Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Share Ownership Suit Needs Sole Shareholder as a Party: Turkish Court of Cassation on Company-Only Claims

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a share ownership action brought only against a joint-stock company can concern the interests of a non-party. That is the case where, at the date of the action, all of the company’s shares appear to be held by that non-party: the judgment to be given then concerns that person’s interests. The court must give the claimant time to bring a separate action against that person and consolidate the actions; it must then also examine earlier attendance lists and the allegation that the documents notified to the Central Registry Agency were forged, and determine whether the claimant was a shareholder at the date of the action and, if so, in what amount. The regional court of appeal decision upholding the first-instance dismissal given without these steps was reversed unanimously; the file was sent to the first-instance court.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, according to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a share ownership action brought only against a joint-stock company can concern the interests of a non-party. That is the case where, at the date of the action, all of the company’s shares appear to be held by that non-party: the judgment will then concern that person’s interests, so the claimant must be given time to bring a separate action against that person and the actions must be consolidated. The court must then also examine earlier attendance lists and the allegation that the documents notified to the Central Registry Agency were forged, and determine whether the claimant was a shareholder at the date of the action and, if so, in what amount.

A Turkish Court of Cassation reversal decision on the course the court must follow where an action for a declaration of share ownership is brought only against the company while all of the company’s shares appear to be held by a non-party (bearer shares, Turkish Commercial Code art. 489).

The Dispute

The claimant argued that the bearer share certificates representing 87.4% of the defendant joint-stock company’s shares belonged to her and that the rest belonged to the estate of her late husband. According to her, at an extraordinary general meeting held to notify bearer shares to the Central Registry System (MKS), one person had been made the holder of 100% of the company’s shares on the ground that the claimant, whose invitation had been improperly served, had not presented her certificates in time, and the notification to the MKS had been made with forged documents and information. The claimant sought a declaration that the shares belonged to her and to the estate, their announcement in the MKS and their registration in the trade registry; she brought the action only against the company.

The company argued that all of the 55 bearer share certificates printed under a 2008 board resolution were held by the person who was the company’s sole shareholder and had been registered in the MKS. The first-instance court dismissed the action, stating that the claimant’s certificates bore no signature or stamp of the company or its officers, whereas the non-party’s certificates contained the formal elements and were registered in that person’s name at the Central Registry Agency (MKK). Relying on an expert report, the regional court of appeal also dismissed the appeal on the merits.

Outcome of the Decision

On the claimant’s appeal, on 07.09.2026 the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed and set aside the regional court of appeal decision and sent the file to the first-instance court under art. 373(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK). The decision was unanimous. The Chamber did not decide whether the claimant is a shareholder; it required this to be determined through a complete examination.

Reasoning

The Chamber framed the dispute as whether the claimant had disposed of the shares shown in earlier attendance lists and, accordingly, whether she was a shareholder; it then looked at against whom the action had been directed:

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/244, K. 2026/4360, 07.09.2026 (action directed only at the company)

“In the case at hand, the claimant directed this action, for a declaration that, together with the share of her decedent, she holds 100% of the shares in the defendant company, only at the defendant company. However, it is seen that, as of the date of the action, all of the defendant company’s shares were held by the non-party ..., that is, that the said person was the company’s sole shareholder.” (translation)

The Chamber drew the procedural consequence from this:

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/244, K. 2026/4360, 07.09.2026 (time to sue the sole shareholder and consolidation)

“Therefore, taking into account that the judgment to be given at the end of the action will concern the interests of the sole shareholder ..., the claimant should be given time to bring a separate action against ..., and subsequently, after it has been consolidated with the present action …” (translation)

It also set out the scope of the examination after consolidation:

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/244, K. 2026/4360, 07.09.2026 (scope of the examination and ground for reversal)

“… taking into account that in the attendance lists of general meetings for 2022 and earlier years, drawn up by the Board of Directors and submitted to the file, the claimant and her spouse appear as shareholders, that some of them also bear the signature of ... as Chairman of the Board, and that the claimant also alleged that the documents notified by ... to the Central Registry Agency concerning the passing of the shares of the claimant and her decedent to ... were forged, it should have been determined, in a manner open to review and through an examination carried out by a proper assessment covering all these matters, whether the claimant was still a shareholder in the defendant company as of the date of the action and, if so, in what amount, and a decision given accordingly; giving a decision with incomplete examination as written was not correct and required reversal.” (translation)

The Chamber cited no statutory provision for this conclusion and did not use the concept of “standing to be sued” (husumet); it did not call for dismissal but required that the claimant be given time and that the actions be consolidated.

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision gives one answer to the question of against whom an action for a declaration of share ownership is to be brought: where, at the date of the action, all of the company’s shares appear to be held by a non-party, the proceedings should not be concluded against the company alone but heard together with the action to be brought against that person. Situations where the shares appear to be held by more than one person are not the subject of this decision.

For bearer shares, a transfer has effect with respect to the company and third parties only upon the transferee’s notification to the MKK (Turkish Commercial Code art. 489(1)). In this case the claimant had alleged that the documents notified to the MKK concerning the passing of her shares were forged. In light of this decision, it is important to identify, when bringing the action, the person shown as shareholder in the MKK records and the company’s records.

A week later the same Chamber, without writing separate reasoning, upheld a regional court of appeal decision in an action for a declaration of share ownership based on a document not bearing the signatures of the company’s officers; that decision had set aside the first-instance dismissal for lack of standing to sue and dismissed the action on the merits (11th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/954, K. 2026/4571, 14.09.2026). There, the regional court of appeal treated whether the claimant was a shareholder as a question going to the merits of the action.

Note: This is a reversal decision. The Chamber expressed no view on the validity of the certificates, the call to the general meeting or the lawfulness of the MKS notification. A search, based on the summaries shown in search results, of Court of Cassation decisions given after 07.09.2026 in the official case-law database (for the 11th Civil Chamber and the Assembly of Civil Chambers, those visible up to 16.09.2026) found no decision departing from this standard.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Turkish Commercial Code (Law No. 6102) art. 489 (Transfer of bearer share certificates) (unofficial translation)

“(1) The transfer of bearer share certificates has effect with respect to the company and third parties only upon the notification to be made to the Central Registry Agency by the person acquiring the share through the transfer of possession. If no notification is made to the Central Registry Agency, holders of bearer share certificates cannot exercise their share-related rights arising from this Code until the required notification is made.

(2) The date of the notification made to the Central Registry Agency is taken as the basis for asserting the rights attached to a bearer share certificate against the company and third parties.”

The article was amended by Law No. 7262 in 2020. For registered shares, see the article on the transfer of registered shares; for shares not embodied in a certificate, see the note on the transfer of uncertificated shares.

Frequently Asked Questions

Against whom is an action for a declaration of share ownership brought?

In the case behind this decision, the action had been brought only against the company and, at the date of the action, all of the company’s shares appeared to be held by a non-party. According to the Chamber, since the judgment will concern that person’s interests, the claimant must be given time to bring a separate action against that person and the actions must be consolidated.

If the sole shareholder is not a party, is the action dismissed?

In this decision the Chamber did not call for dismissal; it required that the claimant be given time and that the actions be consolidated, and the decision given without these steps was reversed for incomplete examination.

What must the court examine after the actions are consolidated?

According to the Chamber, taking into account the attendance lists for 2022 and earlier years and the allegation that the documents notified to the Central Registry Agency were forged, the court must determine, in a manner open to review, whether the claimant was still a shareholder at the date of the action and, if so, in what amount.

Did this decision treat the claimant as a shareholder?

No. It is a reversal decision; the file was sent to the first-instance court, and whether the claimant is a shareholder was left to the examination to be carried out.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Share Ownership Suit Needs Sole Shareholder as a Party: Turkish Court of Cassation on Company-Only Claims”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/share-ownership-action-sole-shareholder-party-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›