Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 22 min read

Last reviewed:

Effective Repentance in Theft under Turkish Law: Art. 168, Partial Return, Property Damage, Breach of Trust

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, Criminal Code art. 168 provides that where, after the offence of theft, damage to property or breach of trust has been completed, the offender, instigator or accessory personally shows remorse and fully redresses the victim’s loss by returning the property itself or by compensation, the penalty is reduced. If the loss is redressed before the indictment is accepted, the reduction is up to two-thirds; if it is redressed afterwards but before judgment, up to one half. For a partial return, the victim’s consent is also required. According to the Court of Cassation the decisive factor is the offender’s remorse: the return of property seized by the police without any contribution from the offender is not effective repentance, whereas the offender showing where he hid the property and thus securing its return may be. Payment made after the first-instance judgment does not, as a rule, lead to a reduction.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, effective repentance under Criminal Code art. 168 in theft, damage to property and breach of trust: reductions of up to two-thirds at the investigation stage and up to one half at the prosecution stage, the victim’s consent to partial return, joint offenders and payment by third persons, property seized by the police or sold on, payment after judgment, settlement and HAGB, with decisions of the Court of Cassation Criminal General Assembly and 2nd Criminal Chamber.

Effective repentance (etkin pişmanlık) under Turkish Criminal Code art. 168 in theft, damage to property and breach of trust: reduction rates, partial return and the victim’s consent, joint offenders, property recovered by the police or sold on, settlement and deferral of the verdict (HAGB), with decisions of the Criminal General Assembly and the 2nd Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation.

What Is Effective Repentance and to Which Offences Does It Apply?

Effective repentance is conduct by which, after the offence has been completed, the offender of his own will seeks to eliminate the consequence he caused; the Criminal General Assembly of the Court of Cassation classifies it among the personal grounds that remove or reduce the penalty (Criminal General Assembly, E. 2017/969, K. 2019/274, 02.04.2019). Article 168 of the Turkish Criminal Code provides a common reduction for theft, damage to property, breach of trust, fraud, fraudulent bankruptcy and negligent bankruptcy, with separate rates for robbery. Unlawful use of utilities was removed from the list by Law No. 6352 and is regulated separately in the fifth paragraph.

The present structure of the article stems from the amendment made by Law No. 5377: the original text granted a reduction only for redress at the investigation stage, while the amendment made redress at the prosecution stage a ground for reduction as well (Criminal General Assembly, E. 2012/979, K. 2013/46, 12.02.2013). The rates are not fixed but upper limits (“up to two-thirds”, “up to one half”).

Statutory Provision — Turkish Criminal Code (Law No. 5237) art. 168/1-4 (Effective repentance) (unofficial translation)

“(1) Where, after the offences of theft, damage to property, breach of trust, fraud, fraudulent bankruptcy, negligent bankruptcy … have been completed but before a prosecution has been initiated against him for this reason, the offender, instigator or accessory, personally showing remorse, fully redresses the loss suffered by the victim by returning the property itself or by compensation, up to two-thirds of the penalty to be imposed shall be reduced.

(2) Where effective repentance is shown after the prosecution has started but before the judgment is rendered, up to one half of the penalty to be imposed shall be reduced.

(3) The penalty to be imposed on a person who shows effective repentance for the offence of robbery shall be reduced by up to one half in cases falling under the first paragraph and by up to one third in cases falling under the second paragraph.

(4) In the case of partial return or compensation, the consent of the victim is additionally required for the provisions on effective repentance to apply.”

Fraud also falls within the same article; redress at the investigation stage in aggravated fraud committed through a bank account is discussed in a separate article: Renting Out a Bank Account (IBAN) under Turkish Law: The Offence and Effective Remorse at the Investigation Stage. Most of the decisions in this article concern theft and damage to property cases; the text of art. 168, however, is the same for all the offences it lists.

Conditions: Personal Remorse and Full Redress

The offence must be completed. For a defendant who broke a door lock and left the house without taking anything, the Court of Cassation held that the theft remained an attempt and that attempt and effective repentance cannot be applied together (2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2020/29496, K. 2022/9222, 12.05.2022).

The loss must be fully redressed. Return in kind means returning the property itself; compensation means paying its equivalent. If redress is partial, the victim’s consent is required (art. 168/4).

The remorse must come from the offender. According to the Criminal General Assembly, unlike the former Law No. 765, art. 168 rests on “remorse rather than compensation”. Return through enforcement proceedings, payment by third persons against the offender’s will or without his knowledge, the property being thrown away while fleeing or being found on an offender caught while fleeing do not amount to effective repentance; remorse may, however, be shown by conduct rather than words (E. 2017/969, K. 2019/274).

Denying the charge is not in itself a bar. In a fraud case, the Criminal General Assembly held that effective repentance had to be applied to convicted persons who never accepted the charge but paid the loss before judgment in the adaptation proceedings, since nothing in the file showed that they were not remorseful. The decision was taken with the dissent of the President of the General Assembly and eight members; in the dissenting view, convicted persons who did not show remorse cannot benefit from the reduction merely because the loss was covered (E. 2012/979, K. 2013/46).

Timing and Reduction Rates

Investigation stage (art. 168/1): Under Code of Criminal Procedure art. 2, the investigation lasts until the indictment is accepted, and the prosecution begins with the acceptance of the indictment. Where the loss was redressed five days before the indictment was accepted, the Court of Cassation set aside, in the interest of the law, a judgment that failed to apply the first paragraph (2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/13782, K. 2024/17143, 20.11.2024). The reduction is up to two-thirds; according to the Criminal General Assembly it must be more than 1/2 in order to preserve the gradation between the two paragraphs, although 2/3 is not mandatory (E. 2017/969, K. 2019/274).

Prosecution stage (art. 168/2): If the loss is redressed after the indictment is accepted but before judgment, the reduction is up to one half.

After judgment: According to the 2nd Criminal Chamber, the “judgment” here is the judgment of the first-instance court; redress at the appeal (istinaf) or cassation stage does not, as a rule, lead to a reduction. If the judgment is reversed, the second paragraph applies to redress made before the judgment rendered after the reversal; the same was accepted for payments made where the regional court of appeal reopens the case with a hearing (2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2023/19173, K. 2023/5662, 18.10.2023). In adaptation proceedings held because of a more favourable law, payments made before the new judgment are also taken into account (E. 2012/979, K. 2013/46).

Robbery (art. 168/3): The reduction is up to one half in cases under the first paragraph and up to one third in cases under the second paragraph.

Partial Return and the Victim’s Consent

For partial return or compensation the victim’s consent is additionally required (art. 168/4); according to the Criminal General Assembly, if the victim does not consent, the offender cannot benefit from this provision. A partial return must be of an amount that satisfies the victim, have a direct effect for the victim and impose no additional burden on him. For a motorcycle returned damaged, the first and fourth paragraphs were applied together on the basis of the consent the victim gave at the prosecution stage (E. 2017/969, K. 2019/274).

The victim must be asked expressly whether he consents (2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/5945, K. 2025/20140, 18.11.2025). Where redress is made in instalments, the date of each part matters: where part of the loss was paid before the indictment and the rest at the prosecution stage, a judgment given without asking the victims whether they consented to the partial return made during the investigation was set aside in the interest of the law (2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2023/21553, K. 2024/4205, 13.03.2024). Without consent, no reduction can be based on the partial redress; under the text of the law, if the remaining loss is made good before judgment, the full redress is assessed under the second paragraph.

Joint Offenders and Payment by Third Persons

The article also names the instigator and the accessory. According to the Criminal General Assembly, if one of the accomplices fully redresses the loss, return and compensation are no longer required for the others; they must, however, at least have made statements or engaged in conduct showing their remorse or their consent to the payment. In that decision, which concerned robbery, a defendant who said he had not contributed because he had not committed the offence could not benefit from the reduction (Criminal General Assembly, E. 2017/654, K. 2017/333, 13.06.2017). In the case of a partial return, according to the 2nd Criminal Chamber, only the defendant who made the return may benefit, subject to the victim’s consent (E. 2024/5945, K. 2025/20140).

Payment of the loss by third persons, such as family members, may also count as effective repentance depending on the circumstances, provided that the defendant has made statements or engaged in conduct showing his remorse or consent and has not opposed it; payment made without the defendant’s knowledge is not enough (E. 2017/969, K. 2019/274).

Property Seized by the Police and Property Sold On

  • No contribution by the offender: If the property was found in a search and handed over without the defendants showing its location or making any attempt, no reduction is made for theft (2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2023/23402, K. 2024/4833, 25.03.2024).
  • The offender shows the hiding place: A defendant who showed the police where he had hidden the motorcycle and thus secured its return benefited from effective repentance (E. 2017/969, K. 2019/274).
  • Information the police would find anyway: A defendant whose stolen telephones and money had already been seized by the police and who then pointed out the houses he had entered was not regarded as remorseful; the decision was taken with four dissenting members (Criminal General Assembly, E. 2013/666, K. 2015/91, 07.04.2015).
  • Property sold on: Since an offender who has sold the property no longer has power of disposal over it, the property being taken from the buyer and given to the victim merely because the offender named the buyer is not a return; there is return or compensation if the offender buys the property back and hands it over or secures payment of its value through his own efforts. Showing where it was sold may be taken into account for the discretionary reduction under Criminal Code art. 62, and redress of the buyer’s loss is not required (Criminal General Assembly, E. 2013/592, K. 2016/94, 23.02.2016).

Scope of the Loss: Damage, Broken Windows and Doors

If stolen property is returned damaged, the return is partial and the victim’s consent is required; this was accepted for a damaged motorcycle (E. 2017/969, K. 2019/274) and for damage to a vehicle (E. 2024/5945, K. 2025/20140). A window, door or lock broken during the offence, by contrast, is the loss of the offence of damage to property, and effective repentance is assessed separately for each offence. Where a car window was broken and materials were stolen, the reduction for theft was refused because the materials were returned without any contribution from the defendants, while the second paragraph was applied to damage to property because the cost of the window had been paid (E. 2023/23402, K. 2024/4833). The offence of damage to property under Criminal Code art. 151/1 is prosecuted upon the victim’s complaint (Criminal Code art. 151).

Procedure, Settlement and HAGB

Opportunity to pay. The text of art. 168 contains no provision requiring the court to remind the defendant of the opportunity to pay. The 2nd Criminal Chamber accepted that if judgment was rendered without giving that opportunity to a defendant who declared that he wished to redress the loss, payment made at the appeal stage is to be regarded as made before judgment (E. 2023/19173, K. 2023/5662). By contrast, it did not accept that a convicted person who made no attempt for about a year until judgment to pay a fixed amount had been denied the opportunity (2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2026/2867, K. 2026/6968, 21.04.2026).

Settlement (uzlaşma) is an institution separate from effective repentance. Under Code of Criminal Procedure art. 253/1, settlement is attempted for offences prosecuted upon complaint and for the listed offences; the list includes, for theft, only art. 141 and, for breach of trust, art. 155 except its third paragraph. If an offence within the scope of settlement is committed together with an offence outside it against the same victim, settlement does not apply; under the sentence added by Law No. 7571, this is not the case where it is committed together with an offence subject to prepayment (art. 253/3). If the agreed performance is fulfilled at once, a decision of non-prosecution is given; if it is payable in instalments, a decision to postpone the filing of the public action is given (art. 253/19).

Statutory Provision — Code of Criminal Procedure (Law No. 5271) art. 253/1 (Settlement) (unofficial translation)

“(1) In the following offences, an attempt shall be made to reconcile the suspect with the victim or with the natural person or private-law legal entity harmed by the offence:

a) Offences whose investigation and prosecution depend on a complaint.

b) Regardless of whether they depend on a complaint, the following offences in the Turkish Criminal Code; … Theft (article 141), … Breach of trust (except the third paragraph, article 155), …”

HAGB. For deferral of the announcement of the verdict, full redress of the loss is a separate condition; if it cannot be met at once, the decision may also be given on condition that the loss is paid in monthly instalments during the supervision period (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 231/9). See: Deferral of the Announcement of the Verdict (HAGB) and Criminal Records in Türkiye.

Statutory Provision — Code of Criminal Procedure (Law No. 5271) art. 231/6 (Conditions of HAGB) (unofficial translation)

“For a decision to defer the announcement of the verdict; … c) the loss suffered by the victim or the public as a result of the offence must be fully redressed by return in kind, restoration to the pre-offence state or compensation.”

Court of Cassation Decisions

Pointing out houses the police would find anyway is not remorse (majority decision)

Court of Cassation Decision
Criminal General Assembly, E. 2013/666, K. 2015/91, 07.04.2015 (reasoning of the Criminal General Assembly; the judgment of persistence was upheld, with four dissenting members)

“Indeed, the phrase “by personally showing remorse” in the text clearly shows that the provision attaches importance not to “return and compensation alone” but to “return and compensation resulting from remorse”. … the telephones having been found by the police officers and not as a result of the defendant’s showing, his pointing out the houses where he committed the thefts, after the money he had taken from the victims had been seized in a body search, would not demonstrate his remorse, since it was certain that the houses they entered and the victims would be identified through a simple investigation by the police officers …” (translation)

Securing return by showing the hiding place is effective repentance; at the investigation stage the reduction must exceed 1/2

Court of Cassation Decision
Criminal General Assembly, E. 2017/969, K. 2019/274, 02.04.2019 (reasoning of the Criminal General Assembly; the judgment of persistence was unanimously reversed)

“… the defendant, as a result of the remorse he felt and with a view to eliminating the consequence caused by the offence, ensured the return of the property to the victim by showing where the stolen motorcycle was and largely redressed the victim’s loss; the victim stated at the prosecution stage that he consented to the application of the effective repentance provision on account of the partial return; … the rate of reduction to be applied under the first paragraph must be more than 1/2, which is the maximum rate of reduction under the second paragraph …” (translation)

Naming the buyer of sold property is not a return; the buyer’s loss need not be redressed

Court of Cassation Decision
Criminal General Assembly, E. 2013/592, K. 2016/94, 23.02.2016 (reasoning of the Criminal General Assembly; the objection was unanimously dismissed)

“… the condition that the loss of the person or persons who bought the property subject to the offence, in other words of the person harmed, be redressed should not be required. … Only where the offender buys the property back from the place where he sold it by paying its price and returns it to the victim in kind, or where its value is paid to the victim by a third person personally or as a result of his own efforts, and in similar cases, can there be a return and compensation within the meaning of article 168.” (translation)

A joint offender who did not redress the loss must also show remorse

Court of Cassation Decision
Criminal General Assembly, E. 2017/654, K. 2017/333, 13.06.2017 (reasoning of the Criminal General Assembly; robbery, art. 168/3; the objection was unanimously dismissed)

“In this context, in offences committed jointly, where one of the accomplices — the perpetrator, the accessory or the instigator — fully redresses the victim’s loss, since there is no longer any loss to be redressed, the condition of “return and compensation” will not be required for applying effective repentance to the other accomplices who did not redress the loss; however, since article 168 of the Turkish Criminal Code is based on remorse rather than compensation, the other accomplices who did not redress the loss must at least have made statements or engaged in conduct showing their remorse or their consent to return and compensation.” (translation)

“Before the judgment is rendered”: payment at the appeal stage is, as a rule, too late; payment before the judgment after reversal counts

Court of Cassation Decision
2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2023/19173, K. 2023/5662, 18.10.2023 (request to resolve conflicting decisions of regional courts of appeal; reasoning of the Chamber, final)

“As a rule, effective repentance cannot be applied to the offender on account of return or compensation made after judgment, at the appeal or cassation stage, nor can the judgment be reversed for that reason. … where the judgment is reversed, paragraph 2 of article 168 of Law No. 5237 must also be applied to an offender who redresses the loss before the judgment to be rendered after the reversal. … if, after the defendant’s statement that he wishes to redress the loss, judgment is rendered without giving him that opportunity, redress made at the appeal stage must also be regarded as redress made “before the judgment is rendered”.” (translation)

A defendant who declared a wish to pay but made no attempt cannot claim he was denied the opportunity

Court of Cassation Decision
2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2026/2867, K. 2026/6968, 21.04.2026 (request for reversal in the interest of the law; reasoning of the Chamber, the request was unanimously dismissed)

“… stated that he wished to redress the loss caused, but considering also that the convicted person made no attempt to redress the loss of TRY 950, the subject of the offence and a fixed amount, until 02.07.2024, the date on which judgment was rendered, it cannot be accepted that the convicted person was not given the opportunity to redress the loss …” (translation)

Redressing damage to the vehicle is a partial return; consent must be asked expressly and only the defendant who made the return benefits

Court of Cassation Decision
2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2024/5945, K. 2025/20140, 18.11.2025 (judgments upheld; the Chamber did not treat the too-lenient sentence it noted as a ground for reversal, since there was no appeal against the defendants)

“… given that the loss relating to the damage to the vehicle subject to the offence was redressed by defendant ... at the prosecution stage; taking into account that the return that took place amounts to a partial return, after expressly asking the complainant whether he consents to the application of the effective repentance provisions on account of the partial return … only the defendant who made the partial return may benefit from the effective repentance provisions …” (translation)

Theft and damage to property are assessed separately

Court of Cassation Decision
2nd Criminal Chamber, E. 2023/23402, K. 2024/4833, 25.03.2024 (reversal in the interest of the law; the request was dismissed as to theft and granted as to damage to property)

“… all the materials were handed over to the intervening party without the defendants showing their location or making any attempt in that regard, and therefore there was no error in not applying the effective repentance provisions to defendant ... in respect of the offence of theft … given the statement that the loss of TRY 160.00 caused by the breaking of the window had been covered by the defendants, although the conditions of effective repentance had been met in respect of the defendants for the offence of damage to property …” (translation)

Practical Points

  • Date: The date of payment or return is compared with the date on which the indictment was accepted; the bank receipt, the handover record or the victim’s dated statement should be placed on the file.
  • The victim’s statement: Whether the loss was redressed fully or partly and, if partly, whether the victim consents to effective repentance should be recorded expressly.
  • The offender’s contribution: Showing where the property is, paying its value or buying back sold property should be reflected in the records; property the police find on their own does not replace this.
  • Payment by third persons: The file should show that the payment was made on the defendant’s behalf, with his knowledge and consent, together with his statement of remorse.
  • Joint offenders: A defendant who did not pay must also have made statements or engaged in conduct showing remorse or consent.
  • Concrete steps: Declaring a wish to pay may not be enough; the amount and place of payment should be ascertained and payment made. Payment after the first-instance judgment does not, as a rule, lead to a reduction.
  • Which offence’s loss: The value of stolen property and the cost of a broken door or window are losses of different offences; receipts and statements should distinguish them.
  • For the complainant: In a partial return the reduction depends on the victim’s consent; with full redress, consent is not required.

Frequently Asked Questions

How large is the effective repentance reduction for theft?

If the loss is fully redressed before the indictment is accepted, up to two-thirds of the penalty is reduced; if it is redressed after the prosecution starts but before judgment, up to one half (Criminal Code art. 168/1-2). According to the Criminal General Assembly, the reduction under the first paragraph must be more than 1/2.

If the police find the stolen property and return it to the owner, does effective repentance apply?

If the property was seized by the police and returned without the offender showing its location or making any other contribution, the Court of Cassation does not apply effective repentance. The offender himself showing where he hid the property and thus securing its return may, however, count as effective repentance.

Can effective repentance apply if my family pays the loss?

If the defendant has at least made statements or engaged in conduct showing remorse or consent to the payment and has not opposed it, redress by third persons on the defendant’s behalf may count as effective repentance depending on the circumstances. Payment made without the defendant’s knowledge or against his will is not enough.

I paid part of the loss; what if the victim does not accept it?

For partial return or compensation, the victim’s consent is required (Criminal Code art. 168/4). Without consent, no reduction can be based on the partial payment; if the remaining loss is fully redressed before judgment, it is assessed under the second paragraph.

If I pay at the appeal stage after the judgment, will I get a reduction?

As a rule, no; payment after the first-instance judgment does not lead to a reduction. If the judgment is reversed, payment before the new judgment is taken into account; if judgment was rendered without giving the opportunity to a defendant who declared that he wished to redress the loss, payment at the appeal stage may also be regarded as made before judgment.

Is settlement (uzlaşma) available for theft?

Under Code of Criminal Procedure art. 253/1-b, theft under Criminal Code art. 141 is subject to settlement; art. 142 is not on the list. Breach of trust (except the third paragraph) is also listed, and damage to property under Criminal Code art. 151/1, being prosecuted upon complaint, is subject to settlement.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Criminal Law

All Criminal Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Effective Repentance in Theft under Turkish Law: Art. 168, Partial Return, Property Damage, Breach of Trust”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-06, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/effective-repentance-theft-turkish-criminal-code-168

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›