Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 29 min read

Last reviewed:

Singer and Producer Agreements in Türkiye: Validity and Penalty Clauses (Law No. 5846 Arts. 52, 80; TBK)

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: A singer’s performer’s rights can be transferred to a producer only by a written contract listing each right separately (Law No. 5846 art. 52); terms not meeting this requirement are invalid, and a penalty attached to them cannot be claimed (Code of Obligations art. 182/2). A valid penalty may be claimed even if the creditor suffered no loss, but the court reduces an excessive penalty of its own motion (Code of Obligations art. 182/3). A merchant debtor cannot seek reduction (Commercial Code art. 22); the Assembly of Civil Chambers holds that, where the penalty would cause the merchant debtor’s economic ruin, it must be held partly void as contrary to morality. Decisions upheld by the Court of Cassation also accept that a producer who itself breached the contract cannot claim the penalty.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Album, single, master and distribution agreements between singers and producers under Turkish law: written form and itemisation of rights, performer and producer rights, collecting societies and digital income; types of penalty clause, reservation, judicial reduction, merchant debtors, defences and Court of Cassation decisions.

A guide to album, single, master recording and distribution agreements between singers and producers under Turkish law: authorship of lyrics and music, performer’s rights and the phonogram producer’s neighbouring rights (Law No. 5846 art. 80), collecting societies and digital income, written form and itemisation of rights under Law No. 5846 art. 52, defects of consent and exploitation; types of penalty clause (Code of Obligations arts. 179-182), reservation of rights, judicial reduction of excessive penalties of the court’s own motion, the merchant’s inability to seek reduction (Commercial Code art. 22) and the economic-ruin exception, one-sided penalties, defences, proof, limitation, competent court and Court of Cassation decisions.

Types of Producer Agreements

In the music industry the “producer” is the person or company that finances the recording, organises the studio, arrangers and musicians and releases the resulting record. Agreements between singers and producers take four main forms. An album production agreement covers the recording and release of a number of albums and the sharing of income, and is often signed together with management. A single agreement is limited to one song and its digital release and has largely replaced the album deal. A master recording agreement concerns ownership and use of the master; licensing a recording financed by the artist to a company also belongs here. A distribution agreement regulates distribution of a finished recording to digital platforms and physical channels, collection of income and reporting.

These agreements do not fit any single contract type; they are mixed contracts containing works-contract, service and mandate elements alongside the FSEK (Law No. 5846, the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works) rules on assignment of economic rights. General characterisation is covered in the first article of this series, and the limits on long-term exclusivity and “handcuff” contracts in the second; this article focuses on validity requirements and penalty clauses.

Map of Rights: Lyrics and Music, Performance and Master Recording

Lyrics and music: authorship

Every song carries three layers of rights, and the contract should deal with each separately. The first is authorship of the lyrics and music: musical works are compositions with or without words (Law No. 5846 art. 3), and the author is the person who creates the work (Law No. 5846 art. 8). If the singer is not also the lyricist or composer, these rights do not belong to the singer; the producer may exercise economic rights in the work only under its contract with the author (Law No. 5846 art. 18).

The singer’s performer’s rights

The second layer is the performer’s rights arising from the singer’s interpretation. These are neighbouring rights independent of the author’s: the performer may authorise or prohibit the fixation, reproduction, distribution and communication to the public of the performance, and may transfer these rights to the producer by contract for appropriate consideration. Even after transferring economic rights, the performer may demand to be identified as the performer and to prevent distortion harmful to their reputation. Performer’s rights last seventy years from fixation (Law No. 5846 art. 82).

The phonogram producer’s neighbouring rights and the master

The third layer is the rights of the phonogram producer who first fixes the sounds. The producer acquires them after taking over the authority to exercise economic rights from the author and the performer, and then holds exclusive powers over reproduction, distribution and communication to the public of the recording. This is why rights in the “master” vest in the producer. Registration by producers facilitates proof of ownership (Law No. 5846 art. 13).

Statutory Provision — Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works (Law No. 5846) art. 80 (Performers and phonogram producers) (unofficial translation)

“A) Performers have the following rights: … (2) A performer who interprets a work in an original manner with the author’s permission has the exclusive right to authorise or prohibit the fixation of that performance, the reproduction, sale, distribution, rental and lending of the fixation, its communication and retransmission to the public by means of devices transmitting signs, sounds and/or images, and its performance. … (5) Performers may transfer these rights to the producer by contract for appropriate consideration. … B) Phonogram producers who first fix a performance or other sounds have the following rights after acquiring from the author and the performer the authority to exercise economic rights.”

Collecting societies and income from communication to the public

Where performances fixed in phonograms are communicated to the public, users must pay appropriate consideration not only to authors but also to performers and producers or the relevant collecting societies (Law No. 5846 art. 80). Collection and distribution take place through collecting societies, established to administer and enforce rights, collect fees and distribute them to right holders (Law No. 5846 art. 42), and obliged to distribute income according to their distribution plans; a member’s rights are enforced under the authorisation document given to the society (Law No. 5846 art. 42/A). In practice authors are organised in societies such as MESAM and MSG, phonogram producers in MÜYAP and music performers in MÜYORBİR. The shares a singer receives as a performer from a collecting society are a separate income stream from the producer agreement; if the producer agreement provides that this income is shared or belongs to the producer, the scope of that clause and its compliance with Law No. 5846 art. 52 must be assessed separately.

Digital platform income

Streaming and download income arises from making a work or recording available at a time and place chosen by the user; this right is granted to authors in Law No. 5846 art. 25 and to performers and producers in Law No. 5846 art. 80. Revenue shares in distribution agreements are freely agreed; most disputes arise from the definition of “net income”, platform and distributor deductions, reporting periods and the inability to audit accounts. The publisher’s duty to keep sales accounts and prepare supporting documents where the fee depends on sales (Code of Obligations art. 497) and the agent’s duty to account (Code of Obligations art. 508) provide guidance for reporting duties in recording and distribution agreements.

Validity Requirements

Law No. 5846 art. 52: written form and itemisation of rights

Contracts and dispositions concerning economic rights must be in writing and must specify each right separately. A form prescribed by law is, as a rule, a condition of validity, and a contract concluded without it has no effect (Code of Obligations art. 12). Permissions given by neighbouring-right holders, i.e. performers and producers, must also be in writing (Law No. 5846 art. 80).

Statutory Provision — Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works (Law No. 5846) art. 52 (Form) (unofficial translation)

“Contracts and dispositions concerning economic rights must be in writing and the rights forming their subject must be specified separately.”

The itemisation requirement is the part most often overlooked. Economic rights are independent of each other, and disposing of one does not affect the others (Law No. 5846 art. 20); unless otherwise agreed, assignment of an economic right does not extend to adaptations (Law No. 5846 art. 55). A general clause such as “the artist assigns all rights to the producer”, in a contract that does not list reproduction, distribution, communication to the public (including making available online), adaptation and performance individually, may not transfer the rights not listed. The consequence is not limited to the transfer: a penalty attached to an invalid term cannot be claimed either. In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, a term transferring powers over an architectural project was held invalid because it was not made in writing and did not list the rights individually, and the related penalty claim was rejected (decision below). The rule applies equally to album and recording agreements.

An assignee may transfer the right to a third party only with the author’s written consent (Law No. 5846 art. 49). A production company selling its catalogue or sub-licensing recordings must therefore have this regulated in the contract.

Capacity and defects of consent

A minor singer’s contract requires the legal representative’s consent; this and the labour-law rules on child performers are discussed in the second article of this series. A party who contracted under fundamental mistake, fraud or duress is not bound; however, a party who fails within one year of discovering the mistake or fraud, or of the end of the duress, to declare that it is not bound is deemed to have ratified the contract (Code of Obligations art. 39). Revenue shares described differently in pre-contract negotiations, or a text altered before signature, are assessed in this context.

Exploitation and immorality

If a clear imbalance between performances was brought about by exploiting the artist’s distress, thoughtlessness or inexperience, the artist may declare that it is not bound or demand removal of the imbalance (Code of Obligations art. 28). Terms that excessively restrict the artist’s economic and artistic freedom are absolutely void under Code of Obligations art. 27. Their application to binding contracts and the “handcuff contract” decisions upheld by the Court of Cassation are discussed in the second article; what matters here is that invalidity of the contract or the relevant term also defeats the penalty claim.

Penalty Clauses: Types and Effects

A penalty clause is a performance the debtor undertakes in advance to render to the creditor if it fails to perform the main obligation, or performs it improperly. The Assembly of Civil Chambers describes its two basic functions as compelling the debtor to perform and fixing in advance, as a lump sum, the compensation payable on breach; in the case of a withdrawal penalty, it enables the debtor to leave the contract easily by paying. A penalty is ancillary to the main obligation.

The Code distinguishes three types. Under an alternative penalty, the creditor claims either performance or the penalty, not both; from an artist who never records the album, either the recording or the penalty is claimed. A cumulative penalty is agreed for failure to perform at the agreed time or place; the creditor may claim both the main obligation and the penalty unless it has expressly waived the right or accepted performance without reservation. A daily penalty for late delivery of an album is of this type. A withdrawal (termination) penalty allows the debtor to withdraw from or terminate the contract by paying the penalty.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 179 (Relationship of the penalty to performance) (unofficial translation)

“If a penalty has been agreed for non-performance or improper performance of a contract, the creditor may, unless the contract indicates otherwise, claim either performance or the penalty. If the penalty has been agreed for failure to perform at the specified time or place, the creditor may claim the penalty together with the main obligation, unless it has expressly waived this right or accepted performance without reservation. The debtor’s right to prove that it is entitled to end the contract by withdrawal or termination by paying the agreed penalty is reserved.”

Penalty and loss

The main advantage of a penalty for the creditor is relief from proving loss: the agreed penalty is payable even if the creditor suffered no loss. If the loss exceeds the penalty, the creditor may claim the excess only by proving the debtor’s fault.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 180 (Relationship between penalty and loss) (unofficial translation)

“The agreed penalty must be paid even if the creditor has suffered no loss. If the creditor’s loss exceeds the amount of the penalty, the creditor may not claim the excess unless it proves that the debtor was at fault.”

Dependence on the main obligation and cases where the debtor is not responsible

The penalty shares the fate of the main obligation. If the main obligation is invalid for any reason, or, unless otherwise agreed, later becomes impossible for a reason for which the debtor is not responsible, the penalty cannot be claimed; conversely, invalidity of the penalty does not affect the main obligation. When the main obligation ends by performance or otherwise, the penalty ends too, unless the right to claim it was reserved in the contract or by notice given up to the time of performance.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 182 (Amount, invalidity and reduction of the penalty) (unofficial translation)

“The parties may freely determine the amount of the penalty. If the main obligation is invalid for any reason or, unless otherwise agreed, has later become impossible for a reason for which the debtor cannot be held responsible, performance of the penalty cannot be claimed. Invalidity of the penalty clause, or its later becoming impossible for a reason for which the debtor cannot be held responsible, does not affect the validity of the main obligation. The court shall of its own motion reduce a penalty it considers excessive.”

Statutory Provision — Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 131 (Extinction of ancillary rights and obligations) (unofficial translation)

“Where the main obligation is extinguished by performance or for another reason, ancillary rights and obligations such as pledge, suretyship, interest and penalty are also extinguished. If the right to claim accrued interest and the penalty has been reserved by the contract or by notice given up to the time of performance, or such reservation can be inferred from the circumstances, that interest and penalty may be claimed.”

Consequence of accepting performance without reservation

Under a cumulative penalty, a creditor who accepts late performance without reservation loses the right to the penalty. The Assembly of Civil Chambers adopts the following principles: the reservation is a declaration of will with formative effect and must be made expressly at the time of performance; it may be made by an entry in the delivery-acceptance record, by written notice before accepting performance, or by an act indicating it, such as paying the price after deducting the penalty; the rule is not mandatory, so the contract may provide that no reservation is required, or the right may be reserved by a warning sent before the late performance. For producers, the practical consequence is that when a late recording is accepted, the reservation of the penalty should be written expressly into the record or delivery correspondence. Under an alternative penalty, once performance has been claimed, the penalty can no longer be claimed.

Reduction of Excessive Penalties, the Merchant Debtor and One-Sided Penalties

The court’s power to reduce of its own motion and the criteria

The parties freely set the amount, but the court reduces an excessive penalty of its own motion, even without a request by the debtor (Code of Obligations art. 182/3). The Assembly of Civil Chambers lists the criteria as the creditor’s loss, the debtor’s degree of fault, the creditor’s contributory fault and the parties’, especially the debtor’s, economic situation; it holds that the power to reduce is a matter of public order, that the debtor cannot waive it in advance and that the court cannot, as a rule, eliminate the penalty entirely. The last point shows the ineffectiveness of clauses, common in contracts, by which “the artist accepts that the penalty is not excessive and will not seek reduction”.

In artist contracts the extent of reduction depends on the gravity of the breach. The Court of Cassation upheld a ninety-per-cent reduction of a penalty of USD 2,100,000 imposed on an artist who breached a one-year post-term exclusivity by releasing an album sixteen days early. In another case, a reduction was upheld taking into account that the manager had not found work for the artist, that the artist had found work without first sending a warning, that both parties were at fault and that the creditor was a merchant (both decisions below).

The merchant debtor: Commercial Code art. 22 and the economic-ruin exception

A debtor who is a merchant cannot ask the court to reduce a contractual penalty on the ground that it is excessive. The Assembly of Civil Chambers sees this rule as a reflection of the merchant’s duty to act as a prudent businessperson (Commercial Code art. 18/2).

Statutory Provision — Turkish Commercial Code (Law No. 6102) art. 22 (Reduction of fees and contractual penalties) (unofficial translation)

“(1) A debtor who is a merchant may not ask the court to reduce a fee or contractual penalty on the ground that an excessive fee or penalty has been agreed, in the cases set out in article 121(2), article 182(3) and article 525 of the Turkish Code of Obligations.”

The Assembly holds that absolute application of the prohibition would produce inequitable results, and that where performance of a penalty agreed against a merchant debtor is likely to cause the debtor’s economic ruin, the penalty must be regarded as contrary to morality and held partly void. The assessment follows the average view of right-thinking, reasonable people, not the subjective view of the parties; having to cut expenses is not enough, and the question is whether the merchant could continue in business if the penalty were paid. In the case before it, the penalty amounted to about twelve per cent of the debtor company’s equity and was held not to cause economic ruin. The decision concerns the period of the former Code of Obligations No. 818 and Commercial Code No. 6762, but since Code of Obligations art. 27 and Commercial Code art. 22 retain the same structure, its principles remain instructive.

Whether the artist is a merchant therefore matters. A person who operates a commercial enterprise, even partly, in their own name is a merchant (Commercial Code art. 12); a commercial enterprise is one in which activities aimed at income above the threshold for a tradesman’s business are carried on continuously and independently (Commercial Code art. 11). Personal artistic performance does not in itself mean operating a commercial enterprise; but where the artist acts through a company of their own and the company signs the contract, the debtor is a merchant as a commercial company (Commercial Code art. 16). Production companies are merchants. This should be considered when deciding whether to contract in the artist’s own name or through the artist’s company.

One-sided penalties binding only the artist

The Code expressly invalidates one-sided penalties only in service contracts: a penalty clause in a service contract binding only the worker is invalid (Code of Obligations art. 420/1). If the relationship between artist and producer is a service contract, this applies directly. In other contracts one-sidedness is not in itself a ground of invalidity, but it is assessed under the principle of good faith (Civil Code art. 2), the content review of standard terms (Code of Obligations art. 25) and Code of Obligations art. 27. In a first-instance judgment upheld by the Court of Cassation, the court found that in a contract with reciprocal obligations a penalty securing performance is possible only if arranged in favour of both parties with regard to balance, that the producer had been given the right to terminate at will while a disproportionate and unfair penalty was imposed on the artist, and rejected the one-sided penalty claim (11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/4318, K. 2025/2915).

Penalty, Withdrawal Penalty and Forfeit Money Distinguished

Labels in the contract are not decisive; the function of the performance is. A penalty attaches to a breach and is reduced if excessive. A withdrawal penalty gives the debtor the power to leave the contract by paying; no breach is required, and the creditor can no longer demand the main performance (Code of Obligations art. 179/3). Forfeit money entitles each party to withdraw: the payer who withdraws loses it, the recipient who withdraws returns double (Code of Obligations art. 178). Money given on conclusion of the contract is presumed to be earnest money and is deducted from the main claim (Code of Obligations art. 177). The clause often seen in producer agreements that “on termination, advances paid to the artist and costs incurred will not be refunded” is also subject to the penalty rules: the provisions on penalties apply to contracts providing that, on withdrawal, the part performed is retained by the creditor (Code of Obligations art. 181), so the review for excessiveness applies to such clauses too.

Defences Against a Penalty Claim

An artist (or producer) facing a penalty claim can attack every link in its legal basis:

  1. Invalidity of the main obligation or term. An assignment term contrary to Law No. 5846 art. 52, handcuff terms void under Code of Obligations art. 27, or a contract vitiated by exploitation also defeat the penalty claim (Code of Obligations art. 182/2).
  2. No breach, or the creditor’s own breach. In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, the producer who failed to prepare the third album was held to be the party in breach and at fault, the artist’s termination was justified and the producer could not claim the penalty.
  3. Termination for just cause. If termination was justified, a penalty attached to “wrongful termination” does not arise. Justification must be proven by concrete evidence.
  4. Non-responsibility. Unless otherwise agreed, no penalty is due for an obligation that later became impossible for a reason for which the debtor is not responsible; illness or force majeure is assessed here.
  5. No reservation. Under a cumulative penalty, accepting late performance without reservation extinguishes the right to the penalty.
  6. Reduction for excessiveness. The court reduces of its own motion; a merchant debtor cannot seek reduction, but partial invalidity for immorality may be argued in case of economic ruin.
  7. Abuse of rights. The legal order does not protect the manifest abuse of a right (Civil Code art. 2). The defence is construed narrowly, however: a first-instance judgment rejecting under Civil Code art. 2 the penalty claim of a manager who had found no work for the artist was reversed by the Court of Cassation, and the case ended with a reduced penalty. It is safer to build the defence on concrete facts together with reduction under Code of Obligations art. 182/3.

Proof, Limitation, Competent Court and Mediation

Proof. The party claiming the penalty proves a valid penalty clause and the breach; it need not prove loss (Code of Obligations art. 180). Where an obligation is not performed or improperly performed, the debtor is liable unless it proves that no fault is attributable to it (Code of Obligations art. 112). The burden of proving the reservation lies on the creditor. For reduction, the real extent of the loss, the duration and gravity of the breach, the parties’ economic situation and, for a merchant debtor, the financial statements (share capital and equity in the Assembly decision) are established by expert examination. Sales and streaming data, platform reports and industry expert reports are decisive in these cases.

Limitation. A penalty is ancillary to the main claim; when the main claim is time-barred, interest and other ancillary claims are also time-barred (Code of Obligations art. 152). The general period for contractual claims is ten years (Code of Obligations art. 146); some claims, such as periodic payments and claims under a mandate, are subject to five years (Code of Obligations art. 147/1, Code of Obligations art. 147/5). The applicable period should be determined by the nature of the main performance to which the penalty is attached.

Competent court and mediation. Since album and recording agreements rest on FSEK rights, these disputes are heard by the intellectual and industrial property civil court (Law No. 5846 art. 76); the first-instance courts in the decisions below were such courts. Actions arising from intellectual property legislation are commercial cases whether or not the parties are merchants (Commercial Code art. 4/1), and in commercial cases for a sum of money pre-action mediation is a prerequisite (Commercial Code art. 5/A). Competence and mediation are discussed in more detail in the first article of this series.

Court of Cassation Decisions

Criteria for reducing excessive penalties; the economic-ruin exception for merchant debtors

Court of Cassation Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2024/108, K. 2024/596, 27.11.2024 (reasoning of the Assembly reversing the insistence decision; concerns the period of former Laws No. 818 and No. 6762)

“When examining whether the penalty is excessive and exceeds the bounds of equity, the court takes into account in particular the loss suffered by the creditor as a result of the breach, the debtor’s degree of fault, the creditor’s contributory fault and the economic situation of the parties (especially the debtor). … The possibility of reducing an excessive penalty is a rule of public order aimed at preventing exploitation of a debtor in a weak position. … if performance of a penalty agreed against a merchant debtor is likely to lead to the debtor’s economic ruin, that penalty must as a rule be regarded as contrary to morality and good manners.” (translation)

A short breach of post-term exclusivity: the penalty may be reduced by ninety per cent

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2010/7984, K. 2012/9177, 29.05.2012 (upheld finding: reasoning of the first-instance court; period of former Law No. 818)

“that a balance not encouraging breach of contract and consistent with equity had to be struck between the loss the claimant would suffer in album sales over the 16-day period and the penalty, and that by reducing the penalty by 90% it was set at USD 210,000, corresponding to 10% of the penalty provided for in the contract” (translation)

Mutual fault and the creditor’s status as merchant are taken into account in reducing the penalty

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/587, K. 2023/7110, 06.12.2023 (upheld finding: reasoning of the first-instance court following the reversal; management and booking agreement)

“that, having regard to the claimant not having properly found work for the defendant within its management services, the defendant having found work by their own means without sending the claimant a warning to perform, both parties therefore being at fault, the claimant being a merchant, and the economic situation of the parties as reflected in the file, the penalty had to be reduced at the court’s discretion” (translation)

A producer who made no album preparations is at fault; the artist’s termination is justified and the producer cannot claim the penalty

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2016/3931, K. 2017/6079, 13.11.2017 (upheld finding: reasoning of the first-instance court; album production agreement)

“that the claimant, who had to take action for the production of the third album, prevented the album productions by failing to act, so that the party in breach of contract was the claimant, that the defendant’s termination of the contract was therefore justified, and that since the claimant was the party in breach and at fault it could not claim a penalty under the contract either” (translation)

An assignment term contrary to Law No. 5846 art. 52 is invalid; the penalty attached to it cannot be claimed

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/2257, K. 2022/6539, 03.10.2022 (upheld finding: reasoning of the first-instance court, affirmed on appeal and cassation; architectural project contract)

“that since the term was not made in writing under article 52 of FSEK and the rights were not expressly specified one by one, these terms of the contract were invalid, and that the claim for the penalty provided for in article 8 of the contract was unfounded” (translation)

Clauses to Negotiate

The clauses that matter most to both artist and producer in negotiating a producer agreement are listed below. For time-limited assignments, the following FSEK provision on reversion of rights is the starting point:

Statutory Provision — Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works (Law No. 5846) art. 59 (Reversion of rights to the author) (unofficial translation)

“If the author or the author’s heirs have assigned an economic right for a specific purpose or for a specific period, the right reverts to its owner when the purpose ceases or the period expires.”

  1. Listing the rights. The rights transferred (reproduction, distribution, communication to the public and making available online, adaptation, performance), media, territory and term should be stated separately; rights not passing to the producer (e.g. authorising use of the work in films and series) should be expressly reserved.
  2. Reversion of master rights. An author who assigns an economic right for a set period recovers it automatically when the period expires (Law No. 5846 art. 59). For recordings, the contract may provide that at the end of the term the masters, registration certificates and visual materials pass to the artist by notarial transfer; a contract examined in appellate case law followed this model (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/621, K. 2021/1652).
  3. Term and producer obligations. A recording, release and promotion schedule for each album or single, a minimum promotion budget and the artist’s right to terminate if these obligations are breached should be set out.
  4. Revenue sharing, recoupment and reporting. The definition of net income, recoupable cost items and a cap, the reporting period, sharing of platform reports and the artist’s right to inspect the accounts through an independent auditor should be written in.
  5. Collecting society income. It should be stated expressly whether the artist’s performer shares from collecting societies and author income stay outside the agreement.
  6. Termination and penalties. Grounds for termination and the requirement to grant a period first should be symmetrical; the penalty should not bind only the artist, should be graduated by type of breach and based on a realistic estimate of loss. If a cumulative penalty for late delivery is agreed, the reservation procedure should be written in.
  7. Assignment, catalogue sale and sub-licensing. The producer’s power to assign or sub-license should be subject to conditions, bearing in mind the author’s written consent requirement (Law No. 5846 art. 49).
  8. Name, trade mark and social media accounts. Ownership of the stage name, trade mark registration and social media accounts, and what happens to them when the contract ends, should be regulated separately; see our article on trademark infringement for the general framework.

Frequently Asked Questions

We agreed orally with the producer; have my rights in the recordings passed to the producer?

Contracts and dispositions concerning economic rights must be in writing and specify each right separately (Law No. 5846 art. 52); a performer’s permissions must also be in writing. An oral agreement, or a general text not listing the rights individually, may not transfer the rights not listed.

Can the producer claim the penalty without proving loss?

Yes. A valid penalty may be claimed even if the creditor suffered no loss (Code of Obligations art. 180). But if the main obligation is invalid, or became impossible for a reason for which the debtor is not responsible, the penalty cannot be claimed, and the court reduces an excessive penalty of its own motion.

The contract says “I accept that the penalty is not excessive”; is reduction still possible?

Yes. The Assembly of Civil Chambers holds that the possibility of reducing an excessive penalty is a matter of public order and cannot be waived in advance. If the debtor is not a merchant, the court reduces an excessive penalty of its own motion.

Is an artist a merchant; can the artist seek reduction?

Personal artistic performance does not in itself mean operating a commercial enterprise; in that case the artist benefits from reduction. If the artist’s company signed the contract, the debtor is a merchant and cannot seek reduction under Commercial Code art. 22; even then, if the penalty would cause the company’s economic ruin, it may be held partly void for immorality.

Album delivery was late but the producer accepted the recording; can it claim the penalty later?

Under a penalty for late performance (cumulative penalty), a producer who accepted performance without reservation cannot claim the penalty (Code of Obligations art. 179/2). The reservation must be made expressly at the time of performance; the result may differ if the contract provides that no reservation is needed or the right was reserved by an earlier warning.

The producer made no album and I terminated; can it claim the penalty from me?

In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, a producer who took no steps to prepare the album was held to be the party in breach and at fault, the artist’s termination was justified and the producer could not claim the penalty. Keeping correspondence and warnings showing the justification for termination is important.

Disputes arising from agreements between singers, producers and distributors fall within our Commercial and Corporate Law practice area.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Singer and Producer Agreements in Türkiye: Validity and Penalty Clauses (Law No. 5846 Arts. 52, 80; TBK)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-10-25, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/singer-producer-agreements

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›