Last reviewed:
Case NoteRooftop Solar Panel Removal Upheld: No Co-owner Consent or Amended Project (Turkish Court of Cassation)
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under the Turkish Condominium Ownership Law, the roof of an apartment building is a common area; as a rule, a condominium owner must obtain the written consent of four-fifths of all condominium owners to have construction, repairs or installations carried out in the common areas (Condominium Ownership Law art. 19/2). In its decision of 02.02.2026, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay 5. Hukuk Dairesi), noting that the condominium owner who had installed three water tanks and a solar panel on the roof could submit neither an amended project nor consent in sufficient quorum, unanimously upheld the judgment ordering the removal of the system. In the case, the expert had found that the weight of the system created a risk of collapse in the building; the fact that the system was useful and occupied an area in proportion to the defendant’s land share did not change the outcome. Earlier decisions of the Court of Cassation allowed solar energy systems without consent under certain conditions; the Chamber’s brief reasoning does not address that practice.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation unanimously upheld the removal of a solar energy system and water tanks installed on an apartment roof without an amended project or the consent of condominium owners in sufficient quorum. In the case, an expert report had found that the system would adversely affect the building’s load-bearing structure.
Under Turkish law, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation unanimously upheld a judgment ordering the removal of a solar energy system and water tanks that a condominium owner had installed on the common roof of an apartment building without an amended project or sufficient consent.
The Dispute
The action was brought by the plaintiffs as owners of independent unit no. 3 in an apartment building in İzmir with six independent units, subject to construction servitude (kat irtifakı). The defendant, the owner of independent unit no. 4, had installed on the roof a heating system consisting of three sheet-metal tanks of about 300 litres each and a solar panel. The plaintiffs asked for the system, which had been installed without a decision or approval of the condominium owners and which they said was used only by the defendant, to be removed and for the roof to be restored to its original state in accordance with its project.
The defendant argued that the consent provided for in Condominium Ownership Law art. 19 was not required for a solar energy system, that the system did not damage the building, that it did not exceed the land share of the unit benefiting from it and that there was enough room on the roof for every independent unit.
Relying on the expert report, the civil court of peace allowed the action: the works were in a common area, placed an additional load on the building and, because of their weight, created a risk of collapse. The 6th Civil Chamber of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on the merits. According to the regional court, no permission from the condominium owners was needed for such a system; it occupied 6 m², remained proportionate to the defendant’s 1/6 land share, and there was enough room on the roof for everyone. However, in a building on which construction servitude had been established in 1990, it was clear that the system would adversely affect the load-bearing structure; even a useful work had to be removed if it damaged the structural integrity of the main building.
Outcome of the Decision
The 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dismissed the defendant’s grounds of appeal and upheld the regional court’s decision under Code of Civil Procedure art. 370/1. The decision was given unanimously on 02.02.2026; there is no dissenting opinion. The first-instance judgment ordering the removal of the system and the restoration of the roof thus passed both appellate and cassation review.
Reasoning
The Chamber first identified the documents missing from the file:
“It is understood that, in the main immovable subject to the action, the defendants interfered with the common area through works contrary to the architectural project, and that no document showing any amended project, or the consent of the condominium owners in sufficient quorum, concerning the interference could be submitted to the file.”
It then tied the outcome to the duty of preservation under Condominium Ownership Law art. 19:
“Pursuant to Article 19 of Law No. 634, every condominium owner is obliged to preserve the architectural condition and beauty of the main immovable, and considering that the contrary could not be proved on the basis of the file and that the interferences made were against the property rights of the condominium owners in the common areas, the decision to allow the action is appropriate.”
The Chamber did not repeat the regional court’s structural assessment in its own reasoning; however, it found the decision under appeal lawful also on the grounds stated in that decision. The outcome thus rests on two grounds: the absence of an amended project or sufficient consent, and the risk that the system would damage the load-bearing structure.
Significance and Practical Effect
In earlier decisions of the Court of Cassation, solar energy systems were treated as an exception to the general rule in Condominium Ownership Law art. 19/2. In 2019 the 20th Civil Chamber summarised the Court’s settled practice as follows: even if it is not in the project and the consent of the other condominium owners has not been obtained, a system may be installed if it does not exceed the area corresponding to the owner’s land share, has been installed in accordance with good technical practice, there is enough room on the roof for all condominium owners, and it does not damage the load-bearing structure of the main building; where the conditions have been met defectively or incompletely, the court orders the remedying of the shortcomings identified by the expert and the taking of precautions (20th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, E. 2017/2578, K. 2019/15, 14.01.2019).
In the present case the regional court applied the same conditions: the land-share and space conditions were met, but the condition of not damaging the load-bearing structure was not; the outcome was removal rather than the remedying of shortcomings. The Chamber, by contrast, based the outcome on the absence of an amended project and sufficient consent and did not address the earlier practice. Whether the decision marks a new approach requiring consent even for a system that meets those conditions cannot be determined from the two-paragraph reasoning; in the present case the structural condition was not met in any event.
In practice, the safest course for a condominium owner wishing to install a system on the roof is to obtain, before installation, the written consent of four-fifths of all condominium owners and to document technically whether the building can carry the load. In this case too, the expert examination was decisive; in its 2019 decision the 20th Civil Chamber also required the approved architectural project to be applied on site and the decisions of the condominium owners’ board and the management plan to be examined. The decision concerns a solar heating system installed together with water tanks; this article does not address the energy legislation on electricity-generating systems.
In the Court of Cassation decisions accessible since the decision (for the 5th Civil Chamber, up to 10.09.2026), no decision taking a different view on solar energy systems installed on apartment roofs was found.
Relevant Legislation
“Condominium owners are obliged to attend to the maintenance of the main immovable and to preserve meticulously its architectural condition, beauty and soundness.
… Unless there is the written consent of four-fifths of all condominium owners, a condominium owner may not have construction, repairs and installations, or exterior whitewash or paint of a different colour, carried out in the common areas of the main immovable.”
“Condominium owners own all common areas of the main immovable in proportion to their land shares, in accordance with the provisions on co-ownership.
Condominium owners have the right to use the common areas; unless otherwise agreed, the extent of this right in places such as the general coal store, garage, terrace, laundry room and laundry drying areas is proportionate to the land share of each condominium owner.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the consent of the condominium owners needed to install solar panels on an apartment roof?
Under Turkish law, the roof is a common area; Condominium Ownership Law art. 19/2 requires the written consent of four-fifths of all condominium owners for construction, repairs and installations in common areas. Earlier decisions of the Court of Cassation allowed solar energy systems without consent under certain conditions; in upholding the removal in the 2026 decision, the Chamber relied on the absence of an amended project and sufficient consent; however, it had also been established in the case that the system would adversely affect the load-bearing structure, and the Chamber did not address the earlier practice.
Is a panel removed even if it occupies an area in proportion to the land share?
In this case the system, at 6 m², was proportionate to the defendant’s 1/6 land share and there was room on the roof for everyone; nevertheless, the removal order was upheld because of the structural risk and the lack of consent.
Is a solar energy system protected because it is useful?
According to the regional court, even a useful work is removed if it damages the structural integrity and load-bearing structure of the main building; the Court of Cassation upheld that decision.
What should be considered before installing a system on the roof?
The written consent of four-fifths of the condominium owners, an amended project where required, and a technical examination of whether the building can carry the load. For systems installed without consent, earlier decisions required that the land share not be exceeded, that there be enough room for everyone, that the installation follow good technical practice and that it not damage the load-bearing structure.
- Condominium Management in Turkish Law: The Board of Condominium Owners, the Manager, the Management Plan, Service Charges and the Annulment of Board Decisions
- Action for Prevention of Interference with Property: Conditions, Interference Between Co-Owners, Encroaching Structures and Joinder with Mesne Profits
- Shared Title Deeds in Türkiye: Selling a Share, Partition and Conversion to a Single Title
Related Articles
- Condominium Management in Turkish Law: The Board of Condominium Owners, the Manager, the Management Plan, Service Charges and the Annulment of Board Decisions
- Action for Prevention of Interference with Property: Conditions, Interference Between Co-Owners, Encroaching Structures and Joinder with Mesne Profits
- Shared Title Deeds in Türkiye: Selling a Share, Partition and Conversion to a Single Title
- General Rules for Multi-Parcel Sites Until Estate Management: Turkish Court of Cassation on Common-Area Actions, Jurisdiction and a Manager’s Authority to Sue
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Title deed cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Real Estate Law
- Turnkey Home Purchases in Türkiye: Off-Plan Sale Contracts, Late Delivery, Withdrawal and Title
- Revoking a Gift of Real Estate in Türkiye: Conditional Gifts, Grounds and the One-Year Period (TCO 295–297)
- Promise to Sell Real Estate in Türkiye: Registration Action, Termination, Limitation and Informal Sales
- Property Inside the Shore Edge Line in Türkiye: Title Cancellation, Compensation and Legal Remedies
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Rooftop Solar Panel Removal Upheld: No Co-owner Consent or Amended Project (Turkish Court of Cassation)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/rooftop-solar-panels-apartment-building-without-consent

























