Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Building Declaration Fails Without Legal Interest: Turkish Court of Cassation on Muhdesat Without Partition

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: An action for a declaration of muhdesat (also called an action to establish who owns muhdesat) is a declaratory action seeking a determination of who created a permanent building, installation or tree on an immovable; under Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) art. 106/2, the plaintiff must have a current legal interest. In its decision of 02.02.2026, the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay 7. Hukuk Dairesi) stated that the plaintiff had no legal interest because no partition action had been brought and no expropriation procedure existed in respect of the immovable, and that, since the determination of muhdesat is a material fact, no weight could be given to the statements of some defendants admitting the claim. The Chamber unanimously reversed the first-instance judgment that had granted the claim on the merits; the file was sent to the first-instance court. As the remedy of rectification of decision (karar düzeltme) is open, the reversal may not yet be final. In another decision, the Assembly of Civil Chambers also listed an urban transformation project alongside these two situations.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that, as no partition action had been brought and no expropriation procedure existed in respect of the immovable, the plaintiff had no legal interest in an action for a declaration of improvements (muhdesat), and that, since the determination of muhdesat is a material fact, no weight could be given to the statements of some defendants admitting the claim. The Chamber unanimously reversed the first-instance judgment that had granted the claim on the merits and sent the file back to the first-instance court; as the remedy of rectification of decision (karar düzeltme) is open, the reversal may not yet be final.

Under Turkish law, the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that there was no legal interest in an action for a declaration of improvements (muhdesat) in a case where no partition action was pending and no expropriation procedure existed in respect of the immovable, and that the admission of the claim by some defendants did not change that result.

The Dispute

According to the statement of claim as set out in the decision, the plaintiff alleged that in 1988-1989, with his father’s consent, he had built a two-storey reinforced-concrete building on a village immovable inherited from his father; he lived on the upper floor, while the lower floor was occupied by the family of a farmhand whom the plaintiff and the defendants had hired to tend the orchards inherited from their father. The plaintiff sought a declaration that ownership of the building belonged to him and its registration in his name, and TRY 1,000 in ecrimisil from the defendant who, he alleged, had not paid his share of the rent.

Counsel for one defendant raised objections that another action was pending, that there was no legal interest and that the house belonged to the deceased. One defendant admitted the claim but later argued that this statement was not true. The civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk mahkemesi), relying on the statements of the plaintiff’s witnesses and also taking into account the admissions of some defendants, granted the action; it declared that the building belonged to the plaintiff, ordered its registration in the land registry and ordered the collection of the ecrimisil. The first-instance judgment, given in 2016, was appealed directly to the Court of Cassation. On appeal, counsel for two defendants argued that this action could not be brought without a partition action having been filed and that the admissions of two defendants did not reflect the truth.

Outcome of the Decision

The 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed the first-instance judgment and sent the file to the first-instance court. The decision was given unanimously on 02.02.2026. The operative part states that the remedy of rectification of decision (karar düzeltme) is available within 15 days of service; as the date of service is not known, the reversal may not yet be final.

The reversal also covers the ecrimisil claim: according to the Chamber, the plaintiff had described a rent receivable in the statement of claim, and his counsel had clarified at the hearing of 05.12.2008 that the receivable was a rent receivable; in view of that clarification under HMK art. 31, the court should have examined the request as a rent receivable under the principle of being bound by the parties’ requests in art. 26 (see our ecrimisil guide).

Reasoning

The Chamber first set out the requirement of legal interest in declaratory actions:

Court of Cassation Decision
7th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/6180, K. 2026/480, 02.02.2026 (current legal interest in a declaratory action)

“In declaratory actions, the person bringing the declaratory action must have a legal interest. Article 106/2 of Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 provides that “a person bringing a declaratory action must, except for the exceptional cases specified in the laws, have a current interest worthy of legal protection in bringing this action.” For this reason, where there is no pending partition action or expropriation procedure concerning the muhdesat on the immovable, this action cannot be heard.”

It then applied this test to the case:

Court of Cassation Decision
7th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/6180, K. 2026/480, 02.02.2026 (the specific case, the defendants’ admissions and the grounds for reversal)

“Since no partition action has been brought, and no expropriation procedure exists, in respect of the immovable … on which the muhdesat in dispute stands either, it cannot be said that the plaintiff has a legal interest. Moreover, since the determination of muhdesat is a material fact, there is no doubt that no weight can be given to the statements of some defendants admitting the claim. That being so, whereas the court should have dismissed the action for lack of legal interest as regards the request for a declaration of muhdesat, examining the merits of the case and granting the action was not correct.”

The Chamber did not separately discuss the registration in the land registry ordered by the first-instance court; it based the reversal, as regards this request, on the lack of legal interest.

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision shows that, according to the Chamber, where there is no partition action or expropriation procedure in respect of the immovable and a declaration is sought as to who built the building on it, the action must be dismissed without examining the merits.

The decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of 23.10.2024 applies the same test (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2023/654, K. 2024/530, 23.10.2024). The Assembly stated that the current legal interest must continue until the end of the action and that, in its absence, the action is dismissed on procedural grounds; it emphasised that, in the consistent practice of the Court of Cassation, a current legal interest is accepted in exceptional situations such as a pending partition action, an urban transformation project or an expropriation procedure concerning the immovable. In that case it was held, by majority, that a plaintiff who sought a declaration that a building on land registered in the name of the Treasury belonged to him, and who had sued a person who was not the registered owner, had no current legal interest; the majority of the Assembly did not adopt the view that a legal interest arose from the building owner’s priority right in a sale of the immovable by the administration. In the same decision the Assembly also stated that muhdesat do not give their owner an independent ownership right or a limited real right separate from ownership of the land; in the case decided by the Chamber, by contrast, the first-instance court had ordered the building’s registration in the land registry.

In our assessment, given that the Assembly lists the exceptional situations by way of example, the decision should not be read as meaning that a legal interest can exist only in the two situations mentioned by the Chamber. Indeed, in a decision of 13.04.2026, the Chamber accepted the other co-owner’s legal interest in a case where the share of a debtor co-owner was to be sold through enforcement proceedings and the muhdesat had been included in the value of that share, because the person acquiring the share would also become entitled to the muhdesat (Court of Cassation, 7th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/3988, K. 2026/1976, 13.04.2026). On partition actions, see our partition guide, our article on shared title deeds and our decision note on a sale made while a pre-emption action was pending.

The decision of 02.02.2026, by contrast, contains no account of any urban transformation or sale process concerning the immovable; the Chamber also did not separately address the objection, raised on appeal, that another action was pending. A limited search, based on search-result summaries, of Court of Cassation decisions given after 02.02.2026 in the official case-law database (for the 7th Civil Chamber, those visible up to 07.09.2026; for the Assembly of Civil Chambers, up to 01.10.2026) did not identify any decision accepting a legal interest in an action for a declaration of muhdesat where there was no partition action, expropriation, urban transformation, sale or similar process concerning the immovable.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) art. 106 (Declaratory action) (unofficial translation)

“(1) By means of a declaratory action, a determination is requested from the court as to the existence or non-existence of a right or legal relationship, or as to whether a document is forged.

(2) A person bringing a declaratory action must, except for the exceptional cases specified in the laws, have a current interest worthy of legal protection in bringing this action.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an action to establish who owns muhdesat always be brought?

No. Under Turkish law, the plaintiff must have a current legal interest under HMK art. 106/2; the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that there was no legal interest in this case, in which there was no partition action or expropriation procedure in respect of the immovable.

In which situations is a legal interest accepted?

The Chamber referred to a pending partition action and an expropriation procedure. In its decision of 23.10.2024, the Assembly of Civil Chambers also listed an urban transformation project among such exceptional situations.

Does the result change if some defendants admit the claim?

It did not in this case. According to the Chamber, since the determination of muhdesat is a material fact, no weight can be given to the statements of some defendants admitting the claim.

Did this decision end the case?

No. The Chamber reversed the first-instance judgment and sent the file back to the first-instance court; it also stated that the claim labelled as ecrimisil had to be examined as a rent receivable.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Real Estate Law

All Real Estate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Building Declaration Fails Without Legal Interest: Turkish Court of Cassation on Muhdesat Without Partition”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/muhdesat-declaration-legal-interest-partition-expropriation

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›