Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 9 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Uncertificated Shares Need Written Assignment: Ankara Regional Court of Appeal Voids a Board Transfer

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the 21st Civil Chamber of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal, registered shares not embodied in a certificate (“bare” shares) are transferred under the rules on assignment of claims and in written form (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 184). The Chamber held void a transfer made by a resolution signed only by the chairman of the board, without the shareholder’s signature or any document of authority, together with the later transfers based on it, and ordered the shares to be entered in the share register in the shareholder’s name. As there was no document showing that the transfer had been ratified or accepted, bringing the action almost eight years later was not treated as an abuse of rights. This appellate (istinaf) decision was upheld with final effect by the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, without separate reasoning.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, according to the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal decision upheld by the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, uncertificated (bare) registered shares are transferred under the rules on assignment of claims and in writing (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 184); a transfer made by a board resolution signed only by the chairman, without the shareholder’s signature or authority, and the later transfers based on it are void. As there was no document showing that the transfer had been ratified or accepted, the Chamber did not treat bringing the action almost eight years later as an abuse of rights.

A Turkish appellate (istinaf) decision, upheld by the Court of Cassation, on the transfer of registered shares for which no share certificate has been printed, made without the shareholder’s written assignment and by a board resolution not bearing the shareholder’s signature (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 184).

The Dispute

One of the defendants is a joint-stock company with two shareholders, formed in 2013 by the conversion of a limited company. Of its 200,000 shares, 199,975 belonged to the claimant and 25 to her husband, the chairman of the board; the Chamber accepted that the shares were not embodied in a certificate (bare shares).

By a board resolution dated December 2013 and bearing only the husband’s signature, the claimant’s shares were shown as transferred to her two sons. The husband died at the beginning of 2014; in the same year one of the sons transferred his shares to the defendant son by a document headed “Share Transfer Agreement”, and the defendant became the company’s sole shareholder.

In 2021 the claimant sought a declaration that the transfers were invalid, registration of the shares in her name and payment of dividends. The first-instance court dismissed the action, relying on almost eight years of silence, trade registry announcements and art. 2 of the Turkish Civil Code. The claimant appealed (istinaf), arguing that there was no written transfer agreement.

Outcome of the Decision

On 19.06.2025 the Chamber allowed the appeal, set aside the first-instance judgment and partly allowed the action: it declared invalid the board resolution and the transfers made in 2014 on the basis of it, and ordered the cancellation of 199,975 of the shares registered in the defendant’s name and their entry in the share register in the claimant’s name. The claim for dividends was dismissed; according to the Chamber, a profit distribution resolution of a general meeting held in the claimant’s absence would also be void, so there was no dividend that could be claimed. The decision was unanimous.

On the defendants’ appeal, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation found the decision lawful and upheld it (11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/4503, K. 2026/1270, 04.03.2026). The upholding decision was given unanimously and is final; as the Court of Cassation wrote no separate reasoning, the reasoning set out below is that of the regional court of appeal.

Reasoning

The Chamber first stated that the endorsement rule in art. 490(2) of the Turkish Commercial Code does not prevent transfer by assignment of claims, and that entry in the share register is necessary for the transfer to have effect against the company but is not constitutive. It set the standard for shares not embodied in a certificate as follows:

Regional Court of Appeal Decision

“Although the Turkish Commercial Code contains no provision on the transfer of the bare shares of a joint-stock company, … it has been accepted that this transfer takes place within the framework of the provisions on assignment of claims under Article 183 of Law No. 6098. … As to form, the transfer of a fully paid bare share takes place by handing the transferee a written declaration of assignment stating that the share has been transferred, … under Article 184 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, it is also sufficient that the assignment of the claim be made in writing.” (translation)

In the case at hand there was no written share transfer agreement and no written declaration of assignment handed to the transferees. The husband had adopted the board resolution alone; the claimant’s signature was not on it, and no document or power of attorney showing that he had been authorised had been submitted. According to the Chamber:

Regional Court of Appeal Decision

“… that the law attaches no consequence to the transaction by which the claimant’s shares were transferred without authority on the claimant’s behalf … taking into account that there is no information or document at all in the file showing that the claimant ratified or accepted the invalid share transfer, the claimant’s raising this despite the time that has passed cannot be regarded as an abuse of rights …” (translation)

The conclusion is as follows:

Regional Court of Appeal Decision

“In conclusion, that the written transfer of the 199,975 shares belonging to the claimant, in the form required by law, did not take place; that the transfer made without complying with the form requirement is null and the transaction produces no legal effect, that it is void; … that all subsequent transfers made on the basis of the share transfer mentioned in the null board resolution of 12/12/2013 are also void …” (translation)

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision shows that, in a joint-stock company that has not printed share certificates, neither a board resolution nor an entry in the share register can take the place of the shareholder’s written assignment. In this case, the fact that the person at the end of the chain was entered in the share register and that the company’s single-shareholder status was announced in the trade registry did not change the outcome.

In light of this decision, it is important that the transferee holds a written declaration of assignment or transfer agreement bearing the transferor’s signature and, where a representative makes the transfer, that representative’s document of authority. Whether a document signed by the shareholder would count as an assignment is not the subject of this decision.

Note: This is an appellate (istinaf) decision; the Court of Cassation upheld it without writing its own reasoning. On silence, the Chamber treated the absence of any document showing ratification or acceptance as decisive and did not separately discuss the trade registry announcements; cases with evidence of ratification or acceptance fall outside the scope of this decision. The Chamber’s formula on form refers to a “fully paid” bare share; yet under the articles of association quoted in the decision, the deadline for paying the unpaid capital was 31.01.2014, after the transfer, and the Chamber did not discuss whether the shares were fully paid at the time of transfer. The transfer of shares that are not fully paid is not the subject of this decision. A search, based on the summaries shown in search results, of Court of Cassation decisions given after 19.06.2025 in the official case-law database (for the 11th Civil Chamber, those visible up to 16.09.2026) found no decision departing from this standard.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 184 (Form) (unofficial translation)

“The validity of an assignment of a claim depends on its having been made in written form.

A promise to assign a claim is not subject to any form.”

For Turkish Commercial Code art. 490, the transfer of shares that are not fully paid and the rules on entry in the share register, see the article on the transfer of registered shares; for the general rules, see the article on assignment of claims.

Frequently Asked Questions

How are shares transferred in a joint-stock company that has not printed share certificates?

Under Turkish law, according to this decision, registered shares not embodied in a certificate (bare shares) are transferred under the rules on assignment of claims and in written form (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 184); a fully paid share is transferred by handing the transferee a written declaration of assignment. Shares that are not fully paid were not discussed in this decision.

Can shares be transferred by a board resolution?

Not in this case: the Chamber held void a transfer made by a resolution signed only by the chairman of the board, without the shareholder’s signature or any document of authority. Situations where there is a document signed by the shareholder are not the subject of this decision.

What happens to later transfers based on an invalid transfer?

According to the Chamber, they are also void. In this case the 2014 transfer between the brothers was also held invalid, and the shares were ordered to be entered in the share register in the shareholder’s name.

Can a shareholder who stayed silent for years bring an action later?

In this case, yes: as there was no information or document at all showing that the transfer had been ratified or accepted, the Chamber did not treat bringing the action almost eight years later as an abuse of rights.

Is this decision final?

Yes. It is a decision of a regional court of appeal (istinaf); the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld it on 04.03.2026, unanimously and with final effect, without writing separate reasoning.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Uncertificated Shares Need Written Assignment: Ankara Regional Court of Appeal Voids a Board Transfer”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/uncertificated-shares-transfer-written-assignment-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›