use offence (Criminal Code art. 191), through the case law of the 10th Criminal Chamber: the effect of positive tests (THC, 6-MAM, synthetic cannabinoid metabolites) on conviction; the insufficiency of a bare confession where the panel is negative (in dubio pro reo); deferral of prosecution and twice-yearly testing under probation; the consequences of a positive test during deferral (art. 191/4-5); effective remorse and treatment (art. 192); and challenges to Forensic Medicine reports.

A guide to the evidentiary force of metabolite findings in blood and urine tests in the Turkish offence of using narcotic or stimulant substances (Criminal Code art. 191): identification of the competent chamber of the Court of Cassation (10th Criminal Chamber), the concept of metabolites (THC/THC-COOH, 6-MAM, synthetic cannabinoid metabolites), the effect of a positive test on conviction, the in dubio pro reo principle where the panel is negative and the insufficiency of a bare confession, deferral of prosecution and probation (art. 191/2-5), the consequences of a positive test during the deferral period, effective remorse and treatment (art. 192), objections to Forensic Medicine Institute reports, with verified decisions of the 10th Criminal Chamber.

The Offence and the Competent Chamber

Statutory Provision — Turkish Criminal Code (Law No. 5237) art. 191/1 (unofficial translation)

“A person who purchases, accepts or possesses narcotic or stimulant substances for use, or who uses narcotic or stimulant substances, shall be punished with imprisonment from two to five years.”

The offence covers purchasing, accepting or possessing the substance for use, or using it. Since use is rarely observed directly, proof in practice rests largely on toxicological analysis of body fluids (blood and urine). Cassation review of narcotics offences is conducted — as the recent decisions in the official database confirm — by the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation; all decisions cited below are of that Chamber.

What Is a Metabolite? What Do Tests Look For?

A metabolite is the breakdown product of the active substance processed by the liver, traceable in blood and urine for longer than the parent substance. Forensic Medicine Institute reports typically screen for THC and its metabolites (THC-OH, THC-COOH) for cannabis, 6-MAM (6-monoacetylmorphine) and morphine for heroin, benzoylecgonine for cocaine, and the metabolites of synthetic cannabinoids such as JWH-018, JWH-073 and AB-CHMINACA. Detection windows vary with the substance, frequency of use, sample type and individual metabolism; which metabolite was found, in which sample, taken on which date, is therefore critical for the defence.

Positive Tests: The Evidentiary Force of Metabolites

Under the settled practice of the 10th Criminal Chamber, detection of the active substance or its metabolite in a sample taken at the time of the offence establishes use by technical means and, absent a substantiated alternative explanation, suffices for conviction. The Chamber reversed an acquittal where THC metabolite was found in the defendant’s blood, and another where synthetic cannabinoid metabolites (AB-CHMINACA M1-M2) had been misread in the report. Even where no substance is seized on the person, a positive test alone may ground conviction.

Negative Tests: In Dubio Pro Reo

The reverse rule is equally settled: where no substance is seized and the panel detects no active substance or metabolite, use cannot be based on a bare confession. The Chamber holds that a defendant whose full panel (opioids, cannabis metabolites, synthetic cannabinoid metabolites) is negative must be acquitted, as no conclusive evidence beyond doubt exists — the clearest manifestation of in dubio pro reo in this field, applied likewise to retracted confessions.

Typical Defences and Their Limits

Common defences against a positive test are unwitting ingestion (substance slipped into food or drink), passive exposure and prescription medication. They fail if they remain abstract; they must be substantiated (witnesses, footage, prescriptions, treatment records) and, where appropriate, argued through expert opinion on which metabolite was detected and at what level. The test must also be linked to the offence date: given long detection windows, the relation between the sampling date and the alleged time of use must be assessed in every file — timing issues, such as a metabolite found in a sample taken after the prosecutor’s interview, directly affect both proof and effective remorse, as the decision below shows.

Deferral of Prosecution and Probation (art. 191/2-5)

Statutory Provision — Turkish Criminal Code art. 191/2-3 (Deferral of prosecution; probation — selected provisions) (unofficial translation)

“(2) In an investigation opened for this offence, a decision deferring the institution of the public prosecution for five years shall be given in respect of the suspect, without the conditions of article 171 of the Code of Criminal Procedure being required. … (3) … During the deferral period, a probation measure of at least one year shall be applied to the suspect. … The public prosecutor shall order the suspect’s referral to the relevant institution at least twice a year to determine whether they have used narcotic or stimulant substances during the deferral period.”

The rule is not immediate prosecution but a five-year deferral with at least one year of probation (and, if needed, treatment). The prosecutor orders testing at least twice a year — the field where metabolite analysis is most heavily used.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Criminal Code art. 191/4-5 (Violations) (unofficial translation)

“(4) A public prosecution shall be instituted where, during the deferral period, the person: a) persists in failing to comply with the obligations imposed or the requirements of the treatment applied; b) again purchases, accepts or possesses narcotic or stimulant substances for use; c) uses narcotic or stimulant substances. (5) The person’s renewed purchase, acceptance or possession for use, or use, of narcotic or stimulant substances during the deferral period is deemed a ground of violation under paragraph four and shall not be made the subject of a separate investigation and prosecution.”

A positive metabolite finding during the deferral period is a violation under art. 191/4-c leading to prosecution of the original offence; under art. 191/5 the new use is not separately prosecuted. Absent violations, a decision of non-prosecution follows at the end of the period (art. 191/7).

Effective Remorse and Treatment (art. 192)

Statutory Provision — Turkish Criminal Code art. 192/2 and 4 (Effective remorse; request for treatment) (unofficial translation)

“(2) No penalty shall be imposed on a person who purchases, accepts or possesses narcotic or stimulant substances for use and who, before the official authorities learn of it, informs the authorities from whom, where and when they obtained the substance, thereby facilitating the apprehension of the offenders or the seizure of the substance. … (4) No penalty shall be imposed on a person who uses narcotic or stimulant substances and who, before an investigation is opened against them for purchasing, accepting or possessing for use, applies to the official authorities or to health institutions requesting treatment.”

Even where a metabolite is found in urine, the Court of Cassation requires an inquiry into whether the use came to light through the person’s own statement before the authorities learned of it, and an assessment of art. 192/2.

Samples, Reports and Objections

Blood and urine sampling is governed by the CCP rules on physical examination and taking of samples; irregular sampling raises an unlawful-evidence issue. Analyses are typically performed by the Forensic Medicine Institute. The defence may challenge the scope of the panel, the chain of custody, the type and level of the metabolite and its relation to the offence date, and may request re-analysis or an expert opinion. The complete investigation file must be in the case file in a form allowing review — a point the Court of Cassation itself checks.

Court of Cassation Decisions

THC metabolite in blood: the offence is established; acquittal reversed

Court of Cassation Decision

“Given that the report of the Forensic Medicine Institute Group Chairmanship of 04.03.2010 found in the defendant’s blood the metabolite of THC, the active substance of cannabis, acquittal on the ground that the offence was not proven — without considering that the offence of possessing narcotics for use was established — [was unlawful].” (translation)

Synthetic cannabinoid metabolites (AB-CHMINACA M1-M2): acquittal based on a misreading of the report is unlawful

Court of Cassation Decision

“Since the blood sample taken from the defendant on the date of the offence was found, by the Forensic Medicine Institute’s report of 16.12.2015, to contain the synthetic cannabinoid metabolites AB-CHMINACA M2 and AB-CHMINACA M1, and the defendant thus used narcotics, acquittal on grounds inconsistent with the file — instead of conviction for possessing narcotics for use — was found unlawful.” (translation)

Where the panel is negative, a bare confession cannot ground conviction; in dubio pro reo

Court of Cassation Decision

“[C]onvicting instead of acquitting the defendant — on whom no narcotic or stimulant substance was seized and whose use of narcotics could not be established by technical methods either — without considering that, beyond their bare statement, there was no conclusive evidence surpassing doubt and sufficient for conviction, [was unlawful].” (translation)

Even where a metabolite is found, effective remorse under art. 192/2 must be examined

Court of Cassation Decision

“Given that cannabis metabolite was detected in the urine analysis performed after the defendant’s statement to the prosecution … it should have been determined whether, in the investigation conducted for another offence, the defendant revealed their offence by stating that they had used narcotics before the official authorities learned of it, and accordingly whether the effective-remorse provisions of article 192, paragraph 2, of the Criminal Code applied.” (translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a metabolite finding alone sufficient for conviction?

Under the 10th Criminal Chamber’s practice, detection of the substance or its metabolite in a sample taken at the time of the offence establishes use by technical means and, as a rule, suffices for conviction — even if nothing is seized on the person. Defences must be substantiated with concrete evidence.

What if the test is clean but the person confessed?

Where no substance is seized and the panel is entirely negative, a bare confession cannot ground conviction; acquittal is required under in dubio pro reo.

What is the penalty, and is prosecution immediate?

Two to five years’ imprisonment (art. 191/1). As a rule, prosecution is deferred for five years with at least one year of probation (and treatment if needed); compliance leads to a non-prosecution decision.

What happens if a test is positive during probation?

Use during the deferral period is a violation (art. 191/4-c) and the original prosecution is instituted; under art. 191/5 the new use is not prosecuted separately.

How does effective remorse work?

No penalty is imposed on a user who, before the authorities learn of it, discloses from whom, where and when they obtained the substance, facilitating apprehension or seizure (art. 192/2), or who requests treatment before an investigation is opened (art. 192/4).

Can Forensic Medicine reports be challenged?

Yes — on the scope of the panel, the chain of custody, the type/level of the metabolite and its relation to the offence date; re-analysis and expert opinions may be requested. Irregular sampling raises an unlawful-evidence issue.

Defence in narcotics investigations and prosecutions falls within our firm’s Criminal Law practice area.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Criminal Law

All Criminal Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Metabolite Findings in Drug-Use Offences: The Evidentiary Force of Blood and Urine Tests”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/metabolite-findings-drug-use-offences

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›