Last reviewed:
Case NoteGeneral Rules for Multi-Parcel Sites Until Estate Management: Turkish Court of Cassation on Common Areas
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: The 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that a common-area interference dispute on a multi-parcel site without housing-estate management is heard by the civil court of first instance. In that decision of 23.02.2026, the Chamber (Yargıtay 5. Hukuk Dairesi) stated that where a site built on more than one parcel has not yet transitioned to housing-estate (toplu yapı) management, the general provisions, not the Condominium Ownership Law (KMK), apply to a dispute over the prevention of interference with a common area and restoration, and that the civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk mahkemesi) hears the action; it unanimously reversed the judgment on the merits of the civil court of peace (sulh hukuk mahkemesi). According to the Chamber, a manager who is not a condominium owner may bring this action only if authorised by the board of condominium owners. Sites that have transitioned to housing-estate management were not addressed in the decision.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that, where a site built on more than one parcel has not yet transitioned to housing-estate management, the general provisions, not the Condominium Ownership Law, apply to an action for the prevention of interference with a common area and restoration, and that the action must be heard by the civil court of first instance. The Chamber also stated that a manager who is not a condominium owner may bring this action only if authorised by the board of condominium owners.
Under Turkish law, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed, for lack of jurisdiction, the judgment of a civil court of peace that heard an action over interference with a common area of a multi-parcel site that had not transitioned to housing-estate management.
The Dispute
The plaintiff site management alleged that, in a site on more than one parcel, a common area shown as a shelter in the project was being used as a market and cafeteria under a lease free of charge and for a term of 39 years made between the defendants. According to the statement of claim, the site had transitioned to housing-estate management under a management plan dated 03.01.2016, and there was no decision of the condominium owners on a change of use. The plaintiff sought an order ending the interference and TRY 20,000.00 for the time being as compensation for unlawful occupation.
The civil court of peace allowed the action. On appeal, the defendant argued that the site management lacked capacity to be a party and that the decision book contained no board decision authorising the manager to sue. Relying on the expert report, the regional court of appeal found that there had been interference, contrary to the project, with the common area of the property subject to condominium easement (kat irtifakı), and dismissed the appeal on the merits; the defendant appealed to the Court of Cassation.
Outcome of the Decision
The Chamber set aside the regional court of appeal’s decision and reversed the first-instance judgment; the file was sent to the first-instance court (the civil court of peace) and a copy of the decision to the regional court of appeal. The decision was given unanimously on 23.02.2026. The main ground for reversal is jurisdiction; lack of jurisdiction was not among the grounds of appeal summarised in the decision, and the Chamber stated that the rules on jurisdiction are matters of public order and are observed of the court’s own motion. It examined the manager’s authority, by contrast, “kabule göre de”, that is, as a separate ground requiring reversal even if the court’s jurisdiction and the application of the KMK were accepted.
Reasoning
The Chamber identified the provisions applicable to a site that has not transitioned to housing-estate management as follows:
“In the specific case, since it is understood that the site in dispute is built on more than one parcel and that, under the Special Provisions on Housing Estates regulated by Article 22 of Law No. 5711 amending Law No. 634 and by Article 66 et seq. of Law No. 634, the site has not yet transitioned to housing-estate management, the general provisions, not the provisions of Law No. 634, must be applied to the dispute. Accordingly, the question of jurisdiction must also be determined under the general provisions.”
The result as regards the competent court:
“In civil disputes, the jurisdiction of the civil courts of first instance is the rule and that of the civil court of peace is the exception. All actions and matters that a special statutory provision does not expressly assign to the civil court of peace are heard by the civil court of first instance. Therefore, whereas the court should have dismissed the statement of claim for lack of jurisdiction so that it could be heard by the civil court of first instance, the court of principal jurisdiction under the general provisions, rendering judgment on the merits was not found appropriate.”
The second test is the manager’s authority to sue:
“Even on the court’s own approach, actions for the prevention of interference with the common parts of the main immovable and for the restoration of deviations from the approved architectural project are brought on the basis of the right of ownership. Article 35 of Law No. 634 sets out the duties and powers of the manager, and these do not include the power and duty to bring an action for the prevention of interference and the restoration of deviations from the project, which is closely tied to the right of ownership. However, owing to the nature of condominium law, in practice a manager who is not a condominium owner may bring such an action if authorised by the board of condominium owners.”
The Chamber required the court first to examine whether the manager is a condominium owner and, if not, whether authority was obtained for the action; it did not say expressly whether separate authority is required where the manager is a condominium owner. It also required the operative part to be worded clearly for each claim.
Significance and Practical Effect
We explained in our Condominium Management article that the civil court of peace is the competent court for disputes arising from the KMK; Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) art. 4/1-ç also gives the civil court of peace the actions assigned to it by statute. This decision shows that in a multi-parcel site it must first be asked whether the KMK or the general provisions apply to the dispute. We discuss the competent court in ownership-based actions in our guide to actions for prevention of interference.
The plaintiff had argued that the site had transitioned to housing-estate management; the Chamber, however, stated that it was understood that it had not yet done so, and did not set out in the decision the documents on which it relied. In our assessment, which provisions govern the site should therefore be investigated before the action is brought, and a manager who is not a condominium owner should obtain an authorising decision of the board in advance for this action, which is not listed in KMK art. 35. We also discuss the manager’s authority to sue in our Condominium Management article.
A search, through search summaries and using the words housing estate, general provisions, manager who is not a condominium owner and authorisation, of Court of Cassation decisions given after 23.02.2026 in the official case-law database (those visible up to 10.09.2026 for the 5th Civil Chamber and up to 01.10.2026 for the Assembly of Civil Chambers) found no decision departing from these two tests.
Relevant Legislation
“A housing estate means several buildings built or to be built on one or more zoning parcels according to a specific approved settlement plan and interconnected in terms of infrastructure facilities, common use areas, social facilities and services and their management.”
“The manager’s duties are set out in the management plan; unless the management plan provides otherwise, the manager performs the following tasks:
a) Implementing the decisions taken by the board of condominium owners;
… i) Bringing actions and enforcement proceedings against condominium owners who fail to perform their debts and obligations relating to condominium ownership, and having the statutory mortgage registered in the condominium register;”
“(1) The civil courts of peace hear, regardless of the value or amount of the subject matter of the action;
… ç) actions in which this Law and other laws confer jurisdiction on the civil court of peace or the civil judge of peace.”
Frequently Asked Questions
In which court is an action over interference with a common area of a multi-parcel site brought?
Under Turkish law, according to the Chamber in this decision, if the site has not yet transitioned to housing-estate management, the general provisions apply to the dispute and the action is heard by the civil court of first instance. Sites that have transitioned to housing-estate management were not addressed in the decision.
What happens if a civil court of peace decides such an action on the merits?
According to the Chamber, jurisdiction is a matter of public order and is observed of the court’s own motion. In this case a judgment that had passed appellate review was reversed on appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
Can a site manager bring an action concerning a common area on their own initiative?
According to the Chamber, this action is based on the right of ownership and is not among the manager’s duties listed in KMK art. 35. A manager who is not a condominium owner may bring this action only if authorised by the board of condominium owners.
If the manager is a condominium owner, is separate authority from the board required?
The decision does not say so expressly; the Chamber made the review of authority conditional on the manager not being an owner in the property in dispute.
- Condominium Management in Turkish Law: The Board of Condominium Owners, the Manager, the Management Plan, Service Charges and the Annulment of Board Decisions
- Action for Prevention of Interference with Property: Conditions, Interference Between Co-Owners, Encroaching Structures and Joinder with Mesne Profits
- Removal of Apartment Rooftop Solar Panels Upheld: Installed Without Co-owners’ Consent or an Amended Project (Turkish Court of Cassation)
Related Articles
- Condominium Management in Turkish Law: The Board of Condominium Owners, the Manager, the Management Plan, Service Charges and the Annulment of Board Decisions
- Action for Prevention of Interference with Property: Conditions, Interference Between Co-Owners, Encroaching Structures and Joinder with Mesne Profits
- Turkish Court of Cassation Upholds Removal of Solar Panels Installed on an Apartment Roof Without Co-owners’ Consent or an Amended Project
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Title deed cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Real Estate Law
- Turnkey Home Purchases in Türkiye: Off-Plan Sale Contracts, Late Delivery, Withdrawal and Title
- Revoking a Gift of Real Estate in Türkiye: Conditional Gifts, Grounds and the One-Year Period (TCO 295–297)
- Promise to Sell Real Estate in Türkiye: Registration Action, Termination, Limitation and Informal Sales
- Property Inside the Shore Edge Line in Türkiye: Title Cancellation, Compensation and Legal Remedies
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “General Rules for Multi-Parcel Sites Until Estate Management: Turkish Court of Cassation on Common Areas”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/multi-parcel-housing-estate-common-area-action-jurisdiction

























