Last reviewed:
Third-Party Ownership Claims in Turkish Enforcement: EBL Arts. 96-99, Burden of Proof, Seven-Day Period
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: If your property is attached for someone else’s debt, you must tell the enforcement office that it is yours within seven days of learning of the attachment (the ownership claim). If the creditor or debtor objects, you bring an ownership action before the enforcement court within seven days of that court’s decision; if the property was in your sole possession when attached, the burden of suing passes to the creditor. If the property was attached at the debtor’s home or business, the law presumes it is the debtor’s; that presumption can be rebutted only with strong evidence such as payment records and commercial books.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Third-party ownership claims over attached property, first in plain language with everyday examples (a son's motorcycle at the family home, a spouse's jewellery, a leased machine, another company at the same address) and then in technical detail: EBL arts. 96, 97, 97/a and 99; step-by-step guidance and a table of time limits for the third party and the creditor; exempt household goods (EBL art. 82); leased assets; the presumption of ownership, burden of proof, organic connection and simulation; the seven-day preclusive period; stay of proceedings and security; damages of 20% and 15%; court fees, venue and appeals; claims in bankruptcy (EBL art. 228). With verified decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers and the 12th and 8th Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.
Third-party ownership claims in Turkish enforcement proceedings (istihkak; EBL arts. 96, 97, 97/a and 99): first a plain-language guide with everyday examples, then the presumption of ownership arising from possession and the allocation of the burden of proof; attachment in the debtor’s hands, in joint possession and in the sole possession of a third party; exempt household goods; leased assets; organic connection, simulation and veil-piercing; the seven-day preclusive period; stay of proceedings and security; damages of 20% and 15%; court fees, the competent court and appellate review; third-party claims in bankruptcy (EBL art. 228); decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers and the 12th and 8th Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.
In Plain Language: The Ownership Action Step by Step
İstihkak means “entitlement”. When your property is attached (set aside by the enforcement officer for sale) for someone else’s debt, stepping forward to say “this is not the debtor’s, it is mine” is the ownership claim; arguing that claim in court is the ownership action.
Everyday examples
- A child living in the same home: the motorcycle outside the house is attached for the father’s debt but belongs to the son. In jointly inhabited premises the law deems the property to be in the debtor’s hands; the son must prove otherwise with strong documents.
- A spouse’s jewellery: gold bracelets attached at the debtor’s home belong to his wife. In jointly inhabited premises, items whose belonging to a woman, man or child is plain from their nature are presumed to be that person’s; the burden then lies on whoever claims otherwise.
- A leased machine: a machine at the business premises is leased by the debtor company from a leasing company. The law specifically requires the enforcement officer to exclude leased assets from enforcement proceedings against the lessee.
- Another company at the same address: machines of a different company operating at the debtor’s former address are attached. If no current documents of the debtor are found and the address is the third party’s registered address, the presumption favours the third party and the burden is on the creditor.
The television example: check exemption first
In the example “the television attached at the debtor’s home actually belongs to his daughter”, an ownership claim is often unnecessary, because household goods are as a rule exempt:
“The following may not be attached: … 3. Except for valuables such as money, securities, gold, silver, precious stones, antiques or ornaments, the personal belongings of the debtor and of family members living under the same roof and all household goods serving the common use of the family,”
If such an item is attached, the remedy is a complaint to the enforcement court, as a rule within seven days of learning of it (EBL art. 16). The ownership claim concerns attachable property belonging to someone else, such as valuables, vehicles, commercial goods or machinery.
The time limits in one table
| Who | Does what | Period and start | If missed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Owner (third party) or debtor | Tells the enforcement office the property belongs to the third party | 7 days from learning of the attachment (EBL art. 96) | The claim can no longer be raised in the same proceedings |
| Creditor and debtor | State whether they object to the claim | 3 days from the office’s notice (EBL art. 96) | Silence counts as acceptance |
| Third party (property in the debtor’s hands) | Brings the ownership action before the enforcement court | 7 days from pronouncement or service of the decision on continuation or stay (EBL art. 97) | Deemed to have abandoned the claim |
| Third party not given the chance to claim | Sues directly | 7 days from learning of the attachment (EBL art. 97) | Loss of the right in the same proceedings |
| Creditor (property in the sole possession of a third party) | Brings the action before the enforcement court | 7 days granted by the enforcement director (EBL art. 99) | The third party’s claim is deemed accepted |
| Third party (in bankruptcy) | Brings the action before the enforcement court | 7 days set by the bankruptcy administration (EBL art. 228) | Deemed to have abandoned the claim against the estate |
The first seven-day period is for notifying the claim; a third party may also raise the claim by suing directly before the enforcement court, and if the statutory procedure was not operated following the claim, the action is in time (Court of Cassation 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/11189, K. 2023/1488, 08.03.2023).
Step by step for the third party (owner)
- As soon as you learn of the attachment, and within seven days at the latest, tell the enforcement office the property is yours; if possible have it recorded at the attachment. The claim must be made by you or someone authorised to represent you.
- If you want the property to stay where it is, accept custodianship (having it left with you for safekeeping).
- Collect a dated invoice and payment trail (transfer, cheque), the entry in commercial books, the serial number, registration and documents explaining why the property was with the debtor.
- If there is an objection, the file goes to the enforcement court. Bring the ownership action within seven days of learning of the court’s decision (pronouncement or service); if you want the sale stayed, be ready to provide security.
- Pay the court fee on the lower of the value of the attached property and the principal debt in the enforcement proceedings.
- If you lose, appeal within two weeks of service; if you appeal, you may ask the enforcement office for a respite (EBL art. 97/14).
Step by step for the creditor
- Have the report record whose hands the property was in, any documents and signs of the debtor and whether the debtor was present.
- Object within three days when notified of an ownership claim; silence counts as acceptance.
- If the property was attached in the sole possession of a third party, bring the action yourself within the seven days granted by the enforcement director.
- If you suspect simulation or an organic connection, collect trade registry, shareholding and address records; if necessary, counter the ownership action with an action for annulment of dispositions (EBL art. 97/17).
- If the action is dismissed and the proceedings were in fact stayed against security, claim damages of not less than 20% (EBL art. 97/13).
- While the action is pending the periods for requesting sale do not run (EBL art. 97/8).
Plain lessons from Court of Cassation decisions
- An invoice alone does not save you: invoices that can be issued at any time and lack distinguishing features, submitted for a motorcycle by a person living with his father, were held insufficient and the decision allowing the action was reversed (Court of Cassation 8th Civil Chamber, E. 2016/19418, K. 2019/11425, 17.12.2019).
- Books and a payment trail win cases: although the attachment was at the debtor’s registered address, payment by cheque and confirmation of the sale by the books rebutted the presumption (Court of Cassation 8th Civil Chamber, E. 2019/5335, K. 2021/4492, 27.05.2021).
- A name on a document is not an organic connection: the debtor’s name appearing on a document merely as a driver did not establish an organic connection (Court of Cassation 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/11019, K. 2023/1682, 15.03.2023).
- A very low transfer price raises suspicion: a business transfer at a very low, undocumented price was held simulated, but 20% damages were refused because no security was paid and the proceedings were not in fact stayed (Court of Cassation 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/3063, K. 2024/747, 24.01.2024).
What Is a Third-Party Ownership Claim (İstihkak)?
In Turkish enforcement law, istihkak denotes a claim by a third party asserting ownership or a right of pledge over attached property. The institution protects property that does not in truth belong to the debtor; but because it can be abused by bad-faith debtors to shield assets from creditors, the legislature has laid down special rules of proof.
The Assembly of Civil Chambers distinguishes two actions: the third-party ownership action, brought by the third party against the creditor to free property attached in the debtor’s hands (EBL arts. 96 and 97/6); and the action to reject the ownership claim, brought by the creditor against a third party in whose hands the property was attached, in order to prevent the attachment from lapsing (EBL art. 99).
Crucially, which party brings the action does not shift the burden of proof. This is the most common misconception in practice. The same rules apply by analogy in proceedings for the realisation of pledges (EBL art. 150/g).
Legal Basis: EBL Arts. 96, 97, 97/a and 99
“Where the debtor declares that property in his hands is the property or pledge of another, or where a third party asserts a right of ownership or pledge over that property, the enforcement office shall record this in the attachment and enforcement minutes and notify both parties. The enforcement office shall at the same time grant the creditor and the debtor three days to state whether they object to the ownership claim. If they remain silent, they are deemed to have accepted the claim. A debtor or third party who becomes aware of the attachment and does not assert an ownership claim within seven days of becoming aware forfeits the right to raise that claim in the same proceedings.”
“If the creditor or the debtor objects to the ownership claim, the enforcement officer shall immediately refer the file to the enforcement court. The enforcement court shall, after examining the file or, if it deems it necessary, summoning the interested parties for a hearing, order the continuation or the stay of the proceedings. If there are serious grounds to hold that the ownership action is being abused solely to postpone the sale, the enforcement court shall reject the request for a stay. If a stay is ordered, security under Article 36 shall be taken from the claimant against the creditor’s probable loss should the claim fail. The decision of the enforcement court ordering continuation of the proceedings is final. The third party is obliged to bring the ownership action before the enforcement court within seven days of the pronouncement or service of the enforcement court’s decision. If no action is brought within that period, the third party is deemed to have abandoned the claim against the creditor. The ownership action is heard under the general provisions and in accordance with the simplified procedure. Where a stay has been ordered upon the ownership action and the action is ultimately dismissed, the claimant shall be ordered to pay damages of not less than twenty per cent of the amount whose recovery has been delayed. Where the ownership action succeeds and the bad faith of the objecting creditor or debtor is established, damages of not less than fifteen per cent of the value of the attached property shall be awarded against the objector together with the main action.”
“A person who has a movable in his hands is deemed to be its owner. Even where the debtor and third parties hold the movable jointly, the property is deemed to be in the debtor’s hands. In such a case, if the third party accepts custody, the property shall not be taken into safekeeping … Among goods in premises jointly inhabited, those whose belonging to a woman, man or child is plainly apparent from their nature, or which are required by custom, art, profession or occupation, are presumed to belong to them. The burden of rebutting this presumption falls on the person asserting the contrary. The claimant in an ownership action is obliged to show and prove the manner in which he acquired the property and the legal and factual reasons and events requiring it to be in the debtor’s hands.”
“Where the attached property is not in the debtor’s hands but is held by a third party asserting ownership or another right in rem over it, the property shall not be taken into safekeeping if that person accepts custody. The enforcement officer shall grant the creditor seven days to bring an ownership action against the third party before the enforcement court. If no action is brought within that period, the third party’s claim is deemed accepted. Until an action brought in time by the creditor is concluded, the attached property may not be sold. …”
In Whose Hands Was the Property Attached? Three Scenarios
1) Attached solely in the debtor’s hands (EBL arts. 96-97)
A person in possession of a movable is presumed to be its owner. The presumption therefore operates in favour of the debtor — and thus the creditor. On objection, the enforcement court orders continuation or a stay; the decision to continue is final. The third party must bring the ownership action within seven days.
2) Attached in the joint possession of the debtor and a third party
The statute is unequivocal: the property is deemed to be in the debtor’s hands. EBL arts. 96 and 97 apply, not EBL art. 99, and the burden lies on the third party. The sole exception concerns goods in jointly inhabited premises whose belonging is plain from their nature or from custom, art, profession or occupation.
3) Attached solely in a third party’s hands (EBL art. 99)
Here the presumption favours the third party. If the third party accepts custody, the property is not taken into safekeeping. The enforcement officer grants the creditor seven days to sue; failing that, the third party’s claim is deemed accepted. Pending an action brought in time, the property may not be sold. For EBL art. 99 to apply, the property must have been attached in the sole possession of the third party.
Special case: leased assets
An asset the debtor leases from a financial leasing company belongs to the lessor; the law specifically provides for its exclusion from enforcement proceedings and, in the lessee’s bankruptcy, its separation from the estate:
“(1) In the event of the lessee’s bankruptcy, the bankruptcy officer shall, before the office is constituted under the first paragraph of Article 221 of Law No. 2004, order the separation of the leased assets. An objection may be made against this decision within seven days. (2) Where enforcement proceedings are brought against the lessee, the enforcement officer shall order the leased assets to be excluded from the proceedings. An objection may be made against the officer’s decision within seven days. (3) These objections shall be decided by the enforcement court within one month at the latest.”
Burden of Proof and Rebutting the Presumption
The identity of the claimant does not shift the burden of proof. The burden follows the presumption. Where the presumption favours the creditor, the third party must prove how he acquired the property, that he had the financial capacity to acquire it at the material time, and why it was in the debtor’s hands. Where the presumption favours the third party, the creditor must prove that the property was attached in the debtor’s hands and belongs to him. The presumption may be rebutted by any evidence, including witnesses, but the evidence must be convincing and free of all doubt; an invoice alone is often insufficient, and entry in duly kept commercial books, matching serial numbers and payment and transport documents are expected. Agreement between the third party and the debtor before the enforcement officer does not bind the creditor, while the debtor’s admission that the property belongs to the third party is evidence against himself (EBL art. 97/12).
Organic Connection, Simulation and Veil-Piercing
Courts assess the organic connection between debtor and third party on a cluster of indicators: the link between the address of attachment and the addresses in the enforcement file; who was present at the attachment; whether documents belonging to the debtor were found and whether they were current; the parties’ registered addresses in the trade registry and tax office; shareholding structures, share transfers and their dates; and the date on which the debt arose.
Two settled limits apply: operating in a similar field of business is not, in itself, sufficient to establish an organic connection; and where a genuine commercial relationship existed, the presence at the site of documents predating the debt is consistent with the ordinary course of life and does not by itself rebut the presumption. Conversely, where the debtor’s business is in substance carried on through the third-party company and the same person controls both, the courts find an intention to use the third party as a screen.
The Seven-Day Period Is Preclusive
The three distinct seven-day periods for the claim, the third party’s action and the creditor’s action are shown in the table above and must not be confused. Persons living with the claimant and business partners are deemed aware of the attachment on the date the claim is made (EBL art. 96/3). The 12th Civil Chamber holds that the period under EBL art. 96/3 is preclusive and must be examined by the court of its own motion at every stage. The date of awareness is construed broadly: submitting a power of attorney to the enforcement file may count. The claim must also be made by an authorised person; a statement by a relative without authority is not a valid claim.
Stay of Proceedings, Security and Sale
The decision to continue the proceedings is final (EBL art. 97/5). If a stay is ordered, security is taken from the claimant, its type and amount assessed according to the evidence (EBL art. 97/3-4). Where there are serious grounds to hold that the action is being used solely to postpone the sale, the stay is refused. During the action the time limits for requesting sale (EBL art. 106) do not run. Under EBL art. 99, the property may not be sold until an action brought in time is concluded. If the property is sold before the action ends, the judge decides separately whether the proceeds are withheld or paid to the creditor with or without security.
Damages: 20% and 15% — and Their Basis
Against the claimant (20%): where a stay was ordered and the action is dismissed, damages of not less than 20% of the amount whose recovery was delayed are awarded to the creditor (EBL art. 97/13). No stay, no damages. The Court of Cassation treats this as compensation for delay and requires a decision staying the proceedings or the sale against security; where no security was paid and the proceedings were not in fact stayed, the conditions are not met (Court of Cassation 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/3063, K. 2024/747, 24.01.2024). Against the objector (15%): where the action succeeds and the objector’s bad faith is established, damages of not less than 15% of the value of the attached property are awarded (EBL art. 97/15).
As to the basis of calculation, the 12th Civil Chamber consistently holds that the lesser of the amount claimed in the enforcement proceedings and the value of the attached property is taken. Calculating the 20% on a property value exceeding the debt is a ground for reversal.
Competent Court, Court Fees, Procedure and Appellate Review
The competent court is the enforcement (civil) court (EBL art. 97/6). There is no special mandatory venue rule for the ownership action: the Court of Cassation has held that general venue rules apply, that the action may be brought at the place of the main enforcement proceedings or at the defendant’s domicile, that an objection to venue may be raised only as a preliminary objection and that the judge may not decline venue of his own motion (Court of Cassation 8th Civil Chamber, E. 2016/9442, K. 2018/17737, 22.10.2018). The same decision stresses that complaints about an attachment carried out under a letter of request belong, as a mandatory rule, to the enforcement court of the requested office.
Court fees: the action is subject to a proportional fee. The value in dispute is the lower of the value of the attached property and the principal debt in the proceedings; if the value is not stated it must be clarified or determined by the court, and the action cannot proceed without completion of the fee (Court of Cassation 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/2366, K. 2024/831, 25.01.2024).
The simplified procedure applies (EBL art. 97/11); the judge freely evaluates the evidence, and ownership actions are heard expeditiously and in priority to other cases.
Complaint versus action: whether the attachment falls under EBL arts. 96-97 or EBL art. 99 is challenged by way of complaint against the enforcement officer’s act. In that narrow jurisdiction, the enforcement court may not determine allegations of simulation, organic connection or asset-shielding — these belong to the ownership action or to an action to set aside dispositions. Conversely, the allocation of the burden of proof settled in the complaint proceedings may be revisited in the ownership action heard under the general provisions.
Appeal: an appeal to the regional court lies within two weeks of service where the value of the claim, right or property exceeds the statutory threshold, and an appeal on points of law against final regional court decisions above the threshold also within two weeks (EBL arts. 363 and 364). The thresholds rise each year by the revaluation rate, and since Law No. 7571 (Official Gazette 25.12.2025) the amount on the date of the action applies (EBL additional art. 1). Recent appeals on points of law are examined by the 12th Civil Chamber; some 2018–2021 decisions are from the 8th Civil Chamber. A claimant appealing against dismissal may ask the enforcement office for a respite (EBL art. 97/14).
Third-Party Claims in Bankruptcy
If the debtor is bankrupt, his entire estate rather than individual attached items forms the bankruptcy estate. A person who believes that his property is in the estate must register the claim within one month of the announcement of bankruptcy (EBL art. 219). The bankruptcy administration examines the claims after that period (EBL art. 230) and decides whether to release the goods:
“The bankruptcy administration decides whether goods claimed by third parties are to be released to them. If the bankruptcy administration rejects the ownership claim, it sets and serves on the third party a period of seven days to bring an ownership action before the enforcement court. A third party who lets this period expire is deemed to have abandoned his claim against the estate. The ownership action is heard under the general provisions and the simplified procedure. The enforcement court may, where necessary, require the claimant to provide security against the estate’s possible loss.”
What to Do at the Moment of Attachment
Ownership actions are often won or lost at the premises. In addition to the steps above, have the following recorded:
- Have documents showing the premises are yours (lease, tax certificate, trade registry record, utility subscriptions) recorded in the report.
- Have it recorded that no documents belonging to the debtor were found — or, if any were, their dates.
- Ensure the serial or chassis numbers of the attached goods are recorded; this is the only way to match them to your invoices later.
- Have it recorded that the debtor does not operate at the premises and that the payment order was not served there.
Court of Cassation Decisions
Definition of the action, statutory presumptions and rules of proof
“Where, regarding property seized in the debtor’s possession, a right is claimed by a third party in its own favour or by the debtor in favour of a third party, the action brought by the third party against the creditor in order to release the seized property from attachment is defined as an "action for recovery of property" (Law No. 2004, arts. 96, 97/6); whereas the action brought by the creditor, in order to prevent the lifting of the attachment, against the third party claiming a right over property seized in its possession is defined as an "action for rejection of the claim of ownership" (Law No. 2004, art. 99) (Baki Kuru, İcra ve İflas Hukuku El Kitabı, Ankara, 2013, p. 543; Timuçin Muşul, İcra ve İflas Hukukunda İstihkak Davaları, Ankara, 2015, p. 3). … The creditor is a stranger to the relations between the third party asserting ownership and the debtor; he extended credit on the basis of outward appearances. Accordingly, if the creditor is not protected in matters of proof, it becomes very difficult for him to establish collusive arrangements between the debtor and the third party, and the ownership action — instituted to protect the legitimate interests of third parties — is used by bad-faith debtors as a means of shielding assets from creditors. … The burden of rebutting the statutory presumption established in favour of the creditor by the first two sentences of that article falls on the third party. In discharging that burden the third party must prove the legal ground on which he acquired the property; if he relies on purchase, that he had the financial capacity to purchase it at the date of acquisition; and the reason why the property was in the debtor’s hands. … For the presumption of ownership to operate in the creditor’s favour, the connection of the address of attachment with the debtor must be established with certainty. … Where a movable is attached solely in the hands of a third party, the burden of bringing the action — and therefore of proof — falls in principle on the creditor under Article 99. … Where the property was attached while in the debtor’s hands or in the joint possession of the debtor and the third party, Articles 96 and 97 apply, not Article 99. It must be stressed at once that if the ownership action is brought by the third party on the basis of Article 99, the burden of proof does not shift.” (translation)
Organic connection; the burden of proof does not shift with the identity of the claimant
“… in actions for recovery of property, the presumption of ownership and the burden of proof are determined not merely according to whether the parties are defendant or plaintiff in the file, but by evaluating together many data such as the connection of the place of seizure with the addresses in the enforcement file, the persons present at the place of seizure during the seizure and the discovery of information and documents establishing a link between the address and the debtor, the addresses of the party to the enforcement proceedings and of the third party registered with the trade registry and the tax office, and their partnership structures (share transfers and their dates). For this reason, it is possible for the decision on the burden of proof rendered by the enforcement court of limited jurisdiction to be discussed in the action for recovery of property tried under the general provisions, and for a decision to be made shifting the burden of proof. … Accordingly, the presumption of ownership under Article 97/a operates in favour of the debtor and hence the creditor. The fact that the action was brought by the creditor under Article 99 does not cause the burden of proof to shift. The contrary of this statutory presumption must be proved by the defendant third party with convincing and strong evidence.” (translation)
The seven-day period is preclusive and examined ex officio; the claim must be raised by an authorised person
“An ownership claim may be raised, in the case of legal persons, by the organs authorised to represent them, and in the case of natural persons, either by the person himself or by persons authorised to represent him. A claim made by a person without authority to represent the legal or natural person is not a valid ownership claim. … Under Article 96/3, a debtor or third party who learns of the attachment must assert an ownership claim within seven days of learning of it; otherwise he forfeits the right to raise that claim in the same proceedings. The seven-day period is preclusive in nature and must be taken into account by the court of its own motion at every stage of the proceedings.” (translation)
The basis of the damages award: the lesser of the debt claimed and the value of the attached property
“Article 97/13 provides that where a stay of the enforcement proceedings has been ordered upon an ownership action and the action is ultimately dismissed, the claimant shall be ordered to pay damages of not less than 20% of the amount of the creditor’s claim whose recovery has been delayed by reason of that action. In the present case a stay having been ordered, damages of 20% must be awarded in the creditor’s favour … In determining the basis of the damages, the lesser of the amount claimed in the enforcement proceedings and the value of the attached property must be taken.” (translation)
Complaint as to whether arts. 96-97 or art. 99 applies: the narrow jurisdiction of the enforcement court
“… in complaints of this kind brought before the enforcement court, the court may not resolve allegations of simulation, organic connection, or transfers of immovables by the debtor with a view to shielding assets from the creditor in a manner that determines the ownership claim; such allegations may be examined only in an ownership action or an action to set aside dispositions …” (translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
Enforcement officers attached my goods at my business or home for someone else’s debt. What should I do?
Assert the ownership claim at the attachment itself, recorded in the report, and ensure it is made by an authorised person. Accept custody so that the goods are not removed. Have the lease, tax certificate and the serial numbers of the goods recorded. Then bring the ownership action within seven days of the pronouncement or service of the enforcement court’s decision on continuation or stay.
The television attached at my home belongs to my daughter. Should I bring an ownership action?
Often there is no need. The personal belongings of the debtor and family members living under the same roof and household goods used in common are exempt, except money and valuables (EBL art. 82/1-3). If such an item is attached, a complaint should be made to the enforcement court, as a rule within seven days of learning of it (EBL art. 16). The ownership claim is for attachable property belonging to someone else.
I hold the invoice for the attached goods. Is that enough?
Usually not. Where the presumption favours the creditor, you must rebut it with evidence that is convincing and free of all doubt: the invoice entered in duly kept commercial books, serial numbers matching the attachment report, financial capacity at the time of purchase, and an explanation of why the goods were where they were.
Does bringing the action stop the sale?
Not automatically. If the goods were attached in the debtor’s hands, you must obtain a stay from the enforcement court and provide security (EBL art. 97/3). If the goods were attached in your sole possession (EBL art. 99), the property may not be sold until an action brought in time by the creditor is concluded.
If I lose, will I pay damages?
Only if a stay was ordered and the proceedings were in fact stayed. In that case, damages of not less than 20% of the delayed recovery are awarded (EBL art. 97/13), calculated on the lesser of the debt claimed and the value of the attached property. If you win and the objector’s bad faith is established, damages of not less than 15% of the value of the property are awarded against him (EBL art. 97/15).
I missed the seven-day period. What happens?
Under EBL art. 96/3 you forfeit the right to raise the ownership claim in the same proceedings. The period is preclusive and examined by the court of its own motion at every stage. The date of awareness is construed broadly — filing a power of attorney in the enforcement file may suffice.
See our practice area page on Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law.
- Action for Annulment of Dispositions (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Arts. 277-284)
- Negative-Declaratory and Recovery Actions: Declaring Non-Liability and Recovering Money Paid
- Precautionary Attachment
- Custodianship in Turkish Enforcement Law: Safekeeping of Attached Goods, the Custodian’s Liability and Liquidation under Article 88/A (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 88, Penal Code art. 289)
Related Articles
- Action for Annulment of Dispositions (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Arts. 277-284)
- Negative-Declaratory and Recovery Actions: Declaring Non-Liability and Recovering Money Paid
- Precautionary Attachment
- Custodianship in Turkish Enforcement Law: Safekeeping of Attached Goods, the Custodian’s Liability and Liquidation under Article 88/A (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 88, Penal Code art. 289)
- Tera, Pusula and Liquidated Fund Investors in Türkiye: Legal Roadmap on Liquidation, Compensation, Complaints, Claims and Full-Remedy Actions
- Physical Attachment When No Custodian Is Available: Safekeeping Where There Is No Licensed Warehouse or It Refuses the Goods (EBL Art. 88 and the Regulations)
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Enforcement attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Enforcement & Bankruptcy Law
- How to Obtain a Stay of Enforcement Pending Appeal in Türkiye: Step-by-Step Procedure, Security, Time Limits
- Service on Persons Living Abroad under Turkish Law: Consular Service, Public Notice, Unnoticed Judgments
- Fees in Allowed Negative Declaratory Actions Await Finality: Turkish Court of Cassation; No Complaint Deadline
- Compensation in Title Deed Cases Enforceable Before Finality: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Third-Party Ownership Claims in Turkish Enforcement: EBL Arts. 96-99, Burden of Proof, Seven-Day Period”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-07-17, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/third-party-ownership-claims-enforcement-proceedings

























