Last reviewed:
Brokerage (Commission) Claims: The Brokerage Contract, Real Estate Commission and Penalty Clauses
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, a broker (tellal) earns a fee only if the contract he brokered is concluded as a result of his activity (TCO art. 521); it is enough that the main contract is validly concluded, and it need not be performed. A brokerage contract concerning immovables is not valid unless made in written form (TCO art. 520/3), and it must bear the signature of the party undertaking the obligation; e-mail correspondence does not replace a signed contract. The Court of Cassation treats a signed property-viewing form as a written brokerage contract and holds a buyer who bypasses the agent liable for the penalty agreed in the form. If the fee has not been agreed, it is paid according to the tariff or, failing a tariff, according to custom (TCO art. 522); an excessive fee may be reduced by the court at the debtor’s request (TCO art. 525), but a merchant cannot, as a rule, argue that a penalty clause is excessive. Claims arising from a brokerage contract are subject to a five-year limitation period, whereas the commercial brokerage fee claim is excluded from that rule and is therefore subject to the general ten-year period (TCO art. 147/5, TCO art. 146).
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
The brokerage contract and the written-form requirement in real estate brokerage (TCO art. 520), conditions for earning the commission and causation (art. 521), determination (art. 522) and reduction (art. 525) of the fee, loss of the fee (art. 523), property-viewing forms and the 6% penalty clause, suspensive conditions in commercial brokerage and limitation periods (art. 147/5) — with verified decisions of the 3rd and 11th Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.
A guide to brokerage (commission) claims under Turkish law: the definition and legal nature of the brokerage contract (TCO art. 520), the written-form requirement for real estate brokerage, the conditions for earning the commission and the causation requirement (art. 521), determination of the fee by tariff and custom (art. 522), judicial reduction of excessive fees (art. 525), loss of the broker's fee (art. 523), property-viewing forms and penalty clauses, and limitation periods (art. 147/5) — with verified decisions of the 3rd and 11th Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.
What Is a Brokerage Contract?
Known in practice as commission agency or tellallık, brokerage (simsarlık) is the contract under which an intermediary who brings together parties wishing to contract earns a fee if the contract they brokered is concluded. Typical examples are the real estate agent introducing buyer and seller, intermediation in the transfer of a business or of company shares, and bringing landowners and a contractor together for a construction contract in return for flats.
“A brokerage contract is a contract under which the broker undertakes to prepare the opportunity for the conclusion of a contract between the parties or to act as intermediary in its conclusion, and earns a fee if that contract is concluded. The provisions on mandate apply to brokerage contracts as a rule. A brokerage contract concerning immovables is not valid unless made in written form.”
The rules of mandate apply as a rule; the broker must act in the client's interest and in good faith. The 3rd Civil Chamber recently summarised the institution as follows: parties wishing to contract often have difficulty finding each other, and the intermediary called a broker (tellal) is used to remove that difficulty, to bring the parties together and to prepare a suitable environment for the conclusion of the contract (3rd Civil Chamber, 18.11.2025, E. 2025/1395, K. 2025/5433).
Written Form in Real Estate Brokerage
Under TCO art. 520/3, a brokerage contract concerning immovables (real estate agency) is invalid unless made in writing; the written form is a condition of validity, not merely of proof. Ordinary written form suffices, but the document must bear the signature of the party undertaking the obligation; e-mail exchanges do not replace a signed contract. The requirement applies only to real estate brokerage: brokerage of company share transfers is not subject to form, although the brokerage relationship and the intermediary activity must still be proven (3rd Civil Chamber decision 2025/3079 below). Where an authorisation (listing) document is limited in time, no fee can be claimed for a sale concluded after its expiry absent a valid new contract (3rd Civil Chamber decision 2025/118 below).
Conditions for Earning the Commission
The broker is, as a rule, paid on success: the main contract must be concluded, and its conclusion must be the result of the broker's activity.
“The broker earns the fee only if a contract is concluded as a result of their activity. Where the contract concluded as a result of the broker's activity is subject to a suspensive condition, the fee is payable upon fulfilment of the condition. Where the brokerage contract provides that the broker's expenses shall be reimbursed, the expenses are payable even if the broker's activity does not result in the conclusion of a contract.”
The Court of Cassation lists the conditions as follows: (a) the main contract brokered must be concluded between the client and the third party — its valid conclusion is necessary and sufficient, and its performance is not required for the fee to accrue; (b) there must be a causal relationship between the broker's activity and the conclusion of the main contract; and (c) none of the circumstances under art. 523 causing loss of the fee must have occurred (3rd Civil Chamber, 18.11.2025, E. 2025/1395, K. 2025/5433). Thus if the sale contract was validly concluded, the commission accrues even if the price is never paid. Where the main contract is subject to a suspensive condition (e.g. finalisation of a zoning amendment), no fee can be claimed before the condition is fulfilled (11th Civil Chamber decision 2024/1707 below). Art. 521/1 is not mandatory law; the parties may agree otherwise.
Property-Viewing Forms and Penalty Clauses
The familiar tool of real estate practice is the property-viewing (“I have seen”) form: the prospective buyer acknowledges having viewed the property through the agent and undertakes to pay a penalty at a given rate if they bypass the agent and purchase directly. The Court of Cassation treats the signed viewing form as a written brokerage contract and holds the bypassing buyer liable under the alternative penalty clause; in its decision of 18.11.2025 it held that a contractor who viewed the land through the agent and then directly concluded a construction-for-flats contract with the owners must pay a 6% penalty on the contract value, that the agent need not also be authorised by the landowners, and that the debtor, being a merchant, cannot plead that the penalty is excessive (3rd Civil Chamber 2025/5433; full quotation below).
Determination and Reduction of the Fee
“If not agreed, the fee is paid according to the tariff; in the absence of a tariff, according to custom.”
“Where an excessive fee has been agreed in the contract, the judge may, upon the debtor's request, reduce it equitably.”
Where no rate or amount is agreed, the fee is determined by tariff or, failing that, local custom. An excessive fee may be reduced by the judge on the debtor's request (art. 525); a merchant, however, bound to act as a prudent businessperson, cannot as a rule plead that a penalty clause is excessive.
Loss of the Broker's Fee
“If the broker, contrary to their obligation, acts in the interest of the other party, or, contrary to the rules of good faith, obtains a promise of a fee from the other party, they forfeit their rights to the fee and to their expenses.”
The broker owes loyalty to the client: acting in the counterparty's interest or taking a fee promise from the counterparty in bad faith forfeits both fee and expenses. A fee arising from marriage brokerage cannot be sued for or enforced at all (TCO art. 524).
Competent Court
The competent court depends on the nature of the dispute: where both parties are merchants and the matter concerns their commercial enterprises, the commercial court of first instance has jurisdiction; otherwise the civil court of first instance. Venue lies, under the general rule, at the defendant's domicile; the place of performance may also ground venue. Where the claim was pursued by enforcement proceedings and met with objection, the action for annulment of the objection follows the same rules; if the claim is not liquid, no enforcement-denial compensation can be awarded (11th Civil Chamber decision 2024/1707 below).
Limitation Periods
“A five-year limitation period applies to the following claims: (…) 5. Claims arising from mandate, commission and agency contracts and, except for the commercial brokerage fee claim, from brokerage contracts.”
Claims arising from brokerage contracts are, as a rule, subject to a five-year limitation period. The commercial brokerage fee is excluded and is therefore subject to the general ten-year period (TCO art. 146). Time runs from the date the fee claim falls due — as a rule, the conclusion of the main contract (or fulfilment of the condition in conditional transactions).
Court of Cassation Decisions
Conditions of the fee, viewing forms and penalty clauses
“Under articles 521 et seq. of the same Code, the following conditions must be fulfilled together for the broker's fee claim to arise: a) the main contract brokered must be concluded between the client (principal) and the third party (…) b) there must be a causal relationship between the conclusion of the main contract and the broker's activity (…) c) none of the circumstances regulated in article 523, resulting in the loss of the broker's claim to fee and expenses, must have occurred.” On the facts: “the claimant performed the brokerage function in the land being made the subject of the contract; the signature on the contract belongs to the defendant; since an alternative penalty was agreed, the claimant is entitled only to the penalty of 6% of the contract value; (…) authorisation of the claimant by the landowners is not required for this; and the defendant, being a merchant engaged in construction, cannot plead that the penalty is excessive.” (translation)
Written form in real estate brokerage; freedom of form and proof in share transfers
The regional court reasoning upheld by the Court: “since the subject of the action concerns a share transfer, the written-form requirement of art. 520/3 TCO concerning real estate brokerage contracts has no application in the present case; as the defendant did not accept the e-mails in question, they cannot constitute evidence against the defendants; and in any event the content of the e-mails relied on is not capable of proving that the share transfer was concluded as a result of the claimant's activity.” The Chamber upheld the judgment “as it was understood that the establishment of the brokerage relationship could not be proven by the claimant on the case file.” (translation)
Expiry of the listing authorisation and the signature requirement
“In view of the reasoning stated in the judgment under review and in particular the absence of a valid contract between the parties after the expiry date of the letter of intent, and, as regards the mandate relationship, the failure to prove by proper evidence that the intermediary activity for the sale of the property was performed by the claimant, the claimant's grounds of appeal are rejected and the judgment, being in accordance with procedure and law, is upheld.” The upheld reasoning also stressed that in contracts subject to written form the signatures of those undertaking obligations are mandatory (TCO art. 14). (translation)
Suspensive conditions and non-liquid claims in commercial brokerage
The regional court reasoning upheld by the Court: “as at the date of the enforcement proceedings, the suspensive condition in the contract concerning the zoning amendment had not been fulfilled”; “for the claimants to be entitled to the commission, the gross area of the plots assembled under the contract had to reach 1,000 m2 by the date of the proceedings”; “since the claim is not liquid, enforcement-denial compensation cannot be awarded.” (translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
When does a real estate agent earn the commission?
Three conditions must coexist: a valid brokerage contract (written, for real estate); conclusion of the main contract (sale, lease etc.); and causation between the broker's activity and that conclusion. Performance of the main contract is not required; its valid conclusion suffices.
Can a commission be claimed on an oral agreement?
No. A brokerage contract concerning immovables is invalid unless made in writing (TCO art. 520/3); written form is a condition of validity and the document must bear the obligor's signature. E-mail exchanges do not replace a signed contract. Non-real-estate brokerage (e.g. share transfers) is free of form, but the relationship and the activity must be proven.
The buyer viewed the property with the agent but bought directly from the owner; is commission payable?
Yes, if a signed viewing form exists. The Court of Cassation holds the bypassing buyer liable under the agreed alternative penalty clause (6% in the cited decision), without requiring the agent to be separately authorised by the owner, and a merchant debtor cannot plead that the penalty is excessive.
How is the fee determined if no rate was agreed?
By tariff and, failing that, by custom (TCO art. 522). An excessive agreed fee may be reduced equitably by the judge on the debtor's request (TCO art. 525).
If the sale falls through, can the agent claim a fee or expenses?
As a rule, no fee: the broker earns the fee only if a contract is concluded as a result of their activity. If reimbursement of expenses was agreed, expenses are payable even without conclusion (TCO art. 521/3). Art. 521/1 is not mandatory and may be contracted around.
What is the limitation period for commission claims?
Five years for claims arising from brokerage contracts (TCO art. 147/5); the commercial brokerage fee is excluded and is subject to the general ten-year period (TCO art. 146).
May the agent take commission from both sides?
A broker who, contrary to their obligation, acts in the counterparty's interest or takes a fee promise from the counterparty in bad faith forfeits both fee and expenses (TCO art. 523). Transparent, impartial dual intermediation with both parties' knowledge and consent falls outside this rule.
Contract and commercial receivable disputes fall within our firm's Commercial and Company Law practice area.
- The Legal Effect of an Invoice in Commercial Matters: The Eight-Day Objection, Commercial Books and the Delivery Note
- Action for Annulment of Objection under Turkish Law: Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 67
- Negative-Declaratory and Recovery Actions: Declaring Non-Liability and Recovering Money Paid
- Agency (Mandate) Contract and Revocation of Authority
Related Articles
- The Legal Effect of an Invoice in Commercial Matters: The Eight-Day Objection, Commercial Books and the Delivery Note
- Action for Annulment of Objection (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 67)
- Negative-Declaratory and Recovery Actions: Declaring Non-Liability and Recovering Money Paid
- Agency (Mandate) Contract and Revocation of Authority
- Travel Agency Status and Receivables in Turkish Law: Operating Licence, Allotment Contracts with Hotels, Commission, Interest and Limitation
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Commercial law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law
- When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye
- Appeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative Court
- Which Court Hears Commercial and Consumer Cases in Türkiye: Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya
- Arbitration Clauses under Turkish Law: Validity, the Arbitration Objection and Lawsuits Filed in Court
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Brokerage (Commission) Claims: The Brokerage Contract, Real Estate Commission and Penalty Clauses”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/brokerage-claims

























